Gurlal Singh v. State Of Punjab





    
 





!

"#$%% &'

((%%  )$# *# +, (        
 *$ 

$ #(-'$.+/0 $'((%%  1($2#$/"/*# +,  4'((%$& '+#&- 

(,51#&/(%
#$/2'%0.''#"#$%% &'

. 0$  # $ 
'6$$#&  *5'$(#, / 7 '$ $$$$8
 
     0  $$      '  .        # $& $&$#-($ - $ 5$ (5 /

/

9 #%'$/#$'$# $&$&$#-($ - $ 5$ 4'# 0:"#$%% &'/.'((%% ,$ '
#$($5''((%,(/'-(#& +#&-  ' 0   , ',;#''$& $-& '- $%5/'($# $5'  /< 4+ &'$-*%*2-,/-$$.' &(% ($5 & &$- 0%%&  #$(#$/ % 2'#$/  % 2%   

  ($00'%/ 

 .'($%% & $',%-  =' '(%($5$' $
'.>%2'#$/' #.' . &'$/>#(%5' $-'#, .%' (  $'$. &'- '&$# /'$$# .$ 0%%&%2% ?.(($' ,5'<4+ &' ' ,#(  , & ;#$/'%' -"#$%%  &' #>'. &'/$ 
'$*/%2% 4' < &  $  $    +   (    .     ' 0& ,# .$5=' '(%5' /.''',

> #,5'#$-'#,'(  ' '$.

 ' &$# .'>/.#   @ (.$4' < $># &-$-'%/(# &  ($(%  $ '  0$ ($%4'$# (.$ '(%5' -#,

&-/.''.%(# (%  $  0$ ($%''($%.$% ,5<4+ &'.''%'0 & $( 8484' ' %($%.$A0--B@*C$- .%% '(-(%%.($%5($($ '%$#. ' 0$?
#%>'  &'##% ($# ($-% >( '( 7 &- @ (.$ <4+ &' $#;B@*B*% 2-,'$#&'

?
. &' ',.''$-% C<B@*C. $$,5<"#$- &''(% 4'< &

$($($ $#&'(% '(%$0$5B@*"

#.$$ ' --B@*.($($ '

D $&$ ? ($ % $' .  #  -- B@*
. ($($

$' &*% 2-,/<4+ &''  0$,''($%% &.'C$- /-(%%.%% #5'#*= < ($6$-% &'0' &0$ --B@*4'< $'%' $ ' ?# $ '%$$0$  (#'.

%,$ & $( 868 '($%>( &'

#,%%>'  -(%%-($ .($($

' @57 /< ($6$-% &'' 0$' # '($%% &.'#- <4+ &'/ .'($#'-,$#5&$/-$$,5-0 &

((% B@*?$$ $$  0 $4'
#$($$B@*1 $($ 0-(%.> '
#$($$#%$$ /'($($5.' ,> <4+ &'.'$ (/,#%>($% '.-(%($%/ '+#%  ($$#%

$#$ '(% /<4+ &'' 0$' ($($5?

6$-% &'/.'>('- #,%%>#(

 7 /*=D ?# $:6$-% &'

&#>$-'*/-$$ #$% 

7 /'' 0$ -(%($%% &.'-(%% C$- ?
'#( &'$( &'- '  
'-%  B@- $/  2'$$  ?
 '#( $   &'  (  ' -(%($% '
'-%B@- $ ,$#&',> $(/.'''($#,$?

6$-% &'

 

 7 /?

&0($%  &,#%>;# 5 '-(%($%<4+ &'$'(#$( ( &'- '+#%-%>' /.'$ &%5 #$ &  ' #$    0& / $($  B@*E  $- '   
'-%B@- $.$0 $-.'''-(%.#   %($A%- $  -(%     0&     '$  $-%/ '%% & #"#$%% &'/.'.$$'(. ($($ % '
#$1#&/(%
#$/-$$

($  '%% '
#$1#&/(%
#$/-$$/'#((%(#- $%#( ' '%% '#"#$%% &'$($0# $

!
$*
 E$ 1#&/(%
#$/-$$ &''$& $ # $  '.%& '#/ '$&''#$' /.''/'(%  &#%5     %-  $%  4'    .  '  @  $  0    ($#

4  ,$ &  '-  &#%    '  #/  '  ($#

@- - 5#$. ($%,%.

*=  <  #%>'   &'/    --,$    '  (%  ($5 '  ,5  <  4+ $   &'  (  $&$ &  '  $0$5    $, $-# '$($ &.'''> (%

'($  *= <4+ &'/.'.' &'(%($5

7 .'''(($' '# $0$5 $, $-'-,$$5 &#' $5 0& ( ' $( *=D?
'#( &'.''> '-(%($% % &.' $5#- '
'-%B@- $ ('-'$/,#'- *= < ($6$-% &'/?

