Chattar Singh v. Randhir Singh
!"!#$%& % '
(!#)'
** ++ #
, ("-"
# '!(!#)'
"*# #
.$ /0..0
.01
!"
"!
"#$% &
&
&'' ( )
""
*# "#$+ & , & & & -''.)
, & "/ *"
"#$$
!
&
, & ( 0 0 1 00
&
-
& - , &
&
&
%
' 0 & &
0 0& & ! , 20
&
!- . &
& !- .-. 0
0 & !-.0 , '0 "#34 0 5
& ! 20 0 & 0
5 & /!6 ,
2& -( 7 & ."#/$
& 00 ( ( 8)
!+ "#43 *"
"#4+ ,0 !!+ !!4 & !9 !9
/
& !!/ : & & 0 00 &- .
& 0 !!+0 &
0
!!+ !!4
;- & . 0 &&
&, 5
5
!!+ &
0& - 1.0 0 0 20 & & 0
< 0 & & : 0
*3 "#34 , 0 0 0 & & 0 0 & '0 = &
>
0 , 0 0 - 1.:
' 0 !!+ 0 0 0 8
!!4 0 0
& 0 & & & 0 0
+
*3 "#340
0 0 &&0 & 0
&0 0 &) "***?9 0
& =: > & & !!90 0 & !9 & 0
'0 0 &0 0
0 ) ,&
!!+ !!40 0& 0 &0 & & !!+ !!40 & '0 & 00 &
0 & & 0
; ( 0 &
0 0, & 0 5
&
, & & 0
8 0
$
& 0 & & 0& 0
&9 ="
@ , 0
A'0 A8 !
@ 3 34
0 0 A' 0 0 & &A'A 8 %
@ !!/ : & & & 'A 8 /
@
A8
@
A8 +
@
A 8
) > #
< & &
& "B! 0 ! &0 0 *3 "#34 00 & & &
:
& & & 0 & : & "#4#9$* ( 2 !+ *+ "#43 ( 8)
*3 *"
"#4+ (
0 &, & "*
0 0
& 00 0 &0 '0 & 0 & -6:
/.00 5 & '0
& 0&
0& 00 & ) ,&-@!.0
=> 0&6:
@!?"
-) ,& &.
& & 0 (
: &&&) ,& &9:
&
""
& ,0 & & 0
%
0&
"!
; 0 &
6:
/?" ( 2 0 : &
( 0
0 0
8 &0 0
*3 "#3400
"%
' % B 3 & 0 !!/: & & 0 0
0
& '0
&
"#4#9$*6:
" 0 0 0 !!/00 : 1 !!/10 &
'0 ( & 0 & 0 & & %* 0 0 & "#34
20 0
&
; 0& %B30 0 & - & .
"/
8 /B+ &
9
0 0& "!% 3 0
'0 5 "3
, & & & & &
9 & %* & & & 20
!!+ !!4 0 , 0
( ' 0
6:
/ *3 "#34
&0 9 0 6
& 0 0 & 0 0& 0 & )&
0 0,& 6:
/ &
0
& : 0 0& 0
' & &
0
( & & & 1 ,100 & 6:
/0 0& &
"+
0 5 , 0 &
,0
2& , & ( 5 '
-( '-6!+," 7!!#)''-6!+ # '
(" ')"#++(!#!
0 5 &
"4
C:&& & &
&0 0 & %* 09 &
-0 0 & .0 00 ' 0 ( 9:
& ) ,&
& & &
) ,&0
( !+ *+ "#43
0 && -.
- &0
6:
!
( 80.
"$
& ) &6:
/?" ( 8 *"
"#4+-6:
%.0 ( 0
&
0 "#34 0
"#
& &0 0 (
( 8 !!+ 5
20 0 9 0 : & 0 & & 0 '0 ( 0 = > & 6:
/0
!!+ !!4
!*
0 (
0 !!/0 4*** &
&0 0 9:
& 3
!4!$ & 1 *3 *# "#$/- @".
( !!/ "#3493$0 0& 6:
/ *3 "#34
!"
; 0 ( & 3 &
- &
D .
!!
8 &0 "#340
(5 9
!%
E( &5 0 & 0
& & ( 0 & "#34 0 0
0 0 &
) ,&& 0
& *3 "#34- &.
& '( 5 09 -.
@, & ( 0 0 &&
?0 & "#++
6:
/ "#340
0 & ( 6: ! %
6:
@/?" 0 A -.
@ *3 "#340 5 & A -.
@ ( 0
?
& A !/
"#34 6:
/0 : *3 "#340 &
2
& & "#+39++ "#++ 0& 0 & 0 !3
!!+ !!4 "#430 C ( 0 /!6 ,
2&-( 7 & ."#/$
9 0 : 6:
/?"
!+ *+ "#43-6:
/?!. 0 ( 80 *3 *"
"#4+-6:
%. !!+ 5
&
0 C 00 & &00 9 0 0 & 0
"3"?"#?" "3"?!*?"
!+
& 0C
5
0 !"
"!
"#$% !!+!!4
2:
& & "*0 , & 0 ( ( , ( /!0 2
0 ( 0= > 0 F 9:
@"
!!+ !!/ 10 0 0&
;
"
!!+0 & :
2 2 & 9 &
!!+ !!4 0 5
"#43 0
& "#34
& 0
!4
F
( 8 *3 *"
"#4+6:
% 0 0 & 9 0&& 0 ( 00 &
!$
' & 0&, & 9 -.
