Gurbachan Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab
!!!""##
$% &
!!! "
'% %! "$%()* %+""## %! +&" %
,#)-)'& ./!
1+
""#
%2
+*%
%%/3+#% #
4&2)2)&" )
5!!1+ ("&2 *% , %, /3+#% #
4&2 &"%*
*
+%2 %, 2
+& %
&& %
) ) 6) )& % +7'!
%*%) +%&2+ "%
2 %%) %, /3 + #% #
4&2 ) !
)+"%
(" &" + )++%
%8% ("%
( ) )
!
!"
!"
!"
!"
!"
!
##+ ,% %%& &%% #3) )+"%
" /3+
. #, %%/ %(+"% + /* ("&2 &/ * ("%
( ) )/( (" &" ++(!1+%%, %% )
# +## 2/3+ )+%&2++ %%%
2+
""#/%+
&%!
!
1+/% + %+ "%"% & %3)97,
%2
%2
+& + ( ("#
:%(.
2+) ,+%
)++ ++
%
* ##2 ;%,#! !
!
) +# 2, ++
3& 2%/%+%:&#"
2++2 %,#;/&6 "(%;
2(# !<+ +3+%+ "+ %
* ##2),+ +
(#%) %+& % +
2+ %.
2+)+3& + % +
2+ %.
2+)-&%/+
2+ % +
2+ : +( %
2+ %.
2+)##%
* ##2 ;%,#,%
"% +% +
2!2: +( %
2+,
%+(!2 +% / +(!=+"
;&"/% ;/ +%, ,% + 2!% "%
%/&
2+ (!=
/%+%:&#"
2++ ; (+& 3
2++3% >&%%#!1+%%)+3+2 %,#; %&% %/& (
& !<+ +3,%%+ % ++& % +
2+)+3+ % +
2+)-&%/+
2+) +%("%
2+) #/ %
2+ : +( %
2+,%
2! #/ %
2+, %(, + ,%)-&%/+
2+, %(, + (##;
) : +( %
2+ % +
2+,%%(, + ;
+%("%
2+, ("3+ ! ;
2+()+%("%
2+%
##;% ++3 +&# / "%/& +3+2 * /% ;//#,+ % 2!1+3+ %/&
2+(!-&%/+
2++2 * ;
/#, , +
;
##+ (),+ ++%
+( #++!
: +( %
2++2 * 2/#,
"%
%%* /#,)++%
+
% 2++ 2+
2% +
+ ! #/ %
2+ % +
2++&2++#:&#"
2+%(+
,
2*+ (
/#, !1+ )+3%
#%(?% % @!'"# %( 2+/&%+)+
, '%,
%:&% & #+
2++( + "!## +& % ,3 %(+ ", + + % % * ,"
!=
& #+
2++%% 2%*+ # ; ( #= "
#):7 :+ )/&+, %%% #= "
#)2&
% &
+
!
%("#
* 2
+% /3+
* 2
2 % )%"%& %
%!'!!), # /%+#% (( #&%) )+#%+%%"% (( +& %% #+#%
&% !
A!
1+& &" /
2+%2%+%%, )
"#2& #3 # (% #!
"%+"% & )+"% & + %# &" +
"% & ,
! ++%+ )+& %# ) &" +
,
6!
1+#% &
#""%
2%+""## )+ , + (&+ * 2% /% +
&%) + + *% ) )
>& +%, + &"% /( (" &" ++ )
( /#%
%% )/
2(/3+
&%)
%
, +* 2%
(
%"% ) ""% *
%%! 1+"% ( %"% & ,
:%(.
2+!=
+
.&%* (!= ""
+,
/8 '< !7
"
("%
8(
+ + &""%+*%
>&+2
+ "% & )
%+
+ % 97 #2 >& + &%% ) ) /( (/
B8!' !1% #3+% /& + & -&%/+
2+) )##+%& )
%
%3%# + % /
2%() )+ % , +& % +%
#
&"
"% !=,*%)++ +& +%(.
, , #
3," !1+%#*
%
%3&%% )%+ ##* +* ('< ##2#3 % ;
2+2+& ), +/% ;/) %+%&%%
(
& +%%) )+
&%% )
(/
"# %%
B8!'
!
1+
&% (3 "%
+ ("# * %3
3+"
'<
%%
8(
+ ) #3 ,+ &%
2+&% +
%
8(
)+( * #32%
#3
(/##
+% ("%*)&" )+
"%* & #3%% (
,%
2) C% +
(
2 % +"% & *%
/( %%
8(
+ !7 +% *&%)%
2+ '< %%
%
8(
%*# )++#% &
#)+ &%
2+"+ +
%
8(
2'< )(+ 3 &22
%+ #
2%(+ () 3
,%)
"%
)>& +
"%
2+ (/##
+% ("%*&"
"%* & ( %%
,%
2) ) % 3 &22
)/(( + () ) /* & #3 % 3# /(& %+%(+ ()%+%
"#3
2)+ +
+ %
2+
)%%
8(
+ !
