Raju Gurang v. State
!" # !$ %%&&!'
( '!' )*+!,$!+ % '
!" #$%$&'
*! ,- !'! .,/!
- !' '+!%%&&!'
! &-& 1&, '
-)*+!,$!+ ( "
*+,,'!'!%%!&+!1%01/'+!%%&&!'! !$!,''+" $2' , ', !' 3
! 0' !' 4 3
%!1/&!,', !&, 5 $-+!,$!+, , !6 3
!,,$ 0786 4 !'
$,' ',
!'
&, '!', '
-+!,$!+- 9+1/-'+!%%&&!'9!' ! &)$#$*'+,& $&'$&*$
!' 88
!-
"
, '&/-'+0! '!'+!'
-'+!%%&&!'!'+
2%&!,!','&! !+!9''
'+'!&& 0 !(,"!/: 2!'
% +! ,$!'' !!% + 0'
1!
*+!%%&&!'1 $+'!
% + 0'
1!
0 9+, +'+ !2!!!&%, 1 ''+
!%%&&!''
&+,2'+!'+, '+!!/&
/- % 9+, +-'+ !1 !2!$/!2!+,'
1!
% +1! ;*+,!$ '+!%%&&!'!+ ! $+'+ & 0'+ !1/+, &&!!'!'$,,$ 0,'1& 9 +,2 '+-+!!!1 2!!& ;, ;'+ !,+, !1 2. '
'+!,1!',$-'+ !0&& 9 '+$ ! 1&
'!'
<,$ 0+,2 '+! !+1 !2 , *+!0'-(,"!/: 2!9!'!;'
'
-#!&= %,'!&-+!,$!+- 9++9!2, &$!&&/>!2,!0'
#8-+!,$!+$, +, , ,', 0 (,"!/ : 2! & 1 &! 0,' 1/ '+
, !&00, -+%!!9!/
!+,% '2 '2 9! '
*+, !&00, 9+ '+,% '
'2>!2,!', %,'+!''+ ! 0!'+9!2!,&/+!," /! '+!' '+ ," , 9 !'2 '2 ! 9 00, ,' '
! !'+ ,
,!/ 0 !' *+ % - !0' 0 9,$ % - '+
% &, 0,&'+0,!&% ' ', 4 !$!,''+ !%%&&!'0 22,, 00 % ,+!1&
8
*+&!',!& ' % 0,,$!%,2!0! , !-0!2 +!$ !$!,' '+ !%%&&!'0 22,, 00 % ,+!1& ',
-'
9+, ++%&! '$ ,&'/! &!,2',!& !,$'+, !!,&!1& -'+&!',!& ','+ ,2% $" $2'!' 3
! 0' !' 4 3
, ' ! ' '+ !%%&&!'! ',
! 2', !1
= 9-'+2!,,$% ', 0'+' !9!'
'+ !%%&&!','+%' !-!0'++!!&!/ $ ! '
/
/!! 2 '+ 0'+2!>,2 2' 0/!-9! % 1/'+, ', !'
?! & 0 '+ !%%&&!'! +! ,0 &/
''+!' % ! !0 &% !& 0'+0! ' 0'+ !!'+,
0'+% ', 9,'-,'1 2!1 & '&/ &!'+!''+!%%&&!'9! 9 $&/ +!$! , '0 00 ',
-9+!-'+ 0! '!''! '! +!$ ',
!'2 '-, '+!&&$! '
9! ' 9,'+; 9&$'+!','9 &&,;&/ ! !'++0 '+
''+!''+', ! 0'+% ', 9!1! '+'',2 ,
@ ! @ 1 ''+, @ ! '1&, % !+9!!
+! 9,'!!&!', 0'+ !9+ % +!1, 1/ @ ,'&! !+!!''+% 8',0 '+ ''+!'
