High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4264/2021allowed

Sikander Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-10-14Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma53 pages

& "

' ()

"""""" *" "

++ ' ()

"""""" *" #"

#$ ' ()

"""""" *" "

+ ' ()

"""""" *" $"

,,# ' ()

"""""" *" "

$ +, ' ()

"""""" *" %"

$%+ ' ()

"""""" *"

$, ' ()

"""""" *" +"

+,,# ' ()

"""""" *" "

+++# ' ()

"""""" *" "

$%# ' ()

"""""" *" "

+ ' ()

"""""" *" 1* 1 2

#"+" - " " (-

./ ("

0 0 ./ (0"

0 0& 0 3

& 0 (

#& ! '& $ & !#

&! ' */,2*3*0

() ,* $ &! '

() *+ +,-,2*3*4 .&! '

() 0/ /1112*3*4 &! ' .

.(!

&! '

() ,5 !

&! ' 554&+015**3152*3*0 1*302*3*,

() 01

&! '

() 1* **12*3*0 ( &! '

() 00 043+&+-1/@+5002*3*0

&! '

() 0, ,1552*3*4 &! '

*() ,5542*3*0 !#( & #

&! '

/0,( () ,*/,2*3*0

( &!

03 " ( &! '

&-&5&104 4() ,*/,2*3*0 !( &!#!$& #6&!# #'

#& #'

$ # 7 #

0+89:7 ;;

;;; 0& 0 < 0 (

# < '

## %2 // ( &

// 0

* <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

2 #

0-3-*3*3 ' $ #(

A( -0> ?'

'## ) ' (

( 55> >

' #

*2 #' '(

& &

'# # :' & ' *4330*3*3 4 7 =

# ' $ #(

?)(

2 053**3*07

' 2 8 2' # "

+ +

, <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3 '# ' 8 ' 0534*3*0&

+ + 7 # # =

$ # # (

## ?) (

*+3**3*0 7

' 2 8 2' #

:8$ # (

8?) (

? #

8''8 '# *+ +3**3*0

# $

/ <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3 '# ' 8 ' 0534*3*0&

+ - 7 # # =

$ # # (

## ?) (

*+3**3*0 7

' 2 8 2' #

$ :8$ # (

8?) (

? #

8''8 '# *+ +3**3*0 "

5 <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3 '# ' 8 ' 0534*3*0&

+ 1 7

' 2 8 2' # :8$ # (

8?) (

' ?

? #

,, #

03 <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # &

( =

2 # # '

*03**3*0A'

-0>'

# *33** *3*0 ' $ # # AB ?>(

A( -4>(AB

?>(

A( -1> >

# :

:' & ' *4330*3*3 00 7

' 2 8 2' # "

$ + ,

0* <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3&

04 7 # # =

$ # # (

## ?) (

*+3**3*0 7

' 2 8 2' #

:8$ # (

8?) (

? #

8''8 '# *+ +3**3*0 "

$%+

0, <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3&

+ 0+ 7 # # =

$ # # (

## ?) (

*+3**3*0 7

' 2 8 2' #

:8$ # (

8?) (

? #

8''8 '# *+ +3**3*0 "

0/ <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3&

2 0- 7

' 2 8 2' # :8$ # (

8?) (

' ?

? #

8''8 '# *+3**3*0 "

+ ,,#

05 <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3&

% 01 7

' 2 8 2' # :8$ # (

8?) (

' ?

? #

8''8 '# *+3**3*0 "

+ ++#

*3 <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> ' 4303*3*3 ='# ' 0534*3*0&

2 "

$ %#

*0 <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 #

( =

' 0534*3*0&

2 "

+ #

** <

! '# **/8**- ( 7 # ( =

(# A5> '

4303*3*3

= '# ' 0534*3*0&

2 *4 C

# #

#' # *+3**3*0

*, ' ' *2#'

' ' (

! * * 4330*3 3*3 0,0

'# # :' 2 :

: 0,0

&++

$ # (

0, ,

, ?'

'## ) ' A?)><

#=#' =

-$% % $"

! "

# $%

& ' # ) , (

) ) *+*&+&+, *+ !

& #'

# :' '

D D & '

433 ## ,3 C ?'

'##) ' A?)>

( 557 ' #'

# ?'

'## ) '

A?)> # '

5#'

*/ <

## # ?'

'## ) '

A?)> '

# # #' ?'

'##) ' A?)>'

& '

#'' ( =#&

## D D ## ( =#& *

## '

2 # ' # # # <

+ '

# &

# ?)'

%2 4

55 "

0267

( 18

0*4,5+ -, */3*3 .

