High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14083/2000disposed of

M/S L.G. Hotels Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2017-07-03Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary14 pages

! "

#"$ % "&'" () !"#$ %&'()!*+,-.) "/)+0-%1"( %&'()!*+,-.) "#)%1!""-% " "(*"+&,-#, "')" "-+$" ,- -# " ,"&

"/)+0-%1"(2 .' )"' ))"' ' $" !/ ' ' 0$)"/'# )'1"1$1' '$"&)"

"$ "')"$2!'')" )$2 !!)&")"$"'!)-,3456 ')$"' !$"/ 2/' 21 # /'$+, " '+$ , # "/" 335, " ' )$") 2$ /"" ""6)) "'/ $ # )) 335.')"2 "

"!)"! .$"!27" "!6 869, "&' ''/ )"!1)/" 2 " ' #"!, $" % ' -0$ -, 3 8 "'",:'-:91 $ 5533 ,

+/ 0$" ' " )$2 )$"), ! &, " $ "" )$2 !)$2 %" ,'+$ ;271"

2&')"$"%4- '-,'1#",1'$ "/'!27# &, $"%5 '- 1$ 53336"! %- '-,1"$ 2$2&' -0$ "8 "'",:' ":9, 1'$"&)" 1&" "!' $ $"%5 '-< "'!=)", 5

1 )$2 " " & ' // #"$ 0$ "" $ ' )")'"& " " "$ '/"' 6 ' =1'' "1"),'"1! 5533 1 .'$/''1")1

, '1#",'$"& $"'")"/ 4

,1' $/ '-# " ,"&.'1")1 & )

,/#/ 2"&')"'" ")"1')" =1+ "!' ""1' "'))")"$'"& ' #"!) !27# & =)$ &)" "2 &1' )" '" !' "!' ") )& '""

61$2!'')"' "1") 1'1" & 1'''20$","'"'1 '")"&,1' '1"))$2 " /- # "!'") &'1") 2&'%,")" 1

,1''1"72&'%

, "

& /6 ')"/"2&'$" +

",'!=)"!$')""') '")" 2&'%! &# " / '1"),'! "!)/1''$'" " &,1'"'!=!$!

)"/"2&'$"13 & "!' ") )& '""?"!' $ $"%5 -, '&1/"2&'$", & &1"# 2 "

$! 1"2&' "')"'#/=)",' 1"12& !,',"#2

"$ "')" $"'"$2!''" 1"$!2" , 1''1'2&')" :8$)"9,1''1$/'2' /,'$/' !&' "'/'"&!'"""/"/' "!&/"2&'$",1'"1' 0$0$/'"2&'%1+/'2 1'"&"!&1/"2&'$",', ')" $ "! 5333,1"$

1 " & 2& ')" ! ( ""/ 7$/! :2 ' %$)"! $"

8 9% ,1$2!''"!&/"2& '$" 4

'1") 2&"<%/'1 =2&' )

,',&)" $20$'"2"2 $')"$"/ 1'')"/"!& 4

"$ "')" $"'"$2!'' 0$ $'%$""$2& 1'' 1" "!0$"10$" &6 &!

)" 1'' 1' 21 ' " $20$ $"% '-.' ")$/'2' /') "!' 12& !,1''7/' ')",1" "!'0$ ".' 1" 5 ;''"', "$ "'%$2!' '1"0$2&')" !)"# %- '-< "')" "$! 1"2& ' "=)","!&1/"2&'$" :8$)"9' )/ '1"),'$"/" )" =1+')"'" " /")" "!

' "",1''12) 1')" '" !' "!' ") )& '"")2&'$"

"!&0$""- "'")"1 2&"<%/'

/1')& "")2&'$",'!1 ) 2&'!)$'"&

" '"!' /"2&'$"1 2"#2&'$"1" ''")"'$ 2)" "2 &1')" '" !'.'!1) =)$ &- "') '" , ')" "!','&1/"2&'$"' ")"1) "! "$2&'$", $,'! ")/'1"'=)",','! 12& !""'/" &,

&1" # 2 ")/'1" ") '")",' 1"1$1' &

"$ "'") $"'"$2!') "!2 ')1!" " &2$, )"/"'/ $)"!, !'' 20$"6' ')"

#'/ $)"!1/".'" 1 2&')"2$'",',2)")" &$ # 7/''"20$""1" "!' 0$.')" '!

