← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4626/2019disposed of

Ex Naik Bhag Chand v. Director General Of Police Crpf And ORS

2024-02-14Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal11 pages



         

     

!"#$ %"& "!

'(#(# !)

*+ ,

#)( ) &!)"-

.

 -#/ ).

"!

)0

 )0 !!(0

      + 

+

0,1234 0 &6+/ "34

+ 6 +

+

$+

$,7+ 8, 3/ 0 +  9

+ + 6 3

!

 : ;

#

+

2 2+/ "34

+

2+< 0=2/ "34

+ + 6 3

!   

 

 

 (2 6 + 2+,52 

 6

, 3+ "+9

>?





,

 # 3 

1 3+

 + 6 3

  

=2 + 6  9+3@ 63 6

 +@ 

(2 + 6 3 43 77, 

33 B :

 ?

"

C,+  

+3+3 +  C

6



3+=

A@ %25

2 36 +

+

0,1234 0 &6+/ ,

9 + 6 + =,93

,A7 2 3,+ 6 3 @  6 / 6 +

6

3 =@

2

= 6

3 =@ +9+

+

$+

$,7+ 8, 3/ 0 +  9 ,

9/

,A7

2

 C

6@7 

73 +7 -)

 3 3 769@

:

-+ 3 ,

9 + + 6 3 A

+

2

,7 

)

?/?:> =

+4+3 +7 3 3 769@ +7  7,



@  +4+3

.3 =2

7 73 A@ 9+ 3 ,

9 +

+ 6 3 ;

#/ +

2 2+/ "34

,A7

2 3 3

769@ 23 ,+  23 , 3+1

6+

3 , 3+1 5/ A 

+4+ C

6@7 4

+7 959 2+



,+ 6 3 @  6+ 6 / %25 2 36 +

6

3 =@



= 

9

7+

(2 7+ =

3<,+ 3 =

 A+

++3 -) / 2=4+/ 99 3/ 2+ 

669

 -)

"

6+ 0/ 7 37  0,A+,9

  ),9 

+3+ ##  /

6

3

 A 5

6 +

(2 + 6 3 A 

97 2 2@ 24 +52  +4+ C

6@7  6



+7

959 2+

 3 3 769@

( + 94 

, 6,

95

 + / # 2  66+6+  3<,3 

,

+ 3 A@

6+

?

0,6+7 ,+ 

  

       

     2

93 3=

+,7  

=2+



3 +7

769@ 3 6 C

6@7

(2

+,7  

,7+3 

<,357 +

  9, 4

(2

+,7  

=2+ ,+

5+99@ 293 2

299

3 + +6+3,3

A9=

   

 

  

         

                           

 

 

            

               !"

#         

   $  $ % !

&  $ &  ' " !"

#           

     !" #                                      !"

#               

  (   

  

                     (     

 !"

         

 

              (    

        

  (        )   * !    

"



 DA9 0,6+7 ,+ 

  

  ! " ## $ 

% #& $ '((

) =29 39 =2 

9

C 3,

293 2 

A  

6 6+4 



"



 73 +7 959 2+

 39+

(2

3 6 

A

++3 A@ 0,6+7 ,+ 

 * + $!##  #,- $ +.

 /0

(

=29 39 =2

, 3+  +9 C "/



(2 0,6+7 ,+

9+9@

293 2 

A  

,+@ 6+4  /



3

+7 959 2+



 343,9

"

2+ 

6+4 

, 3+  +9

C "/



3 +7 959 2+

 3 3



(2 +94 C+

 <,357  0,6+7 ,+ 

 * +1 2 +3

+,               + -  . /

    ,  0 12 3  4 -   



  -       5    

         

) 

- 

  ( 

  



) 

              

   -

 ( 

             $ 6    78 299  

      :  



 :  -        

 -( 

                    

; 

 

     

 !< "

 

         8 

    

:

          ;

 

 

 - .

 .       

++  8 2=0    ) .  7 > . 3 %   7  5     .

 .      

 

  

                               2 .

  +          

   

      

   ?         

