Jasvir Singh v. State Of Punjab

 
    
 

!"#$#%&'&() 

!'*&+&(,- ..#//!(" *#+'0'

"!"#0(1!2   #'.($#("

3) 4 53 
35 +#'#(") 3+6!7!/.+##" !8!9$*%!"#9 +"-#!..#//!("

3+ :!/&!9+90(1!2  359 ;+!/<

="-&'!..#!/9"-#!..#//!("%-!//#(,#'-&'%(*&%"&(2="-# /#!+(#$  0$,#9  .#%&!/ 
0+"9  3,!9  +  "-#  %77&''&(    !(  #(%# .0(&'-!2/#  0($#+  #%"&(   ;%<    "-#  !+%"&%  +0,'  !($  '=%-"+.&% 02'"!(%#'%"9> ;-#+#&(!"#++##++#$"2#!'"-#%"<9!'!/'"-#+$#+ '#("#(%#&7.'&(,!.0(&'-7#("=#!+'4+&,+0'&7.+&'(7#("0.( -&79&(!$$&"&("!&(#' 9? -!*&(,2##(&7.'#$9&($#!0/" 8-&%--#&'"0+"-#+0($#+,+&,+0'&7.+&'(7#("+@7("-'  '.#+"-#%!'#"-#.+'#%0"&(90A-1&($#+&(,-9!/(, 8&"-
 !/1&($#+&(,-!($'7#"-#+./&%#&%&!/'98!'.+#'#("!"

0,-&.0+!
-8A!//&(,0($#+"-#10+&'$&%"&(/&%#"!"&(3#-(!9 &'"+&%"3,!9(.!"+//&(,$0"=98-#+#"-#&''"!"#$"-!*#+#%#&*#$ '#%+#"&(+7!"&("-!""-#!..#//!("9 !'*&+&(,-'(!&2&(,-9+#'&$#("

*&//!,#!/8!($& -!&9&'&("-#-!2&"'#//&(,.&0798-&%--#8!'$&(, !""-!".&("!/'9!""-# 0'"!($95&(A!$93#-(! -#&''"!"#$"-!*#+#$0%#$&("8+&"&(,"-#&(+7!"&(

 +#%#&*#$9!"#+8-&%--#!/(,8&"--&'.!+"=+#!%-#$"-#20''"!($98-#+#(# %/#!('-!*#(.#+'(8!''##("2#'"!($&(,;!'.#+"-#.+'#%0"&(*#+'&(<9 8-('##&(,"-#./&%#.!+"=4,".#+./#B#$4!($8!'!..+#-#($#$ ( #(C0&+=9-#&''"!"#$"-!*#$&'%/'#$-&'(!7#!' !'*&+&(,-;"-#.+#'#("

!..#//!("<

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

+%#/'.+#.!+#$;"-#'!7./#!($"-#+#7!&(&(, ,+!7'<9 8-&%-8!'"-#('#!/#$8&"-"-#'#!/"-#92#!+&(,"-#&7.+#''&(44 -#'#!/&''"!"#$"-!*#2##(-!($#$*#+"
 !/1&($#+ &(,-98&"-"-##("&+#%!'#.+.#+"="!A#(&(.''#''&(*&$#!+#%*#+= 7#7%0++#(%=("#'? !($!72&/#.-(#9!.0+'#!($!$+&*&(, /&%#(%#8#+#!/''"!"#$"-!*#2##(+#%*#+#$9!//8-&%-8#+#"!A#(&(" .''#''&(*&$#'#.!+!"#+#%*#+=7#7' 
&'"-#('"!"#$"-!

