Usha Sharma v. State Of Punjab And ANR


    
 
 
 

  !" #"$%&%'( &* +* ,-  .."// '!

0",&1& +! !" 1'2 3 '# '!*", "&.'#"'!&
  

    



  ,"&"'!( ,4 2. !+* ,- 5#6$ !"

,!*" .."// '! 

   !   .."// '!3"%'8 88,%"6"# #%&-%&& / $-./ %'!1'#", +"$!%'&  5  9:5 

;5 

<  
 '#  $'&"=1"'!  $=1%!! /   $$1&"#,"&.'#"'!  "6+* ,- * &.,"

",,"#!*"%'&! '! .." / &  .",  .,&"$1!%'  6",&%'5  '  #6",!%&"-"'!  , - !,%-'% / //% '$"> &8%6"'3?,"&.'#"'!@ "6+* ,-  1,&1 '!!!*%& #6",!%&"-"'!5$-./ %' '! .., $*"#,"&.'#"'!  '#1/!%- !"/?!*"%,- ,,% 8"> &&"!!/"#': 9!!* !

!%-"5 $$1&"#&!)>"," /&.,"&"'!
-./ %'! 8 %'&! $$1&"#&!)> &#%&-%&&"#':<3?!*" 1#%$% /  8%&!, !"%,&!
/ &&5 A%/B  !" - ,,% 8"> &?"!!3" %C"# >"6",5,"&.'#"'!&! ,!"#6%&%!%'8!*"$-./ %' '!D&*1&"

!",&"!!/"-"'! - ,,% 8" '#!B!*"$-./ %' '!1!!!*"

 - ,B"! '#!*",./ $"&//"8"#/?,"&.'#"'! !"'&! ?"# !

!*"$-./ %' '!D&*1&" &*"> & ,"&%#"'! -,%!& ,5>*%$*%&

, ,-!*","&%#"'$" !*"$-./ %' '! ! A%/B "%'&%&!"#!*"

$-./ %' '! ,#"6"/.%'8.*?&%$ /,"/ !%'&>%!**%- '#'*", ,"

1& /5*"!*," !"'"#!* !*">1/#'!$'!, $!- ,,% 8">%!**",! %& 1,!*", //"8"#!* ! >""B !",!*"&"!!/"-"'! - ,,% 8"%"'

9,"&.'#"'!$ -"!!*"$-./ %' '!D&*1&"%' #,1'B"'  $'#%!%'5  &! ?"#  !  *",  *1&"  '#  > '!"#  !  #"6"/. .*?&%$ /,"/ !%'&>%!**",'*",,"

1& /5*"3"$ -" 1,%1& '# $--%!!"#, ."1.'*",
-./ %' '!!*","

!", .., $*"#!*"

!*", $$1&"# '#%'&%&!"#1.' %C%'8!*"# !" - ,,% 8" "&.%!"

!*"%,  &&1, '$"5  # !"    - ,,% 8"  > &  '!  %C"#  /!%- !"/?5 ,"&.'#"'!,"

1&"#!- ,,?*",%'!*" %,&!>""B +".!"-3", 9  >*","1.'  &*"  &13-%!!"#   >,%!!"'  $-./ %'!  !  +"'%, +1.",%'!"'#"'! /%$"5",A".1,'

<9 ,,"8%&!, !%' $ &" 8 %'&! //!*" $$1&"#.",&'&%'$/1#%'8,"&.'#"'! >"6",5>*"'' $!%'> &! B"'5&*" .., $*"#!*%&
1,! , ,"8%&!, !%'  $ &"",."!%!%'> &#%&.&"# >%!*/%3",!?! %/"

$-./ %'!3"

," ..,.,% !" ,1-+*"!*","

!", %/"#!*"%'&! '!

$-./ %'! !%&'/?,"&.'#"'!>*> &&1--'"#! $"

!,% / ,!*"

"'$".1'%&* 3/"1'#",+"$!%' 9:
4" ,'"#!,% /
1,!' ..,"$% !%' "6%#"'$"',"$,##%&-%&&"#!*"$-./ %'!

'# $=1%!!"#,"&.'#"'! !*"$* ,8" , -"# 8 %'&!*%- 6%#"%-.18'"#21#8-"'!# !"#

>*%/"&."$% %$ //?*/#%'8 !* !  !*","  > &  -%&", 3/"  %/1,"  !  .,6"  !*"   $ &"  8 %'&!  !*"

$$1&"# 4" ,'"#$1'&"/ ,!*" .."// '!6"*"-"'!/? ,81"&!* !

