High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1215/2021dismissed

Khazan Singh (Deceased) Through Its Lrs And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-12-08Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal18 pages

! " #" $ %&' ( ) %&) * ( ) *

% ) *(

&("# %$ +

( ) ",,'

#" $

%&' -#

. / (

0+ (

1 23

(53(

653 7 * * ) + # 4

(

.# ' 851

. . )

.# ++ 0+ 9 :

" ;. + ')

) # 0

) (

)

- ( . 4 ++

) )

(* ) #.

# . # * (

) 0+ " (

< + ) 0+ ().

0+ ( = )

( # 0

+, ( *

# $

& '

(

& ' $ $ &

&$ '"

3 1

+. 9

) ) ++

* ). ( +

) #(

)

+ + 353

! "

2 + ) 4 . 1 "#

)

% ?<

@%$A$ !,,

B">(B">(B"> B">(

353 2

4 +

2 (= 92+ ) ) 1 /53 * .

922* *B*

2/ * 4

-.-= (1

&+1 * *

+ ₹ +=) 4 (2(C> ,

( '(

+= ₹ ) 4 39(8(3C> :

') 0+ 2/ ₹ )

+=) 4 /((8C> "*)("

7. +') 0+ 2

"(%)*+)% ",*-. /0! "1&1) 23 &%4&*& &*+ 21.)%0 5 65 + . = '*

* + ) , (

)

+ + .# 4

' ₹

'A (2(C>

( * . +

) -.-= (= 5+ (

* (2 (< + #( . 4 29 1 '(

( + *

> ) $

"+,, #- .

/,+)*8) 9%2+(8)+ :4 1.) %)09)81,/) 9&%1,)0 / 1 * (

) (

) (<+

$: + ( * )<+

B +B (&) + ) ! $: <+ B

$:9 / , + # ) ( * ) *

+ (+ (. + *

890+ > ?<$ '# )# 235) * +

2 4+

,%1 % *

2(9(2C> ?<$ '# )# 55) * +

32 4 +

,%1 % *

5(5(C> ?<$ '# *

.#' D E(&+

/ '

?<$ ' #

?<$:C

1 &

0 ?<$

= 0 ?<$ ' #$:%

6 &

0 ?<$>9 ' #$: +

6 &

0 ?<$3 ' #$:9E

6 &

0 ?<$2C ?<$D '# *8

.#' !

=+ * ( E&+

6/ 2

/ '

?<$5C ?<$F '# *98

.#' !

=+ * E(&+

6 &

/ '

?<$F '#E+. #>9) -. -= ?<$F '#E+. #558>5) -. -= ?<$F9 '#E+. #55>59) -. -= ?<$F3 '#E+. #559>53)

?<$F2 '#E+. #55>55)

?<$F/ '# & * #559>53)

?<$F8 '# = 0!

?<$F '#0+. #559>53) B

?<$F5 '#0+. #55>55) B

?<$F '#0+. #55>5) ?<$F '#0+. #55/>58) ?<$F '#0+. #55>5) % ?<$F9 '#0+. #55/>58) % ?<$:C ! ?<$:C .# B +B /9 1",,' <+

- (

% ( %$' (G#!

(&+( :

/3 , + #) ( ",,' *

+ (+ (. +

890+ > ?< '# * 2/ ?< '# .# # '++

)

H '

) &+ ?< '# # .

+ *

?< '# = 0 ?< '# */

.#' =( E($ * (

6..,+& &*+ 2%0 ;0! "1&1) 23 &%4&*& &*+ 2%0< ?< / , 0$

,08(00,2* &*+ *&'40,0 :4 1.,0 2(%1 8 "

* .

.# ' * ' * *

00() 2! 8

( * . +

) .#.

)

. +(*

> "&') +))+0 9%2+(8)+ :4 1.) '&*+2=*)%0 $

?< .

B 1

B ?<$ 2 35 2

4 +

2(9(2C> ((8(3C> % ?<$ 5 5 324 %

5(5(C> 5(9(59C> % 9 ?<$9 /5 >/> 3% 5(/2((C> (2(25C> $ " 3 ?<$3C 38 9 >>% 3((3(C> ((32(322C> -.-=

?<$/ 2 ?<$2 3 928 >% 2(C> ((C> -.-= / ?<$/ 99 288 3>% 8((2C> 38((C> -.-= 8 ?<$8C ?<$8 8 935 >>/% 3(8((C> (((C> -.-= ?<$5 523 2 5>52% /((C> 3(/3(/5C> $ " 5 ?<$ 898 >>% 2(((C> 3(/(//(//8C> E "&') +))+0 9%2+(8)+ :4 1.) " B ?< .

?< 3C ?< 3 99 /33 3>% 5(9(C> 9((C> -.-= ?< 83 3>% ((C> 3((C> -.-= 9 ?< / 8/ /3 9>8% (92(C> 9((9C> -.-= 3 ?< 8C ?< 935 82 23>8% 99(5(/2C> 3(55(C> -.-= 2 ?< 89 53 >5% (8(C> 9((C> -.-= / ?< 95 22 39>9% 8((2C> 2((C> -.-= 8 ?< 9 5 32 3>9% (2(2C> 9(8(829C> -.-= ?< 2 95 2 />3% 9(8(2C> 2((C> -.-= 89

( *

)

.#"# .+ )

) )+=) 4 ( ' ) # *

I >3> 6" /0!

> (11 &*+ 21.)%07 8 83 1 ' * )

-. -= ( *)(

353 I(

?<$2

82 ( ?< 3 2 .#",,'*=

2 1#* # * .#

', (

1 #.

+ *

* + *.#

) *0+ &' .&*+ /0! *,2* 23 *+,& ? " 6?! 1 ( '

.# ",,' ?< 3 2 .# * #

253 8/ , ) *.)

