High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1107/2016dismissed

Gajender v. Ompal & ANR

2017-04-24Mr. Justice M. Jeyapaul,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

Sumit Gulati 2017.05.20 12:53 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

" ##$

!"#"$%&'"(&)*+,'&)%$-+$($-./!"&00"&( !"&00($1&-/ %*2.!/%0"1$&(("&3"/*+$("&-&00"&(*-

!"'"(&)*+,'&)% !&'*112##"''2"/*/!"*45"1/$*-%#&$%"'4)/!" ".$%/#)&-'/!"1*-%"62"-/ %/"0%/&7"-4)/!"&00($1&-//*#"8*3"/!"*45"1/$*-% %/!"&4*3"'"(&)$% +*2-'/*4" &-'2-$-/"-/$*-&(/!"&00($1&/$*-$%&((*9"'&-'/!" '"(&)$%1*-'*-"'

*80(&$-&-/ &5"-'"# !&% +$("' /!" 0#"%"-/ &00($1&/$*- $-3*7$-./!"0#*3$%$*-%2-'"#"1/$*-:

;<=

%""7$-.%0"1$&(("&3"

/*+$("&-&00"&(&.&$-%//!"&162$//&(*+#"%0*-'"-/* 80&(9!*9&% 1!&#."'2-'"#"1/$*-:,

!"1&%"*+/!"0#*%"12/$*-$%/!&/*-, &/&4*2/ & 1*80(&$-&-/ &5"-'"#1&8"/*7-*9/!&//!"#"9&%&+$#"$-!$%!*2%"

-&##$3&(/*/!"%0*//!"1*80(&$-&-/&-'!$%+&8$()8"84"#%1&8"/* 7-*9/!&/&112%"' 80&(!&''*-"/!"8$%1!$"+ /9&%&(("."'/!&//!"

&112%"'!&'1*88$//"'8$%1!$"+'2"/*&-*('#$3&(#)+*#/!"1*80(&$-&-/ .*/#".$%/"#"'&1*80(&$-/"&#($"#&.&$-%//!"&112%"'*-

-/!"%$'"*+/!"0#*%"12/$*-,9$/-"%%"%9"#"">&8$-"'

?&)&&-'@&)& &89&%&#"%$'"-/*+/!"%&8"3$((&."9!"#"/!" 1*80(&$-&-/#"%$'"'

"!&''"0*%"'/!&/!"1&8"/*/!"%1"-"*+1#$8"*- ("&#-$-.&4*2//!"+$#"$-1$'"-/ !"1*80(&$-&-/&-'*/!"#%&(%*.&/!"#"'&/ /!"!*2%"*+/!"1*80(&$-&-/ $#"4#$.&'"%"#3$1"9&%&(%*#"62$%$/$*-"'

? &5"-'"# 28&# "#8&9&%/!"#&+/%8&-9!*0#"0&#"'

%1&("'%$/"0(&-*-/!"'"8&#1&/$*-*+&(9&-/$-.! ,

?:"&' *-%/&4("&!&4$#$-.!!&'#".$%/"#"'&+*#8&( +$#%/$-+*#8&/$*-#"0*#/> ?:B*-/!"4&%$%*+/!"1*80(&$-/.$3"-4) ?A &5"-'"# ?&(9&-/$-.!9!*9&%/!"$-3"%/$.&/$-.*++$1"#$- /!$%1&%"#"&1!"'/!"!*2%"*+?A &5"-'"#&-'1&(("'/!"+$#"4#$.&'"&-' .*//!"+$#"2-'"#1*-/#*( "#"1*#'"'/!"%/&/"8"-/%*+/!"9$/-"%%"%

!"#"&+/"#B &(5""/$-.!0#"0&#"'+$-&(#"0*#/2-'"#"1/$*- :

&-'+$("'$/4"+*#"&1*80"/"-/

;

?A &5"-'"# 9&% /!" 1*80(&$-&-/ 9!* '"0*%"' /!&/ !" #"&1!"'!$%*('!*2%"9!$1!9&%%"/*-+$#"*-,B

&-'*-&-"-62$#) 1&8"/*7-*9/!&/&112%"' 80&(!&'0(&)"'8$%1!$"+4)%"//$-.*-+$#"*- !$%!*2%"'2"/*&0#"3$*2%"-8$/)

?, &52!&%'"0*%"'/!&/!"#"1"$3"'&-$-+*#8&/$*-&4*2/

: /!"+$#"$-/!"*('!*2%"*+?A &5"-'"# &-)0"#%*-%.&/!"#"'&//!"

%0*/$-1(2'$-./!"1*80(&$-&-/ "!&%&(%*'"0*%"'/!&/9!$("!"9&% 1*8$-./*!$%!*2%"&+/"#&//"-'$-.8&##$&."0&#/)!"%&9&112%"' 80&( 1&2%$-.8$%1!$"+4)+$#"/*/!"*('!*2%"*+?A &5"-'"#4)0*2#$-. 7"#*%"-"*$( ?!"-!"/#$"'/*%/*0&112%"' 80&(/!"(&//"#/!#"&/"-"'!$8 9$/!'$#"1*-%"62"-1"% "8&'"&/"("0!*-$11&((/* &5"-'"##".&#'$-. /!"+$#"$-1$'"-/

112%"' 80&($-!$%%/&/"8"-/2-'"#"1/$*-::

!&% 0("&'"'/!&/&+&(%"1&%"9&%+*$%/"'*-!$8

"&#-"' 1*2-%"( &00"&#$-. +*# /!" &00($1&-/ 3"!"8"-/() %248$//"'/!&//!""3$'"-1"*+?, &529!*9&%">&8$-"'&%&-")"

9$/-"%%/*/!"+$#"$-1$'"-/!&%4""-1*80("/"()$.-*#"'4)/!"/#$&( / $%!$%%248$%%$*-/!&//!""3$'"-1"*+?, &52"%/&4($%!"%/!"1!&#."

