(O&M) Puran Singh v. Nachhattar Singh
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-- ./#, *,01$1/&.01 1*+ 2+ ------ 33%44#,$ 5%/+.+ *,01 $1/&.01 1*+ 2+ ------ %+3&,(%,$ 6 2 -
/%+%,$ /- 7--
&(#/#8 (9&)#$%
'&/ #33%44#,$-
/- :1*;%%$ 1#.(1#/<8 (9&)#$%
=*).+./*#% '&/ /%+3&,(%,$- - -
8
-
- 1*+ *+ #33%44#,$(%'%,(#,$6+ %0.4#/ %)&,( 33%#4 #0#*,+$ ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- 8 3#++%( 4%#/,%( %,*&/ .:
.(0%8 */+#> ?1%/%:< '&/ 3&++%++*&, 3/%%=3$*&, '*4%( &/*0*,#4 34#*,$*''
*,018 (%)/%%( #4+& ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- 8 3#++%( 4%#/,%( ((*$*&,#4 !*+$/*)$ .(0%8 */+#> ?1%/%:< #, #33%#48 '*4%( ./#, *,01
(%'%,(#,$ +.*$ #0#*,+$ $/*#4 ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- 8 (*+=*++%(- - , $1*+ ;.(0=%,$8 3#/$*%+ #/% /%'%//%( $1%*/ &/*0*,#4 +$#$.+ :%'&/% $/*#4 &./$-
- /*%'4<8 34#*,$*''
*,01 +&, 1*$#, '*4%( '&/ 3&++%++*&, 3/%%=3$*&, #0#*,+$ (%'%,(#,$
./#, &, 34%# 1% )&+1#/%/ ;&*,$ @1%?#$ 4#,( #$ $*=% +#4%8 %A%).$%( =$- #)1*#/ 7#./ ?*(&?
1/* ./;%%$
*,01 +&, 1*$#, *,018 9*(% /%0*+$%/%( +#4% (%%( (#$%( -- 8 '#9&./ (%'%,(#,$
./#, *,01- $ 34%#(%( 34#*,$ 34#*,$*''
)&,$*,.%( :% )&+1#/%/ $*44 '*4*,0 =$- #)1*#/ 7#./ 1#( +&4( 4#,( (%'%,(#,$
./#, ?*$1&.$ #,< ,&$*)% 34#*,$*''
*,01-
- $ 34%#(%( )#+% 34#*,$*''
1% :%*,0 )&+1#/%/ ;&*,$ @1%?#$ 4#,(> %,$*$4%( 3/%%=3$ +#4% .3&, 3#<=%,$ +#4% )&,+*(%/#$*&,- ))&/(*,04<8 '*4%(- -
, &$1%/ 1#,(8 ./#, *,01
(%'%,(#,$ #33%#/%( )&,$%+$%( )4#*= 34#*,$*''
'*4*,0 ?/*$$%, +$#$%=%,$> ?1%/%*, 34%# $#@%, 34#*,$*''#)11#$$#/ *,01 ,&$ )&+1#/%/ 4#,( #$ $*=% +#4%- $ './$1%/ +$#$%( 34#*,$*''
1#( ,& +.3%/*&/ /*01$ 3/%%=3$ +#4% B.%+$*&,- =&,0+$ &$1%/ &:;%)$*&,+8 *$ #4+& #++%/$%( ./#, *,01
(%'%,(#,$ :#//%( 4*=*$#$*&, :#( '&/ 3#/$*#4 3/%%=3$*&,-
-C $ #33%#/+ 34#*,$*''
+.:=*$$%( 1*+ /%34*)#$*&, '/&= 34%#(*,0+ 3#/$*%+8 $/*#4 '/#=%( '&44&?*,0 *++.%+
!