, @ -'!'2'2!1/'+!%%&&!' ',
!'+, 0.@!!&&, , '+!''+9!!+!' > +!$ 0 9 1'9 '+ !%%&&!' ! '+ ! 0 9 1/ $!%%&,$9+, ++ 9'+!''+9! %%&!2 ', ,'', '
! !'+& -,',!!2,'' ! 0'+% ', '+!' 9!% 9! ,'+!&&$ +!& 12,'''+!' @1,$'+ '
9+ ''+% '2 '2>!2,!', 0'+ !- !'$ , !&&/ '!',+, >!2,!', '+!'!&&0 ," , ,1/'+ ! 9% ,1&0 20!&&,$ !+! 0! 0! 9!A @ -9+ ,'+
2%&!,!'-!& % '+!'1 '+ !!9&&!'+!%%&&!'0&& 9 !+! 0'+ !+,'!'
&/,$ '+$ !'+ ,' ! '1 ,2%&,'+!''+!%%&&!'+!'+; 9&$'+!'20,'1& 99 & ! ," ,&!,$'
+,!'+
. ?! &0 '+!%%&&!'0 '+%!/0 !&,',9
0'+, ', '+!%%&&!'+!!&!/ $ !1 /!!
'+ 0'+'
'!&' 0/!!9!'
+,2,'+%' ! !$,'+0! ''+!'+9!%
2', !'! &/3/! &!'
'+',2 0'+!&&$ 4 ?!'!' ''+!''+,!2%&, '
% '+!''+!%%&&!'+!$,0,'1& 9'
'+2 '+-+!!!1 2
0'+ !!!& ;, ;+,2,+,!1 2 '
9+, ++ 00 0!'!&," ,!'+0 - ,'0 ,9!!'1/'+, ' / !
3 8+!+!&! &0 '+%!',!% '+%!%
;9,'+'+,!1&!,'! *+&!',!& '+! ,,' 0,,$'+!''+9! 2 ', ,'', '+%!' 0'+!%%&&!''
! !'+1 '+!'+; 9&$'+!' +1 ,&/," ,9 &&,;&/ ! !'+= -10 % ,$0 '+-,',%',''
% '+1! % ,, -9+, +!!0 9
!
"
# !$
! ! $
!
"
!
!
0
!
A,0'+% ', , '+!''+!%%&&!'$!0,'1& 9'
'+ !!;, ;+,2,+,!1 2-,'!;!','0! !& -',&& ,' ! '1+&'+!''+!%%&&!'+!'+; 9&$'+!'2&/$,,$0,'
1& 99 &&!'
'+!'+ 0(,"!/: 2!8''!%,'+!''+ '
9+
'% '2 '2>!2,!', 0'+ !9!>!2,! @! , +, >!2,!', - + '!' '+!' !&& 0 ," , '!, 1/ '+ !9% ,1& '
!0!&& !+! 0! 0! 9!7 '+-'+ 8',$!',$00, >!2,! @+!'!',+, >!2,!', '+!','9!B ,'% ,1&'+!''+% +!%, ' &!1-1, ;!'
A'+ 2%&!,!'>!2,! @ 1/'+ % ', -9+ 9!%'!''+%&! -!& % '+ !2&,'+!'1 '+'+!%%&&!'!9&&!'+ !0&&!'++! '+ !+,'!'
'+!'9!&/,$ '+$ 8'+!!& 2'
'+ '+!'% ', >!2,0 '
1 ' 0'+29!;'
>%&!,9+'+'+," , '+ !9% ,1&1/0,'!;, ;
1& 97 '+2 -'+2, !&, + 9'+!''+9!
0! ' !/%!' 0'+1 / 0'+ !8',!& !!2,'' ! '+% ', '+!' 9!% 9! 1/'+!%%&&!' ,$'+, ,' 8'+ ! 01#*$2+&,$#&1&)$%1&),'3$#%4%"'1'$(5#+! 069+,2,&!0! '! , 2'! 9, &-'+ , ', ',
%!'88 9!'!,!'+! 9 , ' ',
!'+0 9,$ 1!', 92! #$% &
' %()* ' %)*+,&
-
*$(
.! ' !
/0$1
34
"%5
!
")+ *$( ! ,
* $( 6
7
*3
!*8
7 8
*38
! !
9
5
,
'
!
*:
!! , !
5
!
!
,
' %3%*+; ,2,&!&/-,'+ ! 03,71%4%"'1'$,89$#121( #+!
