← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1500/1988dismissed

Om Parkash And Another v. Om Parkash

2019-03-29Mr. Justice Amit Rawal7 pages





     





!"# $%&&'()(*+ $,'-#.# / $,0$)- $*%-&, 11&22$*%) 3&,)4) / $,0$)-  &)1*5&*%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

,&)&*%+

, / $,0$)--$,/$.56'$%&.

,%-&$11&22$*%)

,&/$*%$))(.56'$%&.

,%-&,&)1*5&*% 77777 )(*$+&

-(),5&,/(*&)-$225()1)& &842$,&'*511&$2 $%%-&(*)%$*'&$11&22$*%"12$(*%()$*5,))"9:&'%(*) !"# 9;%-&,&)1*5&*%"5&&*5$*% $,()(*8 4% $5&'()(* ,&*5&,&5(*(6(24(%#%(%2&5$)< / $,0$)-$*549-$)- )*)/%-$8=$%(3&,)4) / $,0$)-)* $/

2$(*%())%$%&5%-$%%-&;$,&)*) -$8=$%(5$48-%&,

$(> &-2$5(*8--$8=$%(-$5/$,,(&5-(/(*8-$*54% %-()  =&52'0.  %=  )*).  (&. %-&  12$(*%()  =&,&  9,*  &-2$5  $(  -$5 14,'-$)&5  %-&  1,1&,%;  6(5&  )$2&  5&&5  5$%&5  ???  ,&8()%&,&5  * ???.(&.-$2)-$,&(*-()*$/&$*5$*%-&,-$2(*%-&*$/&*& / $,0$)-%&,%-&5&$%- $(.-$8=$%(=$)%-&)2&=*&, %-&1,1&,%;$)-&.54,(*8-()2(&%(/&.&@&'4%&5$A(225$%&5#B?

,

@ C)1&'(;(*8%-$%-&-$5*2;*&5$48-%&,&&*5$*% / $,0$)- =$).(*$'%.%-&)* $/ &&*5$*%  =$)  &$,2(&,  1,'&&5&5  &@"1$,%&  $*5  $%&,  -$6(*8 8,$*%&51&,/())(*%'*%&)%.11)&5%-&)4(%$22&8(*8-(/)&2%9&)*

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

<   

      

  

         

 

   

    

    

      



 

    !      " #           

$      %       & '  



 " 

  

    ( (  ( & ) * +

-

2$(*%().(*)411,%%-&&6(5&*'&.&@$/(*&5)(@=(%*&))&) $*5$2)9,48-%*,&',55'4/&*%)@ %@ B4,(*8%-&1&*5&*';

%-&)4(%.$/&*5/&*%=$)'$4)&5(*%-&12$(*%%12&$5%-$%-$8=$%(-$5 (*-&,(%&5-$2)-$,&%-&-4)&$2)*%-&9$)()%-&A(22&@&'4%&59;

$($*5*%-&9$)()%-&$/&*5/&*%.$55(%(*$2())4&?=$) ,$/&5-&)$/&,&$5)%-4)+"

<',   -(   "

   (

  . 

"        &+ -&,&$%&,.%-&12$(*%()&@$/(*&5 A"B $%4(*8-. A" $25&64%%$*5 A" &,/$*$*5$*59,48-%*,&',55'4/&*%)@  %@ #C *%-&%-&,-$*5.%-&5&&*5$*%&@$/(*&5)&6&*=(%*&))&)$*5 9,48-%*,&',55'4/&*%)@%@B*,&94%%$2.12$(*%()$2) &@$/(*&5*&$8$, $2$) A"-&)$2&5&&5(*D4&)%(*-$)9&&* 9,48-%*,&',5$)@.=-('-,&2&'%&5%-$% $($2*8=(%- /

$,0$)-.-())*.-$514,'-$)&5%-&-4)&(*D4&)%(*:(*%2; *%-&9$)()%-&$,&/&*%(*&5&6(5&*'&.%-&%,($24,% 5&',&&5%-&)4(%-25(*8%-&12$(*%()%9&=*&,)%%-&&@%&*%-$2 )-$,&$*5)4(%D4$%-&,-$2)-$,&=$)5()/())&5=$11&$2)-$6&9&&* (2&5.94%%-&)$/&-$6&9&&*5()/())&5*%-()/$**&,.%-&1,&)&*%$11&$2 $*5',))"9:&'%(*)=&,&(2&5

, / $,0$)--$,/$.2&$,*&5'4*)&2$11&$,(*8*9&-$2 %-&$11&22$*%"12$(*%())49/(%%&5%-$%5&&*5$*% / $,0$)-=$)**& &2)&94%)* $/$*5%-()$'%=$)$%%&/1%&5%9&1,6&5 %-,48-%-&%&)%(/*; A"#$;$$*5.'-2&$'-&,.=-9,48-% *,&',5-())'-2$5/())(*,/5$%&5!? @ #%&)%$92()- %-$% / $,0$)-=$)%-&)* $/*$'%.5&&*5$*%$(2&5% 2&$5 $*; &6(5&*'&(*  %&,/)  1,6()(*) &'%(*   %-& *5($*

.