+#&8"' &.&$-%/ /!" &112%"' 2-'"# "1/$*- :,

"+"##$-. /* /!"

"3$'"-1" *+ ?A &5"-'"# /!" 1*80(&$-&-/ $- /!$% 1&%" !" +2#/!"# %248$//"' /!&/ 0#"3$*2% 8*/$3" +*# /!" 8$%1!$"+ 4) +$#" 1*88$//"' 4) &112%"' 9&% &(%* "%/&4($%!"'

!"#"+*#" $/ $% !$% %248$%%$*- /!&/ /!" &00($1&-/8&)4".#&-/"'%0"1$&(("&3"/*0#"+"#&-&00"&(

?"1&#"+2(()9"-//!#*2.!/!""-/$#""3$'"-1"*-#"1*#'

?, &529&%/!"%/&#9$/-"%%$-/!$%1&%"

!"0#*%"12/$*- !&% 0#*5"1/"' !$8 &% &- ")" 9$/-"%% /* /!" *112##"-1" 3"- /!"

1*80(&$-&-/9&%-*/0#"%"-/&//!"/$8"9!"-!$%*('!*2%"9&%%"/*-+$#"

-()*-#"1"$0/*+&-$-+*#8&/$*-!"!&''"%1"-'"'*-/!"%1"-"*+1#$8"

+/!""3$'"-1"*+?, &52'*"%-*/0#*3"/!"1&%"*+/!"&(("."'8$%1!$"+

4)+$#"1*88$//"'4)&112%"'/!"1&%"*+/!"0#*%"12/$*-9$((1#&%!/*/!" .#*2-'

?"/!*#*2.!()0"#2%"'/!""-/$#"#"1*#'%$-/!"4&17.#*2-'*+ /!"%248$%%$*-%8&'"4)("&#-"'1*2-%"(&00"&#$-.+*#/!"&00($1&-/ A

-/!"%/&/"8"-/2-'"#"1/$*-,

%2++"#"'4)?,

&52!"!&'1&/".*#$1&(()%/&/"'/!&/*-'"%1"-'$-./*/!"%1"-"*+1#$8" &+/"#!"&#$-.&4*2//!"$-1$'"-/9!"-!"9&%&/!$%!*2%"!".&/!"#"'&- $-+*#8&/$*-/!&/$/9&%*-() 80&(9!*1*88$//"'8$%1!$"+4)%"//$-.!$% !*2%"*-+$#"

2/2-+*#/2-&/"()?, &52!&%1*8"*2/9$/!&%"(+ 1*-/#&'$1/*#)3"#%$*-4"+*#"/!"/#$&(1*2#/ "!&%%/&/"'/!&/!"9&%&/!$% !*2%"&//!"/$8"9!"-/!"*112##"-1"/**70(&1" -!"&#$-.&4*2//!"+$#"

$-1$'"-/&//!"*('!*2%"*+?A &5"-'"#!"#2%!"'/*/!"0(&1"9!"#" ?A &5"-'"# &##$3"' *- !"&#$-. /!" $-1$'"-/ - /!" -">/ 4#"&/! !"

'"0*%"'62$/"&.&$-%//!"%/&-'!"!&'/&7"-$-!$%%/&/"8"-/2-'"#"1/$*- ,

4"+*#"/!"$-3"%/$.&/$-.*++$1$&(/!&/9!"-!"9&%1*8$-./*!$% !*2%"&+/"#&//"-'$-.&8&##$&."0&#/)!"%&9 80&(%"//$-.+$#"/*/!"*('

!*2%"*+?A &5"-'"#&-'9!"-!"*45"1/"'/*%21!&-"+&#$*2%&1//!" &112%"'/!#"&/"-"'!$89$/!'$#"1*-%"62"-1"% 21!&1*17&-'42((%/*#) #""("'*2/4)?,62$/"&.&$-%/!$%*#$.$-&(%/&-''2#$-./!"1*2#%"*+ $-3"%/$.&/$*-9$((!&3"/*4"/*/&(()#"5"1/"'4)/!" *2#/*+&9

9$/-"%%$%-*/%200*%"'/*0#*5"1/&-"9/!"*#)+*#/!"+$#%/ /$8"4"+*#"/!" 21!&0#*5"1/$*-9*2(''"+$-$/"()/!#*9&'*24/*- /!"3"#&1$/)*+%21!&9$/-"%% !"%/&-'*#$.$-&(()/&7"-4)?, &52&-'

&%"(+1*-/#&'$1/*#)-"93"#%$*-0#*5"1/"''2#$-./!"1*2#%"*+/#$&(1#"&/"&

A '"-/$-/!"1#"'$4$($/)*+!$%/"%/$8*-) !"#"+*#"$-*2#1*-%$'"#"'3$"9 /!"/#$&( *2#/!&%#$.!/()#"5"1/"'/!""3$'"-1"*+?, &529!*9&%/!"

%/&#9$/-"%%$-/!$%1&%"/*#"1*#'&162$//&(

?"'*-*/+$-'&-)8"#$/$-/!"&00($1&/$*-%""7$-.%0"1$&( ("&3"/*0#"+"#&-&00"&( "&3"%*2.!/+*#$%'"1($-"'&-'/!"&00($1&/$*-$% &11*#'$-.()'$%8$%%"'

%! 0#$(

2(&/$ %! ?!"/!"# "0*#/&4("

* ?!"/!"#0"&7$-.B "&%*-"'