← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1370/2018dismissed

Suleman v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-10-16Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi19 pages

   

        

 

  

  !    " !  #$% 

 !!    "!

 & !   !

 # !!     

'    !( ) * '

+ )   

  ,-.* /0 '    !' + ) '   !12)(2   !3   3 )(2   !

'

1 )4   !5*6 )  !3  )7  !

'&)0   !'&)'      !' 2     "  ")2 )  )    

2   '  " &   

 0    &      08'8#)"" 2   0   !  

&  

   "   " 

!

)(2   !3     ! !      !6     



   7  !'&  8 "      

&    0  ! &   " !      '  !12)(2   !'

1 

2"       !   '   

 &     "     2  " $ !   !    0   !'& " &" &  6!   8

     ! )  !   "  !   2  "  6     ! 

  

& "   "      

   &!

"   & ₹ 9:82 6 

!

₹9):8" " "

& #!;7+7 26 

" !   ! !)  &  &;

  8

)

"   $ 6!

   )

 

"  &6'

6 * ,*<8/0  

,-.*%/

  ,-.*/0  ! 0  28

 -.*9 -.*  "    2

  8 -.*0    -.*!  !

    5   

 )     6   "     

;

 & 

 ) !!   

,-.*#/    !     ! !!  "      !   "  2

   -.* 2 ,-.*$/! " 8     -.*!  ! &"   6 6   !  -.*9 9 ;

9)6'

6 *  

 ! 

=$!)   $)$%)$)#87)$)$)$#)$#9)) #)#)##)9 *+ :$:!6 6 )* '

+ )



2

    &   08'8#  -.*  6 '    "   %58 

 )  "  !     % ;

9)!

  

 )!  

 ' #+*+"  

! + 6(8  ) 

 '  6   ;

9) 

 6'

'

3   (2 5 

 ) !!   

-.

*#    !   & ,  

 / !   ) !)""  2

 8   -.*$    -.*!  ! & " &*<6'

'

36   !

  -.*9    

&  " ! 

 (2  9$9!  (    6 '    !' + )'   !12) (2   !3 >3 ")4   !5)7  !

'& 0   !'&"    

  !!  2 !   

&  

)     ;

+

 ) "!

   ' $%)##)$)9)#)$#9 $#" ' $ *+ &   &   

 #

    )   .  



"

        ?8  



       

    *<8 '    !

(  0   

0    -.* '0;*'+  0

!     8

" !  ! 

  *<8 (' 

!(  0  &"

     "  & 2   0

! 6 0

8 !          & -.* "  " 2

       0" )    "

" ! #9 " 

 !  8.  *<8# 6'

@*2 

%)( 0+

  0          !!

-.*<#:6;

#6'

6 *     "         &     &"  

&  '1 ( 

 * 

# *<8$ +

  ( ' 

# ;

 %     '    

"      &

 ;!!*<86'

6  *  *<8 6'

6 3) !



0       -.*#

  !*<86'

*  *<89 ' 2  ) "!!'' 8 

'  &"

    

' 

!     '           *<8 +

  * 

#+ 7 )  '  #)  0            !!

-.*<:6;

$    & '1( )3  

 *<8% 5( ' ) (;A  

0   ) 7  0              

    !!  -.  *<%:6  8    -.*$ -.*  

*<892   *<8'   *<8 +

  5 

%) *  ;

 #      2    8  !  !*<8'  0    -.*9 -.* *<8    *

* '0;*''  )  ;

9   !

8

)    # +*+  

  *<8 0+B*2 

#%)

8 )

)@+) +*;!!!

 ;

    8  6(        !! "   & & *<8 

  !

") 0  "

 ! 0 8   !   *<8# 0+5*

$** +  0         "   ;  

) 

 ! 

     ) 6 "      )    8 

-.*#" 0 8  &-.*$ "  "  2  

       0    2 -.*$  &-.

*) -.*9 *<8$ 2  !' 6 0 0  "

 !   2   0    !    

!  '    )6  (2  *<8 6'

6 *

 0  

 !!!   0        -.  *) 

  -.

*)  

   -.

*%)  -.*9 -.*)   -.*!  !8  ) &-.* "   " 2

  

&)   

-.*#!