6(5&*'&'% ,)-,%.%-&'%%&)%$92()-%-&1$,&*%$8& / $,0$)- *%-&%-&,-$*5.12$(*%($11&$,&5-(/)&2$*5$2)&@$/(*&5$*%-&, =(%*&))=-%&)%((&5%-$% $(-$5*2;*&5$48-%&,-$8=$%($*5 **&&2)&$*$, A".%-&(,)%'4)(*-$8=$%(.)%$%&5%-$% $( -$5*2;*&5$48-%&,$*5*%-&,)*-&A(22$,&/&*%(*&5-$)9&&* 1,6&5%-,48-%-&%&)%(/*; A"B $%4 $/.=-)%$%&5%-$% &-2$5

$(.54,(*8-()2(&%(/&.-$5&@&'4%&5$A(22=-('-=$),&8()%&,&5&-$5 )&&*   &-2$5  $(  $2*8  =(%-  %-&,  $%%&)%(*8  =(%*&)) $11&*5(*8  %-4/9 (/1,&))(*)E)(8*$%4,&)*%-&A(22@ C.=-('-=$)542;,&8()%&,&5-& A(225&)*%)1&'(;$*;%-&,'-(25$*5.%-&,&,&.%-&'4,%)9&2=48-% %-$6&5&',&&5%-&)4(%(*&*%(,&%;

,  &/$*%  $))(.  2&$,*&5  '4*)&2  ,  %-&  ,&)1*5&*%" 5&&*5$*%"',))9:&'%,)49/(%%&5%-$%%-&A(22()4%'/&$,$45$*5 /(),&1,&)&*%$%(*-&,&()*,&D4(,&/&*%2$=4*5&,&'%(*?C '%-& *5($*4''&))(*'%$*5?%-&6(5&*'&'%$%%&/1%-$)9&&* /$5&%&@$/(*&,&2$%(6& $((*%&,/)1,6()(*)&'%(*?   %-&  6(5&*'&  '%  2$(*%()  -$5  /()&,$92;  $(2&5  %  &)%$92()-  %-$% -$8=$%(=$)5$48-%&, $($*5=(*8%%-&,&'(%$2(*%-&)$2& 5&&5.%-&)4(%(*&*%(,&%;=$),&D4(,&5%9&5()/())&5

,  -$,/$  -$)  5,$=*  %-&  $%%&*%(*    %-()  4,%  %  %-&

()'112('$%(*9&$,(*8B"#?)49/(%%&54*5&,  ,5&,!

42&#B ,1,54'%(*22=(*85'4/&*%)9;=$;$55(%(*$2 &6(5&*'&%1,6&%-$% / $,0$)-5&&*5$*%()*%%-&)* $( 94% $/+"

< #$5-$,'$,5 / $,0$)-F # C6%&,2()%G



-$6&-&$,5%-&2&$,*&5'4*)&2,%-&$11&22$*%).$11,$()&5 %-&1$1&,90.,&',5)%-&'4,%)9&2=$*5%-&6(&=%-$%%-& 22=(*849)%$*%($2H4&)%(*)I$=$,()&,5&%&,/(*$%(*9;%-() 4,%+"

 /  

 (  0 

1,

 0 

    



 . ".2      (     549%.%-&$11&22$*%"12$(*%()-$5/$5&$'*'&,%&5&,% %1,6&%-$%-$8=$%(=$)%-&*2;5$48-%&,9,*4%%-&2(*) &-2$5

$(.94%%-&12$(*%().9&(*8%-&)*)-$8=$%(.=&,&&*%(%2&5%&*%(,& 1,1&,%;.94%&D4$22;).'$**%)-4%/;&;&)&6&*( $(-$5* %-&,)*'(,'4/)%$*'&)-$6&9&&*1,6&5$*59,48-%*,&',5% &)%$92()-%-$%-=$*54*5&,=-$%/$**&,.,%-&%-&,-$2)-$,&$)1&,%-& )$2&5&&5@. / $,0$)-)* $(=$)%-&'"=*&,-& D4&)%(*$,()&)(*'$)& $(-$5$)* / $,0$)-.=-&%-&,%-&&*%(,& 1,1&,%;=$)%9&5(6(5&5(*%-$2)-$,&&$'-,(*&*%(,&%;=$) /

