Sukhvir Singh @ Sukhi v. State Of Punjab
!"#" $%&'('
% )* ' +
, +**
!"#!
$ !""%! !&'
( !"# %( !"#!#)(
, +**-' * + #(( ,- *.
.,.*/" 01-2 &( " !3!) (# ) &# (## !4 %) )#&# 5 & # () &6*7-/829 .
*.
.,.* /" 0 1.2 # ( & # 9(( ( ).
.
.,../" 01:2 & ( ; ! 3! # & - *.
.,.*/" 01-2 ) .
+) 3'< ,*.=*7 ,8 .,.*!( (# ! !>#3! # -,.!-,7!
/.2
-=*!=.7!?,:!*=8!*=@!*.,1 '9 # .?!.7!?=!?@") "#/# -.--.='9( 2 +3' ( # ) < ! AB/ B2 )(&%
) ( C ! % 0 & *@@: ! ( '5( $! ) )/'5( ( 2) & &( # ( '5( (& )( ( ) ) '(( '5( (AB/B 2 )(&" ( B # (
# (# <'! ' (( *7 ,8 .,.*! # ( ! /#)( 2 ( ( ! < < ( # )
! # < >$1*,1931 ,*., D(& &!(##(A#B#(! A+B#(! A' B#( )#( # 9)( B ! #!# ( ## #((( )#( )!##((( # # ( ) (( ) C ! & /#)( &2 #) !#( ( # ' (( " )! ) ( *?6., ( ) #(
/-2
#& #& #! (( ! ! # " (( #)( B < < ) # 0 #) # ) ( ( 1 1( '5( " (( ( ( )#)( B + ( (# #)( B # ( ' (( #)( B 1 1( ( # < ! ## (# ( (( < ## &)(( # # + ## & ) # #( < 9( C(! ) %% #(9(( !3!##) + #)( (( ##
#)( ! < /#2
!& ( ! # &! # ( '5( '(( '5( # # " ( !&) - " # 3'! ( ) ## ) 3'! ##((&) *?1.,( C (( # +(# (7## # () ! 6 *7- 9 ( *:
** .,.*! # # ( (& ( ## ) # *:7/.2 9
/=2
# # @, & 6 *7- 9 0
' # ) @#1## & (-7 # 1 ##! ( 4 ! %) ) (# # # # (( ! *7-/829 ((( + )7##! # 1!(( * " .
'5( - +./01"2+"$30
= " ?
4
:
%)
> = + ) @ ##! #( ! ) #() < .*:
** .,.*(6*7-9 + ) @## ( * % .
% - = C ?
:
; ; C @
/?2
?
5 (&! .
*.
.,.*! # ) () & *7-/829 /" 01.2# ! 4 %) (# #() # # 6*7-9 *:
** .,.* (! # ! ')& ) *, *.
.,.*! & *7-/82 9 /" 01?2 &# > ( # ! :
' # 5 ( ,.
*.
.,.* /" 01.2(6*7-/829 &# # # ! 4 %) ! ( &" C !" !#( && ( - *.
.,.*/" 01-2 + - *.
.,.*/" 01-2!) )) .
.
.,../" 01:2 &( ; !3 + ( # ( ) (# ((& #(( *:
** .,.*! 5& (# )& B # # ((
' ) 0 5& # #& (#!3 # #( )! # # 5 (&! () & 6 *7-/82 9 .
*.
.,.* /" 0 1.2 & (#! #( #
/:2
' ) " ) - *.
.,.* /" 0 1-2 #( ( ! # 5& ! ( (& ( # )( # #&#)))'' ) 9" ( ; ! () ) .
.
.,../" 0 1:2! ## 5&! #()# # @ E !( # (&( # ( #)( )(##((## # #( # #& (( < ' ) # #& & ) ) 9 # # ) *7- 9 (& !() &6*7-/829 # ( #### # ) 9 (& # & 9 ' )( " ( ; !3 #(& ( - *.
.,.*/" 01-2 *, '# () 9 ** # ##( #! )( (&( # ( & ( () & 6 *7-/82 9 /" 01.2 # # ## ( *:
** .,.* 6 *7- 9 )1# (&! # ' # (
/72
() & ! # ((& # & ( # *7- 9 9! ( # #&(# ) 9 (#((&0## #( # ###(( (& ) # ## # *.