$=1%!! / ,"&.'#"'!%&.",&"%//"8 /4" ,'"#!,% /
1,!* & 8,&&/?  ",,"#  %'  '!  $'6%$!%'8  !*"  & %#  $$1&"#    !*"  

"'$"

.1'%&* 3/"1'#",+"$!%' 9:
!%&1,8"#!* !!*"$-./ %' '!

*",&"/ * &!"&!% %"#!*" $!1- , ."3"%'8$--%!!"#'*",'

9  !  %&  '!  '"$"&& ,?  !* !  !*","  &*1/#  3"  '?  !*", $,,3, !%'8"6%#"'$"!&13&! '!% !"*",&! !"-"'!" ","'$"%& - #"! 21#8-"'! +%'8/" "'$* !*%&
1,!%'"#$%&'()$*%*

+#+) #$,#-#.

$/0/-#1 %'!*%&,"&."$! !%& 1,!*",&13-%!!"#!* !!*"/" ,'"#!,% /
1,!* &3""' >,'8/?&> ?"#3?!*" //"8"##"/ ?%'!*"/#8%'8 !*%&$-./ %'!
-./ %' '!* &#1/? .., $*"#!*"./%$" 1!*,%!%"&+*""6"' .., $*"#!*%&
1,!>*"'!*"?,"

1&"#!! B" '? $!%' '#%!%& '/?!*","

!",!* !!*"$-./ %'!> & %/"# E*%/","

",,%'8!21#8-"'! 'D3/"+1.,"-"
1,!%'

#+2#1 /-3'()$*%* +#+) #$,#-#  

$/0/-#1 4445  %!  %&  &13-%!!"#  !* !  !*"  #"/ ?  %'  /#8%'8  !*"    %'  &"C1 /

"'$"&&*1/#3"$'&%#","#>%!* #%

","'!? ,#&!%$B'6%"> !*"&."$% %$&! !"-"'! !*"$-./ %' '!5,"&.'#"'!&*1/# * 6"3""'$'6%$!"# ,

"'$".1'%&* 3/"1'#",+"$!%' 9:
'#&"'!"'$"# $$,#%'8/? E"* 6"*" ,#/" ,'"#$1'&"/ ,!*" .."// '! '# %'# '%'

%,-%!?,.",6",&%!?%'!*"%-.18'"#21#8-"'!# !"#

>*%$*>1/#> ,, '!%'!", ","'$"3?!*%&
1,! //"8"#%'$%#"'!%&&! !"#!* 6"$$1,,"#'

9

%"  '"  >""B  !",  &"!!/"-"'!    - ,,% 8"  '  : 9  %'

.1,&1 '$"! #6",!%&"-"'!%'!*"'">&. .",
-./ %'!!!*"++5  A%/B  %&  -6"# !", ; -'!*&  %"  '

<9 &  .", !*"

//"8 !%'&%'!*"$-./ %'!5,"&.'#"'!6%&%!"#*",*1&"%' #,1'B"'$'#%!%''

95$--%!!"#, ."1.'*", '#/"

!

*",*1&"%'!*"-,'%'8'

9!* &3""'3&",6"#3?

!*"/" ,'"#!,% /
1,!!* !!*"$-./ %' '!* &'"&'1'%&* +* ,- 5>*> &.,"&"'!%'!*"*1&"'

95>*"'!*"

$$1&"#* #$-"!!*"*1&"E*"'&*", %&"#*1" '#$,?*", &' '%&*+* ,- #%#$-"!!*",-31!!*" $$1&"#!/#*%- !/" 6"'>*%$**",&'/"

!+ %#6",&%' , %&%'8*1" '#$,?

'#!*"$-./ %' '!D&&' '%&*F1- ,3"%'8!*","5%&'!"6"' -"'!%'"#%'!*"$-./ %'!,%'!*""C -%' !%' %' $*%"  '%&* F1- ,* &'!3""'"C -%'"#
-./ %' '!* & #-%!!"#!* !&*" * #3! %'"##%6,$" ,-*", %,&!*1&3 '# 2"&*+* ,-  &*"

> & ##%$!"#!%'!C%$ '!&  '#* #3! %'"# &1- 
:5G

,-*%-!*18*%!%&&! !"#3?*",%'!*"$,&&"C -%' !%'!* !%! > & '$* ?!%#%6,$"+*"&13&"=1"'!/?- ,,%"#'"0"# ,B &* >%!*  >*-  &*"  /%6"#  ,  &%C -'!*&  31!  !*","

!",  &*"  3! %'"# #%6,$" ,-*%- '#,"$"%6"# 
5)5G  ,-*%-
-./ %' '!

