High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/93/2025disposed of

Lachhani Devi Deceased Through Her Lrs v. Land Acquisition Collector And ORS

2025-11-27Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

-!3 3 3 3

-! (&$-/ (&$-/ (&$-/ (&$-/ 4 4 4 456-/ -/ -/ -/9;9 9;9 9;9 9;95'%'%'%'%D(%+ D(%+ D(%+ D(%+ 3-/ -/ -/ -/9;9 9;9 9;9 9;95 E E E E $.''-% $.''-% $.''-% $.''-%9 9 9 9! !9;9 !9;9 !9;9 !9;95

!!!!

!!!!88$**(%& 88$**(%& 88$**(%& 88$**(%&

! !!!

$8-%+$%& !!!

$8-%+$%&

#$$%&

/-#

# " " " "

! "

! " !(%+$$80(#7( +,-.(&$<'& &0 !'&(%)(*'

+,-.(&$(%+ ! (%'%$$ +,-.(&$ &0$(88$**(%&!

!10'%(0('% !!!

(#2(% %(! CCCC ! #(* ! #(* ! #(* ! #(* -!34 -!34 -!34 -!3456 69;95 9;95 9;95 9;95 '% %.$ &0$ 7('% .($ ' (*#$(+2 *'

'&$+ &-+(2 &0$#$/-#$ &0$ 8#$ $%& (88*'.(&'-%'+'

8-$+-/('%/#=.&=-=! -!

-!9:3 9:3 9:3 9:36 -/9;9 -/9;9 -/9;9 -/9;95 2 <(2-/8#$$%&(88*'.(&'-% 8#( (2$#0(1$$%7(+$/-#.-%+-% %'%? &0$+$*(2-/:

::+(2'%/'*'%?&0$8#$$%&(88$ $(*! -& &'.$-/&0$(88*'.(&'-%! $( (#%$+&(&$.-=%$*(..$8&%-&'.

.$-%1$0(*/-/&0$#$8-%+$%&( (%+ =17'&&0(&0$+ +-$%-&'%&$%+&-/'*$#$8*2&-&0 0$(88*'.(&'-%! -% %.$+$+*2 &0$-&0$#'7'*(#*2'& &=(&$+*(%+-<%$#8$#&('%'%?&- (7$ (.>=''&'- -% 8#-.$$+'%? <$#$ 0$*+ $%&'& &*$+ /-# &0$ $%0(%.$+ (7-=%& -/ .-78$%(&'-%8 $#&('%'%?&-&0$*(%+'&=(&$+'% &0',$#2#$,$%=$$&(&$-/'** (?$ 0-7( $0'*( (%+'&#'.&=#=?#(7 &-&0$&=% %$-/ F ;5 5FFD68$#(.#$, ,'+$ +$.''-%+(&$+9 9;!;5!9;:8($+12&0'-=#& '%

-!445-/9;9 0-<$ $,$# '% (% (88$(* /'

*$+ 1$/-#$ &0$ -%@1*$ 8$A -=#& +$+=.&'-% -/ 5B &-<( (#+

-& <( 7(+$ -% &0$ (/-#$7$%& +$,$*-87$%& .- &'-%$+ ($$+ 7(#G$& ,(*=$ , ,'+$ -#+$#+(&$+;5!;

;!9;8($+'%','*88$(* ','*88$(* ','*88$(* ','*88$(* -!F4 -!F4 -!F4 -!F46F:4-/9;#' F:4-/9;#' F:4-/9;#' F:4-/9;#' '%? '%? '%? '%? -=& -/ -=& -/ -=& -/ -=& -/ -!F;94 -!F;94 -!F;94 -!F;946F;4D9; F;4D9; F;4D9; F;4D9;&'&*$+ J J J J &(&$ -/ (#2(%( E &0$# $&.! &(&$ -/ (#2(%( E &0$# $&.! &(&$ -/ (#2(%( E &0$# $&.! &(&$ -/ (#2(%( E &0$# $&.! ,! ,! ,! ,!

(7 0(%+$# E

(7 0(%+$# E E (%-&0$# $&.!@ E (%-&0$# $&.!@ E (%-&0$# $&.!@ E (%-&0$# $&.!@ ! ($+ &0$#$=8 8-% (%+ (88*2'%? &0$ 8#'%.'8*$ $ -/ 8(#'&2 1$'+$?

?#(%&-/)=&(%+/('#.-78$%(& &'-% &0$*(%+-<%$#D(88*'.(%&1$ $'%? '7'*(#*2'&=(&$ $+'$%&'&*$+/-#?#(%&-/'7'*( (#(7-=%&-/.-78$%(&'-%!%& &0' #$?(#+#$*'(%.$.

.(%1$8*(.$+=8-%&0$+$.''-% %-/-%@1*$=8#$7$-=#&'%.