5
% #3) + ) + '< ) % ( * %3,%+!1+&%+%% %(;
2+%
% )
%,
%(+&(+#% &
#)&" )"%
2 & %
8(
)&" '<
(
&22
+ ()>&+" # &%% ) ) % /& + & ) /
2 >&# + & 8%
2+% 2+"% * /3!1+"%"2 +% /* & #3
(2
%3+ >&
2+" # &%% )%+%;
2"#+%#*
&%% !
1+ ( '<
&""%/3+ ( +
/%+% :&#"
2+),+ # ;'< )'<+ )
8(
+ % /&
%
%3%#+& !B*
%
8(
+#% &
#)+ / /## %(+ ( 3
,%) 3 &22 )+ )(2
3
2++, &#%,
+ &%% ) ) % + / /# # %( + () 3
,% %+%
3
2++ +%(/##
+% ("%*&" )+
"%* & #3%%
(
,%
2) C%+
%
%
8(
)+
%% >&+"% & ) %%
8(
+ )
%) 3 % &# &%
+
"
) >& +
%
2 + '< )+
/%+%!1+ >&#+%
+ + % '<%(
& ("+) )# &%+%
% /(
"&%% + + "% & + / "% ( /# "%* + "% & ) %+
+97) )%%
B8!' !
1+/* %% % /#&#%& >&+ "% & )
&""% /3 ( # * ) ("%
+ '<!&%
2+
8(
+ )++ "%* B8!' 6!
B8!' 6
+( #2#% * (:%(.
2+!=+ # "%* +&() /( %%+%
) /( 8% +%
%!
! "# $
!
%*%)'<A,++( #2##38(
* (:%(.
2+)+ &%
2+&% +
8(
+ )+ "%* 1 1+""
1 )/( /%
B8!' 6!%*%)++ # +)&" )+
"%&
2+1 %"%) ("%
B8!' 6) +%(+"
)++
8
B8!' %# 2%
!
+ (3)+&2+ +%
+%( % /#( #& >&+"% & ), + ( #* &"%!
!
%*%) , + '<
+
"
("%
+
8(
+ ) "%*
2 +
%%
2 +
# &% ( & -&%/+
2+) (/
B8!' ),+%
)+
&% +& ) )+,
+% = .
2+)+ 8
!
9&%+%(%)
&/ >& +%+%&2+%*%3((/%
B8!'
A)+
%
%3,"
(&+ )+
# /3+
B8!' )/& /3+ (
&
&" +* ( ) %+% /( %*%) ) ,+ &( "%"% +%) %+% %(
"%* #3 &
/3 & -&%/+
2+! 1+%%) +
%
%3 %# -&%/+
2+
+ " # %
) /(
&""%)/3+%%, (( )% *#3("%
B8!' ) )
B8!' A!
A!
)'<
(/
8(
+ )+ "%* B8!'< C),+%
/( (/ +
# &%
( (+ ()/3& #*
2+), +% "+
#
2;
%"
+& ) ), ++
+%
>&+
, ##
&% %*%3+
)+
* 2
2 % !
7("% #3+%
)+"%* #3&
&% +%& #/ %
2+)8
!
&/ >& +(;
2B8!'< C)& #/ %
2+
&%%*%3;
%" B8!'< C9%(+"#
;"
2)+
* 2 % ) )>&+%, +%*%3 ((B8!'< C-/("%"%!1+%%)
% +
%
%3 %#& #/ %
2+
) # 2+% &""%+%%(!
;,
)+
# &% ( & +%(.
2+
"%* /3'< + //%
B8!'< C=) )+%
"%* #3 &
&% 8
) ),+ ++%%
&%+%*%3+
%
%3," )
(&+ 2)+
* 2
% )+%&2+((/%
B8!'< C7!
6!
%(+)+%&2+##+%/% (( ""%
2 +%%*% (% *#3+
-&%/+
2+) #/ %
2+ +%(.
2+)+"% & "%* +2& #+ & &"%) +()+ "%* #3
+8
+ % *#
&% ) ++% *#3%, (( &"%) )/( "%"%/3+
* 2
2 % )+ %% *
! %& +/*)3+%
#3/&&%3
+ #2
2+97) )(/
B8!' )+
:%(.
2+
.&%* () ),++ ""
+,
/8 '< !1+ "% & (3 #)(%#3 & +%#3)3) *# 8"#
% " + % #3 , / ( /3 + "% & !1+%#3+&2+""% /,## 8"# /3'< )
(&+ )
+>& ; "%(" >&#+;
2"#+ %#* &%% )%+%+("#
:%(.
2+/(
2#% /3'< )/ (; ( ),+% )+
>& %
2+%>&
) #3 6!
!
!=,*%)* +%#3+ ) +% (2%& %+%/(,##8"# /3+"% & )3)'<,
"%#&(; (
% "+" #&%% )+ "# 2 !1+%%),+ '<)+* (E /%+%)%+%,
&#%,
+&%% )3+
(
2#2 97>&+ &%% ), ++"# 2 3 )
)+"% & !
