High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/199/1988disposed of

Sardar Singh & ORS. v. Fateh Singh & ORS.

2016-12-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

!"#"$% ! &' () $*+),- (* ("$.// (# 00 11 $# 2 (#3#

/"$./#"$! * !

# * /(3./4 $*/ (# #0$* $#

!"#$% &'

#'&(")$%*+#

( # $%

(2"5 6/ +*7!

(/ $#

(3*/"( 1+*7!

(/ ( #0$* $# 88888 '&(")$ 00 11 $9* $* $# ( "$ .31 ( !$*00 .

"$#/ !$!3(( $"$*"$.# !+:/ ( '6/ #3"/ ( #0$* $901 # ;"$.* !1 "$/ !/ / 1" $ "$/ 1 $** "1 *"$

#<+ $*/ 01 "$' "$.$3117"* $*$'"$*"$.30$/ ( 7 (#"$ (6("./#/ 01 "$"$/ 0( &"# / / # & :

##1*'6 (3:"/3 $61 .

1$ ! ##"6 $*!$#"* ( "$+/ #' $* !( *

(2"5 6/ +1 ($ *!3$# 1(/ $9* $* $# #3'&" */ / 3(#' 1:/ 7 (( *"$* !"*"$./ "##3 #"$/

'# $! $6*!3& $ (6 $*( 1 7"* $! $( !(*$ !+= > = </ 7 $' $0(7 * $*+/ ( ( +$( 1"

$! !

$' 01 ! *$/ "**!3& $# #/ # & : ( $ *&"##"'1 "$ 7"* $! / ( "$ / ( & $"$ **!3& $#/ #$# $/ 1".// * 6/

3(#' 1:/ 7 (($ 3#16(& * $0"$"$:"/31;"$."$/ !$ $#/ # & / # & $?9!

$$' ( .

(* *

*&"##"$"$(* (0(7 "##3 )$ !+/ $3#1" *30$/ ( #0$* $901 "$" # '1"#// / #3"0(0 (6 / / $*#

$! #( $*!0 (! $ (6"$$ 3( / 3(#' 1:/ 3(/ (&"#"$ (0( * $*&"#!$#(3 */ *!3& $ (6 7"* $! +&3!/ 1 ## #0 (/ # 1 *1 :$! / 0(0 (6:

#$0(7 *' $! #( 1+ / # 1 * *!31*$/ 7 ' $!/ 11 $. *:

(( *'61 : 1"&"

"$ #/ #3":

#"$#"3 *"$/ 6 (<+:/ ( #/ # 1 * * "#@< ."# ( **!3& $!

((" # 0( #3&0"$(3/ $*!

$$ ' # 9 #"* "$/ '# $! / 7"* $! $( !(*3("$.!$#1"* "$

$*0#!$#1"* "$+;/ #( $3&' (#*$ 116 #0 (/ # 1 * *

$*+/ ( ( +"$7" :/ $$9( # &'1 $! / ;/ #( $3&' (#+/ 0(0 (6!31*$' '( $* * $! #( 1 3(/ (#3'&" */ #0 (&3 "$A,))>)A+ = 3# *"#$31"6 +/ .( $! #(+/ ( .

(*"$.

B/ :

#A $*@:

#'"./ $*<'"#:

$*))'"./ $*- '"#:

$*+/3#+/ #/ ( 3# *":

#C@// 5 $*"(/ 6 ))9)A= ( .

(*"$.B/ :

)+B/

3$"#/:#

#$ 3# *"D#/ (

$.3 $*// 53#$#/ .:

$ D#/ ( / 1#/ ( !& #'"./ #-'"#/:

#$ !+( #0$* $901 # "1 * 01 ! $ ( !(* / 5 $*" # (& ) > $*"= ,0 ( "$#/ 6 ()-9)<+:/ ( #/ / $*"$ 73(

&#$ 3# *""#,<'"./ #>'"#:

#B/ :

)C)+ B/

3$" A /

& #$ 3# *" # 0 ( $*"(/ 6 (@,9@= !& #->-'"./ #,'"#:

:/ ( #0 (# 1 * ** * )@@<+ (3

&$' / 1/"# &"$('(/ (

&"$./#1*/ +" +>;

$ 1#A& (1 # ("3#7 $* #+" +/ $#'

("$. 3( # $*+B"11 @+<9A+>C)9>CA+-),/ $ :;/ #( $3&' (#*$ 116:"/ / ;/ #( $3&' (# "$ / # 1 * * 7"#9 97"# / 5 $*" #

( & $"$ */ 01 "$"/ # "1 *0(*3! $( !(*/ =! (0 ( 0(+:/"!/"#( E3"( *' '(3./$( !(* #0 (/ "./3(

31 # .31 "$# $*/ 1 :1 "**:$'6/"#3("$! . / 0

.01211304 / 0

.0)5,3",56/3#+/ "$*"$.#/ 3(#' 1: ( 0 (7 (# .

"$#/ ( !(*$ !+"

"# 7"* $/ / 1 $*!&0("# *"$/ # 1 * *:

#03(!/ # *'6//

$.3 $*$(&/ 1 $*"$/ (" *(& 3# *"/ * $* $# 7 03(!/ # */ 1 $*'60 6"$.& (; ( / / (/ 01

$*#"$! / $/ 6 ( "$0## ##"$/ # "*1 $* 3(/ (#3'&" */ / 0( 7"3#161 $*& #3("$.AA '"./ #A'"#:

$*03(!/ # *1 $*'6// 53

$.3: ( !13'' * . / (*3("$.!$#1"* "$ $*/ 1 $*"$!( # *> '"./ #,'"#:

#/ &"16+" +// 53

$.3D#/ $*

&D#/ 3("$.!$#1"* "$+# 0 B/

3$"

"& "#/

&"$./:

#0( 0 ( * $*/ ."7 $/ &:

#@<@;

$ 1#) (1 # 0 B/

3$":

#0( 0 ( *// 53 $*

&+:/"!/ #$' $0(*3! *'6/ ( #0$* $901 "$"/ #3"!31*$/ ' $ * !( * $*+ /3#+ / ( "# .(## "11 .

