High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13770/2000allowed

Ajit Singh v. Registrar Cooperative Societies Punjab, Chandigarh And Others

2015-01-27Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan17 pages

"#"

" $ % $'

( "%#$)$*

"&* "

#$%& !

'()*&

" * & (* +"

(*"'

+ ,"-$*

&$"%*'($

- , --/- $ 0$%*'($

. "&* -122222 " * & (* +"

(*"'

.3 *& $4. 5#$"

"3#*$ *67-7-889%:

)4%

0$ *$*$3". 5#$"

* *$ *78-7;-88< &$""

* )4

" $ % $'

( "% = &# '"% = &# $* * "*$ *6-7-6777$*9-7>-6777 &$""

* )4

" $ % $'

( "% :

)4%

"$* * :$"#&

3*-

:$" $&& * $" $ "$3 "0$

?/ ? $ (& $'

(#3# $3 ( 4@0 *%

6 $

?/ ? $ ? "&* -1%:

( "$ $'

( 4

*#*

& '"".#$) $'

( "(% 89- " "$ $

*$ . ) .

7;-79-8;9 $*

% " *# *$ . :#3* )

A7-79-679-

:$" &3$( * #* "#"& " ;--88;-

*$4"

$. - ->--8>;%$( ?

($>( "B C# ?D:$"""# * 0$*

:$" $"E * "#)0 " &34

( "

("# *3E

")476-6-88;- :$""$ $.$4

".#*$$"

$. ( &.

( *%$"#&&3 $ 4( ?"

:#3*)

""# * 0- 6<--88;%

"#)0 * " &34 B C# ?6D

* 4

$33 $"$* "$ $( $$" 0:$""#)"$$ *- #

$*"#)0 * " &346<--88;$"*($ *$)'

"3#71-6-88;:$"&$""

*($33#& 0"#)0

&34

)

#)?

)4A-6-88;-

&3 *"$ $

$*$3 $*4"#)0

&34

76-6-88; "

E/#0$ % "& (

0 0) ".

$* $

") * && *$*

( ?"

) .3 *-

7A-7-889% $

( B C# ?;D :$"

A *

("# * .

5# 4$$" 0%:

)4%.#

3" *$$"

)$"

*"0 5# 4$(0&3$0$* $$"

0)4

&#)3(-:$""$ *

(

5# 4 $33

"$*

""# *

$ 3 >--88; :#3* )

3* >-7-889- :$"

5# *$ *

..(

"( 4$*& "*

>-7-889-:$".#

"$ $($"

**$ * "* :33) "#0

"3 $$" 0$ ($*.#

$(*"& "

: :#3*) $E -

"#)0 * " &34

"#&&3 $ 4 ( ?"

*$ *7A-7-889 ;-7-889-

$. %

( '

*$ "

*3 *$ *68-7-889%0$

0 $ ""

" $*)

0$ *-:$""$ $$#)

("# * 5#

*$ * >--88; $* 7A-7-889- " &

& .

$33

$33 $" $*)

& '

,$$

( 4 $* #$0#"34 $(( &

(00 *$ .

" 0

3* 67-7-889$*

$"$3 "0$B D $* )

0$ *:- -.-;--88;-

.3 * $ $&& $3 $$"

"$*

1 )

&#4 " $ % $'

( 4% = &# % #* #3 ; BD .

#$) $ $'

(#3# $3 ( "% #3 "8>9B. "

8>9#3 "FD ( *% $3$% $) 0$

% 5# 4:$"

:$"$""($ *: $4"#(

5# 4- :$".# "

*$(&4.

5# 4 & '

$4 && #4 $$"

& &"

* &#"

&#4 " $ % $'

( "% = &# $(( &

$&& $3 .3 * )4

$* '* " * *$ 71-6-889 B C# ?>D% "

$"*

"3# *$ 67-7-889- $"

&#4 " $ % "&* ?

( 4 .3 * $ '" & )

" $ %

( "% = &# - " '":$"$(( & *%

(".