* & #-%!!"#!* !&*" $$-. '%"#,"&.'#"'!'< 9 %" !",!*" //"8"#%'$%#"'!'

9!!*"
1,!
-./"C5  A%/B  '#.1,$* &"# 8,""-"'!3'# 
)G " $* ,!*".1,.&"

- ,,% 8">"6",5!*%& $! /&#"&'! %'#-"'!%'%'!*"

$-./ %'!  "8%&!, !%'   

) # !"#  91'#", +"$!%'&  :5  '#   
 3?,"&.'#"'!   8 %'&!

$-./ %' '!  ,  , 1#  '#  -%& ..,.,% !%'    !*"  -1'!  
5)959G %& #-%!!"#3?*",!%& #-%!!"#3?!*"$-./ %' '!!* ! ,"&.'#"'!      > &  ! B"'  3? *", !  !*"  *1&"    +*  /3%, + $*#"6 5#6$ !"5>*","%!> & 8,""#!* !2%'! %C"##".&%!
/ B*>1/#3".,". ,"#3?$'!,%31!%'8
)/ B*3?3!*&%#"& '# !*"%'$-"8"'", !"# ,-!*"%'!","&!>1/#3"1!%/%A"# ,,1''%'8 !*"*1&"*/#%' 1!1,">*"'!*"%,- ,,% 8"> & %' /%A"#*","%& '!"6"' >*%&.", !*"&"- !",% / $!&%'!*"$-./ %'! %/"#3?

!*"$-./ %' '! !%&%'!*"&"$%,$1-&! '$"&!* !$-./ %'! %/"#3?*",* & 3""'#%&-%&&"# '#,"&.'#"'! $=1%!!"# !*"$* ,8" , -"# 8 %'&!  *%-  13!/"&&/?5  #"/ ?  %'  ,"8%&!, !%'      %'  &"C1 /

"'$"&* &!3"$'&%#","#>%!* #%

","'!? ,#&!%$B31! !!*"

& -"!%-"%!%&'!!* !#"/ ?%'&1$*$ &"&* &!3"#%6,$"# ,- !*"$%,$1-&! '$"& '#!! //?%8',"#*""'!%,"$'&."$!1&  $!& * &!3"$'&%#","#! %'#1!>*"!*",#"/ ?%',"8%&!, !%'  $ &"G&13-%&&%'    $-./ %'!  * &  ,"&1/!"#  %'  "-3"//%&*-"'!  '# "C 88", !%',%&,"&1/!  ' !",!*18*!, $'$$!%''!*"

.,"&"'!  $ &"5  $-./ %' '!  * &  ,  !*"  %,&!  !%-"  &13-%!!"#  *", $-./ %'! !", / .&" ;-'!*& ,-!*" //"8"#%'$%#"'!+*"

&13-%!!"#$-./ %'!'

<93"

,"++5 A%/B %',"&."$!! !*"%'$%#"'!!, .">*%$* //"8"#/?!B./ $"'

9*1&5 / $B $,,3, !%' !*"$-./ %' '!D&6",&%''- !",% / &."$!& %&- !",% /%'!*%&$ &" '6%"> !*" $!& '#$%,$1-&! '$"&5%!>1/#%'#""#3"

1'& "!$'6%$!,"&.'#"'!'!*"&/"!"&!%-'? !*"

:

$-./ %' '!5>*%$*#"&'!%'&.%,"$-./"!"$' %#"'$"!%&!,%!"

!* !%' 8%6"'$ &"!"&!%-'? .,&"$1!,%C$ '3" $!"#1.'

>%!*1!$,,3, !%' - !",% /. ,!%$1/ ,&>"6",5%'!*".,"&"'! $ &"5*",!"&!%-'? %/&!. &&-1&!", !",% / $!&* 6"3""'

$'$" /"#  3?  *",5  >*%$*  $ &!   #13!  '  !*"  6", $%!?    *", !"&!%-'?5!*","3?,"'#",%'8%!1'& "!$'6%$!,"&.'#"'! &/"/?'!*"3 &%& *",!"&!%-'? *","%&'-%&," #%'8  '?"6%#"'$"3?!*"!,% /
1,!5 '"%!*",* & '?"6%#"'$"3""'%8',"#4" ,'"#$1'&"/%&1' 3/"! .%'!1! '?%'

%,-%!?,%//"8 /%!?%'!*"%-.18'"#21#8-"'!$ //%'8

, '?%'!", ","'$"
'&"=1"'!/?5>" %'#'-",%!%'!*%& .." /5>*%$*%& #%&-%&&"# )0#-+%2+#  /*#/11 %53)  %53) .,%/5

















,!&