← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13074/1999dismissed

J.P.Jindal v. Uco Bank And Others

2025-05-06Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages



       CWP-13074-1999 (O&M) 

! "

"!

J.P. JINDAL 

 UCO BANK AND OTHERS   #  $%#  &' &  ( )))))     

 ! " #     $  ! " #    %%%%% ' &  (* + ,-.

    &  # ' ()  ( #

  *+,---     .   (  /0  1     ( #

  ( 

  # ( #&   

(  #  #        ! **+--2   (   &   # * 4

5

 # # "

      !  6 ' #  7-   #   

 --2 0##" .

8889"  # "

" (

)     & 

*       

(   !" "    9 "

    !       #

 " (  "   #      &  (     " "    & "

 ! ##" 

(  #    #     #   &" ( ( 

  

   "  & " #      #       # (    "#" "  " #"  "

" "!  "  8   (  & ! "       

             #   #  &

  1 :   !#  "  " ( #! " ;     ! #3 0##"#  "

   ! #" "&

'  3 0##"&  " (  :   ;"

) " #

""

 #

"

!  "

#   1 8"

 !#    "

 &  "

#    # 

" " # ": # "

 '#   ! <,--, = "

  

 

  

        

  

    

 

7  

       !   "



#    $   %

 &

   '

%

 ( )   *

     '%

 

"

$ $ + %   

 ,

   !   "

 '

 %

     -

      $ " $   %



 '

 %



   . 

 

 /   $  /0/  1/2  *13 

 /## //45   /16  /  

  7 7 9    ""  

 &  #    "

   ' #  & (           &"  & ( ! > "    ## "4

5

#

 "

 

    (     &

 # " #9(5

 + 9 #

  "

  !    

  # #    &     (   (  !   (    

   --2   &!    

  # & 



   ** ,  (     !  5

 #   6 '  & ! ( 6 " ( & " (7--,& ! 

(  < #  50 6 ' 0##"   /$"  ? 1 (   

+ -@< #   

(  "     8 & "

!      & ((    ( #     "" "     #      #   3 0##"   ##

   " #  &  #"   ; " (  ( : ( #  (  ! (     = "

  & 

5 "  

  



 

#5     

 

 

  

 $



 &     " 

  #5 %

2   $  $

  89

:

% #5 %

 ;  < 8

 9    =-,    >



 

   ! 



      

  

    "  ? 

    $  $

  8 9

 :

% #5 %

 ;  

 9  =-,    

5 "  

 

     $







"     

 2    $  $

  8(9

:

%#5%

 ;  

 9    =-,     (  /  @) @  $ 

      

#5 "       



   !



 $  & 

,          !

#5

$  5   < "

     &

 #

    #"

  "   (      )

 &

  " (: )

&"

 " # "  " #   " # 

 > "     

  & (           # "  "

    (   #      &   & ""      "

    &   ( #     #      #  # "      # 

 

"  "   )

0##" "

 & "

 &"&     #   &  &     &&  &  "

 (  "

   &     "

   #  5   6

  # !(

   " (  #    "#" # "

    )

 0##"      ! (   (  ""     "

   &  ' #    ! # 

 # "

  &  =            "

    &  "#  "    #  "  #" #    #    "

  # &"  "      ##" #568: ! = " # )

 

  A%A+A==,

/%;



 3  6   3 #  %

 )>*@%;       2 )   %

 "



   

<

  

 

 $ " $ ;!

" * ;B3C

;!3C  

B B = "   # 5  8 # 

 # 

"  ! "< *

B*  B ="   #   5 (  # C  7

B7  B = "  # "   ;5 D.. /14 +

B+  5   #     #  ;" ; 5 D.. /1 4 ,

B,  5  #   *2-- #9:4 <

B<  5  #   <2-- #9:4 @

B@  5   # D6 "  *2  5 (    -2--  ( ( ;5 # ;5 D../14 2

B2  5   #    7- -#  < , ;?  ; -

B-  5   # 3  0##"  530 5 --;2-,  @-  B  5   #  "     2--;5 D.. /14  B  5   # 5   6 ' 4 *-2-- * B*  5  #   -2-- #  ; D

((E ' 7 B7  5   #! #"   *-- % 

  $

   

/%;2      5

  

  "



   

 

!

  !

+A==,

     

 "

    /%;  /%; $

@

 / 



  5

  

     

;  

;  



 ?



A==,



   % A==,

     





 

;B3C ;B3C 

  

 



 /

  

 



#> 

  

    %



 

#>

   

     2  %





  

!