06-0 9,$ 1!', 92!1/!.,,, + 0:!&!=,$+ ' #$( ' %() * +
/
' %((
'
! <
<
!
! < !
<
+ 3 ' %((* + !
!
!
$$, = !
=
<
<
<
<
+
!
!
$3,
+
!
6
!
> !
' 3::
* +
*
' %()* + $%%!
& '
(('
)* +(,
)-./01 =
+
' %3% * +
!
2
2 & '
3(('
0/ +((
)-1 ? @ +
@
=
, + ' %()* + $)A
'
B @ 4 + 4
$# 5& & 6
(./ )- .0,
9
!
!
5
! !
,+
' %3%* +
$8 7
!
!
7
4
' %3% * + ;
8'+ !!'+!-'+ &!, @ 1,$'+/ 9,'!'+2, !&, @1,$'+ '
9+ %0 2'+ % '2 '2>!2,!', 0'+ !&!'+, ''
%,'+!''+ !%%&&!','++!,'', ; 9&$'+!'+,! '9 & &','+ !'+ 0'+ !7 '+-$,'+0! ''+!''+!%%&&!'9! &/3 /! &!''+',2 0'+!&&$ !+!0! !% '! '',!& '+&!'
/!-!&,',9,'
1&/'!; 8 $,1#1+&1&)124"'1'$,8
.5 05-!'+ 5 $ 1 + 0 '+ = C1& %2 ' +! %, '+!' !9!,$ ' , '!20 2!&,'/, ,2,!& !@+!2,,2 2! 2!>,2 2 '2 , % ,1 1/ '+ '!' ' 9,'+ $! ' '+ %, ' -!, ', !/&2',','+ ' ! ;$ 0! + !-9+, +, & 0! '
&,;$!,'/ 0'+ 00 -2!,9+, +'+
00 , 22,''- !$ 0 '+ ! - + & 1 , 9+,&
'2,,$'+B !' 2 0' !'+,, ', , ''
1 !1,'!,&/ 9+,2, !&&/0'!,$!&&&!'0! ' -% %' + &1!9!1!,$,2,'+%, ,%& 0% % ', !&,'/'
'+ ' ,,'+> ,&/+!+ ,' 2! !&,'7 '+- !'9 5 $ + 0'+= C1& %2 ',141)11%+:1214"'1'$ ,8
5(+!,'!''+!''+,2% ,', 0' !&
! ,!&% % !,'! '!!''1/2!;,$'+! !&, '+!2!$ ! &/'
'+, ',21 '!& '
'+ ,'/!'&!$*+ &!9,'+,$!,9&&''&'+!' %% ' ,', 00 2!', 2 '1 $!'! +, ', ,'
1> ,1/!& !',$!&&!'',$ , 2'! 0! + !1/ ', ,$'+!' 0'+ ,2-'+2!, 9+, +'+ ,29! 22,''!'+ ' 0'+! '
',;!
1!&! 1'9'+00, ! / 0&!9!'+ +! 00 2!', 0'+ ! 8 '
'2,'+B !' 2 0' - '+ &1!, 2,'+%, ,%& 0% % ', !&,'/!!9!,$% ,+2', '2&/ ',1 ',1 '!& 0 2!', 8,9 0'+!1 , , -'+%'!%%!&,,% ,'+0 9,$'2
, *+ , ', 0'+!%%&&!' ',
!'88 ,'!,1 '+,+&$ ,&'/0 22,, 00 % ,+!1& ',
,$&/-'+!%%&&!'
,' '
,$ ,2%, 2'0 /!
,, #,'+0! ''+!''+!%%&&!'+!!&!/ $ !
'
/%, /!! 2 '+-9+, +,2 '+!'+ 2!>,2 2' 0/!!9!'
+,2 ',
-'+B !' 2 0' !9!'
+,2,2 ,0,'
'+%, !&!/ $ 1/+,2 ,$ 2, &&! !%%&, !', - ,0 !/- +!&& !& '! ,% 0!
,$&/
"
0"
.
7 @+'+%!;,$D! ED6
@+'+% '!1& ED6