&#4 " $ :$""

$"* $*

"3#.

"( 4*$ *67-7-889:$"#&

3*-

$""$3

* . " $ )4 .3 $ & )

" $ $'

( "%

$*$ -

"&* ?"( 4 ( * $

"$* .3 *#* (AB1D.

( "( :$" 0$$$)3 -

" $ '* " * *$ 9-78-88> B C# ?7D *"&"

* .

0 "

: #"& (.($334$*'

""# .0$$$)34-

;

.3 * G-<<66.88>%( *

0 ".

0$ $*)

$ # *)

" $ $*4 $* ("0 " $*)

*- :$"*"&"

*.'* * *$ *7>-7<-888$*

($"

:$" 0 *

" $ . .

* ("- "

5# 34%

" $ ?

$ *

0$ $**"0""

'* *

*$ * 78-76-6777 3* $ 34

:$" 0$$$)3 )#$3"

:$"$&&$ #3$ 4

'"$3 * *$ *78-7;-88<&$""

*)4

" $ -

$. %

.3 *:

& $4 $"

*- ,"-$*

&$"%3 $ *(#"

$"$""$3

* . 0$

#* $$.

"#)0"" . &34

( ?"

" )4

5# 4:$"

"-3 $"

:$" $""($ *: $4"#( 5# 4-3".*(#0 ") 3 #&$$"

3".: ""

""#&& .

$33 $":$" "#&&3 *

$4&& #4( ""?

C$0

: ""

" $**#(

'* ".$'# -#

%(&4.

5# 4 & :$"'

) 0&"

&#"

- #"%

:$"$3) $(

& (&3 ".$# $3#"( $*

"$# 4 & ( *# ) 0$

" .

9 - %

0&# * * "$ '*$*3$)3 )

5#$"

*- #

%$*'

5# . "

)$"" . 0$ $3 ( *% "

"$ " $

(*H"#&&3 $ 4( ?"

:$""

*( *$ *7A-7-889. 0 0

5# 4

"($ *

"#&&3 $ 4( ?"

$3"

"($ *

$ 3 ?"

:#3*)

3* >-7-889% . :

(

:$" 5# 0"

3.>-7-889-

"#)0 * " &34

"$* ( ?"

;-7-889- " &

0$ * %$. ( '

& .

3* $$33

$33 $"($ *

"*$ >--88; $* 7A-7-889 $* )

& '

,$$

$(( &

(00 *$.

3*67-7-889- "$ #

(#3* $'

$"$)34$ '

* $ $((3#" : $ * & . .

$33 $" ($ *

( ?"

: # C$0

'* $*: ""

4*$4- ->-7-889%:

( :$"

$&& $ $*& "* - "

$ #

& .

5# 4 ..( %:

( .*"

(*( ?"

B C# ?;D$*

< )$"".:

( %

"#&&3 $ 4( ?"

$*)

""#

) $ $3 & .

"( 4%(#3*)

$E ) $ & .*"(&3$ 4$# 4

)$"".:

(

*"(&3$ 4$((#3* $'

)

$E -

$ # $

: & %

& .

( "$33 *)

.#*$.

0$ $")

&3$( * ( *-"% #"%$ #

0$ * ": #)$""- @ $ *(#"

3 $".#

$ # $ .

"#)0 * " & >-7-889%

,$$

(#3* $'

$E $ ("

67-7-889%) ($#"

$"& #3 >7.

#$) $'

( "#3 "%89A$3 $";*$4"F(3 $ ( "& (.4*$ %&3$( %0 $*$ *$" 5# *. $

. $ $3 )*4H (00

- I# "

*$ *8-6-6777B C# ?6D&$""

*)4

" $ %:

3* $$ '"& ( $33

'"$3 *$ * 78-7;-88< &$""

* )4

" $ :$" 0$$$)3 %3 $ *(#"

3 $" 3 *

#*0 .$#33 . " # & * $" , (-.

