High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/333/2019dismissed

Moti Chand v. Senior Divisional Manager, Lic Of India And ORS

2019-04-08Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mr. Justice Arun Palli8 pages

!" #"$%&%'( ) *

!"#

$ ( + ,-,. , + ,.

% &$' (

& /// . )!

+ ( ,-&,.&-,". /0 1!1 /0

1 /0/ ,.&""&-,"2 ! !( !/ ( & / !/0

/ +

(

"-&,3&"4.4& 0 1 5 6 ! . / ", 0 1 56 !"7 & / 11

! 0 $&#,,8) ( 1! 1 /9 0 ! $&-,,,8) 0 "444& !!( 1

!!! 1 !

( ,"&,3&-,,,

1 /0 1! 1 / !( 1

1 ( 0 / (0 !& ! + $

1 56 !"7 /9 0 !!(( / +0 !

1 ( &

0 ( !

1 ! -7:-75 -76 ! 1 ( 1! 0 ! /!1& !1 /0 ;< = 0 ( 0 ( 0 /1

1 (0 ! ! 1( ! ! 56 11 ( 0 0( $&#,,8)&/ 1! ! 1"- ( 1!1= (((&

/9 01 ! ! ! 56 !"7 &! !/1 1= ,"&,3&-,,, "-( 1!= 2"&,7&-,,"&

! ! 5 6 1 ! ! /0 (( -#&,7&-,,, !

1 /! ( ! ! !(( 1 1 1! ! 2"&,7&-,,,10! !/ ! ! &

/ 0 1! 1 / !0 ! ! ! 1 = ! ! 2"&,7&-,,"& > ! (/! ! !

!( /

( "-&,3&"4.4 /

1 1 0! ! 5 6 ! ! ! ( $&#,,8) ( & : ( 19 56 ( / ! ( / ( !&!(

?=&-?=&"7

!! 1! ! / /0 1 ( 0( 1 0 0 ! 9 ! ! !!

/ 56& !!( ! 1 ! 1 ( 1 ( 0 & /0

1 01+! !( ! 1 1 (0 = ! ( $&#,,8)1!1 $&-,,,8) ,"&,3&-,,,&:+/! /9 0

11 ! ! 5 6!"7! /( (56 !.56 !"7& ( 0 ( 0/1 ( 1

,.&""&-,"2/ ! !(

1 1

// 0 ( ( ! ! ! ! /0 / 1 / ! =! ! / & !! 01 1 ( &

@ ! !

1(0 /( 1 ! / +! ! & $ ! 1 ! ! 6 A/ ( 0%'! 1 ' '# '!0"2&,! !" #03 2 #"&0.

B "5%'#"2 ,%'60 5 7'%$%8 9 7'$%9. , ' 72.

& ?= !9 ( ! 1% 872&7 '!!!0"9"!!"2# !"#

) ;< !0" 88"99 '!= & %'#""# 88%'!"# & 2"! >"2 '# 0"2"1 %'"#%' !0" "18931"'! !0" 282 !%' & &7$0 !%99 0%& &"25%$"& ="2" !"21%' !"#? :!

! "-&,3&"4.4 1 / = 1 ! 1! % @ , 2!0"2'A'". %5%&%' 9 %$". &! ;* .

""5 ' 2> &0.,"$!2 )B .0 '#%6 20 0 )444. ))*.

C). )) C.*

:4 " "2&''"9DB

!"#(

B:B) ,0!%0 '# ) . ,"$!2 :. '$0>79

" 2,%2. "( , , 0%&0 &2" "2"'$"!3729"!!"2# !"# 44) 2"E7"&!%'6 ! = 2# 37 !0" $'!2 $! 2 !!"'#%'6 7"&! 7&" ! 0 '#%6 20

! 0 & F""' #"$%#"# ! = 2# 37 !0" $'!2 $! 2 !!"'#%'6 !0" 7"&! 7&" ' !0" 99=%'6 !"21& '# $'#%!%'&(B

0"8"2%# $'!2 $!'!0" %2&!%'&! '$"=%99F" 2

1'!0&

0" $'&9%# !"# 17'! &C

DB 8"2 1'!0 =%99 F" 8 3 F9" ! 37 & $'!2 $!7 9 1'!093 17'! 0" 8 31"'! !0%&$'!2 $!1'!093 17'!=%99F"1 #"! 37 %' !0" %2&! =""> !0" 99=%'6 1'!0 ' !0" &!2"'6!0 "2!% %$ !" 2172&! !","$!%' 7=%99F"2"E7%2"#!$'! $!72&! !"&"$!%' ,

