Chander Prakash v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And Others
!
"# $!%&'&"(
) ) *+ , + -
+ .'
)))! & &"(!/ 0++
*+
. 0 1 .
+
)))!'2"($!( '
1
3 . 1) + + +
+ + 4 ) ,/ 5-
""#$""% & ' ( ) ( *( +, +% "++- ./ 01 +0 +
"+"+ ./ 34567 !( ( !2
( 34567 * 8 " 9#
$ (
:
-;
* *
+ + "
/
( (
!
( < =( 3 42 5> 6(* 7* .
345671 "#
000
*2
*
3( 2 "- +- "+"+
!( (
(
(
? ( *2 8 82 * * *
@
! !( 6 &@A%9"++# &@A9 "++#
'
&@A%9"++# * !
*2 * "#
000
* * 2
* +
+-
00-
+
+-
( *
- +"
00-
*2 "#
( * *2 / +
+-
! ( *
2 *2
( 2 2 * *
2 !
' &@A9 "++# *
( * 8 ""A--%$
( * 2 ! ( * * *(
&@A%9"++# * ) * * 2 !
&@A9 "++#
& "
( * * *( 2 8 " #,0"$ * *
2 !
2 )2 2 ( 2
( *
2
(
* ( *
"
( &@ -+ ""++#
3 5
, ( ( *
A ( +0 +"
"++%
!2
( * ( * * ( * ) * ) *
2 ! * ( (
( 2 * 8 " 9#
$ * ! * * ! * 2 !
,
( * ( &@A0--"++% #
+, "++- 3 5
2 * ! ( * 2 *
8 " #,0"$ * ! !(
2 >
' 2 * ) !
* ) * *
2 ! * 8 " #,0"$ ( * * *( *
! 3 5
3 5
!"
#$ %
&
'
' 2 !
3 5
4 3 5
!
( 2 * *
? ! !2 ( ($? & 34567 6 % ""
+A "++- (
* ( * *
!* (
* 2 * *
!
""
+A "++- ./ %1 !"# $%$ "&'"%"($)*$+$&"%%$,"- ( ) * %+, - ./012 2 3- ,4 56%(& '
-%.)*%+,. ./012 *2- #"%6,#78 . 9 %:;% ::<
./
56
+, .
4
!:!$: :: =
$
0
3
4 > +, . ./012
!?603%@. 2!!
@/012 A B%-*3-C :"!:: B
?603%@. @/012 , B%-C 8;:8;::
7 ?60 3%@ . 2!!
@/012 A B%- C7#;87:: %(
$
12342255
$
& 123422556
7 )8/$069& :
!;
4
=
.)*%+,. 4
4
4 )*%+,- ./012 2 &
'
#
2 - ( ( 2 8 "
".!1 &
*'' 2 ( *2 * 2
2
4
*( 0 +, +% "++-
( =($?
& 3456 6 !(
+, "++- ./ #1 & !
2 (
( $
( > !( ! 2 8 " 9#
$ ! * *
( + ( (
2
*
*
*
/ *
! 2 *
%
4 2 2 ( ! &
( &@
%9-""+ A
(
+ "+ - * * 34567 *
*( +0 +
"+"+ ./ 01 > & =($? 3456 3
2 8 "
".!1 &
( ! ! ! ""
+A "++-
*
+, "++- ./ #1
( 2
( ) ( *( +, +% "++- ./ 01 +0 +
"+"+ ./
* 8 " 9#
$ (
:
-;
*
+ 1+++ 1
.
+.
-
!*
/
! *
&
2 8(
@ (
!*
* *
B
( *
*
! *
2 !
( * 8 " #,0"$
( ( * * *( *
( *
! ( (2
5
3 5
#
+, "++- 3 5
!
( * *
3
* *
4 !* (
! 3 5
#
6
( 2 * * 2 ( !2
( 2 ! (
%
* * 2 2 2
7 !*
2
* 2 "++-
! 2
* 2(
*
4 !* 2 8 "
".!1 >!