. 11 2 3345

4/. 0 6 2045 ( * $"#( '"$$"$$&& 33$

'"$3 * &$""

*)4$$# 4& (

*"$ "#.

( "(%89

#3 ". $0

> 3 "-

( $ 4%3 $ *(#"

3. "&* -1

$"$ # $ ( ""$ 4& ( *#

.33:

*$*

:$"'

$* 5#$ && #4* * 0"

3.-

"( 4 $* ("# * $ #)

$33 $"$$"

$33 $"3 *$$"

$ ."

#"$# % "& ($334. 0) ==3 .

$3(00*4$*?& *#(.

( *)

(( * ..( -

$" $'$3

* " .

$&& $3 $* '"$*

'"$3 $# 4 $" .#* . 04

0&# * * 0$- $'

$ * 3 $ * (#"

3 .

&$ " $* #"

( *-

%" ( ""$ 4 & *#(

'$ "$# 4& '""-

(*"."

0&34

(#3# $3 ( "

$ .

#$)$ '

*)4

8>9#3 "-

#3 ":

. $0 #* #3 6>.

#$) $'

( "#3 "%89A- #3 "A$*1 $*$"#* + J (3 D

(00

0$4&3$( #* "#"& " $ 0&34

$$" :

0 *"(&3$ 4 & (

*"#*

#3 "$ $(&$ *- D 0&34

$4($"

$33) E &#*

"#"& ". 0 $:0 "-

8 D

. $ "( 4 0$4%

C( &$3( (#0"$( "% C *

"#"& " * :

& $&& '$3 .

&#4 " $ - 'D 0&34

#* "#"& ""

$33) &$* $ "#)"" $33:$( 5#$3 ;7K . "$3$ 4- 6 4 D

.33:& $3 "0$4. *$* "#..( $""%) 0&"

*$ 0&34

(00

0"(*#( "$)3"

"&$ + D

"# - D *#( 03#0 "- D 0'$3 *"0""$3. 0"

- $** $4 .

* & $3 "%

(00

0$4 ('

4. 0 "&$4.

&$ .

$4& (#$ 43""($#"

*)4 0

"( 4)4 3 )4 $4 :3.#3 $( . 0"" (00""- D * 0&"$4.

$3 "& (. *"#)? #3 BD"

$33) &$""

* C( & $. - D . 0

0&34

%: %.

( "3 *$$" 0L$*- D

0&34

$&& #4

"($"

: ;*$4". 0

( & .( -

(34 4 BD : "$* $4 ($ *

#3 "%

& ( *# 3$* *: " #3 $33$&&34$"( 4:

(

$ " $'

)

"#)"( ) * )4

0 3$)34)4:$4.#$ $

) : C(

*..4& ( .

: E ($&$3.

"( 4

#* $E )4

0 + '* $ "

$33 )

(#0) #& "#( $ "( 4 .33:

& ( *# 3$**:(3$#"

"BD$*BD."

: E($&$3* " C(

*"-%77%777 " $'

(& $'

"( 4$""

0) +?

BD 3 $"..

*$4"(3 $ ( "& (.4

*$ %&3$( %0 $*$ *$. $0

$4 "0$33 )*4 "

#& )4

0% :

*)4

" $ %

$33) '

$33

0 0) ".

$3)*4H(00

"0$33 )*4%$"

($"

0$4) + '* $$"

( 0$4) '

$33

0 0) " .

$3 )*4H (00

"0$33 )*4%$"

($"

0$4) % :

0"".

" $ #* * (- B?$D

" $ %0$4%. ":0 $

0$* 0%* (3$

& (

*(3$#"

BD$"'$3*% .

" "$". $

:$"

3* : #& & ( : #$33

0 0)

$' ( '

( .

:$"(*#( *$

$&& & $

&3$( $*0 +$* BD 0$ $33 C( &:

0"" * (".

