Gurinder Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others



 
!

 "#$#% #!&###
#%#!



       


 

   



!"

#$!%&'


 '()*(+,)-.+) */)/)*( !, , ,//*'12/.*(3 !*34*/3



(
 )
 '()*(+,)-.+) 55*/)/)*( !, , ,//*'12/.*(3 55!*34*/3 * +,-.



/0#12.

#*/..3 *4*# #** (*3*/ ('(6
.4(7,(#68/*7 33)3/*29(#:3./%++7#68/*7 (/.*4*/)/)*(3 (0)3.6.)7%#7'12 ;;;;

#*/..3 *4*# #**'

/

.*26*<*/)*/==()/4*/)/)3.6*2**)+*29 /.*4*/)/)*(7=*(*.*(1)/+9(*2*)-*8)*298<<(*( 3/.*)33'*3(*(*+/*/*/.*(

  $()*8/3=.)8.(*>')(*/2*/)8*(*/.//.*4*/)/)*( 1)*/.*)8*%)3/()8/,*33)3"'-*7#<()/3(73,*)(
+*(:  ? @=.*(*/*(7.*=33*+*8/*44)/*3,*)(
+*(:     )A2'(%*4(/<*/#/*(.6)-1)*7)/44*(3/./ .*.)34'/*=)/./.*88*(*A2'(B8'<B
8)++)/) )8*( .4'/2+<*2*)-=(-'++93'34**/(3*((*) 8)6)+3')/4(**((*29.)<8.++*-)-/.*3)3'34*3)/(3*(

*#)/)+,*)(
)6)+"'-*7=.)+*433)-</(9)1'8/) (*(   <*8*(/)23*(6/)3/.*(*(3.6)-2** 8/'/* 29<+)*/44*(3/./)34'/*3=*(*(*3+6*/*(/.* */)(*<'/=34)//.*4*/)/)*(.*=3(*)3//*2'/.* 8/)'*/.6*8<4+)/3-)3/.)33'4*()()8*(3.*+3 (*<)*23*/(<'/9(+-4*() *'+/)</*+94(**((*
)6)+()/*/)/)2*(*/.)3
'(/=.*(*).*4(9*/)(*8//.* (*34*/3/8<4+*/*.)3,*(6)8*$:(*+*3*.)33+(9=* 9 +3-(/.)<()8)*89,/*4 4/=3++*-*/.//.* 4*/)/)*(=3*/)/+*(()8)*89,/*4 4=*   ?2'//.* 3<*=*(*/(*+*3* *=3+3/-)6*3+(9=*   .*=32*)-.(33*8/)''3+929(*34*/3? 7=.

 =*(*/++=)-/.*4*/)/)*(/4*((<.)3'/9/.)3(*-(7 (*4(*3*//)=33*///.*(*3)*/3=*++3//.*
.)*))3/*( 6()'3/.*()8)+3#%*4(/<*/+)>')(9=3))/)/*-)3/ /.*4*/)/)*(((*<))-8/)''3+923*/(<'/9#+/.'-..* .)(<*/./.*=3'=*++ .

.)<=*(*+3/:*)/83)*(/)(</.*8/3=.)8..6* 2**3//*29/.*(*34*/37/.*)>')(9(*3'+/*)4')3.<*/ 3/44)-.)3/.(**-(*)8(*<*/3=.)8.=38.++*-*29.)<) 44*+/.*4')3.<*/(*(=33*/3)*)44*+6)*(*(/*  ')3.<*/(*(=3433* /.*44*+ =3*8)*

A*(*  8'3*+  (  /.*  4*/)/)*(  8/*3  /./  /.* 4*/)/)*(=3*/)/+*/2*(*B*3)-/*3"')(#33)3//+3 */)/+*/(*6)3*4938+*/.*3)43/34*(331')(//.* 4*/)/)*(=.=*(*4+8*)/.*3*)()/9+)3/=*(*-(/*/.*3) 4(</)3.+32**'(/.*(-)6*4(</)//.*43/ A2'(  34*8/(  (*B  =.)+*  /.*  4*/)/)*(  =3  /  -(/* 4(</)3A2'(34*8/((*B((*B *4(**((*
)6)+ ()/ */)/)  ?

    =.)8. =3 )343*  /.*  29 /.* %)6)3)$*8./.)3
'(/)(*8/)-/.*(*34*/3/43334*:)- (*( .*(*34*/3/*(83)*()-.)3(*4(*3*//)7(*B*3)-/* .)<3"')(#33)3//6)*(*(/*   =* ?

