Tarlok Singh And ANR. v. Chief Settlement Commissioner Hy. And ORS.


   
 

 ! "!#$%$&'() (

*+,-$&./&"& /!* ! $ $&!*% 0%
/$!

-! +!1!& 
11$%%$&!*2*3&&" /!*% !%4&"!& %
5' 6 75-
5--578
 

 

   



  5--578297:

       !! "# !$$% &'(
)%* ++ "# !$$% &'(
),* 

 ( -

. . (       .  ,"

 0 . (    +! "1 !$$% 





2 .  -    -

(  -  0 % %  

  ') "1 !+ !$$% 





3   . (  

 ( !1 "4 !$$, 





3   

(

 5 .

  (  6 . !! "! +"!4   (  0 % % (  "1 !+ !$$% -

 

     ')  7(  (      0 % %    (

-8

 !$#"

  

(  

9(      :   !+)$;

   <

( 3 758

 75( (  

.

8 0 ,) =

- 0 !"% 3

 .
8   .( , !"

  < 0( 3

 >  ?( . 

  )/  & * . !4 !! !$44    .

+$ !! !$4+ 

 .

..

  !! "# !$$% &'(
)%*   ++  -8

 (  .( %"

8 . ( < 0( 3

 > .

      0 !1$+ "# !+ !$#" (  @       .

<

( 3 758

 75( ( 

8.

=

 



.- =.

A   

   !+)$;

  <

(
  .   .

. (

=-

. 
(/- 

8.

=  ( (   .



   . 

  -(   < 0(

 > 3  .

3)(.) @ =-

.
(/- "1 "B !$B1 &'(
)!* @ - "1 "B !$B1 &'(
)!*  =

  =-

.

8 ( . 

 .

..

   .  .( , !"

  ?( 

  ( < 0( 3

 > !1C!B "B !$BB 6  -  

 .

..) 0 !   !! "# !$$% &'(
)%*   !B  -8      !! "# !$$% &'(
)%*   .  

  ?( !! "# !$$% &'(
)%*  0 +  ++ "# !$$% &'(
),* 

  ( 

    -  &'(
)%* 

 ( 

 .

..   (      

( ' ( .(  

 &'(
)%*   !#  -8 ( 

  '  ( .(    .  



  -   (  -8 +$ !! !$4+   !4 !! !$44 

  (  6    - (  

 .

..) .   (  '  ( .(     .  ,"

   (  (  ,!

3


 !BB+ &  D !BB+*

- (

       - (      -(   ( 3 

(  

7,;10%-  ! *3&&" /!*%2 9 :7 3  - .

7,;1D &(*   (

     ( )
  

       

  





       

 

    



      

 

   !  "# $

 

 #% 

  

 & 

 



   

  #

 '   

      &  &

  

<   &

  & 

& 

                

 &

         

&     &     

' &



   &

$ % ' 

  (  $ &

$ 



 



 ( 



 

)   

 (  $ &

$'

  


  

 
   

    "# $

*

         +   

 , &

-           



   

 .

' 

 

    ( 

 

               

      

&         

  

+ $ 

 

.   !     ,& 

  

 

/    01& 

+        )   # 

        +&         ,     01  & 

+&'

       

       

   

+     +&

     &   

2+3

& 

     

        &       & + &        %     

 *

         (                  



                 

     

      

 .   5 3 /(.

.  





$=&$*7+84*&"

 /!*%0%/!-  ! *3&&" /!*%2(

(9 :7(3

(      

7,;

1D &(* 





$=& $*7+84*D &(*   /(. !% "! +"!# 
(   9%$>-$&./&" /!*%0%-  ! *3&&"

 /!*%: 7( (  - ( (    (  ,!

 !BB+    

 "% "# +"!!

 ( (  95"&4+%& -/5/& %%&" /!*% 0%  $&&#$+ 
11$%%$&!*  9!?!&;!:  &"  -!#*! *3    ?!*&1!& 2 *3&  &"  /!*%:2 ( 

( A (  - (  /(    /(.

) 2  ( ( 5"&4+D &(*

 , "% "# +"!!  ( )
                &

  

          *&  +   &              

 
   !  "!


  #   !

$%&'(   &  (  



  

 & 4.    

  &

 & '  

 



  

 & 462&

  7     

)*   !"!

+   $ % ,'- ('    

 /       8 &!   

+9   '

        

&            &        

       :      ;

  < 




. /"!





0

  1 !

 ,  '2 (   
   "!

 
* !!

 . / 1 !

 ,'2-    



  9   

+9



 /      8 &! '     *   &   

            

  &  5 2     (   (  (   

.( (. 

  - .  2    

7,;1D &(*

 5"&4+D &(*      - (   -         6    -(  '  /(  ' ( .(       .  ,"

 6  .   

(  ( (    

7,;1D &(*   ( .  -    .  (

- 

(  (

 (  ,!

 !BB+ 3      (     0 !1$+ "# !+ !$#"

(       -(    

      (  3   ' (    (  .

(  

  - 

 

 (   .  - 

    - D    ' (   . (  .

  .

9  ((  (.   8   !BB+ - ( 6     ( 
(/- 



8.

=  ( .

.  )  6  .   ( 

  

  

8.

=  -( ( (    .-

    .      .  (   0  (. 

 (  (.  - (   .

      - (  ( /( - ( .

  .  (    -

  2   

=(  - .            @5--578A +1 "B +"!#     2 8C FC0 2 - FC0