 6 )-.* "  "  2

   )

 2 -.*$! )   

-.  *  !       !   &  0   -.;6)-.*

" &    08'8#"  2

    *<89 +

 (  '  # ;

9   

  !       6  (2   !3 "  

   0     8 

 -.  *#  !     (2   0 

!    0  -.*$ "   

 "   &     *<8 6'

'

3

 0   

  

 0  (2  0     8 

-.*#! (2 ) -.*$ "   "

2

   0    -.* -.*9  "   !

  $     ! " 

?

      

 -.* + 

 &*<8'    !( ) !'0;*'+   -.*  & "  !  !

 " 2 &*<86 * )    !*<8'  ) 

 *<8(' -.*# '      ! & *<86 3 -.*$ (1 ('::#  "  

*<8'  " 8  &.  &  A07  -.* (1 ('::#%  " *<892  "!!'  " 8  & .  A07  -.*9;

-. *  !  !  -.*# 5   

 !!& 6 

     !*<8#0+5* -.*$ '2 !  -.*  &  " "   &*<86 * !    !

 6        

  !*<8#0+5*  -.*9 5   "    !  !

 

*<8' 

-.*

  %#       !

 

 &*<8' 

-.*% -  

   ! 

-.* -.*     &*<86'

6 *  



-.*  & #9 "  " 2

   &*<86'

6 * 

  !*<8+

 5  % -.*      !" 6     ! !!   -.* * &! & "

  &   0-B-0%"  2

   &   

 $ 9   $)$%)$)#7)$)$)$#)$#9)) #)#)##)9 *+ !6 6 ) 

* '

+ )  -.*# 5   

! (2  9 !!   !*<89+

 (  -.*$  & 9 "  

 "   & (2     !*<89+

 (  -.*     &*<8 ;'

3!

 !" (2       &  -.*9 5  9 "  (2  

!   !*<8 '  "" 

&*<89+

  ( -.*C

'1  &7 7  ) ''

!;!!

   ".    ##! +!

+  *

    !  

  

  "   &       !    9 !   ! " 

?8       

  * &!

!'   9

 $ 9   $)$%) $)#7)$)$)$#)$#9))#)#)##)9 *+ !6 6 )  * '

+ )

  * &!   !  !* &  !@ 6

   * &!     !  !* &

!@ 6

   '

 ' 9+*+ #!

*<9' 2    '

 ' 9+*+ #!

*<

  '

!

 

)

 %# )   $)$%)$)##)$#9)$#)$) #)9 *+)*'+ )   '

21!@ 6

 

%# )   $)$%)$)##) $#9)$#)$)#)9 *+)*'+ )   7     )   

8    

 

  % !



    !  +           !     

 

   

    "    

 !

 " !       " 

  

"     !    6  &8 "

     !  

  

!      &      0) !) &      

          !    '

8  

 =  "     !  

: 



   



"         ) !) 

! 

 "             !  

 :  

=

$)   )

  !  ! "   

        &   

 !   !  

    ')  !)  &     

   2     "        <      !    . 

 # *<8'       ?# "  

  0"    !!!! = 6

)$8  "  &"  2 )  ) ! ) ")&       &    & "     !(   !;

 !

'    !' + )(2   !3 ")6   !3  ) 7  !'&)0   !'&)   '   !

' 2)'   !12)(2   !'

)4   !

  5  "     )" !  "    '    !' +    D  & (2   !3  2  !  &       

  !(2   !'

1    "      ' (2   !'

1  "&  !   8

         !&  2     

2  " 0  (  &(2   !'

1  0     &  

  ₹9:8 0" "

₹ 9):8! ;7+7 2)    @ + "  $0   -.*! 2    

      . ) 

 

2  0 

 

-.* 0     

 "  

  0    D!! &0 !    90 

 $  9"    * '

+      ) 

-.56 9,0"  !

 "  

-.56  

 $ 

! 

-.*   &



 "  

  /0!   8#  

     " !#8$    0   8  "  

 !( )   ! * & 6        "   !6+

A

 ( "    "  @ 8

      

 0 

"  0    

    

 )  !   !0  " 0 

 " & A  

  8   0    & 

&  7 !   

&  0  



   2      " " ! 

!₹9):8 $ *<892  "!!'  )  

 9? "      '     !

) " 

2'     D  2&  2  2  4  B "&     

   (2  '   12        "' 6 6  '  2 " &   !  5  !  

&   " ! 7 0       '

!   '  6     . ) 

"     &' 

  !  

!  0

-.55"  9 ,7 -.55  #/'

  .  



-.55 !    " 

 

  0   

    !$8& ' "  !

