High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1520/1988allowed

Harbans Kaur v. Chiman Singh And ORS.

2016-01-19Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal18 pages

! "

# $ % & ''( )(* ++,, - .(/ )( + '

! "

# $ % & ' ++,, - 0(1 ' & + '

3'("'4 -0 )("'4

(++,,

(0 ',"'4 '

&(/ )("'4

( + '

56 -'(// 7')/ "1++,

,'8$ % & ''( )( * 4.(/ )( ' 9 ' ,'

8$ % & ' 40(1 ' & 9 % ) ''' 6 : '+, % )0 /

,'8$ % & ''( )(* 4 .(/ )( ' 91(( ' 5;6 2,

( ,'(), '++,) (7')/ '' ''< <+'%!'' , ')" = , 1( %! ( ++, ,' %! +,

++,, 1,,1' '4, <

;1 ' ' ', (

( (! 1

+ , ' / ) & , # , '

' + ' 1 ' /'+ )(

; / ' / ) (+ +,

++,, ' ),!"4,

'' ; >1,,1' '

,'%!$ % & + 1'/' 5>6 2,

++,, ,' + + & ,; , , '/+ ' &( <<? '&( <<?

+ 7/% ' (! < + (',)4 (+, 2,

,,)'(( 11 (, '% )&( <<? '&( <<?

1((, '% )&( <<?

;1,'@ ( )( ( (' A

(1!"+,

/ '1 + (, '

/+ ' &( <<? ' &( <<?

/ 2,

,,)'((' (' ('+ ( , ',,),,! ! + , ) (1((4 ) !

)( (/ 5 6 ' ( ,, 0 ) %7 ) ' ) /7 ' " 7 ' " ,/ '

++, ,/'(( ( @ ( )(

> ('+ (', '/ )& ,> ,/+ '

&( ??

#> : / ( '

B , ''" ( ( ' / + ( , ' /+ ' &( ??

< ) ,' "&( ??

1% ' 1 + &( <<? '&( <<?

& ,# , '' / ' +

( / 1( (! (' ' % ' ! 1,, ' , '0( (, ?#! ,+,''((!(', ,,'%1,, (, ' 2,

(' %7 ( ' 3(!

0'( ,/ 1 (+ , '/ )& ,> , (% + ( 'C / ) ( % '4 + 5#6 , ) +, "+ 1 , ,,1 ) 56 D(( ( +,

1 ( + + ! '+",,)'E22

6 D(( ( (+,

7 ' ' / 7 ' !

+ E2 5;6 D(( ( ' (4 %/ (1 (+ + ! '+%!1!

'4 + E2 5>6 D(( (' (4 ' !

( '+EA "

E2 5 6 D(( ( ( +,

1( ,/ E2 5#6 D(( (+ ,%,% !',,)' (+ ,/ !%7

#E2 5<6 , 5<6 3 ,. 0+ ';7 ,! '(,'

(/ 4 (+,

') (' A 1,(,' 4 (+,

A>"

# '#1 ,''' 4 (+,

'(1 ' '2,

1(,' ,' 4 (+ & , , , '/+ ' &( <<? ' , ( , ' % ) &( <<?

1 (,' ,' / + , '

/ )& ,> , (% ,''FB2 ' + & , , '' /% ' FB2> (! < A (1!"' +

+ , '/ )& , ,/+ ' &( <<? '&( <<?

1+'%!( ,. 4'7')/ '' ''

# 56 /, ,!"4, <

; ,'%!

