← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4852/2019disposed of

Dharampal v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-03-28Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj12 pages

    

  !



"  

  "





#$% &'

%()*)&+   



 ,

 

-  .

 !



  -

   

  / ,  

- 0 -

 

                  ! "      #$%        #& 0 -

 



 , '     (    )

                        ) * + "               ,$$-$. / 0 1&2("03  ) )  )      " 3   #&(    3

 ) 

  $-4$   $-4     

)  5 3

  33  "   ) 6  "7 '   3 (  8

 9 (

)8 

   

(3

    )    #&1 !) : 8     /   

    ;:<2     

 ) 33("=    )  )3 )    9

    )  = 

    

(3 ("  >  3  ?   $-$-$% '      3    $-$-$%       )  =  #,   ( 

(3("> 3 ? =  3 

   ( 

(3("#('  /    #%2           (

(3 ("    "933

   "933

     ,$-,-$%       3      > *  ? (  $-$-$%'    :(  ) 

        0  : ) 6   3 " )  !): @      " ( )     $A$--$%  3   "   *   ?        0 1    3  $B-,-$%  *  ? ' "

      ) 

  $-4$   $-4   :    )     ' 

 :    ! "    :3  

" "933

                $-A-$%     :     )

 )  3   



 ("    

  =   

        (  

 )  )    (   3   "       0(  (      " (    #$  ("  " :   ! "    

  * + "(" " *  ?   (  

  :

 )$-4

)" 

   "  "5 )   =     

   :  )3      3  ) :          97C   " (  )  (" 3 '  9 "  )! " '

 97C   ) 

" 

     3 )3 

  

 $-4       

   

33  3("* + "   

 ) -&--$.    A /2   ! "  : *      --, 3  --&      #&1:  " )  (    3

(   3

  =    

    #&

(3 ":     )   " -$&1$. 9

D $-  "

   ) )     #&1: ,$-$-$D    *3   ! "    03  

  #&1=   3 )    )    (       



 $B-,-$D

(" *   ?   )    #&1:       (  )           :  " *   ! "        3    *  ? )  )  +       3  )3    (  ) 3      C  

   )   :3   

 )    3  3E!):8 F       (   " )    3  3   "  :

 )     

  " )    3 6      : :  "   3  ! " :*   3  

 (      " 933

     

(3  * + "

  33  $AA5   $-A-$%   

:

 )

$-4   (

 =  

(  )  

)    . :    ?

 # 1,5$-5  ,$-,-$- ' 

 )    *3  " *   '    )        3   



 *3    -B-$-$&     )        3    (     *3   

     )    (:8    #%5%A1

 -$% :/*2  .$-  3     3  0 3

 -,1A =    "   #&)   3 

   3

 '      

6 

  :    )  @ :





(3

3  @  ) 

3  *3     3 " 933   (" *3       

         " / 0  12   

$-4$ $-4 ( ) : =  ("  * + " 933     (  )  

  3"(   (  ) 

  ()   5 "+ (  )     3  ('( 

(" *3  " *   ?         *3  " *   ! "       "   3 

(3 ("    13        (   "  +        3"       )   (  )  ) ) 3  3 6

=  

 (  ) #%5%A1-$%:/*2.$-  "  ) 9@#D&$1-,   3   ( 

  3   0 $-&-, #  5   

  3  ("

    ( ("   7  

            

  1      )       

     " ( 9

$-4 ( )

 3     !           ) 

    33 

3"(    (  )    (  

 ("            

"(" " :   97C 

(  )( )   " 

" 

 =  3 " )    )(  (

 )$-4$ $-4 

  3 :   

  

"  (  ("3=   " ( (" *3          (     (" 3 !                     3  0 3 "     "     " (       #& @   )     

    :            (    ("  :     (   " : :  ":*  9  "  (   (   3   : *      (     (" *3   !    

 +     )   )   :     

       :    0   "

    :  )      )    "   *3  " *    3   "     *3  " *      " 

     ) )  9  "          (    ("     :  "

2 *     3 !

(3   #&1 :     

 3 )      

 

  (  " 33    3  

  3

 

(  "   3 

("9   

      )   )    (" 

  (   9

     #&1:      

   ("       * + "      "   *   ?  

     *   ?         "  -$%        3    

" )   $-4$   $-4 

 !      

(   3    

(3 ("       * + " 933     ("    *   ?  

 )     ' * + "933 "   $-4$ $-4

( )  3  +   !           #&1: 

 )  " 

  "      :   :  " : !     

   #&        )    )     :  :  " : '  

(3 

 )  " 

  "     933     

    ("     

           " 

 !     

     )    )   

    "  ( 

(3          #&1:

    "

!3 " )    

(3("* + "933    $A$--$%  

( 3  )

  '   )       * + "   

   (     )!

(3  3  

(  (  +    (03 (" 9   0  



     )  

                

  

3  (           !

(3    :     3 

 "

 '0  

 A! " *    --, 3  " --&  "  " )  

)  5    ("   +   '    : *   ( )   ) "      #&1 :           (  

5 33   3    3   "   

 )        !

(3     )       (            )   )    3 

 9

 D   $-  3 )    !     )  

 )    ( )     +  (  ) )



("  )  ) " "  "(     13 #    (      ((  (

("

9  =      

   )   (  

       )   )   3      )

  

  '   

"   +      "    )"    "     #&1:    )

$-4$ $-4   +  '   

    3                   $A$--$%

(3 ("   "   *   ?    *  ?  =    

(  "

 * + "933     +   )    

 )           ) $-4$ $-4

  ( )

 3  +     -$& =     (       (  )      " (  

       )   

)  5       (  )    "   )       3 :     3  ! "  =        )      (    1

3    (" 3 *3  " *            : :  " : *   ! "   )  

  * + "       )   )    "    )     #&1:      (  

    )   )       #&1 : (    333 3  03

  -,1A *   )  9  0

    

        "   )     )  +  

(3 "(  " -$&     )      "   3(  -        3    -B "

      )        

(     

    

  "         )=   0  33        ( " 3   ("    

     *3     3 ! "  33 3    3:

  "  13              =        0             :  " *         )  

  #&1: 

" ) 

  " )             "     ! "  : *      --, 3     "  --&

1  :  :      "   )          " )  5 

     :  " *    "    

    3  ( )    3      +        3 (" "       =            1   :   :  " *    )   )   

   #&G:      " 

  

 ) 3    3     ,A   ! "  : *      --,               13 "      #

     

 " ( 

(3 ("

  #& :      "

  ( 

)   ) )          9 03 )" "  :  :  " :*   5 

3              "

 = (   "

    ( 

3     "   3  



    

 )     

 

 ("        :  :     (                 ("   " :  :     "(   "   3 "

    9   )

(   3            

(3

  

   "  -$%    3  * + " 933

(3 ) 

 

  3             ) * + "933 ) (  )("     "  )     

   ) 

(   * + " 933    (       

   

 = 

(

3    

$-4$ $-4  

 ) 3   +   =                  

      " 35   #&1: 

"   )     

 )         33 3  03

  3

   3"      3   '    ( 

 

3            =  "            3" )       

(( "    3     " ( 

 3    =           (     )      

(  3     

("   *3  " *   =      

  

    

  ( 

         ' 3     )"   ) #3(4 1  

0 -

 

 3#5 #3&3#

"