← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2683/2002allowed

Vijay Kumar v. Ramkali

2023-09-26Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra12 pages



     ! "  !  #

! %!* +

 , 

+-.

 ,     

         



  ( / 0( $  $ ($ 

 

 

 ! "!

# 



  $  "  %& %'

(%()

*** ($ 

 1

  &

+ 

  #

         &, %- (%%(           .  /!0   1"

2 3)#(%%%



 4   %& %) (%%%

 ##1"2 (%,#&''3 1 #  1"// ."!56 ! 4 

4 

(

7 6#"!   #

  #      "

)

+#   #  ## "   44  # 4 66     #   64  81.

22

44   $4   66#  # 9 &,%:;  

#4 6  # 

 66<4 <   #  4  ! # ! ##  "    &%3#+ # #    "66<  

 #  +##    "    66  !   # !      #        #

 4# ###   66 #  # " # # &(%%:;

 #  #  #  %& %& &''3)& %= &''3

-

> #!##4        !; #     # $

4  ?  !4 #  6644 266 #  44



# 44 <  #" #  # $@&( && &'=A

+ 4  ##66#

#266  66"     #  <!&'

%A &''3! 66##  # ,%%%:; $   #" #  4 !#4  #66<4  # >4 

22

 4# ;;4# ### 4!4!

 !1 8   <  # #8 ! ## 44    >4  6#

 266  #  4 "!#

$@&( && &'=A#"

>4   "    ##   "  

@    !  #  #

,

+ ###  "  6 4   ; #  ?  # !#44   1 "  (% %) &''A ;

&

@ #  ##"

    # &,%:;  B?55

(

># & "!4  ##

" #

 # B>#4$B?55

)

@    ##      # "   #

#   #  #B?55

-

@  ##      #  B?5.

,

#

+  4  " 

# "  + ##$ 5@;&/  !"# " #

4 $

5@;(  4     #  $   #  4   !  .@;& !.@;(8!   !.@;)5  1!.@;-    #

4 $.@;,

#    "   

"  !  1 "   %& %) (%%%! # ##  "# " 4  "  

  #  4  # "# " 66<

=

7 "! ###"

     1    #  #   

  4 4 4"  &, %- (%%( >4

##4 " 4 #  4

" 66# +

 4  !  # 1 4 # ##4    #

#66 #" # ##  #

" # # &(%%:;#  #44

'

.#4 !

;# #" 7

           7  

  1      

    ;

##44 #66    # $ 4     7



"

   "  ""    ;

##

 "  +#" 7

 1 4    4   #4 + # !4       7

4   4      1  "

  

#   "  

&%

+   $ 

&&

!4   

 

#5 !  C+1    -&#5 1  !&'&=  &%%#1#1"5  ! # !1  



"#   1  4 #  #"## #   "  # 

 !            1  8     #  D    1  565+7 &!.)7 870 +-  7 . 5!(%&3 311&,A  !4 E 

!1  

#   1  7 

!   4 !   "  

#"    # 4         9 (7:.- 

;:!(%(%&'11,A!

4 4 "  D   1 1 # 

 

####4 ;

22

 +1  4"   " "F  +1 " 44 # #   " # 

4

F

 +1 "4   # #

    #        +<:

 -  (  *5 +:= &!.) 7 87 0 +!(%(& &(11 ,('! 4  D       1    "            #   4 <##  #

! 

 @ 1 #"4 4  1  4" " #"4 

#"G## #    

 H!1  4 # # 4# &(

4 "    # 

 +    #" 7

44 ##!"  ""  !  44 #66     # $ 4   7 

"! 7

  4"  "   

;

#4   >4 "   266  4  

    " 466$!# #266    4

2>2

4  266 



" 4 6 

4266  ! # !4 

;

##  4 #66  ?   4  !1 #   7

    

4   ># 4  

2 )#4   

;#

 # # 266 4   # 266 $ @&( && &'=A#" # 4 66" 

  >4  # #  !

 #266 ! 4    1 8 <  4" #  !#  4"   4266  4        +     7  

  1        

4 #66  #  4  #4 + # !1   "  7



  4 #  4 4  266    



&)

+ 7

   I$ 5;3

" 44 #  66 

 >4 " 7

.@;)5  1

2#2

444#

 #  # #  4 66 44    

! # ! # #4  # " 66   #   4    4" !  # # #.@;)5  1  #I$ 5;3!1   "4    

#"   + I$ 5;3

 G  H  4" !  #

  ?!5 !56 #   "    "     

  4  "    

   66 " 

 4 "I$ 5;3!4 

4" 66 &, %= &''3 + " # ?!

5! !56 4#



  $           "          4   #   ?

+

4     "  6

 4 4  66< 4   ;

##4   4    4   6   2 !.@;)5  14  4 " I$ 5;34   #

  44  I$ 5;3 4  4 4 4 !1  

2,2

  "    ## 



# 44 #66  

 

&-

!"4#  "!   #" 7

 I$ 5;3  #.@;) 4  !4 

 

# "!

 # !   #  

# "  # 

&,

I #  !4#  

  "  " "44 #66  $  

 > 4  !#   44   #266  

!4    4 #

4 266    ##   44" 466 4$ 44 266 !4#   "4 

  4 #  2   

!4$   4  4 #

 4 266 "    # !4    

  +  " 

 "4 4   #  66   4   

22

 4 #"    #  " 4$    5@;&/  !  

   # 4  "4 466 4

  

   4  4$  #4 

4    !" 4266 44 4"    266    4  # ;;4  #      + # !     "# 

 !    "   4# 4     "44 #     



&3

 ! " 

    44  266 !

4 <  #" #.@;-  44  #  $@I$ .;&#"    "I$ .;( +

!  @I$ .;&4 # # 4$  266    266 "4 4 "     # !   "#@ I$ .;& I$ .;( #   4

   266 " " 4  664$!  # ;;4!  

22

 # +$#@I$ .;& ! 

" 

 $ .@;&!  !.@;( 8  !    4      @        $   

 #@ !.@;- 4    +44  ;$  

  #  4  $# @  266 #" #.@;- .@;-"

 4 #     ! 4  "$#I$ .;&  266

&A

@!   "   1  7

 4" < "# I$ .;&I$ .;( > 

  !4 "#@I$ .;& # I$ .;(   ;

## 4 # 4   4  4

#  !   44  

#266 66 4 #

266 ! # !#   #

44

     4

 

4 4 #66  44  

  "    

 " 4 

" " 66 .@;- 4   4 #  " #@I$ .;&  

22

 #   "I$ .;( !1  #" 7

   !   "  +   #7

4 !      1    +# 

;

## 

4 +   

&=



!#! #

&($  )  ,  

!  @  6:

 J:2 @   J:2