← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4575/2021allowed

Sham Lal v. Union Of India And ORS

2023-12-22Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages



  

          

   !"#" $%&%'

()   *  + ,&- & %&%.  

/0 + ,%% % %&%.       

!! 

 

 

(, 12 (  3 4 3(    



    

   "#$    

   % &#' (((( 4 3( 5  )* +*    +

 *   ,

   

  



!

%

$

- * 

    ,

 

 /

 

 ,*   !

 '

    + 

 +

 * 

,

   * ',*

 

  

   

 

 % )

* 

     

+- ,* % ,   ,   0+    +

 

    0   





 

!

1 +*2%&3)4!12

%

%&3)5 

 "&6677

"&6%77



  8   9

 41,  !

 :35  9  41,  !

 3%5  ;

       

   !

  

 $  4$5  !

 1 +*

 %6'< '6 7$

 07 +7*8 0 )9+,  %'7:"7%3 ,*

 

$4%5

%37<"7%6, - *++

"$%""7%6,* '29

* -

2 2, 

 

      ;

       

 '6 7$



:

 $  +7*8 29) .     

 +   +

-

   8   9   +

  %3%0"<&7 /, 6'00&4"2%656'00'432%5 +   ,

=   =

   

   

>

  1>

0 1  



!

%'7$

%"7$"77& +,

,*

   

 + 

* 

   ?

 /, 6'00& + +>

6'00' ! =

 !

 '29

+  

+

"$%""7%6

/, 6'00$&@<& :7'02  + >

 /, 

* 6'00'

+ @%$ %"'02  + ++ *,

* 

* " ?

 9A !

%:<3% "7"7 ,

+  +

+



":%7"7"7' ;/ <.)

  *

  

 

* ; 

.

 



7&%""7"7' ;/ <!)   

 $



 



/ *





 +

 =  



"<7""7"% 9

$



   



+ 

  , 

     * 

 %67'"7""   ,*   !

$

 #   

,



/, 6'00'+    / /, 6'00 $ &     ,

  B/C)  ,

   B/;

+  +    /, 6'00&6'00'+ +    / 0' ;/ <)1  ,

+

, ,   

>

 

* 

  ,   

   !

 '29  +   



 %&

  > D

         

   4 % &#'5+     !1 4 !

"#$5 ,

 

 *

+ 

$=4'5

 + 

  



*

/ ,

  

 +

 + 

  ,   

 

  

 

 $=4'5

 +     +

!

  

       

 

  



  



 

           

   - 

+ *  ,

  

 

       ,

 ,* +*  +

 

* ,

  + + +

 ,  &  

     

     2,

/  ,    ,* 

 

   ;, % +

"$%""7%6 

,  6'00&6'00'+  +    ?

+  8  9 ,

 , 

+

   1

+   

      !

 ,

 / ,  +

. * 

 % 



6'00&4  6'00$6'00: + 5

,

,

 B/)  +  B/

+ , /

+   ,   

 + = /

 @  "%$602   -  * 4   <& :7'02   5 

+

"$%""7%6       E"##$ !%& &$'!!''() *'!!  "  



  

 

   

 !

 

"

#

 $%&&' ( )      *# + 

  *# -     

    !

   #

    

  

   #

    

  ./0 0 +  # 0  



 



 

 



 !

  #

 $%&&'()     0 #    1  # 0 ,2

3 45 -."44"6'      7  + 8# 9   

 !



   #

 $%&&' ( )   90  #    #  '$&2! .  D

 +



6'00'

+

 +   

  *     ,

   /  

 /  

  

 

 + *

* 

  /      

 

 + 

  

  

  +   @  "% 777  4 %$ %"'02 5 '+&'' !%& &$'!!''() *'!!  .

:

$(&&;$&$&6&$%&&%

 !



  

 2

"% 

  



   7    #

  

 0    



66$        

             #  #  0    

 " 

  

 

#

  

  

  #

 - 

   #

     5    

  

   0  , 

    

2    #

 8# 9        

=

  

 

  0   +        7  #

     0  0 ,0     1 # 0  











; 45 -."44"6'  7+8#9  

!



 #

 $(&&  ; $& $& 6 < $%&&%  0

: 7 66666&  ! 

 / 0' ;/ <)+  +

+ 

*>

-  / !

6'00'   +



* 



  -  / ,  6'00& )

  ,  ,



*>

 F,

 B/2)  ,

  

B/

+ 

+

 , +  +    

+ + *,

* "  ?

    45   

 

 

 +     ,

*     

 

  / ,  6'00'



    / , 6'00&  

 + +   

 + 

  

;    *     - * 

, , *  

,

  

 *





 , 

+

,



 



         F      * ,

   

* 

    ,

        

#



  

 *   +  

 

* 

      * ,



9

 B



+ 

 ""<  9

   

 

*    



 +

   +   

  >

  = 

 *    +

 +*?

* + $$ +

 

2  

+



 

 /, 6'00'+



  

/









*+

/!

6'00&  

 ' 





      / !

 6'00'   

    , 

+,

 ,

 

    ,  +   

 ,

  # 

   

 

45  *        @:

%%5%&%.    '4 3( ) = >& ## =      ?2# 0&

@&A

?4  @&A