0+(!7&(,-"/&%#"!"&(3#-(!9("-#2!'&'8-&%-!(8!' +#,&'"#+#$2=E!A##/&(,-!($"-##("&+#%!'#.+.#+"=9&(%/0$&(,"-# '!7./#98#+#"!A#(&(".''#''&('&"#./!(&'!/''"!"#$"-!*#2##( .+#.!+#$

 "!"#7#("'"-#8&"(#''#'8#+#!/''"!"#$"2#+#%+$#$("-# '."9!"#+8-&%-!'.#%&!/+#.+"&''"!"#$"-!*#2##('#("&("#+7' #%"&( "-#%"9""-#9-!+!7A"F;B >2#+#"-#"+&!/
0+"< -#!%%0'#$!($"-#%!'#.+.#+"=!/(,8&"-"-#4
5+74 8#+#.+$0%#$2#+#"-#/#!+(#$0"=3!,&'"+!"#93,!98&"-"-#/#!+(#$ 3!,&'"+!"#'"!"#$"-!*#'#!/#$"-#%!'#.+.#+"=!'!/'"-#'!7./#"!A#(&( "-#
0+"98&"-"-#'#!/2#!+&(,"-#&7.+#''&(43498&"-!$&+#%"&(" $#.'&"&"&("-#./&%#  -#!..#//!(""-#(&''"!"#$"-!*#2##( '#(""./&%#%0'"$= -#+#.+""-#
-#7&%!/B!7&(#+8!'.+#'#("#$2#+#"-# /#!+(#$"+&!/
0+"!'B  90.("-#7!""#+-!*&(,2##(%77&""#$""-!"
0+"-#.-",+!.-'"-#&(*#("+=8#+#!/'#B-&2&"#$2#+#"-#"+&!/
0+"!'B':

?":

?


 -#  .+'#%0"&(  #B!7&(#$   8&"(#''#'9  &(%/0$&(,  "-# (*#'"&,!"&(,&%#+;0A-1&($#+&(,-<!': 9
('"!2/#-&*1!("

&(,-!':98&"-8-7"-#%!'#.+.#+"=8!'$#.'&"#$2=E!A##/ &(,-9E!A##/&(,-;:

<9
 !/1&($#+&(,-;:<!($
0+&($#+ &(,-  ;:

<9  "-#  '!&$  8&"(#''#'  -!*&(,  "#'"&&#$  !'  .#+ "-#  .+'#%0"&( *#+'&(!/+#!$=(!++!"#$-#+#&(!2*# @ -#!..#//!("7!$#!'"!"#7#("&("#+7'#%"&(  
+
9 $#(=&(,#!%-!//#,!"&(!,!&('"-&7!($'"!"&(,"-!""-#%!'#-!$2##(./!("#$

0.(-&7(!%%0("!$&'.0"#8&"-"-#8(#+"-#"+0%A"-!"-#8!' $+&*&(,9&#(# +&15!/9(!%%0("8-&%-$&'.0"#"-#'!&$ +&15!/-!$ !/'#/=&7./&%!"#$-&7&("-#%!'# ('0..+"-&'!+#'!&$'"!"#7#("9"-#!..#//!("!/'#B!7&(#$

8&"(#''#'&(-&'$##(%#;"-#=2#&(,:
-!+!(1&"&(,-9:!+!71&" &(,-!($:


('"!2/#!1&($#+&(,-< :!($:!/'"#'"&&#$&("#+7'"-#'"!"#7#("7!$#2= "-#!..#//!("0($#+#%"&(  
+
9""-###%""-!""-#!..#//!("-!$! $&'.0"#8&"- +&15!/9 

!"+0%A0(&(9!($"-!"!%"0!//=-#-!$2##( &7./&%!"#$&("-#%!'#(!%%0(""-!"98&"-"-#!..#//!("-!*&(,2##( !++#'"#$+7-&'-0'#&("-#.+#'#(%#"-#'#8&"(#''#'!'!/'&("-# .+#'#(%#-&'!7&/=7#72#+'!($"-!"("-&(,&(%+&7&(!"&(,8!'+#%*#+#$ +7-&7 -#'#8&"(#''#'!/'$#.'#$"-!""-#=&(!%""/$"-#./&%# &%&!/'8&"-+#,!+$""-#$&'.0"#!($"-!""-#=80/$,#"!%7.+7&'# ##%"#$2#"8##("-#.!+"&#'9!"#+8-&%-"-#="A"-#!%%0'#$""-#./&%# '"!"&(!($'02'#C0#("/=%!7#"A(8"-!"-#-!$2##(!/'#/=&7./&%!"#$&( "-#%!'#&(C0#'"&( '+#,!+$':