"   

-.55  

 

  " 

  ' 

  

 !  

 !( ' 

 !₹):8  &    *<8

 

")   ) 

?#"  

 (   !!= '      

(  !

) "  ! &   &      !'  "  

 D'    !' + "      & (2  !'

1 )(2   !3 )'      !' 2)7  !'&)'   !12     

" 

6   ! (  "   D0 

!  '     '&)(2 )A ) 3 )3  )4)(  )=   

 0 

 '   

-.5-, ! '  "  !   

-.5-/0   "  

 !   "    &  0 

 $ :9"    

0 

! !  

8 

"  

  

0 "8#     !'  '     8

     0 "!    89  " 0    

 !

) 2 &

,

-.5-  9/0

  !

 0 

'     "

 

 

 $0

   " 

 ( "   "  

! & "  8 !6+

A)7  9 *<8$ 2  !6 0     9?"  

       @ 6

      !!!! =   !  6 ) '   (2 "

 

  !'  &" "   )   &      !'  

!&" &%8  0 

!    0  

!& &!      (  !& .

     ) 

)       0

!   '  (2      . )

 

" &   #0  2  

   "  @ 0"  !

"    

-.5A)"!   !  

    !     "  ! 0     "    "

  

   && !  

        "  !!  0  "   !#8$! !   !'  0!    



          !             

  %     

=$   

"  8

   0

 $ )

 

       



  !'  08 

 !   !    !

( + &0 

A  

    &

! 

    

!    0 " 8

    &!   

 !( 

 &     !6+

A)7  

 

 "

  !  8

 "  !  )     

   

-.* ' )'  )(2 )4 )6 ) 7)0 )'    0" )   

&  )  &)'    )6  (2 !

  

*<8'    "

       

    !!  8  

  

)-.*     "

  !  8    !&  !     )   !   %

 )      ! "      " "   @ 6

   



!(  * &    "  &      @  

  $  !  )       $) $%)$)#87)  $) $)  $#)  $#9)  ) #)  #)  ##)  9 *+   :$:!  6 6 )* '

+ " 

!*<8

'

!*<8

 *<8' 

  "  

 :9 

E  8 

-.56"  ' 9+*+    

 $ 

    

    

-.56 

   &     



 9      

               &   8  

"    D) !)  2

0"8 )   &! " 

&)

 

-.

56"  9    . 8  

-.*"  "  & " "

 %8 !

)   %"      6  &)  

 "  

 

         #

 )     

 "  8  &  .   & *<8%5( '  9  ? !   

   &      !.     

&)

   "   "

   !8  &.    ! 

   " 8   "  92  ) "! "  8  &.    ?#'  !     !8  &.    !

 . (1 

    

!  ! &"        !!

  !

 

  !

! !  )

&)

"     !

 !   #    !      !

 9):8" "

&  

!  !;7+ 7 2  ) 

&!"   

     !

  ) A  

     &

! 

    !!&  ! ( + &



 

!

!! & !  " &!  !

 ! A  

 

 & #  

*<8'    . 

   

    !7*<92  !  .8    &

&    )  F   6 

!*<8%5( ' )

&

 (1-.*    ! !  0 

& 8 !'  (1-.*$"    

! 

  &     

)  &)'   2  

   8  &.  !!

  ! " 

  &      "! 

)           

   ! "

  !  8   ## 6     )*<86'

6 * ) 

  !   !  -.*   !

  *<8'      -.*" 

 ( 1 &!   &  6  ! '1 -.

*C  "  2  )  )      "  !    

 1 & )  

!                    !       !

 "

  ! &2  )  )   &  !    "!         ! &   #$  &!  !6    !   &   &

     !  (2 "   

!!   &   !)  &!

      !      #             ! &  

 

 &  =0-'8#"    D0" ) 

&         

       "   ! 8  

 ! &! ! &  #9 6  "  

 

! 

     " ) 0 E '+ 

    

 ! "#    ?8 G   

    

         

   

       

      

 

                     

        

  





 

 

 



      !    

 



    

   "  

 





 

   

     

 !

 

   

 #  



 



  !

     !         





 



  

   

  

  $   

       

  

   

     



37

"! !

    2  "

 " "



$ /)"!   



!"  "   

  & 6  '  B) )"& 8  

= $)  &)6 )'     (2    

 !)       !  2   

 !            

  

   



 !"

#$

%

2

<  2 :   ?H := <    ?H :=