← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1134/2016dismissed

Manjeet Singh v. Jagwinder Singh @ Raju & ORS

2017-03-10Mr. Justice M. Jeyapaul,Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal4 pages

SUMIT GULATI 2017.03.20 14:21

  

      

      

  

         



                   

 ! 



  

  !  

""#$%&%'()*+%,-./$**,012,--/3%'#%3415'%5*31 *1 /5'%#%-*$153678886,5'9: ,--/3%'#%3415'%5*1  ,";$5'%#$5"+  ,<//5'%#%-*$15912*+%#=3-*#%3415'%5*1  ,--/3%',";$5'%#$5"+  ,</,5'*+#%3415'%5*,--/3%'=#$*4,0$5"+ /5'%#%-*$1588:#%,';$*+%-*$156> *+%-1=40,$5,5*+,32$0%'*+% 4#%3%5*,440$-,*$15/5'%#%-*$1587?6@ # 

3%%A$5"0%,&%*12$0%,5 ,44%,0



*$3*+%-,3%12*+%4#13%-/*$15*+,*157  ,*,(1/*> 8 , = ;+%5,5<%%*$5"+;+1;,3*+%-1=40,$5,5*;,33*,5'$5" ,015";$*++$3,/5*/#$5'%#!,/#,5'/#$5'%#$5"+1/*3$'%+$3+1/3%5%,# +$3",*%,--/3%'!,=,0<$*$5"+,5',"&%%#$5"+,#=%';$*+ ",5',3$3 ,--/3%' ,</,5'=#$*4,0$5"+,#=%';$*+#$20%,--/3%',#5%A$5"+ ,5'$A,5'%#$5"+,#=%';$*+(,3%(,00(,*3,5',--/3%',#$$5"+,#=%' ;$*+A$#4,5-,=%,015";$*+/5$'%5*$2$%'4%#3153$52#15*12*+%",*%12

 +$3+1/3%  --/3%',#5%A$5"+,5',#$$5"+#,$3%', 0,0A,#, *+,* ,5<%%*3+1/0'51*(%,001;%'*1"13-1*2#%% ,5<%%*$5"+*#$%'*1 01-A*+%'11# --/3%'$A,5'%#$5"+",&%,(,3%(,00(,*(01;;$*+,5 $5*%5*$15*1A$00;+$-+0,5'%'15+$30%2*3+1/0'%# --/3%'=#$*4,0 $5"+2$#%',3+1*2#1=+$3#$20%15*+%",*%12+$3+1/3%  ,</2$#%',3+1* 2#1=+$3#$20%;+$-++$*15*+%;,0012*+%+1/3% +%1*+%#,33,$0,5*3",&% A$#4,5',5",5'",5',3$(01;315*+%",*%12*+%+1/3% +%#%,2*%#,00*+% ,--/3%' 20%'  ,;,)2#1= *+%341* ;$*+  *+%$# #%34%-*$&% ;%,4153 ,3  *+% -1=40,$5,5*4,#*)#,$3%'#,/0,

4,#*2#1=*+%,(1&%,5<%%**+%4#13%-/*$15%B,=$5%' /#$5'%#!,/#;+1;,3,031,5%)%;$*5%33*1*+%1--/##%5-%6   ,A,= $5"+  ;+1  #%"$3*%#%'  *+%  -,3%  ,5'  -15'/-*%'  4,#*  12  *+% $5&%3*$",*$15,5'8,0;$5'%#$5"+;+1-15'/-*%'*+%#%=,$5$5" 4,#*12*+%$5&%3*$",*$15

9# ,3($#!,/#%'$-,0 22$-%##$=,#)%,0*+ %5*#% ,0;,5'$!,0,5'%413%'*+,*15>  3+%=%'$-10%",00)%B,=$5%'

$5</#%',5<%%*$5"+,5'21/5',3-,(=%,3/#$5"-=BC6-=1&%#*+% 413*%#$1#,34%-*120%2*3+1/0'%#<1$5* +%-%#*$2$%'*+,**+%,(1&%$5</#) ;,33$=40%$55,*/#% 5+%#14$5$15*+%$5</#)+,'(%%53/3*,$5%'() ,5<%%*$5"+,(1/*67+1/#34#$1#*1+$3%B,=$5,*$15

5*+%3$'%12*+%,--/3%'/#$5'%#$5"+;,3%B,=$5%' *134%,A*1*+%'%2%5-%*+,*513/-+1--/##%5-%*11A40,-% :

+%*#$,0 1/#*+,&$5",5,0)D%'*+%%&$'%5-%15#%-1#'-,=%*1 *+%-15-0/3$15*+,**+%4#13%-/*$15+,'2,$0%'*1%3*,(0$3+*+%-+,#"%32#,=%'