.($ -/ H'%?(88( H'%?(88( H'%?(88( H'%?(88( 0-&(88( %?(+' $(+ &0# 0-&(88( %?(+' $(+ &0# 0-&(88( %?(+' $(+ &0# 0-&(88( %?(+' $(+ &0# #-=?0 $#= 8$.'(* ( #-=?0 $#= 8$.'(* ( #-=?0 $#= 8$.'(* ( #-=?0 $#= 8$.'(* ( (%+ (%+ (%+ (%+ .>=''&'-% //'

.>=''&'-% //'

/'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 9;9; /'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 9;9; /'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 9;9; /'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 9;9; 5 5 5 5! %, ,'$<-/&0$+'.='-%7(+$0$# #$'%(1-,$(<$**(.-%&$%&-/ (88*'.(&'-% &0$ 8#(2$#'(**-<$+(%++$*(2-/ /::+(2'%/'*'%?&0$(88$( (*' 0$#$12.-%+-%$+ +!

-!3 3 3 3-/9;

-/9;

;9 ;9 ;9 ;95 E E E E ! 2 <(2-/8#$$%&(88$(* .0(**$%?

?$0(1$$%*('+&-&0$<(#++( (&$+ 9F!;F!9;8( $+12&0$*$(#%$+++*!'&#'.& =+?$ =#=?#(70$#$'%(/&$#&- -1$ #$/$##$+(&0$J

$/$#$%.$-=#&@ <0$#$12 $/ /$#$%.$ $&'&'-%/'*$+=%+$#$.& &'-% F-/&0$(%+ .>=''&'-%.& F4/-#0-#& #&J&0$F4.&@(&&0$'%&(%.$ $-/ &0$*(%+-<%$#< <(8(#&*2(**-<$+<0'*$?#(%&'

%?&0$1$%$/'&-/$%0(%.$+7(# #G$& ,(*=$ K ;

4!F; 8$# (.#$ >=( &0$ $ (.>='#$+ *(%+ 1$'+$ (<(#+ -/ &(&=&-#21$%$/'& &D'%&$#$&(8#-,'+$+=%+$#&0$ F4.&! 9! #'

'$/*2 &(&'%?

'% &0$ 8#$$%& .($ $ *(%+ 7$(=#'%? 4!3 (.# #$ '&=(&$+<'&0'%& &0$#$,$%=$$&(&$-/,'**(?$0- -7( $0'*(%+'&#'.&=#=?#( (7 .(7$ &- 1$ (.> >='#$+ ,'+$ -&'/'.(&'-% +(&$+ 95!;!9;;F (%+ F!;3!9;;F '= =$+ =%+$#$.&'-%4 4E:-/&0$F4.&#$8$.&', ,$*2/-#&0$8=1*'.8=#8-$%(7 7$*2 /-#+$,$*-87$%& &(%+=&'*'L(&'-%-/*(%+/-#5; 7$&$#<'+$8$#'80$#2#-(+*'%G G'%? <(#G( -<%0 0'8 $*0' /#-7 (#2(%( -=%+ +(#2 -!6F %$(# ,'**(?$ "0$ $#G' (=*( (& =#=?

?#(7 /-**-<$+ 12 (% <(#+ 8($+ 12 &0$ (%+ .>=''& &'-% -**$.&-# /-# 0-#& J&0$ @ -% 93!9!9;;

&0$#$12 +$&$#7'%'%? &0$ 7(# #G$& ,(*=$-/&0$(.> >='#$+*(%+K !:;*(.8$#(.# #$/-#(**&28$-/*(%+!??#'$, ,$+ &0$#$-/ #$/$#$%.

.$=%+$#$.&'-%F-/&0$F 4.&<(/'*$+<0'.0.(7$&- -1$

(<(#+ +(&$+ 9F!;F!9; 12 &0 +$.'+$+ ,'+$ ( 0$ *$(#%$+ ++*! '&#'.& =+ +?$ =#=?#(7!&'** (??#'$,$+ &0$8#$$%&(88$(*<( (8#$/$##$+! 3! 0 0(,$ 0$(#+ *$(#%$+ .-=%$* /-# &0$ 8(#&'$ (%+ ?-%$ &0#-=?0 8(8$#1--G(< <$**(#$.-#+-/&0$.($! 4! &0 0(%-&1$$%+'8=&$+-%/(.&&0 0(&'=$-/+$&$#7'%(&'-%-/7(# #G$& ,(*=$(*#$(+2& &(%+(+)=+'.(&$+=8-%/'%(**21 12&0$-%@1*$8$A-=#&,'+$ $'& +$.''-% +(&$+ ;5!;!9; 8($+ '% ','* ','* ','* ','* 88$(* -!F4 88$(* -!F4 88$(* -!F4 88$(* -!F46F:4 -/ 9;

F:4 -/ 9;

9; 9; 9; 9; #''%?-=&-/ #''%?-=&-/ #''%?-=&-/ #''%?-=&-/ / -!

/ -!

/ -!F;

F;94 946F;4D9; F;4D9; F;4D9; F;4D9; &'&*$+J&(&$-/(#2(%(E &0 &(&$-/(#2(%(E &0 &(&$-/(#2(%(E &0 &(&$-/(#2(%(E &0 0$# 0$# 0$# 0$# $&.!,! (70 $&.!,! (70 $&.!,! (70 $&.!,! (70 0(%+$#E(%-&0$#$&.

0(%+$#E(%-&0$#$&.