"
# "
C
$ "
! % &
% ' % ( )
* -
,(%/ *++.% &- 8 $/*#4 1%4( &, :#+*+ %9*(%,)%8 *$ %+$#:4*+1%( 34#*,$*''
)&+1#/%/ #$ $*=% '*4*,0 )&,$*,.%( :% +& $*44 (#$% 3#++*,0 ;.(0=%,$ *-%- (#$%( -- > #))&/(*,04<8 34#*,$*''
1%4( %,$*$4%( 3/%%=3$ +#4% .,(%/ )4#.+% &./$14<6
%)$*&, : .,;#:
/%%=3$*&, )$8 C
+1&/$ 6C )$6-
- %'&/% $/*#4 &./$8 (%'%,(#,$
./#, #4+& /#*+%( 34%# )#+% 34#*,$*''
?&.4( ,&$ '#44 .,(%/ )4#.+% &./$14<6 %)$*&, : C )$8 :.$ +#=% ?&.4( '#44 .,(%/ %)$*&, : C )$ 34#*,$*''
9%,(&/6+
#)1*#/ 7#./ 1.+:#,(6+ :/&$1%/6+ +&,- $ +$#$%( 34#*,$*''
*+ +&, 1*$#, *,01> ?1%/%#+ 1.+:#,( #)1*#/ 7#./8 ,#=%4<8 ./;%%$ *,01 #4+& +&, 1*$#, *,01- $ )&,$%,(%( %)$*&, C )$ (%)4#/%( .4$/# 9*/%+ &,+$*$.$*&, ,(*# &,6:4% .3/%=% ,(*# )#+%
> $1%/%'&/%8 34#*,$*''
)&.4( ,&$ )4#*= /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&, #$ #44-
- 1% #'&/%+#*( )&,$%,$*&, /#*+%( &, :%1#4'
(%'%,(#,$
./#, (*( ,&$ '*,( '#9&./ ?*$1 $/*#4 &./$8 ?1&
&:+%/9%( #4$1&.01 %)$*&, C )$ (%)4#/%( .4$/# 9*/%+ &,+$*$.$*&, ,(*# &,6:4% .3/%=% ,(*#
)#+%
+.3/#> 1&?%9%/8 %)$*&, C )$ +$#,(+ *,$#)$ )#,,&$ :% )&,$/&44%( 3/&9*+*&,+ %)$*&, C )$- ))&/(*,04<8 *$ /%*$%/#$%( 34#*,$*''
)#, )4#*= /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&, .,(%/ %)$*&, : C )$8 $1%/%'&/%8 '*,(*,0 /%$./,%( .,(%/ *++.% &- 34#*,$*''
1#( +.3%/*&/ /*01$ 3/%%=3$ +#4% B.%+$*&, &, :#+*+ 1*+ :%*,0 )&+1#/%/ 4#,(- -
,(%/ *++.% &- 8 '*,(*,0 /%$./,%( 9%,(%%
./#, %,$*$4%( +#4% )&,+*(%/#$*&, +- 8 -
,(%/ *++.% &- 8 *$ 1%4( 9%,(%%
./#, #4+& %,$*$4%( +$#=3 /%0*+$/#$*&, )1#/0%+ '&/ +.= +- C8 8 /%)*$%( +#4% (%%(
A--
,(%/ *++.% &- 34%# (%'%,(#,$./#, *,01 :#( '&/ 3#/$*#4 3/%%=3$*&,8 #4+& /%;%)$%(-
,(%/ *++.% &- 8 '*4%( 34#*,$*''
1%4( :% ?*$1*, 4*=*$#$*&, 3%/*&(-
- 7%%3*,0 9*%?
'*,(*,0+ /%$./,%( $/*#4 &, #44 *++.%+8 '*4%( 34#*,$*''
(%)/%%(8 9*(% ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- 8 0/#,$*,0 '&44&?*,0 /%4*%'
+ , - "
".
/
"
) 0 &1 ) &.+++1
) &1
!. .
"
/
2
) 0 &1 3
) &+++1
1& 4
" ) . &1
5
&60(
! . ".
" " %
* -
%%4*,0 #00/*%9%( #0#*,+$ #'&/%+#*( ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- 8 (%'%,(#,$./#, *,01 3/%'%//%( #, #33%#4 :%'&/% '*/+$ #33%44#$% &./$8 ?1*)1 1#+ :%%, (*+=*++%( 4%#/,%( ((*$*&,#4 !*+$/*)$ .(0%8 */+#8 9*(% ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- 8 /%4%9#,$ %A$/#)$ ?1*)1 /%#(+ .,(%/ ( 3
" 7 8 9 .
1 &:
; , 5 4 &:
; , "
52 4 7 !
, # < 4 5
. 60' 47 0&6
! " !
4 &:
; ,
# "
" , # 3.
&:; , !
2 2 "
.
4 &:;:; = ,.