"8!!# %93!=79#F"372";$97&%5"2"&8'&%F%9%!3! !!"'#!0"7"&!7&" ! 99!%1"&7=%99 9&1 >" 22 '6"1"'!& ! #"87!" &1" !0"2 #"8"'# F9" '# 2"&8'&%F9" 8"2&' ! !!"'# !0" 7"&! 7&" %' 372 F&"'$" & '# =0"' 37 =79# F" $18"99"# #7" ! $"2! %' 7' 5%# F9" $%2$71&! '$"& '! ! !!"'# !0" 7"&!7&"0"'"$"&& 23&7%! F9" 22 '6"1"'! 2 #"87!%'6&7$0 8"2&'=%99F"1 #"F337 !372=' $&! *!

;;; ;;; ;;; ;;;

7!02%!%"&2"&"25"!0"2%60!!!"21%' !"!0"$'!2 $! ! !0"%2 #%&$2"!%' ! '3 !%1" =%!07! &&%6'%'6 '3 2" &'!0"2" 37 2" 62"" F9" ! !0" F5" !"21& '# $'#%!%'&. 89" &" 9"! 7& 0 5" 372 $'&"'! ' !0" "'$9&"# $83 !0%& 9"!!"2 72& %!0 7993. ,#DB

%5%&%' 9 ' 6"2G

/ 0 //01

1(0! !1(! ! ( ! 5 6 ! 0

! 1 1 & 9 7&"

( !! !(

56( / ! /8 //&: 0 /0 /=!00 (/ !

( 0! ( 1// /0(&: ( $9 7&"

) ( ! !

! 0 (& !

1 ! !0 11 =!! ! ( "-&,3&"4.4 / ! 11 ! !&> ! ) ! ! ! 1 9 / (

( 1 !

0 !1&$!/0

( / 0 (/ 1 (! 11(0 ! ( $&#,,8) ( 1!1 ! $&-,,,8) ( "444&C 1/ ! 1 1 0 180 /0 ) & ! 01 0 !( + 0 !( / ( 0( & > /

0 !

0! ! 1 ! 1 (

1/ ( 8! / ?( 0A

: 8 0 ? ! / 9(&11 !1 / 1 !8 !( & ! ( ! ! + ! %

1 !0 ( 0 1 ) 10 0 = ! 8 !( / 1 / ! &C

+ ! ,#&,.&-,," 3. )/ /0

% ,0!%0 '# 2"! >"2 '#% . 7"&!7&"

:.,"$!2 4B 0 '#%6 20

" 2,%2. "( , ,, 4B . 9" &"2" "2!372$117'%$ !%'# !"#)

%' 2"&8'&" ! 72 9"!!"2 #! )C

. =0"2"F3 37 0 5" 2"E7"&!"# 7&!2"'"=372$'!2 $! 2 27''%'6 7"&! 7&" =" :

0" 1 !!"2 0 & F""' "; 1%'"# !0276093H '# $'&"E7"'!93. %! 0 & '! F""' 7'# 8&&%F9" F3 !0" $18"!"'! 7!02%!3 ! $$"#" ! 372 2"E7"&! 22"'"= 9 !0"$'!2 $! & &7$0. 89" &" 0 '#B5"2 $0 26" !0" F5" 7"&!7&" &8"2'5"'!23 &%'#%$ !"#%'72 F5"B 2" "22"#9"!!"2# !"# )C

)

72& %!0 7993. ,#DB ,2 %5%&%' ' 6"2G :(/ ) !

2"&,7&-,,"1 1 0 ! !

1/ !( 0 !! 9& 1

! / 0 /! ! ! / ! %

( !8( 0( !& ! ! /0 !

! 6 A/ ( 0%'! 1 ' +& $ &" &782 10( ! 1 ! / ( & 1 ! "5%'#"2,%'60+&$ &"&782 1 !

0 (1 )(( 0! / /1( ( ! -;< !& @ 9 ! ! / 1 0 ( 0 ( 0/1 & 1 /1 11

/0/( + ( /0 &

/ ( !! 0

( & -2%&0' 72 2% 27' 99% 0%" 7&!%$" 7#6"

) *

I ' @ 8 % D? @$ /% CE