$,0$)-*$%%&/1%=$)/$5&9;%-&5&&*5$*%%1,6&%-&=*&,)-(1* %-&9$)()%-&5&',&&B.=-&,&(*%-&5&&*5$*%=$)-&25%9&=*&, %-&-4)&(*D4&)%(*11&22$*%"12$(*%()=&,&*%1$,%;*;(*5(*8% %-$%&&'%'$**%%$0&$=$;%-&6$24$92&,(8-%(*%-&$9)&*'&$*;'*%&)% &&*5$*% / $,0$)-'2$(/(*8-(/)&2%9&)* &-2$5

$(. $2)  9%$(*&5  $*  &2&'%,('  '**&'%(* 9;)49/(%%(*8  $*  $112('$%(* ,&&,,(*8-(/$))* $(-&I&8()2$%4,&(*(%)=()5/.-$5 1,%&'%&5%-&(*%&,&)%%-&1$,%(&)9;(*',1,$%(*8&'%(*%-&'%. =-('-&*$92&)%-&1$,%(&)%2&$5&6(5&*'&%&)%$92()-1$,&*%$8&$)%-&

/

)'(&*'&&@;,(94'2&(''(5 %&)%=$)*%(*&@()%&*'&$%%-& ,&2&6$*%1(*%%(/&

A"$*$,)%$%&5%-$%-&()%-&(,)%'4)(*-$8=$%(.94% '425*%5&*;%-&'*%&*%))$2&5&&5@=-('-,&2&'%&5%-&-$2 )-$,&    &-2$5  $(  $*5  %-&  ,&/$(*(*8  -$2    -()  )*  *  )4'- '(,'4/)%$*'&).(%,&/$(*&5$/;)%&,;=-&%-&, $(-$5%='-(25,&*.

(&.-$8=$%($*5 / $,0$)- 2$(*%()-$6&*%9&&*$92&%'**&'%%-& 1$,%('42$,)%-&)'-2'&,%(('$%&@ #=(%-%-&5&&*5$*%%-$%-&=$) $'%4$22;%-&)* $/ -&$55(%(*$2&6(5&*'&)48-%%9&12$'&5*,&',5%-& 1&,(5#'$**%9&%$0&*(*%'*)(5&,$%(*&6&*($*$%%&/1%()/$5& %9,(*8'&,%$(*$'%)=-('-=425&*$92&%-()4,%%,&*5&,5&'()(* &&'%(6&2;*$%%&/1%-$)9&&*/$5&%12$'&*,&',5,&2&6$*%/$%&,($2 =-('-=$)*%=(%-(*0*=2&58&94%2$%&,*$'D4(,&5 ='/(*8%%-&&@&'4%(*%-&A(22%()$,&8()%&,&5 5'4/&*%.

=-('-'$,,(&)$1,&)4/1%(*%,4%- A"B $%4 $/-$59&&* '-&,&*%$*5'*)()%&*%=(%-,&8$,5%%-&'/12($*'&%-&1,6()(*) %-&$,&/&*%(*&5'%%-%-&=(%*&))&)-$5)(8*&5(*%-&1,&)&*'& %-&%&)%$%,6&*(%-&A(225&)*%/&*%(*$94%%-&2(6(*8)*$*5* %-&,1&,)*-$5'/&%)%$0&%-&'2$(/(*,&)1&'%%-&1,1&,%;9;6(,%4& %-&)$2&5&&5 ,$22(*%&*%)$*514,1)&).%-&12$(*%()'425*%'2$(/ %-&)-$,&(*%-&1,1&,%;.,.

$(-$5948-%$*;1,1&,%;%%-&&@%&*%-$2)-$,&(*-()*$/&$*5 %-&,-$2)-$,&(*$64,5&&*5$*% / $,0$)- ;  %$0(*8  (*%  '*)(5&,$%(*  %-&  )%'0    &6(5&*'&  $*5 '4/42$%(6&,&$5(*8%-&)$/&.$/%-&6(&=%-$%%-&(*5(*8)%-&

0

%,($24,%(*8,$*%(*8%-&5&'2$,$%(*%%-&12$(*%()%%-&&@%&*%-$2 )-$,&(*%-&)4(%1,1&,%;$,&1,&&'%$*52&8$2$*5'$**%9&)$(5%9& )4&,(*8,/$*;1&,6&,)(%;,(22&8$2(%;.%-4).)49)%$*%($2D4&)%(*() $*)=&,&5$8$(*)% %-&$11&22$*%"12$(*%() $*5D4&)%(* # $8$(*)% %-& ,&)1*5&*%"5&&*5$*%

,%-&,&$)*)/&*%(*&5$96&.%-&$11&$2$*5$)=&22$)%-& ',))"9:&'%(*)  $,&  5()/())&5  *)&D4&*%2;.  %-&  $112('$%(*)  , $55(%(*$2&6(5&*'&$,&$2)5()/())&5  1,+,   )(*$

231 &'45% *161378 93

 :39

*161 6; :39