← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4466/2020dismissed

Bhupinder Kumar Sharma v. State Of Punjab And Others

2020-12-17Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan11 pages

           



" #$% &'(  ) *+ ,  -'

#.  )//#$% 01'(  ) *+ ,  



         

 % 2 23 4 2 52                

 

       !  " #  $   

 % &       

 % '  ( )    

 % *  )+   

 % , ---  3 23 6 -7/"(- , 3 . /

 

$      

 

% &  ,     0  (

 0

1  230(0 (45   .6 2.5 25   (

   .78* 2(5 /  



  $ # 

 ' 2,5 2!5  25     ! (

  2

   

#

(        !    (

  0  1 5

 96.8 23(

96.845   $   !$   :6  #  .6 2.5 25 (  #

.6     ! 

 "

 

 966, 23"

45





9 / !$        .& 0! 96.8 #

  (

 0

(

   ! 2(0 (5 $ 

 

!

  

  ..

   0(0 (    !

 #   !  /     .6 2.5 25 (  

 # ;  #     !   <   !  0  "

$



!      0  (

 1 = /   



 ;>     # 

  $   

  !



   

   



  

 !   ? 

  

   

 

 $   

 # $



   

 

  

   / 

 

 ! <          $$  

$  

  

2  !

      $ 

 = : @    

!A  3B  4  #



 ;B 

. / 

 

 



 #   !     

   

!    <   ?    ! $ $ 9 / 

  <  

! 

   !  #  ?  

$  

#$ 

 A 9. >    $ 

A 25 





!   $   

$ #      

    

$   25 > 

   

 !  

        $  $  25 >   

     $



$   !    $ 

    $       

 

    !    99 >         

   ;% ><  (= #

! 

   



9: (

 # (

 .6  



$!

   



   #

 ! 

 /  



!    !

 # # # # < #    !

!

    

  9& ( $

 !$  < 

         !

$ C

 

  $ # 

 = &  :        #

!   !

  (       .6 2.A5 (    

!

  (

96.8 >      ;/   ( 

  

   

#$  

25       $



!$    !  

$ 

 

  2!5       $ ?

  #$   (        $   (

       !   !

  ( 

      ?

    

 D 25       !   #    #

  

#$  / <  $    

! '6E= /          ?  

   #    ! 

  

!A

 25 #

     !

   '  .6  ..       3F    4 

;0 <  =  

 .9   (

 96.8  .&         ;  # #

   

  $ #  

     #

 !  

 =

*  .*    #        

 ;.* / 



  

  < 



      

 

  

      $   (

 0

(

   ! 0    :,A ( $   ! 9&6.96.7

 '66  

  

  

      #

!  

      

 #= /   #   #  

#

 

    , *9 

 # 



     / #  G ?  (0 ( 2

 %95 

   ( 2

 %:5       .6 2.A5 ( > 

  !  

 %  9  :    *9 

  &' #  $!

!    

   < 

   .:     $!

 # $C 

 0  H 

 "

$ 20"

5  0  H 



"

$ 20"

5D 9 # $ 

  0   205 " 0     $D .6  # #$C  C!   0(0 ( 96 

# $     > 

      $    # #  $!

 # 

  #    # / 

   $ # 

  # F  !  #    ( 2

%:5      

  ..

   0( 0(

  .6 2.5 ( 8 /  # #$  

 0C

        0       $   ! I

! 

  .& "  96.7 J      !   

    

    <   I #   

  #     A  /      

    #

     #  0! 96.7  

 #  

#    ?

 A'  $       %  . 9 : & '  ..        ! 0" C0"

 /    %7    

 !     0(0 (  $

   .,   #      ;    $ $    

 

<    

       0  (

 1        != 7 I#  $    $    G     %  *, 8  .6 #    !  !

  0(0 (  #   

       ! #

 <   ! 

     0(0 (  

 



 !  <  

      .6 2.5 25 ( /   

 %:   

    &   #  

    

 % &  ,     0(0 (

 !$

$     .&  .*   (    >    $   !

 # .6 /  <          

!

   96 0! 96.7 I#   

 /   #  # 

 ! .. /  

  :6 295 (    #     ! 

 

   .6 2.5 25 ( I

!    

 '   

 ' 2,5 2!5 

25   (

96.8 !   $!    

        0(0 (   #   :6 

#  .6 2.5 25 (  #

 .6   "

 #  9::  9:*   (    >  >    ! !$      !  !    



 

 

 

.9 J   #   .8 1! 9696    #

 #

$ !

