Dayal Sarup v. Om Parkash Etc.





    
  

     !"#"$%&%'()*)*+  , - ./0 00"-- '!  1".&/&  2 .3 &4 &%'$"#" #!4./546 &!4".&  "&0'#"'!&    ( 76

 

      

 

 !"

#  

$$    $%  !"

# !  " 
  8 &  '$  #"

 $   ( $" ()  " 

*'" + ""#"

", ,- .!

" () '( /'"  #" 0$ ! /

"  " 1#  ' 1 "#" "2 *'" + " "# "

" 3,,

!

" () "" $4#/'" !+( 1()

 $  "() " 5

$$ !1

$) $$1" 6 ( ! 

! +  %  " 0 +$ 4 !  " 1"1  
+   "!  # $)! $" '

 () "+    "'($ )" ('$"  1 ()

 $789 '$$)" $" "  
+  "!

 

 "'( "

3 " ( :

 0 "! 1 1   '( "   "   !

'# "  "'($ )" ('$"  #+     1  + %" ()$7;9 "789& " '#  + " '($# '#$"

< $" 4  "!  '1  )= $! ) "( + " 1  ()  " < $"  4  "  

'  
+ " '+ 
-!,,,5>
+  """3 ,  .?:

""+" " )

" ( " )# $    0@'$)! :

 0 " + "           ) 1"()
+  +  &  "+  #  "  # + 

 
+   ":

 0 "(  '"

#$ + 

()   +$   ( A#$'  1  ) 1     '(# +  

&

 " $" # $'3 - 0' B"'(" /'" ! /

"!  "#$     

#    

  " '(#  "+     )

 " ' & #$ + 1 $) " () :

 0 '$+ $)  #+ + 1  ('  ('   0'  ?,  -6+  "#+ +! @' $"(($  

"1 +  + "1 1:

'+ 
 ,,,5> &  1 A" , # ++ &A #'"():

"

# + + )1 "( + "' (   '+0 "/ !"4&

1@'" 

)   -C  '+ +'#'" + +:

"1  ##' #+(  $ " () + "   + 1   ( ""'#" +  + " +' 6 1 "   

 1'$" ( $""+ )



)  +'  "

(  6 +     " #+ +!  "#$  ) "#

" ()  0'  ?,,  - 6 1 ""   

##"

#1 "+!  #1 + "'+ 0 " / !

 "  "*'"#    +'   A  #'" () :

 0 " 1 " + +  )  " ''+0 "/ 

 " "

$"





$#   3,     - '" # 3,    6"

 ( #!    "+ " '$ 0'& 0''$+ $)"#""+ 3,?

& +' A "'#'"():

"1 + " 
?335>: $ $" $" 
3,,5>  $  A  ("
?.5>

"()+ ) A " $$!  $ +'
?. 5> &   A   +  +' 1  1%" '(
. ,5>  "" ?3 , "  +' + +1 # $#'$ " 
 ,5>    -C  '+  "'

?3 ,61 )!  $ +'

) ($()

?3 ,1 $"
-!, 5> #$'   + 

+' 
 ,,,5>              $ +  +' 
-!,,,5> 6 1 ""   # 

 1 "  "++ " )! #1  "..

 $ $ :

"!1 "#""!" ##' #+# " ""+ )#     ( # +' "'  + &)    $) "

"  .

 '"

 #$ + 

"     

  " ( A '" 6 1 $ "#$" $) '" D$$A#'"():

"! 1"1 ( 4 1 $61 ""  ( 

 4 " #'(  " '"

) +  ( 4 "'#"4/'

$!'%(  "

"4 "'+ / !" 3.  '"  " 1   $   + +  (  4   $ ($  " ##'  +'   $""'  "

"   $ $ ($  '"

#   

)" '

'#" 3 . $ ($ "  

"+  &

' "" ' !)1# " 

  '  ##' "*' #+1 " + +) + ""' +

   "+  

#"! $$ ) 1  ") 

) )

+'   + ) ( '" "' 1 " +  "+   + 61 ' ""   # ' #( $"  

 ##'"     $ "

   +     .?!#+ +"

"?,  31#1 "'$) " () :

 0 " # "

"  

  () :

 0 '   "

# 

+' 

#%1$" +

#+ "'"# B+ # "A" " $+ &

! !'  "#



()"+  + " ) " $"  "  1'

)+ ) +'

)+ '# +' + )( '""'()0'

  '  ##' + )(""() ( 4 ! "  ( 4 """'  "#) ' :$ $4) $ '

"1+ "" ' & $ $     (  4 $" 1  +

""    ( 4  "A#$' $)

$$   4 ) $ '

!"  &"

 +  "+" 3 ,  .?('1 "" + 

+'1 
-!, 5> "
 !,,,5>61 ' ""   ( 4  "(#+ '$$ $" "1  ) " ' () $

   +!   ) 1    "+" 1 #(" " $+ B   )

' " 3 "?1 "+"6 0' "

$"$ "'+ !