&
8 !
42 ! 34567 *(2 * !
(
*
* , 2
* ! 2
*
! 2
34567
4 !* 3 5
2 ( !2 C
D !
* 3 5
(
* *
+
7 ((
./ %1
2 !
* 2 *
2 - (
2 2 * 2 *
( *( 0
4 !* 0 (
*
2 8 " 9#
$
4 !*
34567
( ! (
*
0 ( * 3 5
# ( !2 2
( >( !
"
2
7 >(* 3 5
& ;
( + % * <7/2=1/155> 1?5@155>"
# ! + ! (+ % *
<7/@?>?/155= 125?1554& %! !
(+ % *
<7/A5?=/155= 125?1554
- ;
(+ % *
<7/21534/155A 225?155A ! 2 )2 2 ( 2 ( ( * * *(
4 !* 6(*
3 42 5> 6(* 7* 2 !(2 6(*
! 2 2 ( 2 ( + 1+++ 1
.
+.
+ +
"
?
!* *(
0
34567 !2 ( 3 5
.
++ + 1+++ .
+.
+
'
,
' 2
*2 34567
/
*
( (
2 & 8(
2 ! & 8( 8( 2 9++ & '
8( 2 / 2
*2 * "#
*! ! 2 "+"+
/
( 2 2 "- +- "+"+
(
( * 34567
' 2 ( ( ( ( 8( 2 ! ", 2
6 (
(
*
( ( ( ** ( *2 8 82
( * * *
!
@
* ( * 2 *
! ( * * *(
(( (
! *2 # 3 5
!
34567
8
* *
4 !2 ( 34567
( 2
4 2 2 2 2 2 2 * *2 2 2 34567
* ( 2
4 (!
!2 (
!>
%
#
2 *
B2 !
( *2 ( *
C$!%&$!$D * 2 * * !
' 2 ( ( 2
(
2 * 2 * * *2 *2 *2 2 /
!(
* * ! 2 3 5
#
! !2 ( 34567 "
2/"%!!$ &( %%"/$ (%!
7& 8 5 7
'
/ *
2
2 "++-
*2 2
! 2 *2 *
2 /
(
8 "
".!1 >!
&
8 !
42 ! 34567 ! *(2 ! (
*2
* 2
( ( /
@ !* 2 -
2 *
* * ! (2 (
*( 0
( =($?
& 3456 6
( (
2 8 " 9#
$ *
(
3 5
&
!2 ( 34567
!
(( 2 2
(
2
0
6 2 2
* ( * * *(
%
3 5
& B 9 :
D; 3 - , 24 @ B !$8 3 - ;;#
>
E
-
3 5
"
# ! B 9 :
D /
3
- / >3 @/ 0>1 2F $-, 2!; ::#
+ $ ::#' >
/ G 3 - , 24 @ B !$8 3-;;# >
E
& 5
4D!
*
7
(
2?@291: 335
!2
! (
>(* D7! ( 0 , > / /- #&8
7$*&92?4@:7C 1@A/- >
/-
)
) >
5
, > - 3 0 -5
>
>
3
4
4
2
/
> 5
, > / - 0 >
)
9"
1 $89 / $!'8 :) (";&/ "
+8&($!
($ (" 8!/4
6 +
)
E
(E E2E *( /
0.
1.1 .
&
2 !( E ! ( * *2 2E
"+
# - 7 % 92?A=:2 >1? 4D!
* ! (2 ( 2 !2 ! * *2 * ! ! ( 2
( 4D!
* !;
"+
;7
2???93:
>3A "
4D!
* >(*
)
) #
1523921: 125 ( (( ! ( ( ( 2 !
6 -
# >(* D< B
- .324 + @ H&!$<7'!3--7:; 5
.B.
