← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1655/1988allowed

Dharam Singh v. Ujaggar Singh

2019-05-21Mr. Justice Amit Rawal13 pages





! "

  "#!$%&

'

& 

 &() &)*+,+- .-.

 

     

  

/ 0%1$!



21     



  !



 "

   #  

   #   

 "



 $$ 

21$ % $ "" 

 

 & '

&()&

 

 

 '

   "

     &  " *+,-   "   ...# /0.# .- /# 1 .*#  .2  ( 



(   )  

() .+*     2*# ..  

  % ""  "

3  "   #  "  '        "3  

"    "  # 

" "      

"

  )

 "

   &  "

 

 ()

 

 

,-,.042  ' !

,* ".042  53

   

6 

  .1*.04- 

   5    

  

  6  

 !

,-- .21.042 210 ",-.040(    7 !

/



  " ""& "   

$  ""!

.  "

 "   ""!

, /  "

 "   ""!

2

*    " 

      " !

.

0 .* .0  "

 "  " !

,

1 .8

.2 .4 .- ,89,.  "

 "  " !

* 4 - .19 .1$    " 

      &    "

&

  )      "       &

   () :

 &  "  !

,,  

   &  3     "

 &   %   ( 

 &   )   "" " ;

 ()( 

(     ) <   "

     )  "  !

,,     &

" !

.

0 .* .0 (        ' !

,* ".042  53   

6   () '

,-,.042= "

  5"  6>   " .04-    .1*.04-    5    

  

  6 = "

   5

 6>  ?) 

" "

  " !

,,  /0# 1  "

# ( 

    "   : 3  : (  !

21 %          "

   "

" 3        @ .01,  3   

   (  

    ) ()A

 B  2*# ..

  :3   .2  " 3 !

,*+,+, 

    "   ?   

 (  " ") 

 " )  .011  "

   &

(

   & "

& "    )



(     &"

 " !

,, )<       3& +3

 !

..0+.82+.** (  # !

.0+.8+,   (  "

 ) .0*8$*.     ? : &       3 !

,*+,+, 

     ?  %     

(    ( #

" ""%  &

( 

(        )  )  C  

 (

"

&)    

"  

*+,-  " !

.

2 0 .8 ..

./ .0 ,. ,,

   " !

.

0 .* .0"  &

      () ( ;

  ( ) 

 

(

(   D      

       )

 (   7 & "

  "

 )"

()   3    "  ;



 00.004      &<

() & 

  " &        "  

       (   "

 (     

       

"   (     &  ("



      & )  &  &  ;

  ( " 

   % " 6  &

(

  # &

"

"

   .,) & &        () "         3        

 

  &

"")

 ") .011   &  

# &

"

"

   .,)  &

"" 

 (

 & ".01, .011 " !

* 4 - .2 .1 .1$ .- " &

     

 &

     "  (" " !

.

0 .* .0& "      &      '

 "  "

 &  $

          

                 !

!

!"" # $     % &' ( ( )        *      (   (+,    -     +     .

          "

     % # / 0 1

  ""   ""

   <   .  """ , 3E / 

 C<.

 ,1    < 

 ( 

 " 

     %   

 ) 22 D 



" <  "

&  .  !   ,      /  F     3   2 %  '

 

   "    !

.$ ;

 <

 

() "  "

"      ""      

       ) $   ""     "" "

"

# ( " "    

 

 <  "

 <    @  & & 

( & (

 .--0$08& .-0/$02

" 

(     



%#

"

  

(

   " 6:

E& " )"

(<

 "   "$ ;

  ) 

(

          7   & '



  (  )   .+*    2*# .. "  "   $ ( ( !

//$' .0-- $G$       

  "" () "

 # (     )

 (

  

   

<  "   @ 

((

D 



"  ")  &"  " & "

   

   C<1 - "

 &  )

        %'

  ,/8*.0--   & 

      

 "       )   

& #  "



 & #  

  )  (

  H( )  ,8.0 "

  

  

    

  

   ("  

 

     

      

   (   )



      (  !

/080$' " ,8.0    

     <  $. = )> )  " &  

 "



  

 

 ("  (

   ( #

   < 

& (     & &  :  '

 D       (    ) &    C  

 '

 & & 

& " #

(  ) .0.1$.*  .--*$-4   .-1,  C    (   ( 3    

  & &   )   &   "$   # (     ).-1,  "3  # (&

"

" 3  !

 "3 ) "3  ) & & 

( "$  7 .--,$-/   @  3  &    &       "     #

(  $        ) .-1,  7   

  $  # (& (  (&(



"

 $ 

   "#  7  .--2$-1   @  "3 &  &  ;

 @  



 " &  &  ( "

).080$.8 "

  

.021$2*& 

 !

./=#>" 

!