 ('"

) '+ 
-!, 5> $ 1"' # $#'$ "       C  '+   "    "!#+ +"

"?,,  -!"# $',3 

!"  ""  +"" +'

 #  1+  "# + "')1

" " "#'+    (  "  $ 1!   +     #@'# & "   3! 4 /'

$  $" 

  1  + "        $ "  "+"!     +  1'$"#+ " :1 #"()  :

)  E( 0$ 


"= ##!

? 4   ? " . $" * 1  +

"    ) (   ! #  (  #" A#   "' #' $ 1 & $0'  +"  + )  3,'<

 $"   #   "# (    $ 0'  

  $  "#! $0'# +##$' 
+  ":

" " '# " )" '

'($# '# & ) 1  + " () < $"  4 ! 

 ' 1! 1  
+ & #+ + "# "

" ?,,  -

#" $'""@'   ""#  )1 61 !

#!  #%1$" + $ ")'(   

&

1$" ( +   ) 1$ :

 0 " 1  $"  (

+  1       
+   " ! 

1$"$""+ )

)+
 !,,,5> + +)0@'$)!'1 "#"

" *'" + " "# "

" ,- .!

" () '( /'"  66"0$ !/

"  F$   "!"  !4 ) $ '

!

$" 

 $ (  "" $ 4# /'" ! + (  & $1

$$ 0'! "*'" + ""#"

"3,,

!

$) $$1"

 $    "  6 1  $" ()  $1 

$$ 0'  $+ )"#1 @'"(

"

 +@'

# + + " " ( + " & !  $+ ) "#   "+  1

"

'

$ 

  ' )

)+ 
-!, 5> " +  C 1    6 1 ' "#" ()  $1

$$  0'    # ! 

 "   '+ 
-!, 5> 1  G  C   0'! ) 

 + )

$)0'

    $"# " (   $"#!

( '   ' )

$$ $   "!" !4 ) $ '

!

$"  '$ #"

 $  $ (

 " *'" + ""# 6  #"" ()  $ " #'$  

$$ 5"  + 1 # ")  .? 1 !  ' 1 $"  ?, 

 1# 1  ()" 

"   $+  6  ' #""    ' "  + )

#'$  + ""&#+ + 

#" (1

 #  #  ) 1      +  ' " 6 #  A"  "   $+  1# " A '"   A )   ?, )  +  "

  A#'    +  6  ' '(+"    0' ($1#++" 

"# '$)(   #+ +    "! " #'$

 "5

 '(+    ' 1 $" 1 $+ &#+ +(1

"  $'1  #%1$" +   + # #%1$" +  + " (   A   

#(" " $+ !  " $+  $$( #+ '" +"

1 #%1$" +1  "6

 1 ! #""     ' +  

'   
+()< $" 4  "+"()" 5

$$  &

#'+ "+  + ():

+ 
+  $ "+" :1 !  1 "" ()  "    () $

   +! 

 $     "+ 

) 6

 "#'$ 

 " '  #" #  0 '" '"

# #   < $" 4 !  ' 1  ) + " ' ) 

'  
+ 
-!,,,5>
+  "! "#   

! " :

 0 "!  '( "  "   ! '# "  ' ) + < $"  4   "  
+  "!:

" "+" + 
+:

"(# ++ $   A      
+   " & " ' (1 

 $   

#   #  ) 1    "+"() 
+  "1 " $+  !  $ $ 
+  ""+ ) "A '"6( #%" !

+    $ !# $'3

1 $"()



 "#$     

#   

 

 '(      "+         )  " ' " '$+ $)!  #+ + 1  ('  ('   0'?,,  -6#+ +! 1()$ 789 $ 1  '

 ) 1  $"  ( + " 1

 1 :

 0  '+  
 !,,,5> &     1 A"  ,   #  + & A  #'"():

"

# + + ) 1 "  (  + " '   (   "#$  )"#+ #+ +1

"() 0'?,,  -:

""") 

> -$

  ("1! +$)!4) $ '

"
 B $ " 1"1! ( 4  "  :

"!$ $ 1" " #   "# "

" ?,,  - &

#%1$" + #$ + $ $ 
+  "():

 0 "#+ +"

"?,,  -$   " $+  & +   >'  +  "

 

#%1$" + # & !0'$" ' $" 1  "   $+  F'!   ##' "  

# #"" () (  0' ($1  ' )+ " 1:

"  :

"!$ $

"

 &

#'$    +  " +"   #+ +> "" "

" ?,,  - "   +  $ ""   ' F'!  "  

 "+" 

#'+   +    1  + & #+ + "# "

" ?,,  - ("$ $ :

$&$1

$$ 0'  

  $+ )"#  +@'

# + + " "(+ "&0'"  )  1$$ "*'" + "#

"()0'($1 0@'$)!

 $"+" &

$$ 5"  $$( $()1" 1 +'" "() "5

F4
'" ""

"3,

"()"" $4#/'" !+( 

)8)*+