/*% 2-,/ -$$,$.'-'< $'($#'# % &.''($($5 .''0$'  ($($5 %  '% ($% (# &'% '0 & $( 868 /'$$('- '#,%%>#( .'?
( '$&$ ='''($# 0 % -     #  .  $$  # $    DD
$*
/ .''%%' $-  &$#- (($ &&  '-.$(#'-,#' '%%&   &''

  ', %%5 0%0 '  ' &. $0$$-'- #$ &  '   /  #  @-   . $   &'/ -,$* '5=/.''#(($' 0$

='' 0 .% $  '$ &  $&#- /  %$   1#&/  (% 
#$/ -$$ 0   '#-  #($/.''

%((%% :#"#$%% &'&&$0 ''%' ($ ((%

  4'  $% 
#$  '  $-#%  '  %%. &  (   $ $- 

 =''$$0$57 &- @ (.$ .-$-'# '-

$%%& ,5'($#  ='' + & (   . '-%%&$0$5F D =''$'$$$(  -$%( 

'  -   -  ,5  '  0$#  ($#

.  /F

 =''$.' &0$--'0, ($($  5/.'''$ $ $ ($($ &.' &0$--F 7 =''$'$%5  &'-(%' 
'-%B@- $F <  '0  '$  %$   # %  $  '  ((%% #  0 %$  0" $%$'*# +, ,& &'$#&''$$ < ''$ -$ ' ((% 4'  $0$5    '   $,   $-  '  (   # ,%'$-'- *=<#%>'  &'

 *= <4+ &'''-.$$@-  % &'    ,'%    '  #  ,#  '5  $-   # '$   #  -#  $&$ &  -$%  %    '  (    .  - $  $  '$-  &$-$ '

! $,# #$#$ (.$($( $   0 /%(--$5#(&-4'*=$  '.

'0 5($0# -5.''# 0%0'- '.$ &%5$(& '-%%5#$,%5 ''$- 4'$$/-#'$0$57

&- @ (.$.-$-# '-

$ %%&,5'($# $&$' ( $- 

'.'' + & (  . '- %%&$0$5/-5,' (  $$,$  $#%($#   $;#$- %.< .'$($0'  ,      (    $$,$ /  '  (     % . $,$#$&'%54' %5'>.'' ,(# #'( '%. $#,+-$ %$# 54'( .. $0$5 ' '0('.'%5 &%#$4'$- $,>

($.'' (  .  '$ ' &(# ;# -$>0$'$$,%5< '$#;%/-  ' '< $'$+ ' (  . ,#

.$5 <-$-- > .%&' .5 ((%& $%%5'-$.$(($. $' ($# & '$- %(($' &'#'$- %-5

#$ .$'- #'$-'-$'$ $$%0 4' '$$'%& &'(% 

 .'

0&  '$ & '
#$/'$$/((%-%5 0+ &' 0& $ &'-%0. 

  4'$$/'($# 

,#, '#  $&$' @   %$ # %$' ((%% ''$'0, .' &0$--($0 $$ , &B@*.'%'$B@ -#' ' &0$-- B@*/?
#%>'   &''%' ,% #-,$

/ .'$ --B@/,% #-,$.%

< -- B@/'%-($ '%?

.-  8=8 .'$    B@*/    .  -      868  <        ' $ &< $<4+ &'/'' &0$ --B@.($($,5'-,5?
#%>'  &' < ($6$-% &'/.'$--B@*.($($,5< ($ 6$-% &'.''.& ,5'-. 

''$' /%$ # %'$&#'' $%
#$'%.''#% &' &' %5 -- .'$($'%% .''.B@* '$ -   --B@ '--B@ ,$ 5C< #-,$/ & #$ ?

  .  %$   ,5-  -'0# ($ 4'$%
#$#( 0%0- # 

0  .'  (%  %     $  '  $  '  $  *  #$%/ -$$> $5 '-$<',  '' '%%  ,$  , &  ($     ' 
#$  .  &  '>  $- ($# & 5  #',+ .$,5($#

& 5''$..' &0$--'.''%< ',  %#'--B@. 0$  , #( 4'#' &0$--,> B@*.'$B@

 .''#- #,#%#' 5 $#%-'  ,>  $   '$,+ > ,5%$ # %$'((%%  '  ,  $&$ & %5    5     & -(% CE $ &'-/$  '($# $5?.0$/< - -($,5'   4'$ ' &'.''  $, @($ ' & -(  # ' -($'$  $- '-  &' & .''(&-4'# '.

'0#$ ($+##% &-(%CE/'%4'$0$5 $-'#-# --$%;# 5  4'-(#& +#&-  0 $$   ( ,5 ' $%
#$ $ .%% $   / , #( ($($ (($% (($ 0  $$ $($ %.

4'$ %%&%5$ $-5'$ 4'+#&-  0

 $$  $#('%.'$'((%# , .'# 5-$ '--$ &%5 "#$%% &'((%% :#, $- ,%&$ '-,5'
#$0$$!

!?,%  %%     '    $    #$$ $  $'.'  ?.0$/ 
' 1#%&$/-$$$#$$.$$ &'- $$->'-# $&'$- &  

!

 $+  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

 '# !+,

  "&#