$ # 0*053- -/ *+153 ! $

0**5** -- *+1,3 ! 0*3+*/ 53 *+513

# 0**3-, 5, *+503

0*3050 5/ *+-54

0**/0- 1* *+//4 .

0*0-,0 1/ *+/33 <

0**54/ 1- *+++3

0*40+/ 030 *+,+3

*345533 ? #

5 03- *3,4*1 . , 0*1 6 *3**45- 0/ /0 034 *3+30+, 0, ,1 03, *3+5,-3 ? #

-, , 00+ # *3,3/5/ . 0+ 5 034 *3,*,55 ? #

5/ / 004 !

*34/**, '' - -- *34-,30 ? #

1/ / 00* !#

*3,/0-1 3- 03/

*3*,414 ? #

3+ 000

*3-50/, '' -* " *3*5/*1 '' /1 ##

*300*54 '' -4

0-4/+3 ? #

2 2 000 !# 4/45,1 2 2 035

# 4/,30* 2 2 03* !

4-3/40 035

45*//1 '' 53 ! 450150 '' -5 ! 45*4+, '' -1 $ # 45-*/4 '' -5 0-35-- ? #

00+

# 0-31-/ ? #

00+ # 005*+3 . 043 B# 0-315+ ? #

00/ # # 0-++1- ? #

031 . 0-4533 ? #

000 .

45,5*- '' -+ ( 450/1, '' -+

4/44+- 1* 4543,, '' -- # 0-+/,/ ? #

004 !'

#" 0-0/++ ? #

00*

0-3-*- ? #

031 0-+*-5 ? #

00/

0-*40* ? #

00+

0-**-3 ? #

00, "

4/3135 03+

# 4/-5** 1, 0-4-+3 ? #

15 45,1/5 '' -/ . 45,+44 '' 005 4/,14* 1- 03- 4-3+,4 3* 03/

$ # 4/,-51 1/ / 03-

# 4/1-0+ 34 03/ $ 4,1/-5 '# 00/ 0-00-+ ? #

-3 3 00+

0-,150 ? #

3, 000 0-04-+ ? #

3 00, . 0-4535 ? #

5, , 00,

0-4+40 ? #

0* 0 03- . 0-**-5 ? #

-5 5 00, # # 0-31*0 ? #

34 000 4/*014 3 031 4/*10/ 1* 03-

4545-3 '' 1+ -1 $ $ 4505-+ '' * --

$ 45+/11 '' 4 -5 450/4, '' 30 -1 B 0-*014 ? #

31 003 !

# 4-/4-5 03- 4/-*11 1+ 03- .

4//1-/ 1- 0**4/5 *-453 0*3,0, */343 $ 0**0// *//-- -

*0+4-/0 +-

*0,40,1 +- *0+5*34 +- # *0+3*/5 +-

# *0,445+ +-

*0,+-,1 +-

*0+,-*5 +- 6 *0+1-14 +- 6

*04/5-* +- " # *0,*0*3 +-

*0+---/ +- #

*0,4*+- +- *0+,4+/ +- *0,44/3 +- <# *04-5-* +5

# *04/-+3 +- !

*0,44-1 +5

*0++-14 +-

*0/440- +- !

003

003 #

0*,

00*

035

03* !

031 $ **0+5- +, $ **/33, ,+ *014/* ,0

# **++11 ,- #

***,44 +4 **34*/ ++ *- <

& 053**3*0&

# $ # #(

' # ?'

'## ) '

' # '

2 # < $ #(

B A++

# '

/+ *++,3

++ */334

?)B A0 0,

0, */3*3 # '

01 *+503 <

## '

# # ?)B 01'

# # # '

$ #(

*5 :

:**3**3*0& '

## '

' ## #' ' .

& '

## '

' *1 <

$ 7& 4030*301 1 03E ?'

'##) ) ' A?) > ' ' ( #

$ 7 7

< '

# -

%2 ./

! " " % 01

01 " "

) , 43 <

& & # *53+*301 '

03E # ?'

'## ) ' A?) > ##

8 8( 8B '# 40 C # 8 ' 4303*3*3

'## ) ' A?) > ' ' ' #

$ $

# 4& 5 0*& %2

#$ %&' ( ' 0 01 "! 2 -2

3 -

2 4 - 5 ' , ($

! " " 01"

) 01 & ( (

, 4* <

$ .'