   !

A(A ==, % A(A ==,

/A;0       $  

          

 

    /* +,-   

/ ?  1/1/D4?1/

  

  *% ;B3C  " 

   $    $" 







  E

       $   7 @ 8   &( ""    "

      ' #    #   "   # " (  ( "     ##"&" "

"

! "&   ! !:&      6 ' # ! (" ( ( (   2 E !  (    "

  #        &      3  0##"   &  (      5

#  6 '  )

0##" 

2 "#"  '  #  >"          

(    "

    )

 0##" "#" "

  # ( &  "

   $  .   (   "   # &  "  "#  "  3 0##"& "  (;! # (   " #"

  &"& )  &  6 " (  "

(     : 5

 "

   "

 &   #  

&  & 

 

6 ' & #    ! ! #  "     

&  8      "   

&      ! ( "  9:4:! #"  #& (  # 9: 4  #

  "

        # "

 !      #  

> D  6 '       ! # &" 

("

 # )

& !    (8   

# &   # "

#"  ( #        &"    ( #"  #  

  '  " "

 &   #  

&     "

"    ; "

  #

 : !  # )

    AF 

 "

$ > " $

       "

    

        "

     $

/3

C

  # 

    

  

   

  

 

  >



 

-   

 

6 3     

 / 3 /%;9

     

 

  

'

 %



  0$ 

"   

  )  

 " 

        "    

 "

 

        3

>    F 

         

   " 

    

'

3  





   >  "

3@ 8 /%;9$  G %





   ==A 

 '

 3 



 



  

 30/ /:3 ;*66)422

> 

      

   



 

  

      

      

  

 " 

   

    

# 3$  3 G 3      





 

   " 

      

   " 

 #  3

     "



 

    

      2 "?   

 



 

30/ /:3  ;*66 )42 2    

  

         3 @        '

 %

    





 

 3 @  8 /%;9           



 A,A===A

    "

 





   (A-+  





 

    

 !   

     

      5



     

  "    "

/%;   

'

 %



     

  

 

 2 /%;  

5

 "  

   



 

       

#5  



#5

 #5 

     ?



    ):*@#*2>%*#*1

    $ 

"

   

):*@#*2>%*#*1 

 5

   



    30/ /:3  ;*66 )42 2 

 ):*@# *2>%* #*1

 #5   



 3 @  8 /%;9

 "?      

G %

 

 

'

3





$ " $  

   /%;

 $

 $ 5 "



 

 "





  ):*@# *2>%* #*1   &32 





  

 

 

 

     "

    

    ?   

 



5 

5   $  

 "  

     F 

"

$



5

"

"

   )% /%;  



  "



3 

  " " $

3@)@ 

/%;   

   

30//:3 ;*66)42



   - 8   (          #        (   #  &  "&# & (   # = (

&     # "  ! (#         "    

(    #

  "

   "   #   # 3 0##"  "      !&    '     "

          ! 

  #  ( # &     & "

 ! ##"&    #

(     (         #  

 # 5

#  6 ' #    ##! #  '

 $!  5#  (  50 6 '  2**+ &       !

   6 '    5   +--,"   = "    &"#  5F .F":"  (# = " ( # "   & *,--<   &!    !       )    5F 

 &       D !  --2 : #     #      &  6 '    *@+* #   & (# # 

  :  #     # !  

 # (  :  & #  "  

  &#*,**

* 9 "  &  ""

 #

        6 ': ! = " # ##!    ( 2      "



     A0A0==. 2     "5       (0A0==+ $

         !



  

     "5 : 

    

     

! 

  





     &

$

  

! 

 

 

        

   



       "

)F     

       

  

  ==.   

 

   EC )F  

   - ,A-   .00==. # )F  

   =-A-   .00==. 6    

  =- A=0C

 .00==. +2

"5     

    

  

    

 

=

# /

 0@  *

-0A(0AA 2    



       

)   "  %   0A+0A    

    

    !  

7    

      

 

"5<  " 

) $   >



 $   

     

   

  =-0C

"5 

)   "  % 2    

      $    " =-.++   0A 0A 2 



    " $        

 )    "   % 

0A+0A

  

  

 !C  

 "     "

  

   " 0     

 " 

       D    (  !  > ( " * 8 !   