122 "<  ()



&  "   &   

 3 !

*.,+/+8$.,       ( 3!

.8/*"  & 3 "

).01.$1, " 

# ( &

 &#

(  @(  "

 ) .0*8$*. " &  " 

   " &  & "# ( 



(   #     "    "   21# -"   ?) "

"

 



 

& ,,. ",. C " :

E&  )   

"         ""&    )()(  (

'

( &(  

"

"

 %   &



  &( (

    $    "     "

 "

  ( ;

 "& !

. ,

 

"   ) 

 "     ) "

       &   7    "

  (    & 

 

    ()   : '

  

   

  !

  ():

6( '

 "## $  

  %&

 &



 '   ()( * ##  % '

 +,-,  " =4> .

** #$ &**

  #+/

  (  - !.+/"

-0=,,>

 #.2 &+,3/ +  4++!.+,3/"003 & <

 

(

(

(   "

   

"

 

&



 "   & "       & 

 

  ():

6( '

 "&#$ & 



'  "$( +  +   ( 3+!.+"303&  



 "

   

"   + ;

 ()")

 ( <  )

   

   #     

  ("  

$ "   (

   &

  

  < # (" 

) & # ( ""()"

 

  < 

  7   " ( 

 

'

 $ #"

) & "

)+,/ 4 /0%  & #



" 

# (    " (&

# %

 

 < " .+*      " 2* #  ..  &  ) (      

 

  # &

     )

(      &

  ;

 "  

  )    ( 

 

 .8. 7  C   7  

" "

  (     

   () :

6(  '

 5 #5#6 (  7'2    #.+,- "+3+!2   #4)& # .+,0 "-, 

 () '

 $( "

)

 "'7 #2  #+/   -!("

)  # "& "

)  # )  +0 3+    (  -/-! 4( "

)  #

 ( #+, +   ( +! 9 #   #" #   #/ +   ( 33! 8  "

) #+   ( 0, 2 (: # "

)  ;'7  "

)   # +-

   /+  7  

(

  

  (

     (    

  

      <   

 (  

 '

 " "" &     )  ) 7 (

   &

'

F 

 &     ,-80.0-,  '

  $   <      3 E  3

 "

,..8.0-,D   

  



 & 

8..8.0-,"  '

 "" "" & 

   <   " " .24+$    ) ./.,.0-,   &  

   

 ./.,.0-,      !       @

  "3E 3

 8..,.0-,    <   7  

"

    (

#  '

( & 

  ( & "

 &  ( ;

 "&"

  ()

'

$

 A=>   (

 '

 ( &  (     

  

     

 )I =>    

 "  "

&   IB 7&

("  )

) 

< F   &  "3E 3

& 

$

 ) 3 45  62,#  ,0,   3 7   5     $. 8  (     9 (   9  (    *":    ;  ( 1 < &  => $/ <!

!/$ =6   5    3 43 > 

$

<

!/$(  6 :     ?

.

!/$ =      

$

!/$ '

5      : ?

$

!/ #  @ %    =6 

                   0

*": 9( )

$ /$ >  , A%  ,     ?     

 '

 )

$ /$ :  ?,0 1     "

F    &     <   #   ( "    " 

  &    " :  '

 D     

      

"  &  "

)?   = >

 ( 

;

 

 <   " !

& 

  ) "#

 C<.

) "  &  #

    (      

3  3  !

@







 3 ( $    $     )     7 &

(  "  

< $

;+2  @  B & &  A *- 9 0 #     C

!

-

!

. C //./" C /-$ !< )" **-

-< 

)) -/) "!$  D "!)



)! -/- "!$  D "!)



*" -!< "!



.$ .)-  "--  D ""



.) .)-  "--  D ""

 *.

$<*

*

 *..

!!

)/ *"- //

-* *"! ""

.$

<). -)/ /-! 

<*" -<< !

/!$<

<!/ */)

<)$ <)*

)! )$"

/$ 

$/" )/!

$)*  %

  

         ,,. " ,.  C "  6 :

 E&   

 

  ) ()( 

(2       ()     &    " 

     )  

$   ""    "

  +  "   (;

     &

    )% 

3   &)    &  )(

"

    )%( "   " "&  (

  "



  ( =      

> 

(

) ()( %'



)(&  

 (

'

( &  )  & '

( 

" "  &

 #    ""

     "

& # ("

"

          (       &  &         )&&

" " &  

 &   "D 2. /.% & '

 (  &

"

      %  

         

 



F  ( &&  

   ()   

(2



  #    &     

( 

      7 & ""

      "  & 

     '

 ( & 

 ( 

 (    & ()  % ( ;

 "&

   "

 $ ""   

$

"  %          "     )  

    &    (  

   ( ) 

21

$!& 

3- 4-.

 #J

 # +  K

  ( !