%*%)+&%+% >&##3
+#2
2+97) )# +
>&# '<) "&%"% &#% ,
+ &%% ) %+% "%("#3%"%
2+
+"# )
+)+ '<
+ "&%"%#3(
2%%/% + '< )
/
3&%% / # 3!1+&%+%%(+)
+ + # %3 '< )
%
+
&%) %(+*% )
>& +%, + &"%) /( (" &" ++& !
1+/*%,
% 2+% (( &(%(+&( '< )(;
2%*% ##+##2
%
%3,"
%(* +"% & +%(.
2+)3+%( %*%3/(
2#
)%(+&('< )+
.&%* ()
%%
8(
+ )%+% #3% &#
2+ +%#* (& +%(.
2+), , #
2 3,"
!1++%#
)
+ + & -&%/+
2+) ) #/ %
2+),+ % *
) %+%%*% +%#*
%
%3,"
+ ,% (+7 * 2
2 % )""%/+ #3 %+% "% +%#*
&%% ),+% )/* & #3++% & >&,+(# '<)
8(
+ ) %% ++3 ,%# , #
%
%3," ) )++
# +
";
&"
"% )
/
%&/"% + %#*
&%% !1+% /
2+% %#3 %*% 3
%
%3," ) )##2#3& /3+()&" )+ "% +* (%+%/(%*%+ %% *
)+ * 2
2 % !
+ (3)++% #&
)
/ (/
# 2, ++ )"%"2
2+% 2+"% * /3!1+7 * 2
2 % )&"
""
+,
/8 '<)+ +++%%5! ) )%%
B8!'
!7
8(
+ '<+ " )+++##+ D % *#3& -&%/+
2+) ): +( %
2+!1+ %%, D ""%
2& -&%/+
2+) ) & : +( %
2+) ) /(% *#3%%
B8!
B8!)* #3"% & )+
%%
+/*D ),%
# + %% *"%
) + (
+ !7 +%,% )+%%, D %#
/(
&%%/( #)&" +"% +& )+ &%
2+&% + &#,+ +%&" '< :%(.
2+) )+& !1+&2+)+%#*
%
%3 &#, &/ >& +&%% +* (/% ;/
2+2+& ) C% +""
(
& +%%!=,*%)
/%(
,++%+ + &
"%*
2)++("#
# 2, + :&#"
2+)*%
2+)++
%
2+) )+
2+)+,+(/(
&22 '< )
%
8(
) / , #
2
%
%3 ," )%+%"%
+22%
%(& + 22%
&" +& ) #3&" +("#
# 2, ++%
%)+
2+22%
)%+%,&#" +& %"&# )+%&2++ % *# #38%
2+% 2+"% * /3!
% )+
&%+ /# *+ '<
,## '<)+%&" +
* /# >&#+%)
+) # + '<
%
8(
%+%
2+##+/*,%%( % *#3 , + ," ) ) # +
2 >& + %
"%
2)
+22%
%(& +22%
&" '< )+ + '<# 2, +++% %),%+
% +22%
%%
&"%)+ &(% # % 2+'< # 2, ++%
/*)+ ,
"%"% ##3+ 2+%+ &(% # % 2++ & ) ),+ ++(,%# >&##3%(!1+%%) +& ,%/#3 # & %#,)%*# #3%"&#
2+ 22%
/(
##3(& &" +()/3'< # 2, ++%
%)&
&" +"% +* (!1+%8%
2+ % 2+"% * /3)/3+& )
&""%)/3+/* %%%D )/(% *#3"%* /3<
1+7 * 2
2 % + ""% #3%+%2 *
+% +% )+/*) )+
( "% & (
% ; %#3
* 2)+97 C%+ ),+% )
++ ( %
* 2 +%
& / & #&% %3>& +" #%
),&#+*(%2!
>& #3)
C#&% *%
)>&+2
+"% &
/(&##3" /3+
&%!'%(
#3%+%,+ %+% %
)+ & +* &
"%*
2)+
+ % ( #3
#
) &" +"% +* ()+ % (;
2+
&"%) #3&"
+ % *# #38%
2+% 2+"% * + %% *"%
!
!
1+%
(%
+ ""#) ) + (
##,! 1+
("&2 *% ) )
>& +%, + &"% /( (" ) &" + & /3 + #% % # &% ) &% %( 2%* "%*%
3) ) / &% 3 2%
(
""% * %%) )# 2%* ""% * ) ""%
2+ % % *#3*# #38%
2+% 2+ "% * + %% *"%
!
1+*% )
>& +%, +
>& +) )
!1+& )
& 3/%+, + # /%3!
(& ) "
/3 +( / %& +(! 1+ % % * "% # &%3/ +## %+, + ##) )
+%2) ) +%% / , %+, +!1+,"
%%%/ %3%+8"
%3+"% #
!
'
2(
## & ""# ) 3)# )
" !
! !!
"#$"#%&'#()*+,-%#(&.+#/0 #&-.