" "$ "')")"$'))"

2+ 3 ",1''")$,"$"@ $ '- 5533

$ 5 '- 5333 %& $"'")"//" 4

2&'$" 5

()" 2&')"

' "1") ()""72&'

!)$'"& -1"$2&' "

.')"$"/1''"!& 4

1)"#

( #)"# %- '-"")"$ '"$" A3 )!-1 4-,0-% 40-.0 "% "4"!1 +0"(( ') #"1).' "' !+1"$" 1')" 1&" "!' ')$2 ' " 1"!1'')", '")"/ "'0$ ' '

5 ) "#'1'"' "' 2 )$2 ' 2 " ' !!! ' -0$ 8-!!9-,3 ,'1" ' 2 ! 1' )" 1 &" "! $'

!!!

6!)$/')" 1&" " "" ' , ' )" $"/ 1'' & ")"/2+)$"$ ' " & 2& "" $" ' 2 = $BC ." # /)'$1''" "

'7$/! $"0$'/& , "')"# 2

" $/ ' , ' !" 1 " "" 2 '" 2& $<';#11' "0$'/ $"

%5 '-, "')" &"1# 2 "$ ""/ 27$"% 4- '-, 1'"'"1' ' $"%5 '- 0$', "' 2$2&')")""2 $"'-.'!"1"2&'$<' :2 '%$)"!$" !"#

$% 8

9 %4

' "/') "2&')" "/"/ "1"/ $ $ !$, :2 '%$)"!$")''$" &")"' )"#"1"' /$/ %589 '-,1''

) $!2/$$.'"1) "/!'/, 12&:2 '%$)"!$"%%

3358 9%

.')")"#$ 2"'

"$ "!' "# '/'$":"",$' ")"$ 2"$1'' /$/ %589 '-( #)" "!$<'7$/! :2 ' %$)"!$" !& 8$)"9"="2 1 A .'"# ) "/"/"1"/ $ $!$" $ "61 )") 1 ' ' $" " &'/$"&)"#1'') $!2/$$-$ ' / $".' /$/!) &$'"!# "

/ # .' " )"!"& "$ "$'' ' / !$ 2 $'1"$2&' / $" .' 0$ 1' !& 2 $)) ' 2 ,2$ 1'' 2 D%$ '$ 2 "$ '"! E$ D F$/ " , D2$ 1" !$ 2 "$ 1' ! !/ ')$")1'' 2''!D8%

/'G & #H#/ ?(4 9.' #11""'( )

$ ** + 8-6(33 % 9 6"(G+' !;"#& .")"!!";"8-6(3% 9 12"#'$"!$#'/" )"""! '!/ )"#2 '" 1 )"# / "$$" " '! 1'' ' )"# 2 ")"!1' .'&" $$") / # $ $" ' /$ ")" ' ")"/)"#'$" & ")"' 1 / 6 )"#

1!$$27'2$ )" 1, "' / $"!,! &"") , !"&I%('2'-/"6$" #<) %"# 8

849%449B J.' / # $ !$ 2 $)) 2& 7$ ")"#)" /$/ %589 ) $!2/$$.'") ""/ !'/,1"!'': 8$)"9 6 7$': 8$)"9, ' )" 1

$"'""''#'!)""$ "! "# /'$":""%$'#12 " 1'' /$/ %5896 '#1 )1$ !'2#"2& & $89 "89 ')"#%5 89,2$ 2&)""2)"%!#" 2' / # 4 == == == 5 .') " /)) 2 & '" )") " &$)2 .' * ''!2 $" 8$)"9 1 "" 533!$')""'!!2&'3

-6 ' / $"/#1 '1'"' "$"%589 0$','""1'&$ '# 2&) &)"#/ ".' ' / $" ) &)"# ")"#"2&"" & " 7$ " & '1 ' '" )" 1 2= $''") "

)"#/&'")" !.'!=!:$ $"!!/"#2:'/' /'2&'?$ <' '"/'$"')) ' $ ' .'#1=)""!'': 8$)"97$':8$)"9,""

3 #""$ 1' ' =)" -% $: 8$)"9;= ":8$)"9

"!C .' F$/! ' $ <' :2 ' %$)"!$" !& 8$)"91 12& #<' '$"

5 +

.'!1 $)' 2&:2 '%$)"!$" & 8$)"9 .' "# 2 "!'7$/! '/'$""' $ '-

$ 5 '- 3

8#+/$"/&)"#9 ' /'/'$"

' 6"!&/"

-1"2&' "

/'$"

$ 5 '-))"$& 27$ 4- '- 1/" ;27$ 4-1"

?"' $ 5 '-

6 ' / ' " 0$ )"/, #<' '$")'# ')" !' $"/1'''"1"!&/"2&'$"= $, ' "$"%5 '-12&')" &",',' $"% 5 '-'"

)"/1"0$'.'%' /' "7$/! '$"2 ":2 '%$)"!$"%) ' "7$/!2&:2 '%$)"!$"'2 ""!&

1 /" 2& ' $" ' " "$ /, 1'" ' /"# ' 1"1''&1")"# /27 $"%4- '-,

&")")""2 "

$ $"%5 '- "!