" $ %) ("*

.$ $3)*4H(00

.$4"0$33 )*4%"

#&)4

0%#3 "" $0$ ""& (.($334(3#* *

$ *$:

( "( (#3$ *$330 0) "$ $"..

(3 $ *$4" "

*$4"$*'$(

"& ('

34-M & #"$3.#3 1$.

*0$E "(3 $ $

$3 ""& (.

#* (3#* 0'$3 *"0""$3 . 0"

($) 0&"

*. *$*"#..( $".

0"(*#( "$)3"

&$ .

0&34

-".#

& '*

$3 ".( "# % *#( 03#0 "

0'$3 *"0""$3. 0"

$33) 0&"

* C( &$.

0&34

. 0 *: .

"3 $$" 0$*'

$&& #4 "($"

: ;*$4". 0 ( &.( -")4::

33?"

3 $"#(

$ && #4 ) 0 $.#3 $* ("$( :

& (&3 " . $# $3 #"( :#3* (3#* .# "

(3 $ $* "& (.(( "$3:

"$ .$33 $":

(

"$ )$"

*-#

%$33

*(#0 "

)$"".

( "#( "$ & &"

*) "#)"$$ *$3:

3".

: ""

"%.$4%& ..

" $'

)

.# "

0&34

"$3") '

.#33$*& &

&& #4* * 0"

3.)4( ""?

C$0

: ""

"$* ' "* - #

% ($"

" :

5# 4

( " "

(*#( *)4$$# 4

*"(&3$ 4$# 4%$ (&4 .

5# 4 & " 5# * ) .# "

35# 0&34

) $4$()$"

"$E )4

*"(&3$ 4$# 4- & #"$3.

*(#0 " ( ** " $3 $ "#( $ & ( *# $" )

.33:

:$"

*: :( ?"

. " *$ *>--88;$* (*H "#&&3 $ 4 ( ?"

*$ * 7A-7-889-

.# "

&34

. " ( ?"

6<--88;$* ?$.. 0

"$0 "&"

(

*$ *71-6-88;- "#)0 * " &34

(*( ?

;-7-889-) " &3 "%

$33 $"

($ *

$*"$

"$0 $ .$3"

$*) * && *-

( %:

)4%

(*( ?"

:$""

*%:$""& (.($334*($ $

#3*$ *

..(

"( 4>-7-889$7-77$0&

A -*#)%:$"*($ $.

** $ * & "* %:33 ) "#0 $$33

( " 3 * $$" 0 $ ( ( $* .#

$( *"& "

: ""

":#3*) $E -

"$ *

: "$

**& 0"

3.)

#)(00

>-7-889-""#0) "%"

$*"#)0 * " &3 ")

( ?"

"%"& (.($334* 4

"$*&3 $* $

4) * && *-

.$( ""#$%

$" $.$ 5# 4..( $&& *(*#($ *"(&3$ 4 5# 4%:#3*) $.$* * $*#*($

5# & . $* '* "#&& .

( " .

0"(*#( $33 * $$"

* 35# 0&34

$)"

. $*0"" . #3

&$ .

* 35#

0&34

%(#3*%: # ( ""$ 4& .$* '* $* : #'

0&34

& & && #4* * 0"

3.%

# $.*.#3-

F)3 #& # (

( 91 (.

2 5

(

3- 7 )"

*$"#* +?

: 7 5# 4..( $($5#$"?#*($3 $# 4 "

&" . $ * * $*#*($ - ""#&&"

*) $ $'

* &$ 0 H*"(&3$ 4 $# 4H 0 -

1 ".#(" C$0

'* *)4

&$ 0 %

$)"

* 35# ..($3"

$":

# )# * '* "

"#..( 3*

"$ & '

($"

"$* & ( *# $" )

*-( $3 '*

C$0

*(#0 " $'

)

& '

*%$*(#3*

)

$E ("* $((3#*

( " $'

)

& '

*$$"

"&* "-M

$' )

($33 * & *#( >-7-889%

"$* ("

(#3*&"")34

)

(*#( * *$4"

3.$*

& "#)0

,$$ (00

$E $(

*$4

- - 67-7-889- , % & .

