High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/4535/2014dismissed

Bijender Rana v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2015-12-08Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh6 pages

!"#$ "

%& & " '()(

& & * + " "# "

&, $( "#"&(

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , !

-.,/) '

1 "2!3 4 !+ #

, ! !

"!'!

1 "2!3 5

-.,/) '

!.$,+ !

,6'

6/ 1 "2!3 %("&

"& /#0 1 & &, "& 7 ,("& , (3" #& 1, "4!)#45"&

16) && # &# 7 ((# 3+ .)# 1 - 4 (& & (& ((/ 8)4 "/ 0 # 9, 1,/ 11)(# "#"&

/ " 5+/ )4 )&&

, 5 , (3" 16) &&# &,1, 4 "1 (

:# &# 74 (&#)"# "(: "#; % &% 1 & & ;/8)4 " +&, 1&( &,1 ( (5 # )& "&,("& &, & 11)(#

1 #&,( 5 " "&& , ( , )( & &,)4)(&)"1& "(1,#)#& 3,# "&,

( 1 &+ $ ' , "&, &&<&/ 11)(#

1#&, ( 5 " "&& 9 &1,3)5 0 ( "#0" (( )&#, 5 (<) + "(0 11 ( "( ,( 5 " "&& #&,( 1&(& , 5/ "&,3 ( ( 9, 1,/ ( #

$9 (4 (&# 4 "(& 11)(#

, 11 "#)1&#&, "0(& 4 & " "# (&#&, 11)(#&1 5& )() 5 & ( "0(& 4 & "/ 1, ")"# "7%9 (("&# 4 "(&&, 11)(# , &1, 49 ( 5#)"# "(: "#; % 4 "(& 11)(#/& 9, 1,/, ##"

&4) &+ "#1 5#& , (1)& " " #& 0 &(1 (< 5 "# (5 "+ ( 09 &"(((/" 5+/ !"# "4,$ " %= / 5 "4, %= / )+ (, % & %= / * > (, " >)5 %= /

)"# "4,%= , &/ (& &5"& &, 11)(# )"# " %9 (1 ## 11)(# ", (#"10 #"1< 5 "# ) 9 &"(((/" 5+/ !"#44 9 = /-( )5 "= / )#(,

, 5 = /, "! ? = "#> (, "? /

$&# (= " ( 0 #"1 0 3 "1 # "# &, "4 &, & (/&,& )& 16) &&#&, 11)(# &,1, 4 0 #!)#45"&# &#7/9, 1, (&,()3!1&5 && 1, "4 "

&,("& ? "#1 &, "&1 "&"#(&, &!)#45"&, ( 3" ((#9 &, )& 1 & 0 #"1 (&,(& &5"& 5 " "&9 (#)+1 &#3+&,(& &5"&( &, (1)& 9 &"(((? "#1 )"()&,1 "&"#(&, &#) "4"#"1+ &, & / " 1 & 5 "4 1, 4)"# "77 #9 &,

" % 4 "(&&, 11)(#9 (5 0#/9, 1,9 ( 9# "# 1, 49 ( 5#)"# "77 %, &/ # 5 "4

1, 4 9 ( 1, "4# 3+ 11)(# "#"&

3+ 9 + "4 0 ( "& & "3 &,## & " (( "(.)#4/8)4 "/9, 1,9 ( 9#0 # ## &#7 &9 ( )"#&, &"

"19 (5 #

)&)"# "77%? "#1 )"( ( 1 "&"#(&, &&,( "# &, 1 5)&/ 9, 1, 9 1 0# 5 &, , )( &, 5 " "&9"

&& @" "& 1 "( # & "3+&, "0(& 4 & "4 4"1+ "# "

#)1& 1 ( &+, (!)# 1#&,1 ( &, 5 " "&, "0(& 4 & "4 4"1+,#&, 11)(#( " "## # & #)1&, "# &,# 1)5"&(/9, 1,9 & "# 1 &,1 ( &+#)& 9, 1,3" & # )3&9 (4 0"& 11)(#

"# 11 # "4+,9 ( 16) &&# &,1, 43+&, & )& & ( ( &, 4)5"& "#1 )"(&, &&, "#& )&, (9 "4+ #) "&,(& &5"&( = "#= )5 "

9, "4 (= (& &#&, &(,9 ((& + "4 &&,, )( , "&( ((,9 (4" "& &&, && 5 "#&,0 1& 5# #" &0 ( &, &,A(, )( 5 + )#(, , 5 = , ((& &#&, &(, 5 "# "&,, )(& & @1 ,4" "&# )4,& " 1&/

)5 "= 4 03 &,& &,1, # "&,5 "&, / "#&, "1 #"& ( &537 ,4" "1+ &&, && 59 ( &9

"&,( "+ "# 1 "(& "& &&"& " 9 ( 6) # & &, & (& 4 , 5 " "& , ( (1 1 + (& &# " , ( (& &5"& &, & 11)(#

&, &"#, (( ""

&& & 3 )&&, "1 #"&& "+ "