# #

# 003/*301

'##) ' A?) > > (#

7&77& 777 7"

' ' ' $ 7 7'

# /& %2 F"

! " " %

01" "

)

, 44 <

$ . #

# *+3**301 1 ?'

'## ) ' A?) > '

' ( #

' ##

$ 8$ $ ! ?' # # 7 . 7'

# /& %2 F"

! " " %

01 " "

) ) , 4, <

' ( # ' $ #8: (

' *++,3 *+503 ?)(

< &## '

# # 2 ?)'

# ' $ #8:(

: 8$ # (

)

) * 4+ '

# A > '

' #'

## # ## & ! '# 0/ A/> ( 7 ?)(

'# 4/ '

# A > '

# ' # #

' '

$ #8: (

' ' '

' ## '

$ # (

& '

% ' ' '# # 4- '

# A > '

# 43 303*3*3

' < & # #'# ' &

#'& * *

4330*3*3 45 '

&# '

(# * *

# *53+*301& # '

' # ?'

'## ) ' ##

# < # 43 03*3*3 '

(# 5&

! " " 01"

) 01 , 41 '

# #

# 4303*3*3 ##'# ' ## ,3 '

?)'

$ # # (

' & #

' = D

?)'

03 ' ,0 ) ) # '

# '

' ,*

'' # # *33,*3*0#

0 ,2 & '

%2 ./ /( !

0(000

( ( "! " " 01 " "

5 2

6" !

" 7

8 7*7&+9; :2 7/++

*+ +&+&+ $% :; " : 0

1 $01<

5 ' ,

+ 8 ? 7 " '

=; . 01"

) 01 , > ( ( 7+*7&+9;:279D ?+*&+& & $% :;& " 7

5 '

@ !0 " # $: 2

( 8 ?

=; +,* *&' & ?% '

?% '

=; "

01 "

01"

) 01 "

) 01 =; A !

) !

! " 01 B )

) 01

)

) 01!

) 01

! ) 01

# # 01 "

) 01 D ( ( % >$D $

" !

% *+$ % > >$D$! 01 !" 5 (

# "

0 01 "

01 " 5 2

-. & & ( (

& "

" 7

8 7*7&+9; :2 7/++ 3%(03 *++&+&+ $% :; " E :

1 $01<

5 ' E E 8? 7 " % '

: =;E 01"

) ++ 01 E % % >$D$! 01 !" !& ,&.2

D" " 7

8 7*7&+9; :2 7/++ 3%(03 * *++&+&+ $% :; " E : 0

1 $01<

5 ' E 8? 7 " % '

: =;

E 01"

) 01 E% % >$D$! 01 ! " 5 E ?(

? " % D$D E8

' E( ! "

# ! "

! 01 "

012

, ,4 !

! # ##

& '# 0* # 4303*3*3& '

## ' ' ## ' ' ''

' ' & ## & '

# 4303*3*3 #'# * *301 ,,

'' # # 0503*3*0 # # *2 #' ' (

& & '

# .> ( (

3 @ 0 "

" # 5 ' $ 7 *+7+7& &+&+! 01 "

) 01 01 5 2

5 , ,+

' ' # # 3+30*3 3*4# 0+29 9 7& '

%2 .

01 !

3 F (! # ! 5

C# 8 *D+* *977&+9;0 $: ! * *+&+9! +G 01 " 2 !( C-2 3 : 5 / C#

= /0% , &&'/" E% 01

01"

" "

) E

,/ !

! #

9 7 ' 4/341808*3012?

>&4030*301 03 '

# ?)(

?) '

2 2 '' ,-

' ' '# 50* # 08 848*3012 (78-334303*3* *3& '

%2 ($

! " " 01"

) 01 & ( (

, ,5 <

'# 5 # '

' 4030*301

# 4303*3 3*3& '

# ' ' ## ' ' ''

' ' < #

' 4030*3 301 %2 1$

! " " % 01

01 " "

) ,

$ ,1

' ' ! '# 0+ 0/ ( 7& '

%2 23$*&45 +&- 5/&%,& /&,6&66 5&4 $(

!! ! !

$&8

!! ! !

! ' ! ! " ;

B$ "

! ! !

$*8

I/& %%; ( 2 $A % %!9> ! A : )

% >$*"

$8 $& &9

(

27$8 .--&.%&- -5%-.% $(

)

! $&8

! ! ! !

! ! !

$*8

" !

5 ! "! !) "

"! ! )

$%8

!" )

( " )

% $ 8

$ $%

" "

! I( 2 $0; % % ! &+++! 2 ( % " $- -"

% D 2 ? % %&+++! $%(

" ("

>+G (

>+ +G $>8

$D8

' , +3 !

