High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2046/1988allowed

(O&M)Labh Singh And ANR v. Sukhdev Singh And ORS

2019-03-25Mr. Justice Amit Rawal9 pages

!" #$% $&

'& #()$%**+ , - ./'0,

&&&1122 3 4 '4567'0+66- 40.& , &&& 16 &

'& !%8$%*%+ , - ./'0 &&&1122 3 4

990 '0, &&& 16 ! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

&&'&2:2"67"

1122/&

& &'&"67"

16& '& #()$%**&

&; <6 '0"67"

16&="("!,8 '& #()$%**&

& <1 ;4 "67"

16&)+- '& !%8$%*%& >>>>> +*,&-( 6 < 22 61 : 042 '6 112 / 0 & #() $%** 6 !%8 $%*% << ?42:6 7276&

'& #()$%** 0472'4&)!@ $%*!26A./'0, 3 4'4567'0, B + 226 A'4 &$B-": 12 7 / 66

62 / 9 : 1 6 :22 4 6 41426 06 66$)&#(&$%8$72 '4&$*=$%8$2202"422,76/C94066 <2041 C&

'& !%8$%*% 4672'4 &=#$%*(26A 990 '0, 3 4./'0, B+

6A'4& B-": /1 21 1466D22 4?": D2266 &$ &$%)% 1466/C12666&$!26/7266 D2266$ &#=&$%*=1 1466/C66&=:46/ 4

466/C414 4< 4206 24 74 12&11226/C66:26<6& 6 '& #()$%** 04'4&$ :42676 69466112"&&"

'& !%8$%*%6" " /05 < ' & #()$%**&

2./'06 <;4 ":6:6

4?"4640'4567'0"5'0" 990

'0"9< '0 4?"64 '02 '0 '0"; 2;4 : '06 '0

4?2<062 C20:66&$(68 9: 126?42 /C2200 6 66$)&#(&$%8$& :220626: 261 C&

4?66/4<1 20466<"

12./'0666&$(68?4 6 /C

. / ": <;4 62 426& ?4 12 1 : 96/C661 < C62 6C/66 $)&#(&$%8$E46/C 4?& 6& 6=26:

<66<6 ./'0666&$(68: 4?"/4 :9 4 1 C/01 CC 6 / 270 1 2C 2 ( C & : <2C 2< 6 4?" / " 4 6 6 66 $)&#(&$%8$&/9?44/0/

6/C2:2<: 25& 2 4 " 1 12" <6 22:04 @ A

" # $

" # (

)**# ! "

# + !,

2"411 <61260"/ 40 6 E& $E 10 106E& E&

40<C D@ 4 /E'0&C: 41 02 661 160 /2E& ="46 4?: :24 64 ;42";42 14614"1 C <67276

41 4?6" ": 24 66 64 /C260 4?426E46 21 C :4C202C/C7 250/92< 6 /C66&112".: 40264 1 C : 2" /4 6<6 4 /C 112C0 7 2!*.<&

&&'&2:2"2 64211 0/2 11224/<62<24: 1 46 < 21 C"1 2$$#.< $ C " 4" 2 !* :426 112C& 2 ?4 6 5:260 <66 :66":6C / 204" 461 262206<2C 2<66206C/" 4"60.: 11224 6<04"2C 0 462< :22C1 7 & : 2 4/<6 '4 & " / 1 1466D22"/466220C<2C2< 6 66$)&#(&$%8$"4"6/::22C116 /1 <6C2:&'4& : 6/C< 460"/4 9460< 4 : 6 *&#!&$%*8"

: '4& (&#8&$%*8"/4/ 4/27: 1 6522C CF 6 C6&

& ; <6 '0" 2 6 42

16&="("!684/<660

76/C .: /C112C01 7 2!* .<

7:61226/2

6C< 2?4?45:2607C7/ 0 46 1 7 2$$#& /110 120/C202 .024 :6<66 1 1 7 2!*& 24/<676 &112&(!!*@ #$$"4 76 6 66#(&#*& #$$"22:6202

16&$68// 40 6/D22 66$!&$$& ##%::7 1 1466'4& "/4< :40/ 22676112&$#%(!@ #$$":: 6 6 / 6 : < & 2 4/<6 <611222:0202 1 7:/6 41<D22:/6661 1 607:

2:266:/CG/2'41 <4 0123 % 04002501 % 0 - !!565 .7 !! 4/<401 / 206 6 4 46 1 60406 <<9 4:426 42209460<"/4 0 61 64 1 /646 6 42! "40 202 1 7/22:6// 40 6/42C 694621 :426751 /4 : D22:04 & . 642 1 66<60 .: 04'4&$:42676 <1419460<66 6/C4 /2:'4 & & 7 62 642 1 "11 6

11 /5" 64 /2:67:22:0 '4/2H4.: 6 </C4 @ A$- D 7: 9460< 6 6 .: 2604 1 C/ 2"1 7 2$$# !*.< :426112C I - D 9460<66 6'4& 260D22$%)%1 1466/C12/ 7264/2 I =- D 12/1 <656 6/C1 1460D226126 6 $)&#(&$%8$I :426/0E 1 7 2$$#6!*.<&< 64 @ 2$$#

C1 E2466 <91 C 0 :27C D E24 /< 5: 12 2!*

/ C

62 C D 04 46 126<121 42 <61 7"

76 2!*1122C 14 1 /0C 62 : 04 4& .: 112":2412606 2 4 : 0 64 6 1 C"264 26/ 2F1 C& 2$$#1 761 6 $ C :E24 <9<2C/<5:

8 12&662C"1 C6 4?: 2 6727641< <<< 6" " 2<:426/=C /4$ C & E?4 : 426C $%*( :426/:2<&< 6 4?66% <1 204&4162C6<" "/64 06 2206 2C6/ & :4267/ 666//212 6C< 2 /26 $%8$:642C 66 74 66 : 5:260&4 0 4 0"64< 76/ 40 6/266 :7 66 74 6&4 4<"12:4267

<622476 4 6/C 4? 74 / & 01 2<0 01 C 0E1 1460D22:4620 46566 &:<6 <9460<66 6724& 4 "4 0/44/4 24F0 6"1 42 2C:'4& "

60: 0 64 1 C 2:/ 40 .: &?4E4D22 :4 202 C 1 5 6 4 C42642202C1 76"/4<2 /1 1466:06 6/4& 1< &?4 /

74 +9153400 3: 15 -+ ;

#/-: :2 01 7.< ":261 0 0/ /462:2<E10 46: 2 16&66726/2C 4 76 6 < : 1 < <69460<& < 04<

&; <6 '0 &$#%(!@ #$$50 22 6 &(!!*@ #$$": /C202 1 7 16&$687 // 40 6/D22 ##%":6 206C&:426/1 1 64 27 42264 $# 0123% 0$0 00 < 64 @ -) .!

' / 0 '" %

! *

! "# $ %&&' '

(%)*

1 2 # *

" '

/3%4

' "

" !

& ' !*

/ !

%/ '

&1 & /!

& /!

2 3%/ ! & /

'%/ '

! ! % / '

'!5

23!* !* & %!/

/ !

/ '!% "

4 *!

/ / '

, 1 42<"<7:<126< 202 1 7 16&$682C 6946 042 '6112/4:426 C2 0C / 62 D22 ##%/ 60<27/202

1 7& 6 66#(&#*& #$$22:0<// 40

6<66" <6"E& 41<C <6/ 7"9460< 66 .: 6<0'4&$/C22:0 1120 462<:22C22461 7 & < /C@6&9460<66 24

6&'4&$6 6& 7: <6 60" 9460< 6 6 4 /2:'4& :4261206 221 7 0 <641 C& 112 22:6/C: 0'4/2H4.: 74 1122"12'4&$666'4& &

1/- +*,&

301 ()<='

,1:10>5 ?0

@0?

,1:1 :9"

@0?