&,9 (,9 @ , 5,(& &5"& 0 1& 5, (3"() &#3+ &,(& &5"& 5 " "&3)&(& &, 11)(#, (3" 16) &&# * #&, 4)5"&( #0 "1#3+ "#1 &, "& "#, 0 ( 4 "&, )4,&,!)#45"& &,& )& "#

&,0 "&1 # 0 3 "&,

"( : "# ; % 0 "& ( 0 "4 &, "& 0(+ ", "# "#&,( 5 #)1# ()"#

485&$ 7

%7!#!+"% '

!+- % " !*!.'/ "!'9 =, 0((/&(& , /# (& 3)&(/<, 3 &( 1 1) &(&

"+( ")"#&, 4 &9"&++ ( "+()1, 3(1"

3!1& ( (#& "&, (&1# "4(1& "/ (

&&5&(( & # /(, 3)" (,#B " (&1 "0 1& 9 &, 5 ( "5"& &,#(1 & &59, 1,5 + <&"#& &,+ (/ "#9 &, "9, 1,5 +<&"#& &9

&, )( "#)(/ "#/ "&,0"& (1 "# ()3(6)"& "0 1& "/9 &, 5 ( "5"& &,#(1 & &5 9, 1,5 +<&"#& (0"+ (/ "# ( 9 &, "9, 1, 5 +<&"#& 0&, )( "#)(C ;%)" (,5"& 1 5 " "& 5 # & "D=, 01 55 &(/ &, "1 1 5 " "& 5 # & " (, 3 )" (,# 9 &, 5 ( "5"& &,#(1 & &59, 1,5 +<&"# & &9 + (/ 9 &, "/ 9 &,3 &,E &, &3& 1 )( # &, 4 0 )(,)&/&1D"# &,&, &3& 1 )( # &, 4 0 )(,)&/ & 1 )(&,#(&)1& "+ &+3+ / & 1 )( " "1)" (, 39 &,# &,

B 5 ( "5"& C/ 9 &, 5 ( "5"& &5 9, 1,5 +<&"#& (0"+ (/ & 5)&/)"1, (& &+& 5 "/ (, 3 )" (,# 9 &, 5 ( "5"& &, #(1 & &59, 1,5 +<&"#& (0"+ (/ 9 &, "/ 9 &,3 &, :;< .'6"

) '

#! %6)6'&$ 6'

6)6,& 6!'D=, 0 55 &(/&, "1 1 5 " "& 5 # & "(, 3)" (,# 9 &, 5 ( "5"& &,#(1 & &59, 1,5 +

<&"#& &9 + (/ 9 &, "/ 9 &,3 &,E &, &3&

1 )(# &, 4 0 )(,)&/&1D"# &,&, &3&

1 )(# &, 4 0 )(,)&/ & 1 )(&,#(&)1& "+ &+3+ / & 1 )( " "1)" (, 39 &, # &, B 5 ( "5"& C/ 9 &, 5 ( "5"& &5 9, 1, 5 + <&"# & (0" + (/ & 5)&/ )"1, (& &+& 9 5 "/(, 3)" (,#9 &, 5 ( "5"& &,#(1 & &59, 1,5 +<&"#& (0"+ (/

9 &, "/ 9 &,3 &, )( ( #(1& "(9 )#(, 9&, & & (& 3 0#3+&, (1)& "&, &&, 11)(#9 ( "0 0# "( "4/, "4/ # (& 3)& "4/<, 3 & "4 1 1) & "4& "+( ")"#&, 4 + ( "+ 3(1" 3!1& "&,("&1 (/ &, ("

&3" 0# 1 #3+&,(& &5"&( %=(&, &&, 11)(#9 (( "4 <, 3 & "4 "+ 3(1"5 & & &,0 1& 5(&, 4 & "(0#3+&, 5 " "&/&, 11)(#, #(, 9"3) 5& &,0 1& 5 "#, (0"

1#, 5& # &,( 5 1&, (1)& ", ( #& #)1 "+ 5 & & ()3(& "& & &( 4)5"&( (&,( "#1 5)&/9, 1, 9 4#& 31 0# 5&,( #"1 5 " "&9 & #)1#3 &, )& "# "&, 3("1&, /5+ "&, 3 ( ( (& &5"&( %9(/ &1 )#"

&3 0#&, & 11)(# "#"&

, #1 55 &&# "+ "1, (1)& ", ( ( "

& 0#&, & &, 11)(#

, #&, &"#&,1 5 " "& 1 5 " + "& 5 &# &, 0 1& 5 , (1)& " 9 ( & 0 &( 1 ( 3+ "# ( " 3# )3&3)&" &, &, (3" 0# 5&,(& &5"&( %=("

"+1 0+9 (5 # ()1, &5(9, 1,9(& &#&

3(1" 11 # "4+/&, ("

5 & "&,1 "&"& "( (#3+

; "#1 &, "& "#&,!)#45"& & )& (3 (#

" 1 & 0 #"1 "# &1 ""

&3( #&, &&,( 5 ( "& +& &,0 #"1 5 " "&

"0 9 &, 3 0/&, 3 "4#0 # "+5 & ( ,3+# (5 ((# 153/ 1 3