0(1 ' 0 '?@ ( )(".(/ )( ' 7 )( @ ( )() $ % & 1,

+ ) A ("+,

,/'', '

+ , ''1'/'%!( ,. " (14 "(!1 (,'%1 + & ,> , , ' (% + (4'7')/ ''

< ''

+' %! '' , % ')"

= , 6 ) %( ( 7')/ ' '

# '

"1++,1 ,'% ( ,1 ++,, . =( 1 ,%%' )( ' 1 '''4'// 7')/ '' ''< < 3(++, ,'%!++,, 4, <

;

1,,1' '', (

(+,

(

1 (,'1 + , '/ ) & ,# , '' 1 ' /'+ )(/

(, '3(++, ,' 4,

; > 1,,1' '( ,'%!$ % & +

1'/'3("(1"1++,

' /% ,' (. 5 6

" ,,1 )% ,C ,1 1 )(% /,'

56 D(( ( ,1 ++,, . ( / ' ( 4' ' 1(, )4 )

' ) ) ' )'4 + 6 D(( ( ,1 ++,, . ( //' + 1(, )4 ) ' ) ) ' )'4 + 5;6 D(( (,1 ++,,. (' 7 ' )4 ' ) '4 + ( % ) +,' ) ) ' ) ) ' '4 + '

% !4' 'E 5>6 D(( ( ,1 ++,, . //'+ / ) ,. E 56 <

" ( . 1(, ' ) ( % ,C ,1 ,! ' 'C ;% % ,C ,1 '( C 1 ' (,1" ,!C ;% ' ' '' )(++, / 5 6 A(4( ', ' , %((+ '

(4,+ '( ' 5;6 '/',!" ( ' /,! @ (

)(+ ('& ,> , , '%!1! ,''

#>FB2 , & ,< , , '

/+ ' &( ??

) ,' " &( << #1,,' , , '/ ) & ,< ,/+ ' &( ??

:( (' 0+ ( , ' ,' )(, '1((1

,'(/3( &( @ '1 FB2# / #> '+ #(1 )@ ( )(% @ @ ( )(1 ''% +

&( << # @ / < ' ) &( @ '1 FB2 FB2 &( << 1 % ' 1 + &( <<? '<<?

'1 ''(

A $ ; ' ;" /

$ % & 1 ''% + 4 &( <<? 4' ' ( '' ,

. ,' " .( ') ( 41 + > ''

;) / + $ > "' 1 '' % + + &( <<? ', &( <<?

#< >1 ' (% ,''/' 4 @ (

)(%!(+,

A $ #"' 1 ''% + (, ' C @ 5>6 3( % , C ,1 +' ' % (. 1(( ( ' ) ''

+ '4 + %!(,1 ++,,. %, ,1 /% ' (! <>< '

< FB2; 'FB2>+ 4'(, (+,

+ (' 4 (, ':( ( ' 1 ''%@ ( /

+ # " % ( ! 1 % 0 4

+$ #$ < : / + < $ < "@ ( )( ' ,/ +

'( " / (' ',, + : ( /"@ ( )(1 ''%

+ &( << #@ , ( + < '( '+ $ < ') ( + < $ 3( ,%' +, '4 + (%' ( )( /B/8

/ + + /4+ ' '/ + / '4 + : ,/ ) '4 + " ( ' / + 4 ( ( + 8 4" ,/" + "9+ ,"+

' 3( + (,' % ," + "

" B,4 ' ( C ' / + 4'' ,13( ! ) ' '4 +

/ '

( ( '4 + (,+ %!, ,! )(,, ' , (, ( 1 + !,/ )'4

+ /+ 4((+ 8 4" ,/"

+ 9+ ,"+ ' '(,'% 'C !" +%,! ' B (1(( + '4 ( 1 A/ 1( 1 ) ,'+ ( ) ,1 ',"4%,"

B,4"(, ' '4 ( !+ ' 5#6 2, '4 + + C

,1" ( /B'C ,1 ' + 1( ,/'4 + "/(1G 1('"( / + E % D( 1 ( ( + ED(( ( / + 10 1 ( + !E'$1, )(+ (' 'E$ + 1+ ' ' %' 5<6 2, '4 + ( C ( ( )((/ + , )(3(+ (+,'

/1('(+ %/'4 " '(/ ',( ! ) ' (+,' )3(1

/ ,'%! + ' ,,!, 3(

;

' (+ '4 + +,''%!( ' ( 1 / "( "(+,(4 ) % 0 ( / )/

% /' ,),+,1(( % ' !) , / '

(+, '4 + /B'C ,1 '

'( "

%(,'%+ C ,1 56 ++ ,!" +, '4 +

% 1 ' 4 (' / ( : ,!" ( ) ' '4 + ''

' ' / ! '(,! ',!" + , '' ''

#>" ( ( ' ,!+ ('& ,> , , ' ,

& ,# ,3(,1 ( ,! '( 1 +

'%1 (+ A (1!"( ( ( ' ,!+ ('( (7 , ' '%/ ( &( ??