4 , . ! 4 4 >. 4 "
8
3
8
"
0 8 6 ! .
%
) )* C- , #'&/%=%,$*&,%( )*/).=+$#,)%+8 *,+$#,$ %0.4#/ %)&,( 33%#4 1#+ :%%, '*4%( :%'&/% $1*+ &./$-
- %'&/% $1*+ &./$8 4%#/,%( )&.,+%4 '&/ #33%44#,$(%'%,(#,$
./#, 1#+ /#*+%( &,4< &,% +.:=*++*&, +*,)% 34#*,$*''
/%4#$%( 9%,(&/
#)1*#/ 7#./> $1%/%'&/%8 1*+
)4#*= )&.4( 1#9% :%%, (%)/%%( &,4< *,9&@*,0 3/&9*+*&,+ %)$*&, C )$8 ?1*)1 +$&&( /%3%#4%(- D*$1 #'&/%+#*( +.:=*++*&,8 3/#<%/ 1#+ :%%, =#(% '&/ (*+=*++#4 34#*,$*''
*,01-
-
, &$1%/ 1#,(8 /- :1*;%%$ 1#.(1#/<8 4%#/,%( =*).+./*#% #33%#/*,0 '&/ /%+3&,(%,$34#*,$*''
1#+ &33&+%( +.:=*++*&,+ /#*+%( 4%#/,%( )&.,+%4 '&/ #33%44#,$(%'%,(#,$ +.:=*$$*,0 +*,)% %)$*&, C )$
(%)4#/%( .4$/# 9*/%+ &,+$*$.$*&, ,(*# &,6:4% .3/%=% ,(*#
)#+%
+.3/#> #))&/(*,04<8 $1%/% ,& :#/ '&/ )&./$+ :%4&?
)&,+*(%/*,0 )4#*= /%+3&,(%,$34#*,$*''
.,(%/ %)$*&, : C )$- % './$1%/ +.:=*$+ %9%, *'
%)$*&, C )$ 1#( ,&$ :%%, (%)4#/%( :% .4$/# 9*/%+8 %9%, $1%, )4#*= /%+3&,(%,$34#*,$*''
'&/ 3/%%=3$*&, +#4% )&.4( 1#9% :%%, )&,+*(%/%( %*$1%/ .,(%/ %)$*&, : C )$ &/ .,(%/ %)$*&, C )$- /- 1#.(1#/< './$1%/ 34#)%+ /%4*#,)% .3&, ;.(0=%,$ /%,(%/%( &,6:4% .3/%=%
!
"#$
%- ))&/(*,04<8 4%#/,%( =*).+./*#% #33%#/*,0 '&/ /%+3&,(%,$ 34#*,$*''
3/#<%( #33%#4 *+ :%/%'$ #,< =%/*$ +#=% :% (*+=*++%(-
- 1#9% 0*9%, =< $1&.01$'.4 )&,+*(%/#$*&, +.:=*++*&,+ /#*+%( /-
&(#/#8 4%#/,%( )&.,+%4 '&/ #33%44#,$ ?%44 4%#/,%( =*).+./*#% /- :1*;%%$ 1#.(1#/<8 (9&)#$%-
- 1% *++.% #/*+%+ :%'&/% $1*+ '&/ )&,+*(%/#$*&, *+ ?1%$1%/ 34#*,$*''
:%*,0 /%4#$%( 9%,(&/
#)1*#/ 7#./ )&.4( 1#9% )4#*=%( /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&, &,4< *,9&@*,0 3/&9*+*&,+ %)$*&, C )$8 ?1*)1 1#+ #4/%#(< :%%, (%)4#/%( :% .4$/# 9*/%+ &,+$*$.$*&, ,(*# &,6:4% .3/%=% ,(*#
)#+%
+.3/# ,&$ .,(%/ %)$*&, : C )$ 1*+ )#3#)*$< )&+1#/%/ 4#,(
- #9*,0 )&,+*(%/%( =#$$%/ *$+ %,$*/%$<8 #= )&,+*(%/%( 9*%?