4+8*.)<)/.*4938+*!3??B@ ? A*(*8'3*+(/.*4*/)/)*(8+)<3/./.*3.'+.6* 2**4(</*(**3)-/*=*   )3/*/*(/.* 4*/)/)*(  =3  *C*(/*  )  /.*  %*4(/<*/+  4(8**)-3  *7 /.*(*(*7)+*
/*<4/4*/)/) ?

 =.)8.8<*/2* )343*=)/.+)2*(/9//:*'4(*<*)*3-)3//.*(*(/*    =.*(*/*(/.*3*8=()/4*/)/).32**)+*

?

.*4*/)/)*(/.'378+)<3)(3/+9(*+)*(*+/)-/2*)- -(/*()8)*89,/*4 4(<   ?D3*8+9.*8+)<3.)3 4(</)3"')(#33)3//(<   '(/.*(4(</)/ /.*  3/    A2'(  34*8/(  (*B    (*B  =*  /.*  /*3 4*(331')(/.)<.6*2**4(</* 
   7  /.*  (*34*/3  .6*  )+*  /.*)(  (*4+9   4)/*  '/  /./  /.*  4*/)/)*(  (*<)*  23*/  (<  '/9  (<

 /  .*=3=(*4')3.<*/3/44)- /.(**-(*)8(*<*/3 .*3<*=37.=*6*(73*/3)*)44*+ .* (*(3.6*2**)<4+*<*/* .*8+)<4()8)*893/*4'4(<    ?)3/<*'/3/.*4*/)/)*(.+(*92**++=* ()8)*89,/*4'4(<    @/*(8<4+*/) 9*(33*(6)8* 34*(/.*4(*6)'36*(<*/3/('8/)3/*   

 .'3.* ='+/2**/)/+*/-*/*C/()8)*89,/*4 4(<   3 4*(  /.*  6*(<*/  3/('8/)3  /*       .*  4*/)/)*(E3 <*)8+8+)<((*(33+(9=*(*++3*//+*29/.*(*34*/3 /.*49<*/.6*2**(*+*3* .*8+)<23*/.*+*//*()33'* 29/.*A2'(B8'<B
8)+)/) )8*(7F4'(/.+/*?   /.*(*(*7)3/<*'/ @

.*  (*34*/3  .6*  '(/.*(  3//*  /./  /.*  4*/)/)*(E3 3*(6)8*(*8(.3/2**-++/.('-.'//.*(*(*.*8'+ /2*-)6*.)-.*(38+*()8)*89,/*4 4)/*(<3/.* 6*(<*/
)(8'+(/*   =.)8.(*>')(**<4+9**3=.3* 6*(++3*(6)8*(*8()3-

A*(*8'3*+(/.*(*34*/3.3)6)/*//*/)/ /.*+*//*()33'*29/.*6*(<*/'12/*  =.)8. 8+())*3/.*
)(8'+(/*   /<*/.//.*6*(++3*(6)8* (*8(/2*1'3/*3G-H='+<*/./ I(*4(/3.'+2* -26*)8+')-/+*3//=/.*+3//.(**(*4(/3 .*(*3/ /.*(*4(/3<92*3/)38/(9J6*(-*#3'<<(9/.*8)*/)+ (*4(//.*4*/)/)*(.3+32**4+8*(*8(=)/./.*(*4+9/)3 +34)/*'//.//.*(*(433*29/.*8)6)+8'(/=38.++*-*) 44*+2*(*/.*
'(/#)/)+%)3/()8/"'-*7"+.(7=..3 23*(6*/.//.*'+/+)*3=)/./.*4*/)/)*((*34*/)44*+=. =3*(* /.* <'/  3'23)3/*8* ++=8*7 2'/ (*/'(*7  /.*(*(*7/.*)/*(*3//.*(*//.

*'4)<'/=3/-(/* /.*44*+=34(/+9++=*  A*(*  8'3*+  (  /.*  4*/)/)*(  .3  +3  (-'*  /./ =-()-    .)3  #
!3  (<  -  /  6*(-*  .6*  /  2** 8<<')8/*/.)</.*(*(*73'8.=-(*#
!38'+/ .6*2**83)*(*/*9.)<()8)*89,/*4 4 *(*+)*3'4 /.*1'-<*/3433*29/.*#4*C
'(/)*&"565!

89!5 9 3

5

)


 ( # ((' 21.# -5%5!

3

!9:

* %5 5!9!5  15& 9:'

"9

5;9"

, "'

"9

5;9"



 #- '89:6!

49

#!9! ) 69&
(
 - '8 7 

#5 ;"

,"9 <96

#!9! ) 69&'


= #1 ( 9;"&5 #5 ;"'

#&>2 $ !