40
D!<
B
I
3
I I !$ I I
4 I
4
I 4
>
>
:
-
- 0 .4 , 3 0 + &!$8!' 3--77: - )
)
J
3, > B 1
3 &!$8"' 3--!E
DE 4
B7::B- !" K DEB7::B-
9
6
D355/" 7
2
E +
>
B -
B7::B- 4
E ""
' #)
7
"
-$!
152392: 3=3
4D!
* ( 2 2 &
2 8( !
* (
>(* F0
-
/
2
&1 9 * ! )
& 9155@:25 >>AD"
7 91525:25 >3D
- 7 % ( " 91522:@ 43?
- # 91522:25 >5>!" 97:*
;791522:? 3=>
"9
' 34567
( *(
0
2 2 !
"
9++ & '
' ( ( "
& ' (
",
& 5
4G!
* E
(
-
92?A=:3 =>=
( (
' ! )2 * ( ( ! * (
*
' ( & 8( 2 (
(
*
* !(
"A
@ ( 34567 * !
"
2 *
( ! &
34567
2 *( +0 +
"+"+ ./ 01 > & =($? 3456 3
"#
*(
2 > ( 8 "
".!1 &
!
4(
+, "++- &@A0--"++%
34567
( 2
' ( 2 ( 2 & =($? 3456 3
( =($?
& 3456 6 4(
! 34567
( 2 *
4 ./ %1 CD C
D )
"%
!
*
# 3 5
!
34567 2
* *
5 !2 ( 34567
2 ( 2
34567
34567
*(
0
2
& **
3 5
2 ( !2 34567
! !2 2
2 *
(
* ! ( * * *( ! 2 )2 ( 2 2 (
' * )2 ( 2 ( ( 2 (
"-
34567
2 ! * * ! * * 2 ( **H .1 @ 3 5
+, "++- (
( ! 2
* * *
**
2
7!2 (
( 2 * * *
5
! !
(
7!2 ( !) !
* (!
!2
.1 ' *(
( =($?
& 3456 6 (
! C D C
D
2
2
)2 ( 2 * 2 (
*
4 *
! *
( * * *(
3 5
!2 (
2
* !( 2 2 8
(
2
?2
* 8 "
".!1 &
2 0
8 2 ! ( 2 >!
&
8 . !
421 6(*
= *(2 2 ! 8 ! 2 * 2 *
7 (
2 >(*
! !
* 6(* 2
.1
2
* *
CD
*
* *2 *2
.1 '*( 0
(
2 - ! ( ( * 0
.1
2
"
2 (
(
*
.1 /
( 2
(((
2 & 8( "
2
"0
' *
5
*( +, +% "++- ./ 01 +0 +
"+"+ ./
!2
834567 * 8 " 9#
$ (
:
#;
* .*1 * * 2
' * * :
0;
*
9+
&( *
2
/ * !
!
(( ! *
2 & 8( (
34567
*( * ! ( 2 "++- "+"+ 2 ( ( * & > > * /*2 34567
8 -+++++$ .=( 1 *
( )* * ! (
( ! )* > !( >
4G!
* !#(
< (2??@92: >24 ! ( * ( 9"
""# & ' ! B* 8( ( "
/ & ! > ( ( /( !2 ! (
( ! 2 B* 8( H
' ! &
!( 2 H ! & /
' ( ! * > *2 2 *
** 2 ! *2 ! (* B* 8( H !
2 !
9"
(
(
8 -+++++$ .=( 1 8 ,+++++$ .B 1 ( 2 34567 * * * * 2
@
( *( 8 ,+++++$ .B 1 * 34567 4( 7(
&** *
34567 *
*(
0 2
8 ,+++++$ .B 1 *
( =($?
& 3456 6 8 ,+++++$ .B 1 * & =($? 3456 3
' 2 * * * /2
2
* * * * ( ( *
,+ + - ) )
8! ( 8 <=/ @ ($ I$6 @ ! I$6