  

     '

  

 

      



                             

5                                             

 -  

                              

   

          3           

            4    

    

2=08+    

   (  

 =!"  

  7    8  2=0        

 

  +<< 7

 =!" 

    

     

        $     

     

9!0"  8    @  

 





  $      . 

              

  8 )  

       



  ) 

9!0"7

9!0"  

 $           

     $    

                 - . 

        

  

=!"   (  . 

      

9  

     

           

          

             

     

   

=          

 

     

)             . 

         

 4     . 

     

- 

            

   

     

              

+ -  

   +<9 7

 =8 

 

  $      

             ,  < 2=A 7     

            

     - 

  

 

    

 =      



     

   

          -       

   

     

7       

         

?

$        

       (   

 -        

 

=8       

        

          $    

0=

  8  2=0      

        

 



    

 - 

 

        

         

          ' 

 

       +    0<  +     

 ;      

     

-  



  $   8  2=0   $    8  2=2    

  

 

  8          

     

 

     

-



    

   

2=08  

     

       







    

 -            ; 

  



       

         

 8 

  4  '     5   $  

    #  )8         

        

.     



     )/       



          



  

   



      

  ; 



+

)-  

8 $ 6     78  

  

        

            

  



        

8  

+  +  . 

'-         #     &. ,  '. , $ !2A1"7$#20    =   #  C .  C   7 $ !229"7$$<2<  <  

      

   

  

  

  -

 

 

  -  

 

     

 

.

    

         '   8 , .        

  

  

        

  .           

   $$6  '  &  !<D<" < 64- A9 !E " -  .         

 

   

$       7 8       

  

   8

   8    

-     .      

     +5

  

 8             

      

  

                   

    - 

 8     4  

           8+! A2"

-  .       6  $ #   

       

     

        ;   

         

     (                       

  ;  

             ,  



  

8    ? $              

        

     

    8          5  

 

 ? $                                      > 

  8  &  FA2G 4# 9 ?4 DD<< 4 $    + 

     

       

 .  @       



   .           .      

             

                     ( 



      



  

                     +

 5           

        .   ? $   E                 .   

#

 

3/

 +73 A@ ,

9 + 6 +/

=  3 3 769@

9+3@ 6

3 =@ 293+

A 7<+ +

 93  79@ 6

 / 2, /

 

 6@

79@ 6



 @ 79@ 77A+  3 3 769@

(2

+ 6 3 ;

#

 33 2



3 +7 959

2+

 3 3 769@/ 2=4+/ A 

3 6,

5+, 2

3 3 769@ 23 ,+  23 , 3+1

(2 , 3+1 5/  @/

,+  23 A@ 3 3 769@ =

A 3 ,6

27 

A  

@

,+@ 6+4  /  

 + 9A9@  959 2+

(2 0,6+7 ,+ 

A43 <,357

293 2 4

C 

 +4+3 +7 959 2+

 6+6++ 26  +

 2+



,+@ 6+4 

"

769@ 5

6



, 3+

,+@

6+4 

(2 +52  6



A

+5  3



, 9 +52



+7

 "+9 B"

 

,

 # 3

# 

6 

 2 6++

 7



 9,

  +9

  

,

 # 3/  =



3+3

, 37 9 +52

(2

,+ 4+@3@ 

5

79+ 

=2+ 2+ 

C

6@7

,  7 1

6+  A

(2 769@+ 

;



 # 3 + 0 &4+ 7 

  ,9 =2+

 

A =2 

 ,9 97 2 C

6@7

A

73

,  

7 1

(2+ 

 =2+



A

, 2 7 1 =

6+  769@

#

4+@  / 2+ 

7 1

6+  A

(2

A

 3 4

5

7+ 2

 @+

93 =3=

# 99

A24

A

#

A4 A13+6/ 2

,+ 

 

3+3 6 

2 6+ 6

3 +4

 3 6 3  =2 3+

2

,+2+

299 3 +7 959 2+

 6 +

3 3

 

          

!"##"#!

. 5  :

H  5

  H