8 ,",$53**+%,--/3%'(%)15'#%,315,(0%'1/(*



%,#5%'  -1/53%0  ,44%,#$5"  21#  *+%  ,440$-,5*  &%+%=%5*0) 3/(=$**%'*+,**+%*#$,0 1/#*-1=40%*%0)$"51#%'*+%$5</#)3/3*,$5%'() ,5<%%*$5"+*+%=%'$-,0%&$'%5-%,''/-%'()9# ,3($#!,/# *+%4+1*1"#,4+3;+$-+;1/0''%=153*#,*%*+%(/00%*=,#A3,**+%",*%,5' *+%#%-1&%#)%22%-*%' ()*+%$5&%3*$",*$5" 122$-$,0  +%#%21#%$*$3 +$3 3/(=$33$15*+,*$*$3,2$*-,3%21#,'=$33$15,3*+%*#$,0 1/#*+,3%##%'$5 %&,0/,*$5"*+%%&$'%5-%$5,4#14%#4%#34%-*$&%

+%1--/##%5-%+,'*,A%540,-%157  ,*,(1/*> 8, =

,34%#*+%-,3%12*+%4#13%-/*$15 +%3*,*%=%5*12,5<%%*$5"+ ;+1,00%"%'0)3/3*,$5%'$5</#);,3#%-1#'%'150),* 4 = ;,3 3/(<%-*%'*1=%'$-,0%B,=$5,*$15*+%5%B*',)15>  ,*,(1/* , =  (1/* 6 +1/#3 12'%0,)$5 #%"$3*%#$5" *+%-,3%,5' : +1/#3 $5 3/(<%-*$5"    *1  =%'$-,0  %B,=$5,*$15  +,&%  51*  (%%5  3,*$32,-*1#$0) %B40,$5%'  ()  *+%  4#13%-/*$15  +%  '%0,)  31=%*$=%3  4,&%3  ;,)  21# %=(%00$3+=%5*12*+%-#$=$5,0-,3%,5',03121#$=40$-,*$5"*+%$551-%5* 4%#3153 +%015"",4(%*;%%5*+%*$=%121--/##%5-%,5'*+%01'"$5"12 2$#3*$521#=,*$15#%41#*,5'*+%'%0,)$5=%'$-,0%B,=$5,*$1512-#%,*% ,'1/(*,3*1;+%*+%#3/-+,3$=40%$5</#);1/0'+,&%(%%5$52,-*-,/3%' (),--/3%',";$5'%#$5"+  ,</  /-+,5$5</#)-1/0'+,&%(%%5 -,/3%'%&%5()3%02$520$-*$15*,A$5",'&,5*,"%12*+%*$=%",4

>

2  -1/#3%  *+%  4#13%-/*$15  +,3  4#1<%-*%'  4+1*1"#,4+3  *1 '%=153*#,*%*+,*(/00%*=,#A3;%#%21/5'15*+%",*% $#3*0)51%=4*$%3 ;%#%#%-1&%#%'2#1=*+%3-%5%12-#$=% -1-A,5'(/003*1#)$3$5*#1'/-%'

6 *+,*,--/3%'*+%=3%0&%3-100%-*%',00*+%%=4*$%3,5'*+%#%,2*%#20%',;,) 2#1=  *+%  3-%5%  /-+  ,5  %B40,5,*$15  $3  51*  ,*  ,00  -15&$5-$5"  +% 4+1*1"#,4+33+1/0'+,&%(%%5%B+$($*%',015";$*+*+%5%",*$&%3*+#1/"+*+% 4+1*1"#,4+%#(/**+%4#13%-/*$15=$3%#,(0)2,$0%'*1%B+$($**+%5%",*$&%312 *+%4+1*1"#,4+ 1#;,3*+%4+1*1"#,4+%#3/(<%-*%'*1%B,=$5,*$15(%21#% *+% 1/#*  +%4+1*1"#,4+3;$*+1/*,5)5%",*$&%-,551*(%3,2%0)#%0$%' /415()*+% 1/#*12 ,;

+%#%21#%$*-1/0'(%2,$#0)-15-0/'%'*+,**+% 4#13%-/*$15=$3%#,(0)2,$0%'*1%3*,(0$3+*+,**+%,--/3%'4,#*);%#%,#=%' ;$*+#$20%3,5'14%5%'2$#%,**+%",*%,5';,00312*+%+1/3%12



5*+%2,-*3,5'-$#-/=3*,5-%3$51/#-153$'%#%'&$%;*+%*#$,0

1/#*+,3#$"+*0),33%33%'*+%*%3*$=15)15#%-1#'$5*+%(,-A"#1/5'12*+% 4#$5-$40%30,$''1;5$5 #$=$5,0/#$34#/'%5-%,5'#%-1#'%',-./$**,012 #%3415'%5*3  1   *1    % '1  51*  2$5'  ,5) =%#$*  $5  *+% ,440$-,*$15

+%#%21#%0%,&%*12$0%,5,44%,031/"+*21#$3'%-0$5%',5'*+%,440$-,*$15 3*,5'3'$3=$33%'

 "  # $ ,#-+   ?   # /0,*$ $ +%*+%#4%,A$5"C %,315%'

 %3 +%*+%# %41#*,(0%  1