(

$       !      /  9  9696   #

   !        !  ;

#

    $ 

  ? # #   

   

= F .& "

 9696  

#$   #

 (  ;J        ! 

     !$ 

    $ 2J!? 

#5 I   

     

$   

   

 

  

  

 

%' *  ,  $  



       

 

    

$   

   

   

$       !

!     !

 

  

%' *  , 

   I#     

 

  

 %&  !$ 



 $   

 $ > #         <   ! ?  (    #    $

  

 !  (  #  

          

 

    

%' * , 

!    !  

 ?   $  $

  

 

 /  



 $   

? = .: /  ..  $

 9696  (     

    ! 



 %& !

      > #

  ;     

%' *  ,    

 

   

 %& 

!    !  

 ?   $=

 

   

   

.& >  

  !   

 % . 9  : 

 !   !   F    (    

 #  !      $   



    

$      (

 >

  

    



          

 

 



  !

"#$%

& '()'  



 

 !

$*+(

& $#)'    



 

 ,"#$#- $"

&& %.( .'     (

$   

!    4

 #      

  $   #  !  

   !     .* / (  

!

    

      

    

 >  

 

! 

       0(0 (



    

 %9 / 

 # #  0   I  "

   !  

 %9 

 97 " 96.7      * 1! 96.7 /      

!$ 

    #

$   > 

#    $          

$

 ' 2,5 2!5  25   (

 96.8 / 

$

   $   

 $   

       

$      

 / # ?

    

 (        

 

 



  5 

              !      

      

 "

 "

 #$  

 

!!"#"%   

 

    &"      '    



              ( "   )*  + ! (  *"     

 '

         "   %       ,"'  "  "

     -   '

  "* 

  ,    "          '

 .  "   % '  /0 #12 % * %         

   "        

    

!         

       !   

 * 

%    "    *      *

  *     "

"

        '

  ,     *  *          

   ! 

 *"

*

 



   , *" %          

    

   *  "

  "     '  $ %&

          

 %

      

    !     

      "    "

    *  

* "

   " * 

      "/ $  

     

    !      *

         

            



      *

   %  

   * 

"    

3 $$'%   ()4 

" !! *# % *    

          /0 5     "    %  ! *    

     

   "



   "

  

   %

  "     " 

!      

   %    "    

    

 *  )    "                   

   

  *        6  



  '

  *           "  



        !   "   *      

 *  4 

    *  * 

"  

         

 

   

 * %   *   $   

  

    ! 

  

      * %  %   

   

  * 

  % 

                 *

     '

 

      $  

  + , - -%  .- % - )+ -%./0 # !1*   

        &"  '               -

              

 -

  

    ""     -

%   ,"'  * "

           7$$

-)+--  2 -%3113!! "

%'  

        "

  * /0 2   "

   ," '     *"  !             ! "      #58

! *   

!  ** *  %        "  

         %      9 

  

  

%   *  *  

   ""          *!        ," '   (   : '$  

   

 "  

        '

 

      

        "    ,"'   

  

   "    

 3 ; $  

  0+ - !-' -- ' -  . % ( -  31   !! 1 %

        '   "      /0 $ *            

*    "

%           *" !         !  "     

 

  "

   < 

. %    

*   "    *     "      

!"        "  &"     =*       ," '  

  "

* 

    " "

 *

      3

., > #   

$

  ( 



 

!   $    

  





 

$$  

 ' 2,5 2!5  25   (

 96.8    

     (  

                 



 #    !  !/ 

   0   



.8 / (    

  4

 # $

  

 %  9  : >  ?  

   $  

 %  9  :  4

 #

     

 * 1! 96.7 # 

   !

#  

 !        $ 

  # 9& "  96.7 ! '

 /  

!

 

  !  /      4

   $   #  

%9 !   A     ! 

.7 / (  

      #    #    

 %, #  

 # # 

 %9 !

   !  $ #  4

  ?



 %9      

  

 

 %,     A  > 

  !

 )+    

 %,      $    

  

     

   $G    !



 (    1 

  

 

 / $**+ ,)-

&2 "#$ / (  $ #    

        #

 %,  

 96 J        $ ! $

    (   

      #   

 %  &  ,     0(0 (

  .6 2.5 25   (  #

 '   (

 96.8

& 

9. > #   !    (  

    



  ! $        /  

 $



 /    

4 

52   01'(  ) *+ , 

   2   !">

 / ? >@ 2    /  ? >@