7!
8 + 8!(" !*"+-!.(((%%+-B2.
8 &
5
-.
5 '
-('-6!+8 7!!#)''-6!+ # '
("
')"#++(!#!
80 & &
0
!#
9
9 0& 0 & "#340 2
0 ( 0
& ?
!!+ !!40 0 - .
0
0 9 & "#34
2
(
3 6:
!0 &5
!!+ 0 &9 0
' 0 !!4 5
0
2
0 0
9 ( 0 & %*
:
( 0 & %* & $ 1 0
5
& *3 "#340 0 0 &"#$% %"
0 &?
!!/ 0 & 0
%!
& 9
& & &
!!+ !!40 & G & ?
!!/0 1 0 0
&
(5 0
& &
0
4 &
0
2
0
0 ( 0 *3 "#34 %%
& & , & ( 05 0 0
& && 0 0
( 0
&
%/
'( ( 0
0 9 0 & 0 0 & @ 0 &
& & 0 (
0 & 0 & - !!/. 00 & & &
% 0 & &0) "***?
& *3 "#34-6:
/.
& '
&0 ( 0 0
& ,
2 & % 5 0
( 0 &
9 0
& 0 & 0 &: !!/
%3
( &!5 0 0 6:
/0 & &
': 5 0
&
0 & " ! & 0 ( && &
& "4)& 0 ,
&& 0 & 0 5 & , & 2&( !
!
'! # # '
(8.
(!
** '
( ')"#3" +!3
%+
8 , & 9 - . 00 09 ="!
& ' 0& 0
& 0 & 0 '
0 &
' 0 & 0&0 & 0& 0 & 0
& &
0 5 & 0
& 0 & 0 > -F 07'H""**$*. ' 0 F 00 & & 0 & 0 5 & 0 0& ?
%4
5 :
+ 8 *- ;!(
(#"+!
!# -"#4+.
%((""#0 09 ="*
'0 & 0& =-".
5
0 G -!.
G -%.
& 0 & G -/.
' 0 & 0 & 0& 2
0 &
& &
& ' :& &
0 "4-!. )& &
G -3.
0
& 0
0& 6
& 5 0& 0 & 0 0 && G -+.
6 0 & & 0 5
& &
& > %$
'
6:
/ & 0
? - &.0 0 0 & & - & & - . &0 ) "***?9- & .
%#
20 && 0 0 5 && 0
&& 05 & "4 )& "#*$ "4 -".- . -. -!. -. 9 ="4 0& I-. 0& & 0
0 : 0C JK'"$+/' )& "$++ ' )& "$4"' )& "$44 I :::::
:::::
:::::
:::::
- .
9 0 & :& 0 &0& 0
G -.
9 0 0&
& : &G
:::::
:::::
:::::
:::::
-!.
C&
- . -.
9-. I
& :::::
:::::
:::::
:::::
-.
L
9-".M & & && &:& & & 0
& &
000: & :& &G> :::::
:::::
:::::
::::: /*
5 0 6:
/0 0 0"4-".- .
-.
9!"4
' : &0 & & 0 &
0 ( 0 &&0
<
- .& 00 ,
& 0 5
20& - . 5 0
5 & & 0
0 & & & ? 0 && 0 0 , 0& 0 5 &
&& "4-".- . -.
0 0
:
9
-.
9-!.
0 0 - .
-. 0 F 0 0 &
&
& <
0
0
& & ? : 6:
/ & , - .
;&
& &0&0 0 '0 & 0 ( 0 0 0&0 & & ? , 0
0& &
( 0& 0
&
"4' )& "#*$
/"
(5 5 0
0
/!
( &5 0 & !% , & 0, & ( 0
&
0 && & & "#++
*3 "#34-6:
/.0
G ( 6:
! & !!+ !!4 ,
: '& & 0 "#++ 0
09:
& 0
& 0 & 0) ,& 0
&
&& 0 :& "* *!
"#++
$ # "#340 6 & & 0 0 & & &
0& 0 -6:
@!?". 10
( 6:
/?"
!!+0 0 ( & ( 6:
! 0 : 0 & *3 "#34 0 &
&2
& ? /%
( 0- , . 0 & - &. 0 ( &
7 ( 0
G
&
&, 0 % C 0 &&& & C 00 :
&
9 & 0
0 C
, ( , : //
(5 ( ( 00
& 6: !%-( .
/?" - 9 ( . "#340 0 ( "#4394+
&3 /3
( 0 & & %* & *3 "#34 -
!+ .0 & 0 & 0: 0
& !+ "#$%0 0
? 0 &"#++
( -6:
/?".
29& !+ & 6:
/( & 0
& 0
9 & & &
& - ?
!!/.
00 & , 2& " ! ! 0 & & /+
(5 5 0
0 /4
6 & & 0 ( 0
0&%5 0 9 0
& , & *3 "#34
&4 0 0 ?
!!/
0 !!+ !!4 &
( 0 && &&
0 & 0 !!/ ( 0 0 1 0 2 0 & & & ( 0 & 0 0
&
& *3 "#349 0 &
&
-
. & -9 ) &.
& 0 % /$
& && ( 0 %3 +
0& ( " !
& /
&0 -
0 & % 3 & ( .
&% 0 9 & <.0= 8 (%1& %
? @
&? ;?C @
;?C