A ( % ! +,

+ "+, '4 +

%'4 ' %++ '%+ ((

> 1,'%'/'%+ %(, ,,(( + ( ' 4 ! + , , ' ,, ( / + ' %! / + %! / ' % ' 4' + (/ ( '"( ( +, ( ,)( + ( (+

% ' 4 " 4' (/ ' ( B (1 )((+ ' 1(, (, (+,

+ , ' " +

1+,''%!(+,

"( " ' / (

+ "+,

1%,)' / 0+ +

(, '1(((1 ,' + 5 6 3(+,' ) (+ ( / +

+,!, "( "4 +, + ,'

/ ' ( B '4 +

4 ' " ,, ( + ( '

%++ '(4,/ ' ,%'

'4 + : (,' )(+ + "'/ 4H FB2 ' '' < <#+'%!'' ,

. ,' "2 7%".( ') ( ,4 %C'3( ' ' 1 +' ( + ,' %! +,

$ % & ' > ( . ,' "

' )(((','& ,> , , '

&( ??

@ ( )( , & ,# ," / ) & , , % ''' / @ ( )( '%)4 ( 3(+ ! 1/'

( B( ( ,' " ,'&( ??

1(1 4 @ ( )(3( . ,' ' )( 4,+,++ '( 4 !(( &( <<(B

& ,# ,1 '' ( / + ' '"

( (!1 (1 B ( ,/ ( % ,''3(/+ ( !4' ' ''

< <#''' (B & , ,

/( + ' @ ( )( '++ '( (( ), !//'(/ /+, '"

( ( B & , > , ,' (

# + ' 1(,'7 ' '(B (

& , , ( ' "1(1 & , , 1 ' (' (+,1B,'' /( ,/ @ ( )( '1)4 (+,

A (1!"( ,/ (+,

10 1,')'%!(( !

() '( ,' " 1 + ' )( , ' 4 @ ( )(3( 1 '

4' ' '' < <# '( ' %/ , 1 (,, )%!( + ' !%C )

6 3( , ) 4, ; >%!(+,

%+ /'%% '%! !,/

' +, '4 + ' %! ( ' + '

% ++ ' ,!

/ + + ,' ' %

, ,, ) ) ' ,' '4 ( ' '' < <#FB2 1(((' ' ,!

%1 (+ 6 41 '"(. (41(+,

< '4 + 4 + ' 1,,

''A ) ' '4 + '3(

, ) + / 0+ ' ''

< <#/ %,3(+, '4 + + ++4 ) , 4 (+,

F ( 4 ' + 4' % 4 " / +

(,' +,

'4 + 4 ( + ' 2 (

( #>% )(@ ( )( (+! ( 1((+,

A (% !+ "( %' ' ) ,' ," 1( ( + ( '1(,(1 )@ ( )(% +

, ' ( B & , # ," 1(( + /+'(+,

,+ ;

<>% ('' , . ,' 3( '1 ' '' '+ (, '& , , (1 / 0 (+,

4' ' '' < <# ,()( ' 1+' 4 %((+ '

' ,! (+ ,'(/ !

6 41 '" +, '4 +

% 1 ' 4 ( + ' ;6 $4 ) ' '(% ,C +'

% (. 4 (++,, "(. ( ' ' 41 ( ( ' ) '' %! ( , . ()(,)(,!1('

)"% ' '+

(. %' + + ' ) 4' 3(

,'%!(+,

' 4%' ' ' ),!"++, +'"/+) '7')/ '' +'%!,1 ++,,. ' '( ,. +(,' !" #$%&'