9"-0,--&'"#'"&7(=-!'("2##($&'%0''#$&( "-#10$,7#(""-#/#!+(#$"+&!/
0+"9!.#+0'!/"-#+#+7"-#+#%+$ '077(#$2="-&'
0+"9'-8'"-!"-#'&7./="#'"&&#$8&"-+#,!+$"-!*&(, 2+0,-""-# 
   ;!&/=&!+=#.+"<$!"#$  9.#+"!&(&(," +#,&'"+!"&((

("-!"$!"#9!'+#,!+$'"-##(%#7!$#0"!,!&('" "-#!..#//!(" (%+'' #B!7&(!"&(9"-&'8&"(#'''"!"#$"-!"-#"-#+8&'#A(#8

("-&(,!20""-#%!'#  *#("0!//=9(%('&$#+&(,"-#!+#'!&$#*&$#(%#9"-#/#!+(#$ "+&!/
0+"$&'2#/&#*#$"-#$##(%#8&"(#''#';:!($:<9("-#,+0($ "-!"(%7./!&("8!'7!$#"!(=-&,-#+!0"-+&"=8&"-+#,!+$"!/'# &7./&%!"&("-#!..#//!("
('#C0#("/=9  (  "-#  2!'&'    "-#  .+'#%0"&(  #*&$#(%#9  "-# !..#//!("8!'-#/$,0&/"="-#%-!+,#+!7#$!,!&('"-&7!'!/+#!$=("&%#$ &("-#.#(&(,.!+!"-&'10$,7#("!($'#("#(%#$!%%+$&(,/= 

#+#"-&'
0+"9/#!+(#$%0('#/+"-#!..#//!("&+'"'027&"' "-!":
 !/1&($#+&(,-'"!"#$&(-&'%+'' #B!7&(!"&("-!"-#$&$(" A(8!'"8-!"8!'+#%*#+#$+7"-#!..#//!(" #0+"-#+.&("'""-#!%""-!"&(-&'%+'' #B!7&(!"&("-# '!7#8&"(#''!/''"!"#$"-!"$&$("+#7#72#+"-#%/0++#(,&(#!($ %-!''&'(072#+"-#*#-&%/#9+#*#(!'"8-7"-#*#-&%/#2#/(,#$9&( 8-&%-  "-#=  8#+#  ,&(,  +  .!"+//&(,  #  !/'  $&$  ("  +#7#72#+  &"' +#,&'"+!"&((072#+ #!/'.&("'0""-!""-&'80/$2#+!"-#+'"+!(,#&(*&#8"-# !%""-!":

0A-1&($#+&(,-98-&''"!"#$"-!*#7!$#"-#+#%*#+= +7"-#!..#//!("9'"!"#$&(-&'%+'' #B!7&(!"&("-!""-#%!+0'#$8!'-&' 8(.+&*!"#%!+9!/',&*&(,"-#(072#+"-!"%!+9"-0,-8-&%--#-!$$0/= #("#+#$&("-# 5#!+(#$%0('#/+"-#!..#//!("0+"-#+'027&"'"-!"&"80/$2# '"+!(,#"-!"
 !/1&($#+&(,-#*#($&$("A(8"-!""-#%!+2#/(,#$" 0A-1&($#+&(,-9-&'&77#$&!"#'#(&+%//#!,0#&("-#'!7#./&%# '"!"&(

@ #0+"-#+'027&"'"-!"!'!7!""#+!%"9"-#(072#+"-# *#-&%/#&'(",&*#(#*#(&("-#;B:

?< #(#B"'027&"'"-!""-#$##(%#8&"(#''#'!/'-!*&(,"#'"&&#$ &("#+7'"-#'"!"#7#("7!$#2="-#!..#//!("0($#+#%"&(  
+
9"-# /#!+(#$"+&!/
0+"#++#$&(("2#/&#*&(,"-#&+"#'"&7(&#''&7./=2#%!0'#( !../&%!"&(-!$2##(7!$#""-#-&,-#+!0"-+&"= > 5#!+(#$"!"#%0('#/("-#"-#+-!($'027&"'"-!":9