! # ! '#

?) '

'# & ( 7 < '

' 8# & '

( 7(# 5 # 4303*3*3 3

( 7 #'

G # +0

' ' .

H# ( 7' 45 54.'$ /<=

&'96 :;:#<39 2$< #

%2 .& &D4 5 !#( #! ! '

2 !

" '

! 5

: !-' J

8 5 :'8 %9/>

226 6

) !

+ 2 ! '

*( '

" - "

" = $ % "

!! 2 2 K $ % "

% >$! >$ $> D$

" 0) 2 ! K $ % "

K *%

!$ ) % 2 B $ % > D ) B $

" 2 ' *&'

# *& %

)

(

= *& 2 ! !

= E1!(

C !6

( 2

% 3 :

% % ( ( %

2 = @ ! ! 0 % B 4 C ( ! 0

! - ! A% 1 B0) C % CC

B% ( % %(%

(3C(

% ( % C ( 8B C 2 %

( (";3 3C8 !99!3 6 %

!0% 5 (C

( 2 E *&&(

) * % "+* 2 ( (

! !

" 2 !"

% *D?2 2 *&&% *D?!

! =; E*D? 2 ;% 2 -

6 ! "-

6 ' 6

6 6 !

! 2

" -

= ; $ >! >>! /*! D& &! $ 2 LL!2 L L !2 M ! $ 4

! $

! *&&& % *D? ! " ' 2 !

J # # #

! "

" " % *D? =; E*D?"

" 2 2 ;$ 8" 2 ! " "

2 " " $&% 2 -

6 ! " -

6 ' 6 '

" -

= ; $ >! >>! /*! D&! & &/9;%!$ $ 2 LL!2 LL !2

M M ! $ 4

! $

! $*8 *

*&&*%

J !% *D?

" ! ; $* ;

; % *"

% *D? ! % * 2

! " " "

" " " A : !

; $

" % *D?% *

=; E* 4"

" N $%

2 !

## "

! ! $&(

"" "

! ! $* !

" ) !; $E "E

C ! !

;

"! ! ! ! "

"B $ E "

4 2

! " "

$ 8

2 *D?E *&* - "

" ) ! ; $D 0

% > ; $D

% D 2 ( " % !> > D! ' ) ! A

! % A

! " " "

2 % $&> *&*% > D!

" =; E> *&4 5 /&% , ,&/ &,6 &6 6+ & - 5&4 ; $ (

! ! ! !

$&8

! ! ! !

! '

! !

" ; $

B $ "

! ! !

$*8

D8 .--&.%& -5%-.%$;$ (

)

$& 8

! ! ! !

! ! !

$*8

" !

" !) "

"! ! ) E *&*& ( % > D! " !

) ) ! =; E> *&4 5 /&% , ,&/ &,6 &6 6 + & - 5&4 ;$ (

! ! ! !

$& 8

! ! ! !

! ' ! ! " ; $

B $ "

! ! !

$*8

$8 $& &9

(

$>8 ; $ $ 9

! "!

(

! " !

$ *+ $D8 ; $ $ 9 $ $& &9

!; $

$ $>B $

$ $>

! " !

$ *+! " "

' 0

;A D! E

" E

D 0)

; $ (

)

$& 8

! ! ! !

! ! !

$*8

" !

5 ! "! !) "

"! ! ) $;%8

!" )

( "! ! )

#, $;-8

$ $;%

$>8

$D8

' E *&**% !/ ?! 0) 2 "; % > D!

=; E 0)

" ;(

) ") "

#+ /% ;E E

(

E E

" " ?% ;$8 !

$&8

$*8 "

! " $8

! "

! ! ! E *& L L 2

)

% D! " C ' :

) % *?!*9 D 2 =;

; E*?

;$ (

! ! !

$&(

! ! ) ! ) !

*9 2

" ; (

! ! "

; $ ! ")

! ) B $ "

B $

B $ ) ) " "B $ "

! "!

B $

OOOOOOOO OO D

2 !

( " ;(

! ! !

( !

E D( !

) !

) )

D> ) % ! 2

2 2 !"" /* "

" '

? '

2 ! 2 !

% >$ 7 >$> 7 D$B

! 2

//% ! ) $D % !!> D2 $ $D% > "

! " "

% >% 9$$ % &9$& ; $ $D% >

" ; $

! ! $D % D

" ! " "

% 0

$D % >! E

" E % > > D

6" !"

" % > >$! >$> D$! !

2 !