C # ! ( #( &C B()9 # 0# # *7- 9 ! #( # 1# /82 + ( # *7-9 45'
6 2 6 7"!
"!
2 $! 867
" $ "$1 # "3
" $' /*2 F& 9 (( #)( #&(& /*"2000 /.2/2 " #)(!# # (# (( ) # G # # (# ! ) # & % ) ! 1 /2 )H /2 ) H /#2 ) #5 ##) ##H /2 & # #)) !! & )H /2 ## H /2 ( !! H / 2 #& # *7,H /2 )#(0) ) # ( # #
/82
-7:! -7:"! -7: ! -7:9! -7:>! -7:>"! -7:> -7:F ' (9/=?*8:,2 /2 + # (( ( #)) #! # ) )& #&% ) !# &)! ! &!& ) ) ( #)) # /-2 000 /=2 000 /?2 000 /:2 000 /72 000
!"#$# % $$$$# #!
!$ & # # % & $$ $ ! $# %& #"'&
$ $# # % $" !( % $ #!
)
& $ "'!&' # '' $ # #!
*+ /)(2 *- C B()9! (# # (# )! " , %* - . /" 00- " 10!( (& (# (& # G # # (# ( (& ) 9# # ' ( #)(#!( ( (( (
/@2
*= F -$/ 2
%*/*-*2 - " 1 ! C B( ) 9 )( ( ) ) ) *?
C B( ) 9 " # ' %* - $ 3 0
" 4&() # )# *7-/.29 !(# ) # *7-/82 9 )
' ( )# *7-/829 ! ( )(! ' ( ( ) ) ) # # #& ( # & (# *:
' 5' 6' % * 7
/ 8
" 0! ) 9 ( ) ! #(( #( ) (( I-, C (& 9 ) 1 #! ((( # #( ) )# *7-/.2 # *7-/82 # *?:/-29 * + # J J J J/ 2 # (# .
" # J J ( (# )# *7-/.29 - + 0 /.2 # )& #( ( J#/2&; # # )& # # #
/*,2
= <#)9 &## 0### & +( # *7-/.2# # #(& # #((& # # *?:/-2 ( # *7-/82( ' #! # ( ( # *7-/82 ?
+ 9 #( #) ! ! ) # # # # ( # # # ( (# # ' ( ( (# ( ! #( 90 ## # ) ! 9 # (( # #& # # # #( :
' #&(# ) 9# J J ( () &# 1 +# & 9 ) ) +# ( # K
" # *7 D(##((&( 5 ) 9 5'6' 9 !/2 ( I=@ < ! )& 0) # # # # *7-/82 ( & # # ' ## 5) # *7-/829# # L L(() & ( #! # (& ( ( (##) ## # L L (L() &L ( # +#! )# !( )( + 5) ( # # # L L 6(L() &L ((
/**2
! #& )(# # *7-/829 +# ": (( ((& #) # ) # )() ( )! # ## &( (## # K /F)(2 *8 D( ) ( &(# # ) ) 9!
( 0 )& ) ( &(## # # # *7- 9 (& 9 ## &) (&#((& ) # # #( # (# ( # "# (# (# (( #& )# ) (# ) (& # # #((#! #!
0# ( # #& )& & 9 ( # (( #( !# # #( + 9#)## #&#) () & # *7-/82 9 # (# # #( ((& )( ##((#5 (& & & & ) # # ( ' # # # # #& # *@ ' # #& & ) 9# # !
/*.2
# 9 (( 9 # # # # G # () & 6 *7-/82 9 .
*.
,.* /" 0 1.2 )## #))9 ! () &# #((5 # (# ) 9 # # +# # ## ., 9) ##! ( ) ## ) 3'! ##((& ) *?1.,( C(( # "# # #&(# " ! ( 3'!
( /2 (1 ( #((#)(### # C 3$ H /2 ) # ## (( # ( #) (### #H /2 )#( # 1)) # < ( $ # * & ( ( H /2 () & ) ., " .,.
