High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2331/1988dismissed

(O&M) Rasala v. Sultan

2024-03-07Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal4 pages

D !"#!$%&%"'()*+)+),+

- .++

-- / - +++ ( 0-

+ -1

2!&!' (

2+++/%23456"$ !#"2 7!88!99' &+

2+6!!'+725:;456"$ ! #"22!&8"'5!' "&+,4444<4*444,4<44<*'5<+ ====== -1

-4+ -

+ ' 7%& !>?92 !$"'5 88!94 7! 5!#!'5' &&%9& 7! $"22!$ '!&&"#;?5>@!' '55!$2!!8&&!5AB 7! %2& 88!99 !"?2 4 :7%$7%' ?2'47&2!6!2&!5 7!;?5>@!' '55!$2!!8&&!5AB 7! 2%9 "?2 +7!82 B&799A!2!#!22!5 "AB 7!%2& ?&%' 7!&?% + + '"25!2 "$"@82!7!'5 7!%&&?!&%'6"96!5%' 7!82!&!' $&!4 7!2!9!6' #$ &4%'A2%!#42!2!C?%2!5 "A!'" %$!5+7!89%' %###%9!5 &?% #"2>2' "#5!$2!!"#5!$92 %"''58"&&!&&%"'$9%@%'> 7 7!&?% 82"8!2 B7&$"@! " 7!%2&72!%' 7!82 % %"'82"$!!5%'>&:7%$72!&?9 !5 %'%'& 2?@!' "#82 % %"'"'+)+*%&&?!5AB&&%& ' "99!$ "2 %2&

25!+7!5!#!'5' :7%9!$"' !& %'> 7!&?% $9%@!5 7 7!&?% 82"8!2 B $''" A!82 % %"'!5'5 7!%'& 2?@!' "#82 % %"'7&A!!'"A %'!5 7!%2A$3+7! 2%9"?2 5!$%5!599%&&?!&%'#6"?2"# 7!89%' %##4 7":!6!245%&@%&&!5 7!&?% "' 7!>2"?'5 7 % :&#%9!5A!B"'5 7!8!2%"5 "#B!2&#2"@ 7!5 !"#%&&?'$!"# 7!%'& 2?@!' "# 7!82 % %"'+ + ' 7!#%2& 88!94 7! %2& 88!99 !"?2 7&7!95 7 7!

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

4 7!8!2%"5"#9%@% %"' :%99A!>%' "2?':7!' 7!5!#!'5' $9%@!556!2&!8"&&!&&%"'+ *+ 7%&"?2 7&$"'&%5!2!5 7!&?A@%&&%"'"# 7!9!2'!5$"?'&!9 2!82!&!' %'> 7!82 %!&+ "2 7!&3!"#$92% B2 %$9!<"# 7!-%@% %"' $ 4<%&!D 2$ !57!2!?'5!2( E!&$2%8 %"'"#&?

!2%"5 "# 9%@% %"' %@! #2"@ :7%$7 8!2%"5 A!>%'& "2?' E<+ "28"&&!&&%"'"#%@@"6A9!82"8!2 B :!96!B!2& F7!' 7!

"2 'B %' !2!& 7!2!%' A&!5 "' % 9!+ 8"&&!&&%"' "# 7!5!#!'5'

A!$"@!& 56!2&! " 7!

89%' %##+ D89' %"'+G "2 7! 8?28"&!& "# 7%& 2 %$9!G :7!2! 7!&?% %&AB2!@%'5!2@'4 2!6!2&%"'!2 " 7!2 7' 9'59"25 "2 5!6%&!!4 7! 8"&&!&&%"' "# 7! 5!#!'5' &799 A! 5!!@!5 " A!$"@! 56!2&! "'9B :7!' 7! !& ! "# 7! 2!@%'5!2@'4 2!6!2&%"'!2"25!6%&!!4& 7!$&!@BA!4 #99&%' "8"&&!&&%"'H A :7!2! 7!&?% %&AB%'5?"2 ?&9%@ !' % 9!5 " 7! 8"&&!&&%"' "# %@@"6A9! 82"8!2 B"' 7!5! 7"#%'5?"2 ?&9%@ #!@9!4 7!8"&&!&&%"'"# 7!5!#!'5' &799 A!5!!@!5 "A!$"@!56!2&!"'9B:7!' 7!

#!@9!5%!&H $ :7!2! 7!&?% %&AB8?2$7&!2 &9!

%'!D!$? %"'"#5!$2!!:7!' 7!;?5>@!'

5!A "2:&"? "#8"&&!&&%"' 7!5 !"# 7!&9!4 7!8?2$7&!2&799A!5!!@!5 "A!

2!82!&!' %6!"# 7!;?5>@!' 5!A "2:7"

:&"? "#8"&&!&&%"'+I +

2"@ 7!$2!#?92!5%'>"#2 %$9!<4% %&!6%5!' 7 7! 9%@% %"'8!2%"5#"2#%9%'>&?% #"28"&&!&&%"'"#82"8!2 BA&!5"' % 9! &799A!>%' "2?'#2"@ 7!5 !:7!2!8"&&!&&%"'"# 7!5!#!'5' A!$"@!& 56!2&! " 7!89%' %##+' 7%&$&! 7!5!#!'5' &76!#%9!5 "82"6!:7!' 7!%28"&&!&&%"'A!$@!56!2&! " 7!89%' %##+

, + '6%!:"# 7!#"2!&%5#$ &'55%&$?&&%"'4 7!2!%&'"!22"2%' 7!;?5>@!' 8&&!5AB 7! %2& 88!99 !"?2 +!'$!4 7!82!&!' 88!9 & '5&5%&@%&&!5+ -1

)*+)+), 82B F7! 7!2&8!3%'>J2!&"'!5 !&J"

Whether reportable Yes/No