← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11642/2010dismissed

Arun Mittar v. S.R. Builders Ltd & ORS

2015-02-16Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh9 pages





       



   

!"!

% % & '( 

       

   '( ))  '( 



   

      

    

  

  !"  

#

$  %"

#

'(  )  

 "

#

 

$ "

#

  *

'(  )

*   

+++   ,     $   &  &          # - &$&#  



& #  .      /    /&

  012"034"030"035"036"07"128

 9

:

 /     

  $    &

/3%$  

  

/ "

,  # / /

  6 2;

122$ < (

 //    # 6 /

 " 

 $ -

#     &       ##   #

     

  $   

# &

& *=:&

#

 < 4789

## 8#

  ( #/ &> * #   # 7'#)    (# 

  & 31";2"222.8&   &# &/$#      ?10@ 





    &  ##   :

    #   #  #    #    $   #    &  



 $  &    , &(# 

  /( ( "#     

 &  $ /& / $ /&  

 ,   &(#   #     &    12  #      (     (  

 $  #  $

 /

 , 

  $    

/

##

  

,

 / < 

  &

$ /&/   <      4 2 122;  "  /  

     #

  (

 (  #/

& / 

&

&&  /  , ##       #   

  (    /  $       //   /

&

&   $#& "& &(#

<  /

  

( /  

=  ( &  - # # #  #

$    /  121 :

"  ## 



   &#    &   #

   &  &&  (    012"034"030"035"036"071289

 &      

 (

  &   (  

%/  



   &     051  :

  -/ 

 "  



/   < 3

/

 /  &

  &    "     !"    

#    (        /   /

       2;

122"  $ / 

$#$ ( A/:

&  < # &   /# #   = *

14 &1220#  B:

 (A /

        C

9   "#  &  89 *

066;  &  1220      6;')'()    $   402:

' < ;)$& 

 /      

& 12#$    /       /         &  &     

 15 2 1221(

       $    

&   %

 # ( & , $  A/  $  (

 #&#     #  # &

9 / $ 

    

 &   /

# 

//   

 & /   (



A/:

& "  # #

 & (    

/

 /  &

# 

 

 /

  # ( #      A/     (      "

&

D/ $  (  , (  /

$ 

/ ( $

  A/    $/

(   (  (

  9 /  

(

  (    (

    A/ :

   

/" 

# 

/  /( ( &  &$" "(

-     &    /           

 

/ ## $     #&# /  /   

"  "  # 

/$   #& /    ( ( # # 

$  9   &#   "   /

&A



&9 

  !" #!"$ %  &"'!   !("

)*+,,-,.& "#".

! "

,/0 &  /  "   " (     /

   A/:

 "

(/ (

#  /   /  # 

/ &  

   #

  (    ##   #

           

  &# 

;

  $ & /    

      # &# # # #  &

  $     &      "     #  (      

 - &&# $#

#  :

( &

 # 9 &  /   (     A/:

 

      

& 12#$ < (   /    - $

 &

         $ /  '$ )   

9

 # &   

## #

 & = *

14 &1220 (

 A/:

  6 (   :

#  # 663

%/#   &  43# ') ') 9 



/"#  $& &

 &   /#  /    6;')'() $   402 :

 # #  

/ & &

   

&  #      15 2 1221        

& 12% , $ A/ 

( ;"122;' < 6)$ ( A  D #

  "  '    : &  D # & 9) $           

(   9   #/  "   ( "  /   

 

 " &  $  



  

                      

     

 

  



 

  

               

  A/:

     

 

#  &  6; $  402:

  # (     #  ( &

 %/    

 ## # $ $   &&# "    

    

 $

/ #  $    # 

 & 6; $  402:

(

 (        #  <:

  12  ( 3 (4 $ ""5 ( 3 (4 *++6)*-) # -,/7,

 #



&/   # 

/ $ &   # #   & / 

     

&  #   '$      )         &  &  ,

#  & ( A/:

&  (  

  

( ;"122;#    $  &#    # 

/ /     /

 #  &   (   (       /

   A/:

# (   (  

/"   "#  & 



%-/ &# 

/ *   -

&& &

 $  (   #  

 &

 # ( (  

(   

/  A

"           

(  

//     $

(  (

 (   A/:

 ,(/   /  ( # &

 #  

 &   /   &&

 ,   #

 /  &   $   

  .      

      //

  

= "  

  &  #

$  ( &#  

,

      

& 12#



 " /(

 (     /    # (   

/

        #&#  

     

 ## #

   # # #  #     &  

    &         

,  - &&# $# -   

 #  #  051:

9 

 

      /   $#

 &  

&# &$# 

( &  $  ( /               ##

   #

& #    A



  .( ($ #'(   

*+++ ),+-,/7 

  < # &

2F /

    !"

              

        

    

#          

 

    ! $

 %       

    

  



          



                       

  #   



 ! #

 &  '

  

   $     %   (     &  )* +  



        

        ,   ) + -   .        / !$!0)121+3332!1

!!

 .

  

        ,     

  

 

   



                          

 #          





  

4             G     &#     ##  #       #  

<    /  &&   < # "   " 

  

 &

 $    &

&   /

&A



&9  

  !" #!"

 '

"

) .& -$      $   - & #  # /     #

 

  &

   # 6;0$##  

  # (  &#        #  &    &&

  (    #

    

      % * / ( 9 

 # "

9 # # # "635/:

## 602 9;2

/

 "    :

  (   /          #     ( # '".!'   !$ ""!  (  )*++6-778   

 / #

   " 

  #  

   & $  #  $

  #/ &  (

 & #  &  (  9 ( # '".!'   !

'

") .& -  A  <  (

 /$  

 & 0 * / (

9 

  #  $ ( "  &     &&

  (    :

 ' #   )"         #/ &     (  

 & # #  & ( 

 #  (

&&

 (  45

* / ( 9 

 # 55 9  #  "  

   (  / 

#  ( &&

  (    :

               $    ( # '".!'   !

 '

"  ) .& -     

   !"

#!"

'

") .& - /   #

              ( "  &/  

 "  

& ## /   *    

" /      #    &  # 

  '+

,(  - ./0/1 2  &% '5