#!9! ) 9?9

 #1


 .6*83)*(*/.*3*3'2<)33)3



.*  4*/)/)*(  .3  3)8*  .)3  44)/<*/  )     2** 8/)''3+9+)/)-/)-)/.*
'(/3 .*++*-/)<+)8*.3/ 2**  .*+  /  2*  4(6*  29  /.*  44*++/* 
'(/    /.*(*  (*  2+ ++*-/)3 .*23*(6/)3/.*
)6)+
'(/=*(*/88*4/*29/.* #44*++/*
'(/23*3'8.++*-/)3<+)8*2)37/.* 4*/)/)*(.3/()*/2')+'483**)+.)38+)<('(/.*( 4(</) =*6*(7(*34*/3.6*4)/*'//.//.*4*/)/)*(E3 3*(6)8*(*8(=3/-=3<*(*6*(-* .*+3//.(**#
!3 /.*9*(3 B @7 @B    B =*(*/6)+2+*3 .*=323*/(<'/9/.*9*(  B )/=36*(-*( /.*9*( B  /  B ?7/.*4*/)/)*(.3*(*6*(-* #
!3 .*(*)3-#
!(/.*9*( ?B   .'37)/.*(*8( /.*4*/)/)*()33**(< B  '4/ B7/.*(*(*+9 /=-#
!3=.)+*/.*(*(*'(6*(-*#
!3/.*(*(*'( #
!3=.)8..6*/2**3'2<)//*29/.*4*/)/)*((33*33<*/

6*(/.*9*(B  B7/.*#
!3(*6*(-*

.'37)/8/2*3)/.//.*(*.32**=-()- *&"565! 7""

89!5 9@ 9 $9'

/ .*#4*C
'(/.*+3'*(3'*(B G 



                          

    

     

          

  

             

         

               

 

  

  

!



  " 

@   #   

  

           $      

                         %   &'    

              
 



  #

 

      

  

                                   

          

 

    



 /=383*=.*(*/.*(*=3=-()-(<G6*(9-H/G-H /.*(*(*/.**/(9-=3(*>')(*/2*8<<')8/* 8

!!

3

5

)


 

# $9;
'3)<)+(6)*= =3/:*29/.*#4*C
'(//./*6*-*/()*382*/(*/*3 6*(3*=)++2*(*>')(*/2*8<<')8/*))/)383* =-()- 

.*4*/)/)*(E33*(6)8*(*8(7/.*/.*(.7)3'/ 2*6*(-*83)3/*/+9=)/.+9/=-*/()*3 .'37)/)3/83* =-()-2'/+93.)/(<*-(*//.*( .*3<*7 /.*(*(*7)/.*4))/.)3
'(/7(*)3/)8/8/3=.*(*)/.* 1'-<*/338)/*29/.*4*/)/)*(=)++.6*44+)8/)

/)3+3/)8*/.//.*4*/)/)*(//)*3'4*('/)  @ *.3+(*92**-(/*/.*2**)/()8)*89 ,/*4 48<4+*/) 9*(33*(6)8*=.*(*/*(.)33*(6)8*(*8( *3/-)6*.)<2**)//.*3'23*>'*/()8)*89,/*4 4

? #3(*-(3/.*8+)<4(</)7<*(*+92*8'3*1')(3 .6*2**4(</**3/*8*33()+9<*/./3*)(4*(3 3.'+2*4(</* 8.*6*(94*(3E33*(6)8*(*8(.3/2* *C<)*)*4**/+929/.*(</)
<<)//**(/.*88*(* '/.()/9,)8*/.*(*34*/3.6*)+*)6)/4)/*'/ /.//.*9.6*83)*(*/.*83*/.*4*/)/)*((4(</)) /).)<3')/2+*7(*+)*82*-(/*29/.)3
'(/3/.)3
'(/ =)++/3'23/)/'/*)/34))//.//.*88*(*#<))3/(/)6* #'/.()/9

3)*()-/.//.*(*34*/3.6*/)-(*)(+9 83)*(*/.*8+)<33*/'429/.*4*/)/)*((*8.*/88+'3) /.*23)33*(6)8*(*8(/./.*)3/*/)/+*('(/.*(4(</) *C8*4///.*43/"')(#33)3//7)/*(*(*8*)3=((/*/3'8. *8)3)/.*(*34*/37<(*6*(73)/)323*/.*(*8( =.)8..3+32**4('8*(4*('3+/.)3
'(/)/.*(*4+9 )/)+)6)/3    6)*=    /.*  26*7  2/.  /.*  =()/  4*/)/)3  )+   88()-+9)3<)33* @ *)-
)6)+<)3844+)8/)37)973.+++33/ )343* #*/..3 *4*# #**
!"

#$!%&'




/087.

<</ .*/.*(34*:)-J(*3* &*3J .*/.*((*4(/2+* &*3J