* & ( #( )## ( #( ;7%9 # < 1,=1">1 ,-,- & " ( 4 % #& C (# #( ;-9 #( < 1-@1%1-?,, % ( .
/*-2
#( A- $ . B # < 17:"1 8--*! .
C " ( # )( ;6 9 #( C & #(()(;6 9#( #.
' () &) ## )(&" !4 !% % #) ) >> < ?* ., " .,.*H /2 " 4 #) .," .,.* (& (( ;7%9#( < 1,=1">1,-,- #() )&" (# #< ! # ..
,8 .,.* C ( #( (# ( )#( 7# ) ((*. H /2 4 ()#() # *. (# " ## # ) # ) &## # #( ) ((((# # )(# .,(# H /2 .= .,.* C##((& ) 3'( '5( (( ( ( H /2 () &) .? ,.
*)& & ( ) # #((#&(#! ## )(& ! C ! > ! ! ; ! ; ! %) ! C ) ##>>< =,.?
,8 .,.*H /02 %) #(# .?
.,.*& ( #!(( >( ( M #(
/*=2
( C # # ( N # < 1**+1,,8?
#() ! N ##)1 1( C H /02 99+ *7 .,.* ) 8"
*, -,"
#((#)% >! " ( H /02 " '5( &(# *7 ,@ .,.* (& (( # & ) E *@ @ .,.*! #() )&" !
# #& # & ) (# H /02> #(#&F01 # = *, .,.*! #( ( 4 % ) ( < # < >$1*,1931,*., ) ##" ! # # ##!((< H /02 #&( +' # # # ###" !4 !> %) #)( 9 ;
'9 3 > & #)( H /02 #(((# #)( ## ( #((# # # " ! C ! % ! ; ! ! C ! (( D > 3 9(( >( #! (# ##% !> 4 # ### H /02 # ) ## # # !3$((
/*?2
.* + # ! ( ) () & .
*.
.,.* /" 01.26*7-/829 ) (&( ##((# & #& # # >( C ' (#(& C(! # # )#( ##1 ) ! # (& # 99+#) (( +( 0#) () &.
*.
.,.*/" 01.2(( I9)( < ?8@ 9,-6.**7 ,@ .,.* )&)
! (( # # >&' #% ((#!3 # ) ( (! (#/>2!3 !I) 5&# #(( &# ( ) >( C '
(#(& C( )# ) ) E> ( ( *7 ,8 .,.* #)** =@ --"
") ) ( # 99+ 9) (( ( )9> ) % ) ' ) < ! )(& >( C ' #(& C(
! B ) #) C( )#( ## 3) # 9> C()&) ! *7 ,8 .,.*>(C' #(& C( ( ##
K ..
! (# ( ) ! (& &! # ! ( # ( & # ( #)( ! ! ) #
/*:2
##((& ) 3' (( # '5( " ! ### # # 5 # .- D(# ((! ) #### (# & & # && ( ! # # ! ) & # '5( " #)) # 5 !
#)( < /#2 ( ( # '5( D # # ( # ## #! # #((# & #& ) ## #! )( ( # ## #& ( # )# ## # ## # #((& (# .= ' 1 ! (( # '5( " #)) #!
# ( # ( # >( C ' (#(& C(!
( # 5 # ' #& # # ) #(& # #)) # &## # D (6*7-9 ( & # *:
** .,.*! ##((& ) ('5( () ( #( ( ( &
/*72
(( ( ( ( ) '5( ( ' (( ( )((& # # ## #&) # #& ) # ! ! & ##) ( # .?
+9! ! ) ) (!5 (&(&( # ##((#&# 5(&# # ) ##)& &# #)& #((#& #& (# # + () &.
*.
.,.*/" 01.2 ( )1# # ! ( '5( ( ' ##) #! 9 &( # #) # & # # ( #! &#! # 5 ( ( # .:
+ )& &(9,- *.
.,.* /" 0 1-2 #( & # ( ,.
,.
.,.. /" 0 1:2 & (9( + ) &) .7 <( ) ! (( ( & ( # # )(# # ( # # '(#()(
/*82
(( ## &(9 ( ((&# # &'('
, +** )( D 6 #9 D( #9