( ! C-" 2

/9 ( )

" E " ! "

% > $!>$> D$ 2 4%%4&'& &&'6+ 4'& 8-&'/54 &,,&-$64 &%' &&'& - -&& &,,&-6 4' /&/ &6 4 5 &'/ 5. + 4&$ 4 4 % -&- 4 5 - --/ & 4 &%'

# & &&' 8 4,&- 6 6 6 /

$ 4 4 4% > &&' 4& '& % + 4&$ & 4 +6 4 -&-&/ &%' & -&& & ,&- ?/ 5 , ./&%'/4 -$ 4&&6 4 % . -&& & , + &%4 &%'&&' '&= 4 5&0/ /$ +&A"

* "

=; :

;

" ) B

" "

2 0

% >$!>$> D$

! ) ;

0) 2 2 2

! !

% >$! >$> D$ 2 >/ ( 2 " 0 % %!&++&!

>/( 2 " 0 % %!&++&!

?& ( $> % > $9* % %! 2 2 &++>" '

2 0 2 ( $: C

C !$&+?22 ?* (

$> % > "

% 9 9$$ 2 !

% 9 9$$ 2 " % 9$D2 2 " $>% > 2 !

! "

$% *+2

" % "

$>% > 2

) % 2 ! " 2 &**(

2 2 ! "!

" ! '

"! !

! ! (- 3

" 2 2 % 2

! "

" ( 2

% 2 <

! < ; "< ! " 2

" 8

! " 2 ! "

" < "

! =< !

! !" <(

2 I:=E 2 % = % 8

4 2 % " E!P :!(

!A !&+Q, +* !

! #

?) '# #''

# +4

' ' .

H# ( 7' 04B%& & '$04 *5 &'%%/ /4&6:;;1<@9 AA6 .

H # ( # #' '

( '

#''

# 1 A4> ' # < # %2 .> >-" "!

! "

" I99&

$*22&/Q!

$?& = E

(" !"!

! < < < < (

2 !

( C-" 2

I$ % D$Q

$% D 6

( !

B "

$ % D D( ) "

)

B ! $C2 !"

! "

;

; E %

" % >$*!

% D$(

! " !

2 % J 5 !99>$2( +*=I99 9>$>22/*Q = E (

C 2 ) $>+G B

) !!2!

( -2B

)

; ) - !)

$ ! " ! !

(

! &++ >G G 2 *+G

"! 2!

=EA2=*+ ! "9 9 "E1 "

=EA2=& 9 " !

*+ EC ! ! !

< << < / ( "

+ 2!( C- -2 % D$ < <

! " ! % D$ >$* < <1 "

% D$! "

! ;

;

" ! "

)

( ! 2 ! " " ! ! )

2 ! ) 2

( ) "

C 2 IL ;

" $ ! :J " ' ! 99>$&2(DD=$99>$&22 2/>!

L 2 !99>$2(D9 9>=$99>$D22D? : : 3P4P !99D D$&2(>&=$99D$* 22 &>* Q -

$ "

" "

2 !

)

$ 2 ;1 1< " )

) !

) C

! )

2 ( ! $

$ ( " " ) "

" 4

9 2 $ $") " !92

" !

9 2" !

2" C ! 92 "" !" 2"

"!"

! 9 2

" 2 I-

9 9 2 " ! "!

)

$ <2;" <

) Q 9 ! $ !" >9! " " "1 >9 &D

" !""

" ) ) <5 2;1<("

"- ":2

" ? $" " !

" " %

! " >9 9

&& " " " $ 8 & &!*!!>!9!9!&!&>! *! *> F F 4 $ 8 >!D!D&!D*!DD D!/!/>!//!/?!/9F ?+ 4

) <5 2;1< (

(

:2 &+G "

! "

+ ! " & C-2! 9 " :2 " C-2 "

$ (! " " <C-2 ; 1<!

" " "

( "

? " ! & C-2

4 ( "

&C-2 " !

) " (

:2 " :

9$* '

- ) "

! 9/ "

&++&

@ C (

)

&++>A

0 " !

C !"

*+&&++ "

1 "

$:' J 3

8 *

$# 4

$# J 5 "

(

" , +, !

! #

H# ( 7 D# '# ##

G # #' ++ 7

H# ( 7& ' # !

'# 0+0/ ( 7 +/ !

!''

#& ?/$< '

2 # 0-3-*3*3 $ #(

A( -0> ?'

'##) ' (

( 55> =

5 ' 4303*3*3# '# ' 8 '

0534*3*0 & #

+- <

' 8 8 2' #

'# #

:' &'#

# ?)(

+5 7 '# ?)'

#' ''

& '

= +1 !

!## #' & &#

'00

& " " $!

0& 0 ( )

& ) 8

) # %I %I