 5

   # # 

"!  !( 

( "

   (&   &   7 8  # 

 # "

 6 '  "  (  # " ( #"

"      (     (    #

      "

 ;   (   >"  ;"  ';# "   " &         6 "        ' " "

 ("

   #  : &#

&  ( "  (&(    

( "" #   "  #    #  6 ' &  "

" ( &      " (  &  !   :

( )

0##" ""

  # "  

+     !  (   "

  # (    " (  (  !   

  & 

5   "  

    



 

#5       

  

   

 $

   &     " 

  #5 %

 2     $  $

   89

 :

% #*1 %

 ;  8

 9  =-,  

&6;*%E)2H)%4; >



 

   ! 



      

  

   "  ? 

   $  $

   8 9 %F :

% #*1 %

 ;   8

 9    =-,  

&6;*%)2H)%4; 2 

5 "  

 

   $







"         

  2     $  $

  8(9

 :

% #*1 %

 ;  

 9  =-,  

&6;*% )2H)%4; ( 2  /  @) @  $ 

      

 #5  "         

 

     !

 

  $    &              !

 #5

 $

 5  

&6;*%(E)2H)%4;

, + 8  !  #    !    #

 " ( ! (  &     !"   #

)

 &

#

             

  #  ( &   (  : "

  "

!  ()       ( 6 " ##"  &!  & ! "    ((   ##"   G  ##"    "     # &  "    #  "  3  0##"& "  (;! # (  " #"

       & 8 & "#" "      # "  "" !   "(   ; ##"# ! #"  "



"  ##" #  6 " (   !##    = #  )    #" (    & "    "

    8 &     3   (  "

# "

    #  +@, " &   # $ "  #  5 

    "

"           ( #    # " ( #

&  (   &  

& &  ## 

>D 6 ' 506 ' ,

 &  "  '"   # "

&   #

&    (;  ' "

# 9:4  > &   ! # "

&   #  #  "  (    !  (#

  " # (8&  "

< "

 #" 

;

& " "

 # &   (   #!  #   9   )

 "

 "  "

"!  #     "

 !   "   8 &   "

      "

  "  "   #   = "   "    #(   6 'H   :    "#" " "

    "  !&&'    (

  #  "  & ( " &"

 !##"  

( 

   "  & " #      

( &"  

 

   :#  (  &      < :     # &     # "

" (     9( 5

    = " #   &  # > "

!&

 "**< #5    #8   5

 #     "  ! "  " 

( "

" (          "

  #   # 

)

0##" 8   #"  ""   

"  #  6 '&  #!( #" " !  (      ##   "   &!  #"

   (

   (

  !     !  

"   (  #

 ""! #  ##"  !        #  &   #(  6 'H   

 =   " (   !   #"  (    # "   : )

0##"

@ ! (   " ( ! (          ! " ( (  ! " 5

#  = " ! !   # " #    "

  

    )

 0##"         "

      &        :  !

 #

  "

 ! "   :  "

(          "

   &         (      9(5

&     &   #    #     @ 8    &      " '     "  # > " !&  "

  "

  (  = & 

   "'"

" " #

 (    " ( !8  #" #     "   

       "

  "' (    2

      "   #    "

  #     " # 

> "  (" &  )

0##"    "

"

  

 # ( "

  )

0##"          (    

   =    "

 '#  (  #&"&   ##" #568 :

 "

  &" & ( ""&

)

   ( "     ##"  # 

2  &

=  # "

 & )

 (  9 "      "

 " #     > "  (

 "  "     " # 

 > "    ""

 #   ""   "    "

    ! " &  #       " #

! " ( #" " #  "

 # 

  #  ( )

  &  &   (   

 "" #  "  "

     " (   -  # "

  #     

  "

"

 !  "

     ##! #     

 !   :  #   #27--2"#" 

= "   &" .F9 ((     "

= "&  # #   & ( "

" ( = " "      & & &  #  ! (  #    "# ""

"

 (  (!       "

    27--2= " #  

  " '  

 & ("

 ### = " # "  &#=*,--<:5F #       # D !  --2 9 "    &    :   '#   (    *

      ="

 &   6 '    ##" &    &= "  # ' ( #

.F

- "&"& "#    

 " &  "

  #"8 & "  "    0 &    **8"

     #    &

(  &          : " #  #  # #    "

  ""

 " &  "/1  &  "    # 

  " &" ! 

5F" 0"  --2  " 5F #&    D ! --2    &  "    # 

 *      )  "& #     ' (  #    #6 '

  .F"9 " 8#           " #    :     

   "

      (   !    ## # 

"

  :&  ""

( 6  *    ( "  " /1  # 

       #  +' &  (.

! "

"!    4 /  E ' (;

 

I;D  E    I;D