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

*#//#$9"-0,--#$&$(" +#7#72#+"-#+#,&'"+!"&((072#+!($7!+A"-#*#-&%/#98-&%--#'027&"' &'  ("  '0+.+&'&(,9  !'  (2$=  80/$  ,#(#+!//=  +#7#72#+  "-#  +#,&'"+!"&( (072#+"-#*#-&%/#9&&"&'("-&'8(*#-&%/# #  +#&"#+!"#'  "-!"  !'  ("&%#$  2=  "-#  /#!+(#$  "+&!/ 
0+"9  ( !../&%!"&("!(=-&,-#+!0"-+&"=98&"-+#,!+$"!/'#&7./&%!"&(98!'7!$# #&"-#+2="-#!..#//!("+!(=!(=-&'!

  !*&(,  %('&$#+#$  "-#  !+#'!&$  !+,07#("'  !($  !/'  -!*&(, .#+0'#$"-#(#%#''!+=.!+""-#+#%+$9"-0,-&($"-!"8-!""-#/#!+(#$ "+&!/ 
0+" -#/$ !' +#,!+$' ( !../&%!"&( -!*&(, 2##( 7*#$ "  -&,-#+ !0"-+&"&#'!'+#,!+$'!/'#&7./&%!"&(980/$("2#8-//=0('0'"!&(!2/# +#!'(&(,9-8#*#+98&"-8&"(#''#'-!*&(,"#'"&&#$""-###%""-!""-# !..#//!("8!'!%"0!//=!++#'"#$+7-7#98-#"-#+"-#!../&%!"&(8!'(" 7!$#(!%%0("#!++"-#+8&'#980/$2#'7#"-&(,8-&%-80/$ %+#!"#  '7# $02" :-!"  0+"-#+  $#'  %+#!"#  ! $02" (  "-# 7!((#+   +#%*#+=!($!++#'"9&'"-#!%""-!"
 !/1&($#+&(,-'"!"#$&(-&'%+''

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

? #B-&2&"#$2#+#"-#/#!+(#$"+&!/
0+"9"-!""-0,-: 0A-1&($#+ &(,-"#'"&&#$""-###%""-!"-#-!$#("#+#$"-#(072#+"-#*#-&%/#&( "-#+   !%"0!//="-!"&'&(%++#%"98&"-('0%-(072#+,&*#(!"#("+=

( 9.#+"!&(&(,"-&7!($"-#./&%#.!+"=,&(,+.!"+//&(,!" .79 ("-#$!"#&(C0#'"&(F;"-0,-"-#$!"#&'("'.#%&&%!//=,&*#(&("-#%.= "-#   !'8-&%-8!'#B-&2&"#$2#+#"-#"+&!/
0+"<-0'9#*#( -#$&$("#("#+"-#(072#+"-#%!+9"-0,-&"8!''"!"#$"2#-&'8( *#-&%/# -!"2#&(,'9&("-#.&(&("-&'
0+""-#+#!+#"7!(= &(%('&'"#(%&#'&("-#'"+="-#.+'#%0"&(9&(%/0$&(,"-#!%""-!""-# ./&%#&%&!/'-8("2#!%%7.!(=&(,"-#./&%#.!+"=9$&$("#*#(A(8 "-!""-#*#-&%/#"-!"-#"+!*#//#$&(2#/(,#$"-&'8('#(&+%//#!,0#9(+ #*#( &"' %/0+9"-0,- &" 8!' .!+A#$ &( "-#./&%#'"!"&( .+#7&'#'9 !' %("#($#$ 0+"-#+9"-#!%""-!""-#.#+'("8-7"-#.+&*!"#*#-&%/#&' '"!"#$"2#2#/(,&(,9&#0A-1&($#+&(,-;: <9!/'$&$("!%"0!