(

* *) )

) .# .=

+=) 4 00() *2! 88

-.-= (*)(# # # 8 1

* . # .

I >85>9 6 .&%&> .&*+ @

.&%&>:,% &*+ 21.)%0 /0! "1&1) 23 &%4&*& &*+ 21.)%0<

I >5> 6,%)*+)% &*+ 21.)%0 /0! "1&1) 23 &%4&*& &*+ 21.)%0< 5(

#*(*)(

4 #(

.&%&> .&*+<0 8&0) 0(9%&( '* * 953 (* +

+=) ) +

353 1 ) 0+ < > @3 4$

)$ -

' $ &

& $

#( !

789 &

' &

' & $ ' ;

< ' & 7 '8

' ;

< ' & 7 '8

' ;

% '

& < '

7 '8 &

' &7 '8

& $ = ;

76 89 6

$ $

6 &

78 $ &

> :9 &

& $ &

$ ' '

% ' ' 7#89 6

$ ? ' @ 6

" # $%

' ( -5 A

B 2 4#C#36-636 #CC3* #!! # #CC3

B 2 E & B

& $ '/ '

F& - 3CC

8 2 / '

6-& 4- & - #3C

, & 6 ' / '

82 / '

- C3CC

8 # 4$

' A / '

F& - #CCC

82 / '

6-& 4- &,

& ' / '

- =CC

8 2 / '

- C CC

( A

$ $

##(#CCG

3 A ' B

$ &

9$ $ &

& $ $ & & B * & .

3#C A

'F / '

4 4(##6-636 #CC*# C ! 4 #CC

' #CCGA ' C!#CC

56 ) $

)

* #

8A F &

2 4#C#36-636#CC3* #!! # C #CC3 $ $

2 4#! 6-636 #CCG* G C=C #CCG9

$ $

& ' & $ #CC 6C! &'

$ F

56 4 ,

H-

7 6

8 H -

$ CGC!#CC

$ F& 2

- #CCC - CCC #

$ 7 8 H 2

8 ,

CGC!#CC7

8B , 7 8F& 62

E 7 &

&$ 2

F& 8 78 I 6J E - =CC - (CCC (

$ B , K & - -$ B K $ ,

- =CC - #3CC

- 4

, 2

CGC!#CC8 , B

$ B ,

4- - =CC

- #CCC

- CC

3 -

& - CC

- #CC

45A

#( 7 8 (CL 7E* #(7#8

8A ' B

$ $ &

7 8

7$ & $ & '

& 8 7

8 - & &

' &

$ &

& $ &

& & A

% 9 $ $ &

&$ $ &

&B * & A $

#(7 8 (CL #(7#8, '

. !

" # $% &'

( # ' )

(

# %+, $% & *

(

- '

" %

(

# % $% & % .

(

. *

# % $% & 1

0 '

" &

)

$% & (

)

(

# % $% &'

(

0 ' (

(. 20

" 1 . (

+ ,

' (

-H 6G 3C6#C

(CC(#C# ('

(

)# A ' = #CCG $ / '

- CCCCC*6 3CCCCC*6

$ $ '

##(#CCG

$ $

# #CC=$

# #CC3 = #CCG

' 3(#CC3 ##(#CCG

' A / '

' #CC3 #CCG'=CL 3CCCCC*6 CCCCC*6

$ & '

M(CL

$ #CC3

(G3L

$ ' #CCGA

& $

' '

$ &

& $

# #CC= &

M(CL & $ '

A & '

# #CC3 $

! H

& &

G(3CCC*6

M G(3CCC*6 A $

' &

$ &

' &

" 1

" 0 # +,+ , $% & - '

(

# + &, *

(

# % $% &

# ( & # $% &

. '

)

" (

(

# % $% &

(. 0

) "

3 '

)

(

# % $% & 3 $% &

(. " - 0

3 .

6 &*

2 (

&' &+

7 &7, - '

# / +,

)

(

# & #

(

- ' (

(

1 '

& "

(

$ %&

' K$

& $

K $

%&9

$ %&

' %& $

& &

$& % A

;

J &

$ .

85 1&) + $ #*

98*

# *

2" ( * . # 00() 2! 8 1

9 .

55? 1,1')+ &0 A,%)*+)% &*+ 21.)%0 /0! "1&1) 23 &%4&*& &*+ 21.)%0< +)8,+)+ 2* ?!!! 1 )

> )9E>4+(

$ &

&* $ '

& +B0

56 ) A & &$

$ & & * & $ 9 ' $

& $

$ '

& E

#( !

& N & &

-$ &

' ' /;

-' $ &

J2, >

$ '

& B J 7-H 63=#C6#C(

/99B

- & C3C#C#8

& - $ #CL 6

& B J/99B

' 3J &

& & $

$ $ #CL

/$ &

' $

$ $

$ & $$

& > &

'& &&

$ '

9 $

$ ' ' &

5 5!

)8,0,2*

) * ( * #

) #(. 353

#32. )+991(

( #(

#" = : =

C D CB :. D CB Sr. No. Case No.

Parties Details ! "

J B,B&"?'?

?1"

HG&",1

BH1"?

!C1 1?HI"

BH1"?

I >> B:

,B&" B BH1"?

!C1 1?HI "

BH1"?

9 I >355> $

??$G%

BH1"?

!C1 1?HI "

BH1"?

3 I >2> $

B,B&"BH??'?

?1"

!C 1 1?HI"

BH 2 I >5> - B1, BH1"?

!C1 1?HI"

B H1"?

/ I >3> -"

B,B&" BH1"?

!C1 1?HI "

BH1"?

#" =