,1' $"% '-1$,' "&2 ) .'#<' '$"1' /' $"

%5 '-#7$/!

,)"!' 1" 27$"%4- '-$20$ & '%$ $"%5 '-' /'

''/'$"1""" 1/ / 27$"

%4- '-$ $"%5 -1'' "0$'/ $"%5 -,#' $"% '- ),'$ '# '!"$'<$ /')"&2!$

&#/$ ' $" &" &/ $) $<'7$/! :2 '%$)"!$" !& 8$)"9,"" '#<'7$/! ' $"1$)' ( #)" "! & 8$)"9, ="2 1 A .' # <' ' )" ' 1 ' " ! %$" (, 1'' " &')"#$#<''

1.' '$ <' ! %$" ( ' ' ' /$/ %589 "$!2/$$,'! )"2"''1$ 2

+)/1'' / #.' '-)) %'' "

$ ' " '$ " & ""$, $'

/ 1$ 2 ' ' " ")" !)""22&!%$" ('$!2/$$ /$/ %5 ' / $" 1 "$' $,1$ '#2&) & )"#/ ",' ")"#" 2&"" &7$?$"'"!",' -)) % ) " ""$;""1''$/"#)"7$ '"/' '()61$ 2) ! ' / )") ' )"& '$ $

" " ' !+ ' $" % !) $ 2'# $ ' '% ,' ;"" ' # <'

"$ ' 1"//!)

" # '$/' ' -1" 1 & )

5'!)&2 )'()'#<' ;"""$+1 &' ",1'' $"1$ '#"$ '"0$ )/, ' -)) % 1$ '# ' "0$)"/,"$ /' ()"#/!)'!"+ "$""'! ' "' '" " ' ' "

2$)' !" &2&#"$ )"#$ # <'K ""$ )"7$ ;"""/"!1'' ' /' $" ' !)$/

F$/!0$ &!'-)) C .'$1 $"'""2&#<' ' $"

,- 8 9 ((8# 9 56' $"% '-1 $ ,1''1 12& $"%5 '- 4 3 3 1 ' // '0$6"!&1/" .'1") 1 ) 4 , 1' / ' $"

%5 '-"/'")'""' 27 2&')"'" "

"/))"$& '"/- ""7 '275 , $"

%5 '-1$ - "= $/')" & "!' "!&1/"'1")1 ) , $"%5 '-1 $22& ' )" &", ', 0$' - 0$, # ' $"% '-1 "'# ) ( #)" '7$/!="2 1 A3 -! &,')",'"!

""1 /"2&'$" 3 3 2&')" " "1''"!)" 4 .'$, " = $/ ' )" 21 ' " , ' ! " $ $"%5 '-1$) .' '#/2$

1, '$, " & 2& ! 0$ &,'1") 1' $$"%5 ' - 8-=$" 9, 0$' -

0$, $"% -' 2"'# )-& 0$ )"/+)$"$' " ' 2 .

4 6

, /

$ 8 9((8# 9 ,/$"! "

"$! 10$'2/2& !6' ,' $ $"% '-1 5

$"%5 '-1$

2&#+/$"/&)"#$"% '-5

31 ' //'0$1''"!&1 /"5

3; , "$"%5 '- 10$'.')"'"1"/# 2"& 27, 1''1"21'!' "!' - "

'27$"%4- '-, $"

%5 '-1$ .') "2&'% '", ' ' $" % 5 ' - 1 1' !, " "!' ") )& '"") 2&'$"0$'/ $"%5 '-,1"7 1' 1/" "7$/! '$" & 8$)"9,0$)"/1"0$' 5 %! "1'#1+2&#<' '$"

,44 4 ' "$ 1"' ')",' &)2 $''1"$ 2&' "2&')" 1&",= $/')"

&/"2&'$".'" #'#2)"3 '7$/!.') "2& "$ "'%'' "$2&'$"'2!) 1',)" '" !'"1:)" "2 &: !6!!$!)2 !,'")"11"1$2&' "-"/$!"!#-' 2&:2 '%$)"! $" 12&'$"' "7$/!,)" "& 2+$"'-2=2&'$"2&" 1"/'$6'',# "'7$/! ' $", &1"# 2 "$! 1",2$ $ 1.'1"'#/2$ "')" 1 &",'!

"#20$'" " 0$)"/ ) .'0$'/ ' " &1 2"'% """&/$& "'=" "0$ , / &)"!2 3 .'

8(!"F9 # F$/ ''")+/ " H ''"()"2 H