Gokal Chand Limba v. Main Pal
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
C"+41/1 ("+4"+8 ..121"'") C"+4$(!/!".$!/!#14!+2!%.$(!
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
C1/1 ("+4"+8 ..121"'"+4"')%."1'!4$%2%+)14!/$(!!#14!+2! */%,-($1+$("$/!-"/4$(")*!!+.,/$(!/2%+$!+4!4$("$1$9")4,'0&/%#!4 *!.%/!$(!$/1"' %,/$$("$$(!2(!;,!1+;,!)$1%+1)),!4*0$(!/!)&%+4!+$ ."1'!4$%)!/#!$(!&,/&%)!
("#!(!"/4'!"/+!42%,+)!'.%/$(!"&&'12"+$"+4&!/,)!4$(! 2")!.1'!
(!2%5&'"1+"+$!B"51+!4(15)!'.") C"+4/!1$!/"$!4(1) )$"+4")$"8!+1+$(!2%5&'"1+$ +%$(!/%..121"'./%5"+8%."/%4" +"5'01/1 ("+49")!B"51+!4") C9(%$!)$1.1!4$%$(!!..!2$$("$$(!
2(!;,!1+;,!)$1%+9")&/!)!+$!4*!.%/!$(!"+8 (!"22,)!41+(1) 4!.!+2!!B"51+!4")5"+0")A91$+!))!)+"5!'0C,8(4!# "'!$(1" C "31+4!/ ,5"/C:"(1* "5"+4CA"-1+ ,5"/ %0"'"+4
: "44,2!4!#14!+2!B)$%= $9")$(!2"$!-%/12"')$"+4%.$(!/!)&%+4!+$$("$+!1$(!/(! *%//%9!4 "+0"5%,+$./%5$(!2%5&'"1+"+$+%/1)),!4"+02(!;,!1+ ."#%,/%.$(!2%5&'"1+"+$!.,/$(!/)$"$!4$("$(!9")1+$%(/"$*,)1+!)) 91$( >) "5!)( ,5"/"--" "5"+41)),!42(!;,!$%(15%+'0"+4$(!
)"5!9")("+4!4%#!/$%$(!2%5&'"1+"+$9(%51),)!4$(!)"5! C ,8(4!# "'!$(1" !5*!/ "+2("0"$ #1''"-!
(,(/19"'" ("++" *0 9"0 %. "..14"#1$ BC> )$"$!4 $("$ $(! /!)&%+4!+$9")"(/"$91$( >)"--, "5 "5!)( ,5"/"+41)),!4 *'"+8)1-+!42(!;,!$%(159(%("+4!4%#!/$(!)"5!$%$(!2%5&'"1+"+$ (!".%/!)"14#!/)1%+9")2%//%*%/"$!4*0CC:"+4 CA &!/,)"'%.$(!2")!.1'!.,/$(!//!#!"')$("$$(!2%5&'"1+"+$ ("))15&'0)$"$!41+(1)2%5&'"1+$$("$$(!2(!;,!1+;,!)$1%+9")1)),!4*0 $(!/!)&%+4!+$1+41)2("/-!%.(1)'!-"''1"*1'1$0$%9"/4)(15 %4"$! &'"2!&,/&%)!9/1$1+-.%/41)*,/)1+-),2("(,-!"5%,+$%. <> (")*!!+!B&'"1+!4*0$(!2%5&'"1+"+$(!2%5&'"1+"+$*!1+-"+4#%2"$! 9")!B&!2$!4$%/!#!"'$(!5"$!/1"'&"/$12,'"/)1+/!)&!2$%.$(!"''!-!4 $/"+)"2$1%+%9!#!/1+(1)2/%))!B"51+"$1%+(!(")."1'!4$%$(/%9'1-($ %+$(!5"$!/1"'")&!2$)%.$(!$/"+)"2$1%+ (!
2%5&'"1+"+$(").,/$(!/ ."1'!4$%)(%9"+0$/"+)"2$1%+$("$(!91$(4/!9$(!)"14"5%,+$"+4("+4!4 %#!/)"5!$%$(!/!)&%+4!+$%5"$!/1"'(")"')%*!!+*/%,-($%+/!2%/4 $%!)$"*'1)($("$,+4!/9("$21/2,5)$"+2!)$(!2%5&'"1+"+$"4#"+2!4),2(" (,-!"5%,+$$%$(!/!)&%+4!
A (1) %,/$1)%.$(!%&1+1%+$("$$(!$/1"' %,/$(")-1#!+1$) 2"/!.,'2%+)14!/"$1%+$%$(!!#14!+2!%+/!2%/4&"/$12,'"/'0$(!4!.!+2! !#14!+2!9(12(1)),..121!+$$%/!*,$$(!&/!),5&$1%+2"//1!41+$(!)$"$,$! /!-"/41+- 1)),"+2! %. 2(!;,! $%9"/4) 41)2("/-! %. '!-"' '1"*1'1$0 (! !#14!+2!%.C"+4C1)2/!41*'!"+4$/,)$9%/$(0 &&"/!+$'0$(!#1!9"4%&$!4*0$(!$/1"' %,/$1)"&%))1*'!
#1!9*")!4%+2%//!2$"&&/!21"$1%+%.!#14!+2!+#1!9%.$(!"*%#!$(1)
%,/$4%!)+%$.1+4"+0/!")%+$%1+$!/.!/!1+$(!9!''/!")%+!43,4-!5!+$ &"))!4*0$(!$/1"' %,/$
!),'$"+$'0'!"#!$%"&&!"'1)4!2'1+!4 ,'0
,'"$1 ! C(!$(!/ !&%/$"*'!
!)>% C(!$(!/&!"81+-> !")%+!4 !)>%