High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/4890/2015allowed

Balbir & ORS v. State Of Haryana

2016-05-05Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan11 pages

!" !

!#$%!%&'(')*#+ , - #./'0#)1$2%0( 33%..#)$( 4( $#$%#0+#)# %(3)1%)$ * 56 7 6! 0%(%)$*

78.1'3')92 0#.

! " #$%&#&%' ( ) * * !! + ,

-( %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 #' " 2 '

&&&0+ #" )4 6 %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4

.'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 #' " 2 '

&&&0+ #" )4 6 %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 ! %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 #' " 2 '

&&&0+ #" )4 7 ! %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 )7 ) %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4

%./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 #' " 2 '

&&&0+ #" )4 ) %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4

( %./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4

%./0%.1 .'# 2&3 45 2 4 '

&&&0+ %" )4 %.10%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4 .'#0%./45 % % &&&0+ 3 )4

(

: - %$&2#&%2 5"

* !! " * ) ( )4* ")

" !

!"(

- 4 " ! " )

6"!

(4)

8 !

") " + " " ( " " "5 6 9 ( ) 7! ": " " "

" ( ( " ; "" "9 %$&2#&%2($2&" " )

" -" " ! "

" 0 )

0 ( 6"! 4 "" -( " < 6 6 " <!" < (

" < 7!" < )" <= )7

) !

)

9 :

" ""( "

" " ""( "

! "" " )

6"! "

" " "!

(+( "

" "" %&&9

9 ( " ) %.1 %./ 2&3 .'#45#'>#3 " %/'/ ? @ " @A " 54; 8 ""

) 5 () 2&3 45 : ( ( ) + "" () %./ )%.1 .'# 2&345

-( 6 ! ) ( 6 + "" ( ) #3 " -(

! +

"" ()#' " "

" 4 :"" B% B# ) B2 6"! B.

)4* ") B'

B$ " B3 -" B1 " B/ C )4)6" B%& C )4 *5 B%% 5)! 6" B%# 4 D!

) B%2 )4* ") B%.

C )4!)

B%'

BE) B%$ ) ) " B%3 85 B%1 )4*6 B%/ )4-! B#&

)46" B#% 5*) B## ! B#2 B#.

5 ( ) 6" B#'

5 ( 6" B#$ ) 6"= B#3

)4 * ) B#1 5 ) 6" B#/ 5 * B2& D B2% 6" B2# 4 ")2%255

( ) * * !!

- 4 8 "

+ "" () %./ )%.1

.'#2&345 ( 4 ( ! :"

" ( " B$ ! " B%< 6"! B.< )

B2< "

B3 " B/ )"

B#< -" B1<! B#2< B#.

" " ! " ""(

+ "" ! "

! " " "

; +:" (

; 8 ) * * !! ) %./ )%.1 .'#2&3 45 " F)8?C:=A " 50%$" "&2%'G " B02" 6 8 ) * * !! ( " ( , H "

# $

%& # $ '

( ) $

) ) *

)

$ ,

(

- ./&01

(

# $

2 1 3 ! $- 2& #&

4 " - 1 #5 4- 2$ -

6 ..78 9 1 81 9:;&

# < #

$ #

G 4" + ( ( ! "

" !

+ " "" "

! "

! !( " "

( ( +

" 4 9 " 4 9 " "

" "" " 5"

%&& 4( ) %./ ) %.1 .'#2&345 ( ( 5 ;

; () %./ )%./ .'# 2&345

" + -( ! " "

F" ")4*6 B%/ " #.&2#&%2 + -( " "C:B%/0 2%' ( * 4 " 2%'(

C:B%/09

""C:B%/0 )"

#3&2#&%2 " C:B%'0 4 " 2%'(

C:B%'0+% ""C:B%'0+# )"

"C:B%'0F " 2#( "

" 5 4 " 2#(

C:B%'0F+ % ""C:B%'0F+#

9#1&2#&%2 ! "C:B%#0 " ( * ( + 4

" %#(

C:B%#0- ""C:B%#05

")4*6 B%/ ( ( " C )4 ! B%'

" " " 2%'(" -( "2#( " ! " %#(

" " " 4 ( 5 5 ( 4( "

4" ) %./ )%.1 .'#2&3 45 ( ( (

;

( (( -( ! " "

"" ()#' " 8 + 6 "

" "2 ) #' " + -(

! # " "

; -( !

" ; " + + :-(

! ( (( ( -(

!( ""! " 7 6! #+ , - !