1"6 $* 0 (7 (#"6 "$ / !$!3(( $"$*"$.# ( :31* *7 (/ (.3& $ (3*/"( 1+ '// !3$# 1*3("$./ !3(# / / ("$./ 7 01 ! *$( !(*

*!0" #/ 5 $*" #$( !(*+:/"!/: ( "$7 ($ !31 (+ " +"$ (*31 $.3 . "#(/ "(#"& +/"#3(/ #' $ 00("# * * !0" # / ( 7 $3 ( !(* / (.3& $ (/ $"! * '7 +:

# *30$/ ( *!0" #/ 5 $*" #+ ( (( * '7

( !$( + (3*/"( 1+ 1 ($ * !3$# 1 ( / ( #0$* $##3'&"#/ / !$!3(( $"$*"$.#!

$$' "$ ( ( *:"/+ &3!/1 ##*" ( $0"$"$!

$$' (& *3$1 ## $*3$"1/ ( "#.(## "11 .

1"6 $* 0 (7 (#"6 *3'+ &3 "$ A, * * ))>)A = +/ *:0 (! 1#1 $*+" + 1AA'"./ #'"#:

#+'3 $*"(/ 6 (@,9@= #/:# 11 $*& #3("$.> '"./ #)'"#:

#+ !3 116>'"./ #-'"#:

#013#D#/ ( <'"./ #< '"#:

# ( 1'6( (("$./ ( *!0" #/ # & 7 (6 *!3& $#+/ #*( :$/ $"$/"#3(13&$)/ $*"(/ 6 ())9)A= #/:/ "$/ ("

$! / 0(0 (6+/ ( ( +/ $ 3( / 0(0 (6' "$. $! #( 1 #3'&"# '/ / 3(# ' 1: / 7 ("./16 (& * $ 0"$"$ / ( !$#1"* "$+/ 1 $*& $"$ *"$*!3& $= >:

#."7 $"$1" 3 / 1 $** "1 *"$*!3& $#= = > $**!3& $= > #/:#/ (3

&"$./: ( / :$ (#/ 1 $** "1 * "$0 A $*>/ 01 "$/3#+/ 0(0 (6 / / $*#

$! #( $*/ !31*$/ 7 #1*" #$1 .

1$ ! ##"6/ ' $0(7 *("$ ="# $! $*+/ ( ( +/ # 1 * */ #("./16' $ # 9 #"* / ( "#$1"&"

"$(!1 "&"$."$/ ("

$! / $! #( 0(0 (6 $*+/ ( ( +/ #3":

#:"/"$1"&"

"$ / 7 / (*/ 1 ($ *!3$# 1(/ 0 (" # 00( "# *

/ 0 0 ('; *3'+/ #3""#/ 6 (< $*/ 1"## * ' 0 $*"$.#"$! +'3'// 0 (" #0( # $ */ "(!1 "&#:"/3 . "$./ *!3& $#+/ 7"16( 1" *30$'6/ &+( *&3!/1 ## ( (( *' ( / 3(#' 1:$16"$ (*31 $.3 . // 3(# *"*$/ 7 $!!

#"$./(3.// 7 ($ !31 ($ # ##3./'

0(5 ! * ' ( /"# 3( 7 $ 1 "& : # !$#3& * "$ 3$* (# $*"$. / !$(7 (#6+ '3 & / 7" : / "$# * 0$* ("$.30$/ "##3 #$& ("##"$! 7 '1 ("./#/ 0 (" # "$717 *+* &" 00(0("

( & $*/ & ('

!;/ 4: ( 00 11 3('6"="$."& 1"$ #"$!

# / $#/ 7 #& !

( 7"! 97 (# + "/ ( / 0 (" # / 1"# / # # 3(6 ("./ !$#"* ( "$' ( / 4: (00 11 3(' "$./ 1 #3( !

$*1 :/ :"#*&"$3$* ( ;"$./ = (!"# ( "$./ ( 7 $3 ( !(*#/31*/ 7 ' $* :$ * / ( 1 7 $"& :/ $/ 1:

0 $*"$.' ( / 4: (00 11 3("$' ( / ("

13(/ 53*.& $#'// 3(#*$( 1 ! $6/ ( & $"$ * !#

#( "# *'6 (/ ( 1 =! 0 =/"'"# $&67" :+/ 3(#' 1:#/31*/ 7 "$#"# *30$/ (" # 3($"#/ / 7 ($ !31 ( / # & ' ( * !"*"$. / !$(7 (#6 / #"& 6+ &/ 7" :/ / & (( E3"( # ' ( &" *'

!;/ 4: (00 11 3(:"/ 3(/ (*"( !"$ * !"* / !$(7 (#6 # =0 *""3#16 #0##"'1 +0( ( '16:"/"$

0 ("*#"=&$/# $*/ ( *!0" #/ =/"'" **!3& $# 0(*3! *'6/ $9* $* $# $*/ ( #0$* $901 "$"' 1# # $'

!;:"/1"' (6/ 0 (" #( (/ # & 01 ! $( !(*"$

!!(* $! :"/1 :(/ *53*"!

"$(/ 1"# / 0 (" #+/(3.// "(!3$# 1+ ( *"( ! * (' ( / !$! ($ *4: (00 11 3($@)),- 00 1# $*#*"#0# * * 49,

),:8 '&(" 410 $%*+# (0.01;/ <1

=1<

(0.0 .9

=1<