Kulbhushan Bagga And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another
!!
# $ &
!!
'
(
!"#$% ! # &!
)!
* +, -(, . + * + / "( $" $"(-+++- &+ * ++$+$"0 -(, . '
( +1+ ! # &!!'
( '
%" ( ( $ .
341 + ' 5" 6" +7( (8+7+1974( $ .
398( 3:4! (
". $ -
". 00""
;("- " ".
;("( 6 '
. (" "" % 0
" .
0" ( (7:+7+1911< = !1>+
"6 ?
(5.
0'" ! '
(
+1 ( ", .
00 . ( + ? , - ?"
, % ' .
-%"5 " ", (
0 (
5 , ( " " ("' -?"."'' 0 .
0" + " 0 - ", /" " '
? %
5' 5" .
'
. (" ?
( % " = ." ( %'
. ( - " 6 ( 6 '
. (" "" % 0 05 6 (" " ". +
" ,"( ( ( (13+1+1911(" .
( "
'' % 6* @ 5* .
(" "
-.
( ( % -( 6* @ * ? (" .
(
("
'
+ ' .
0 - (*-;(" "
( (A7+A+1911
+B"
'
= (
" %.
0'"
"# 0(& %
(*(
.
( ( 13+A+1911 ?"
%$#"'0 .
( ( A9+A+1911+ " - (*-;(".
.( (" '
"
'' " , ("
.
0" , "5 ( "
.. (" ' . (.. (,
( . (
."0 ( %% ( + , ( (.
% " -' ( .
( ( '
5 (*-;("+ ' %
5'
,""
341 + ++?
( ? "
050/ . ( -05 . 5
", %% .
5 ( ( (
' , .
%5
?"
. ( ". +$ .
A19 + " 65 , .
"( -?".' . " . ( %
.
(" %% . ( (" ( + '" "," ? %% . (5.
00"
( ( %.
" , 0".5
( " ("' - .
%. "0"'
. ?
( % " = ." + C $' 0 "0 %. ".("
!" #B.S.Joshi and others ,State of Haryana ) *'
+,#-.'/-' 01% ? (5 " .. %2-(3)'#4* ) *'5# 6-7 8 ) *'9
0+:
1, (
?"
"
", , (" ' . (
( ?+ % - C $' 0 "Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another ::
#-.'/-' + +% (
?"
" ( " ?
(5 $' 0 6"
"State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal9:#-..:#++1+
87 &( (( )!
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
,
( $
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 ''5" ?
( 5 C $' 0 " ' %&( ( ""
-"
"'' ?
' " , ( "
.
0" - .
% . (" ?
( 0 5 %'
. (5 ?" (.. '
' 5 56"
?
( . " ( ". -?"."' "0 "5 & .
" .
( $ .
341 + - %"( . "(6 5% ?"
" 0"
(' 0
(5&("."' . ( ( . -
+7( (8+7+1974( $ .
398(3:4! (
". $ -
". 00""
;("-" ".
;("(
6 '
. (" "" % 0 6 ( 6 " .
0" + (
5 " 0" (5 0(.
("
.
0" ( "
.
( ( % .
?+
( ? (+ ! # &! !"
<
./5 B ' /" @ () @
B
) @