#'&/%+#*( *++.% ?&.4( :% )&9%/%( ;.(*)*#4 3/&,&.,)%=%,$ /%,(%/%( &,6:4% .3/%=% ,(*#
! )#+%
+.3/#8 ?1%/%*, *$ 1%4( /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&, *+ #9#*4#:4% /%4#$*9%+8 ?1& 1#33%, :% )&+1#/%/+-
, +#*( )#+%8 #33%44#,$ 1*@1# #= '#$1%/6+ :/&$1%/6+ +&, 9%,(&/> #))&/(*,04<8 *$ 1%4( %A3/%++*&, 6&$1%/ )&+1#/%/+6 *=34*%( )4#.+%
&./$14< %)$*&, : C )$ ?&.4( )&9%/ #33%44#,$ $1%/%*, 1% 1%4( %,$*$4%( %A%/)*+% /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&,- , ,.$+1%448 *$ 1%4( $%/=+ %)$*&, : C )$8 /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&, #9#*4#:4% @*,+'&4@ 9%,(&/8 *'
$1%< 1#33%,%( :% )&+1#/%/+- 1% /%4%9#,$ %A$/#)$ &:+%/9#$*&,+ =#(% &,6:4% .3/%=% ,(*#
! )#+%
+.3/# /%#(+ .,(%/ $ 3 /
#
2= 2 4 &:;:; , 9 / ,. 6+&. "
. 4 .
.
. / . .
"
. . .
.
.
? .
:
;
" .
.
/ "
!
"
.
2 2 3 6+& ,
6 ,. , 4 & ,
6'+.
/
.
" ? .
.
.
.
?
".
.
. ".
.
4 &
6'+ "
/
/ .
". = .
2 2 " "? 4 .
2 " "? 3 .
2 2 2 " "? = .
=
) .
" "
4 &:;:;
"
"
2 2
"
4 7
" "
.
/
"
.
. #
"
" , $ & 7 ,
3 , 2 . : ;
.
# #
3 7 "
4 &:;:; ,
"
.
- , 6:;:+.
"
, $ & 7 72 , 2
"
" " "
4 &:;:; "
3
2 2
"
# # "
!
#
"
. /
3
4 &:;:; 3
22
"
7
" " , $ &
3 "
7 3.
7
#
"
3
. .
"
2 2 4 &:;:; , 7 > 2 :,!) 60( 4 7 '0; #
22
2 2 . .
" > 2 " & !
3
7
2
" "
. 8
"
.
" ".
"
"
! 8
. 7
7
"
8 7
3
@* - D1%, '#)$+ )*/).=+$#,)%+ *,+$#,$ )#+% #/% )&,+*(%/%( &, $&.)1+$&,% '*,(*,0+ /%$./,%( &,6:4% .3/%=% $1% ! )#+%
+.3/#8 $1%/% *+ ,& =#,,%/ (&.:$ /%+3&,(%,$34#*,$*''
1#( /*01$ 3/%%=3$*&, .,(%/ %)$*&, : C )$
*$ %A*+$%( &, (#$% 3#++*,0 ;.(0=%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( -- $/*#4 &./$ :%*,0
)&+1#/%/ 4#,(8 #4$1&.01 1% #4+& /%4#$%( 9%,(&/
#)1*#/ 7#./-
- , 9*%?
#:&9% (*+).++*&,8 *$ *+ 1%4( '*,(*,0+ 4%#/,%( /*#4 ?%44 4%#/,%( '*/+$ #33%44#$% #/% :#+%( .3&, 3/&3%/ #33/%)*#$*&, '#)$+ 34%#(*,0+8 %9*(%,)% &, /%)&/( ?%44 4#?
+%% ,& *44%0#4*$< &/ 3%/9%/+*$< $1%/%*,- -
%+.4$#,$4<8 *,+$#,$ %0.4#/ %)&,( 33%#4 *+ (*+=*++%(8 :%*,0 :%/%'$ #,< =%/*$- - %,(*,0 #334*)#$*&,
+8 *'
#,<8 +1#44 #4+& +$#,( )4&+%(- - %'&/% 3#/$*,08 $1*+ 34#)%+ &, /%)&/( *$+ (%%3 #33/%)*#$*&, '&/ 9#4.#:4% #++*+$#,)% /%,(%/%( 4%#/,%( =*).+ ./*#%/- :1*;%%$ 1#.(1#/<8 (9&)#$%-
!
--
+;@+ D1%$1%/ +3%#@*,0 /%#+&,%(
"%+
& D1%$1%/ /%3&/$#:4% "%+
&