$ * : ": & - #"% $03 .: &)#((3#*

$* )

$ $"$)3 && #4* * 0"

3.$*

0&# * *

&$""

*'3$

5# ".

#3 1.

8>9#3 "- . " #

: "$ .3 * )

$3. . "&* -1% &$ $ $& 6 .

30$ 4 ) ("

$* )

0$ *$. .33:

& ( *# 3$**:#*

; #3 " )$"

5# 4 & "#)0 * )4

"& ( B--D%$33$3$)$*%

(

: E$"$3 "0$B ""

$3 00* "D $*0"$&& & $ *H

0) ==3

.#*".

"( 4- ) $($"

:$"& &$ $$" 0. 0"$&& & $."(E". ""

$3(00* $*$:$ *

&$""

*)4

) $ $$"

$&& $3$* '".3 *)4

$$"

$:$ * :

*"0""

*)4

$# "#*

(- (&4.

&$""

* )4 '"$3 $# 4 6-7>-88< $" )

$ *$" C# ?1H- ""$** "$4:$4 .#

($"

"&* "-& #"$3. C# ?1H

$3" $

$ ) $ $:$ * " *$ * 6A-76-889-

$&& 33$ * &$""

*)4

%$=3E$*"0""

$&& $3 .

$$"

$:$ * " *$ * 6-79-889-

'"$3 * C# ?1H"*$ *6-7>-88<-33

"#)"

&$"".

0&# * * *$ *67-7-889 $* (#3* &"")34 . 0

)$"" .

"$0 - " &

C# ?<%$#)

$*)

("# * 5#

"$$"

$*$(( *

& .

$33

$33 $" $*)

& '

,$$

"( 4 #$0#"34 $(( &

(00 *$ .

" 0

3* 67-7-889$* 0$

9 * " $*'

$4 5# 4 & "#)0 * )4

"& ( B--$33$3$)$*D$". 0

)$"".

* .

0$- "

$4 ( *"

: $$

5# 4

" $*)

#" *"& ( %$33$3$)$* )4

,$$

- #"%

(# ($

0&# * * ) "#"$ *-

* *$ * 78-7;-88< .

" $ %

( 4 $* $3"

* " *$ * 78-76-6777 $* 9-7>-6777 &$""

* )4

" $ $'

( 4 $'

( *

5# 4$$"

3*)4

$" )

.#33 && #4 * 0"

3.- .$3#* "$*$":

$)$""

"$* $# " $'

((3#* $

:$" '

.#33 && #4)4

* * 0"

3.-.

.$( $

** & 0"

3. )

>-7-889 " $E $" * 0$'

&& #4& '* *$*$'$3 *.%

% ($& "#$*

04"

3.$

"$0 - C( &&

$&"($"

35# 0&34

$*0" "#3%

5# $# 4" '

".*

)$"". '* $**#( *) $.

' *# && #4

* 35# 0&34

$*( ""?

C$0

: ""

"& *#( *)

$3..

* &$ 0 -

" ( **($ :$"* -

& .

" ( *%:

(

:#3*

3&#* "$*

& ( *# $*

)$"".((3#" $ '

*$)4

- ($#"

"% $0#$)3 #& 3*

* ".

" $ % $'

( 4$*

" $ % $'

( 4 3* $ $* 5#$

&& #4:$"'

5# 34%

: & " $33:

"3#*$ *67--889 0$

(00#($ * 0'* * *$ *68--889"5#$"

*$ *8-;-88<&$""

*)4

" $ $'

( "% = &# $*

* "*$ *6--6777$*9->-6777 &$""

* )4

" $ $'

( "% #$) $ $3"

5#$"

*- :

$33) &

"&* "& (

5# 4$$"

. 0

"$ . &3 "

".3 *)4