//= #("#+"-#(072#+"-#*#-&%/#&("-#$!&/=$&!+=9"-0,--#"#'"&&#$2#+# "-#"+&!/
0+""-!"-#-!$'#("#+#$&" -#  .#+'(  '"!"#$  "  -!*#  2##(  1&(#$  !'  !(  4&($#.#($#(" 8&"(#''49!""-#"&7#"-#!//#,#$+#%*#+="-#%("+!2!($9&# -0.&($#+ &(,-98!'!/'("#B!7&(#$2="-#.+'#%0"&(!'!8&"(#'' "&//0+"-#+9&"!..#!+''"+!(,#""-&'%0+""-!"!./&%#.!+"= %('&'"&(,!"/#!'" " ./&%#&%&!/'"-#+"-!("-#9$#'.&"#-!*&(, !/+#!$=!..+#-#($#$"-#!..#//!(" !%%0'#$9%0/$(".+$0%#-&72#+#"-# (#!+#'",!D#""#$&%#+3!,&'"+!"#!($&('"#!$,"4!%('#("7#74'&,(#$ 2=-&798&"-(+#!'(,&*#(!'"8-=-#%0/$("!%"0!//='.+$0%#$ (  "-&'  +#,!

       
 

(##$'

> "2#+##++#$"98-#+#&(#*#("0!//="-#&+5+$'-&.'-#/$!'//8') 

      !" # $%&' !( (  

  !   ) *         ++  +   + !(+    + !      ! ! !

 ) ,   -   +   !+ 



   !.        #      $%&  '      ( /  +  0 +   +(  +( ++ +      +(!

(++ +        1 

   ( (2     

3  '!


 45

  3

 6   (    + ++  !(  ++( 78 +  !  91*(  (+    + 

    +  * 2 + +  *  + : 3

-                   

 !  + + ;/ # $%&'             
     
  ! + 

 !. #  + 



 4 $+  / 

   ! !++ /  # !    +   +! !+ !++ ( ( !+  +   ! +

3
- ++  #     *    !   ),  !

 

(    (                  +!    ! ,   "(    (      +    +(    + (          (+(   ++ ;

;7.-!'&'!../&#$2="-&'
0+"< #(%#9  !//  "-#  !+#'!&$  %&+%07'"!(%#'  '##(  ",#"-#+9  8&"- #'.#%&!//="8$##(%#8&"(#''#'!/'-!*&(,"#'"&&#$""-###%""-!""-# !..#//!(" !%%0'#$8!'!%"0!//=.&%A#$0.+7-&'-7#(!%%0("! $&'.0"#!+&'&(,2#"8##(-&7!($"-#/#!$#+"-#+0%A(&(9 +&15!/9!($ "-0,-"-#="+&#$"##%"!%7.+7&'#9"-#%!'#8!',"+#,&'"#+#$!,!&('" -&79!+#"7!(=!%"+'8-&%-9&("-#.&(&("-&'
0+"9$%+#!"#!*#+= ,+!*#$02"!'"8-#"-#+"-#.#"&"&(#+8!'!%"0!//=!..+#-#($#$8&"-"-# %("+!2!($+"-#'7!//C0!("&"=!20" ,+!7'.&078!''&7./= '-8("2#+#%*#+#$+7-&7 (7=.&(&(9&('0%-%&+%07'"!(%#'9"-#"+&!/
0+"+#/&#$" 70%-("-#!%""-!""-#$##(%#8&"(#''#'-!$("!..+!%-#$!(='#(&+ &%#+8&"-+#,!+$""-#!..#//!(" !%%0'#$-!*&(,2##(!/'#/=&(*/*#$&( "-#%!'# (*&#8"-#!2*#9"-#&7.0,(#$10$,7#(""-#/#!+(#$



0$,#9.#%&!/
0+"93,!9&'-#+#2='#"!'&$#!($"-#!..#//!("&'!%C0&""#$ "-#%-!+,#+!7#$!,!&('"-&70($#+#%"&( "-#%"9,&*&(,-&7"-# 2#(#&"$02" #9%('#C0#("/=92#+#/#!'#$+7%0'"$=+"-8&"-    












 .A?(&"&(?$&(#'- 






























  :-#"-#+'.#!A&(,?+#!'(#$ 

#'

:-#"-#+#.+"!2/#

#'