0(%+$#E(%-&0$#$&.!@ (%+&0$( (7$/-#&0$(.>='#$+*(%+0(1 $$% ($$+12(88 *2'%?+$+=.&'-%-/5B&-<(#+ +$,$*-87$%&.-&-,$#&0$7(# #G$& ,(*=$ ($$+ 12 &0' -=#& K F ;5

5FFD6 8$# (.#$ <0'.0 .-7$ &-

4!F F;8$#(.#$!0$*$(#%$+ $/$# #$%.$-=#&0((<(#+$+&0$( (7$ 1$%$/'& '&&0=.

.(**/-#%-'%&$#/$#$%.$! 5! & &0'&(?$ '&7(21$%-&'.$+0$# #$&0(&&0$*$(#%$+ $/$#$%.$- -=#& ,'+$'&'78=?%$ $+<(#+0(+$%'$+&0$&(&=&-# #21$%$/'&D'%&$#$&&-&0$(88$**( (%&6 *(%+-<%$#/#-7 793!9!9;;'!$!&0$+(&$-/8( '%?-/&0$<(#+12&0$ &'** 3;!;3!9;'!$!& &0$+(&$-/&0$/'*'%? $/$#$%.$

$&'&'-% 0-<$,$# &0$(7$ '% ?',$%/(.&(%+ .'#.=7&(%.$-/&0$.($'<0- -**2=%.(**$+/-# $8$.'(**2<0$ $%( 8-'&',$ /'%+'%?

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

%?*2

+'%?-%&0''=$'#$&=#%$+'%/( /'%+ (,-=#-/&0$8$&'&'-%$#(%+(?('%& & &0$ #$8 8-%+$%&!I :! & 7 7(2 (*- 1$ %-&'.$+ 0$#$ &0(& & &0$ (/-#$('+ /'%+'%? 0( %-& 1 $$% (('*$+ 12 &0$ #$8-%+$%&D&(&$ $'&0$# 12 <( (2 -/ /'*'%? -/ (%2 (88$(* -# $, ,$% &0#-=?0.#-6-1 1)$.&'-%! =#&0$#7-#$ '&7(2( (*-1$8-'%&$+-=&0$#$&0(&1=#+ +$% &- 8#-,$ &0$ /( (.& &0(& &0$ #$/$#$%.$ 8$&'&'-% 8#$/$##$+ (& &0$ '%&(%.$ -/ *(%+-<%$# <( 1(##$+ 12 *'7'&(&'-% (*<(2 <( =8-% &0$ #$8-%+$%&D& (&$ 0-<$,$#&0$(7 7$<(%$,$#+'.0(#?$+(%- $,'+$%.$'%&0$/-#7-/(%2%-& &'.$ =%+$#$.&'-%9 99-/&0$F4.&$,$#$#,$+ +=8-%&0$(88$**(%&D*(%+-<%$#< <( 8#-+=.$+-%#$.

.-#+-(&-(&&#'1=&$0$#(1-=&& &0$/(.&=7-/G%-<*$+?$-/< <(#+ +(&$+93!9!9;;

;(%+'&.-%&$%&!,$%8(27$% %&-/.-78$%(&'-%<(#$*$($+ +'% /(,-=#-/&0$(88 8$**(%&D*(%+-<%$#-%;3!9!9; ! ! % =.0 .'#.=7&(%.$ -%.$ &0$ $ $/$#$%.$ $&'&'-% /'*$+ (& '%&(%.$-/&0$ (88$**(%&D*(%+-<%$#<(0$*+& &-1$<'&0'%*'7'&(&'-% &0$*$(#% %$+

$/$#$%.$-=# #&.-77'&&$+'**$?(*'&2<0'*$+$% %2'%?0$#&0$(<(#+-/'%&$#$& /-# &0$8$#'-+/#-7 93!9!9;;'!$!&0$+(&$-/8('

'%?-/&0$<(#+&'**3;!;3!9; '!$! &0$+(&$-/&0$/'

'*'%? $/$#$%.$ $&'&'-%! F! ..

.-#+'%?*2 '%,'$<-/(/-#$('+# #$(-%#$.-#+$+12&0'-=#& ('+ /'%+'%? #$.

.-#+$+ 12 &0$ *$(#%$+ $/$#$%.

.$ -=#& ' 0$#$12 $& ('+$! 0$ (88$**(%&6*(%+-< <%$#'0$*+$%&'&*$+/-#&0$(<( (#+-/(**&(&=&-#21$%$/'&D'%&$# #$& /-# &0$ 8$#'-+ /#-7 93!9!9;; &- 3;!;3!9; ( <$** -,$# &0$ 7(#G$& ,( (*=$ ($$+12&0$ -%@1*$8$A-=#&! !

$% %+'%?(88*'.(&'-% '/(%2 (#$( (..-#+'%?*2+'8-$+-/! -,$71$# -,$71$# -,$71$# -,$71$#9 9 9 9 9

9 &'G 9;9 9;9 9;9 9;95 " " " " M0 M0 0$&0$#8$(G'%?D#$(-%$+ $ 0$&0$##$8-#&(1*$ $ D- D-