← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/5011/2014dismissed

Ranjeet Kaur v. Jashwinder Singh And ORS

2015-12-07Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan16 pages

 

            

   !"# $$%%  &#" '() # *( (# $           +# 

#!+&#,-.#($$%%     /(      #0 %  $$%  (  1  %  12  ( 0$% $$%% -  0$"* *  (  "*0    

3  - $12(%#  % '"*-!(% #(#- 4(#%"#4-)(#12-("#$  (.1 5" ((#* 6783 3  9-#*#"

#  9 9-9 :- ;- 3:-;(7  + %-+ (,

#$# *"#(#-)#()(% (

(%(0$"*  "*0 

3  )%% ( 00$#

<)(($# $$%-( 0( #$  8   (# -(.1 #%'() #

 *(     ' *#   *(-  #$.%2-  )(#-    12    ( 0$"*  "*0 -((.%1  ') # *( '*# *(-#$.%2-0$%/(##- ## . 2 " -1."$$%% )"%1### '() # *( ' *# *(- ($#  "*0 

#( ( -##12(%#  #%"# $#*#$(8 ;(0$"*  "*0 -# "

#   

    

    



    

       

 !

   " 

   

 !

 

!



# !

 $  #  $ # 

$  % &

'

 (  !

 # 

$    "

 ) !

  !

 ) 

 ( *             

 +   !

 ) 

  ( *  , -  (  .) (  .'   #  $ !

   $   $  /- $    "

 0 "

  1         0  !

!

 ) 

  ( *   2    "

  

    

    !

          3

    

3

!

# !

 $ !

3 & 4 "

 ! 0

) 

(

   $ *    3 

         ! *  3      31 + * !

 /

   

3



  



 ! 

3



 3

 ! 

3

 

      

 !    

3

 

5   6 

 

 !7     3

  % 

  

 3 ,48 3

1 



1/

!  "    3

 

 3

 3



  "

   !



!



 3 3

  5      1!

         1 31 3 

1   3

    1      !



  

 

3

 

 "

  ) !

) #  $   3

    3!  

 5  3    9 1 "



       ,8  !

1!

        

 

3 "

 !

 

 ! 1 

 !

 

 

    1 3 ,58  3

 ! 

 3 !

   3   

              3

3 " 1 3 1  

 3 3  /  3 3

 



   

 3   "

3   

    ! ,8 1!



!  "

 1: 

 !   1               

   

 3  ! 1  5

 "   !

   +  %  !

!



 5 

   !

 " 3  !

 3 3  !

3 ,8 !

 "

              +   (3  $         $      0   $ 

  

 !!

  

 "         3    3  

,58 -! 1  /

  

3"

  " 3 1   3

    3"  



       !

 

     ! 

 1 3 3 3   

   

3      3 3

  3     5 3  !

  

        (3   %3

!

!

   3 

3    3%!" *  "

!   !

 */3 % 



     31 

  

 

 3 1 !

 " 

  1    

    *       3

3  

 

 3 

 -! 1     ! 



-! 1!

1!    "   3  1! !  "

 1  3 3

3

 !

  

 3 )

     !

  

   1     3   ;  !     

, -  (  !

 "3   

 !



  : 

 

3   3 

!   1

   1  

 !  

    * 1   

   !  *   3  

      3     ,58 -! 1   

1!*

  

 !

 *0

 1 

     3   - 

  1    3

 !     

 !  

  

 

   

 

 3 1        ! 1 

       3  

     3     

1

  *1!* 3: ;       

  "   !



33 1/$<#

 !

<

23 = 

3 *  

      $     ;     ;/  5  < =  

 !

       " 

!

  33   1 $<8$%: )   "   3 !

!     :    +

  = 

  !   1+ $ 

$    !

!

!  *  

     "

   " 1  33   

 

"   !

  33   1  $< 

"

 , - )   "       

 # !

 !

  3



! 1

!   " !

! 



  1    3

  "

  

 33" !

 3



  = $3 )"

     $     

    " 1 !

    $ 3 !

!    /

!

      *    !    ! 1 

  !    + * :4



  

     3  

!

3 &4 

  " ! 1

'   



 !+

$   "  3  3 

  3   !

! 1 !

  >  "

 

               3       

 (  ?* ) 

( *    31 *!   

  "  3%  !  

 

 ,  *!

   *!*! 

)    3 !

   " !



 !

       :       !

1

 3 

!

 1 =   )   "     ;  

   

 

  

       3!

!

   

1" !

 !

        " >  "



    %, )

5;

!

!

 "  3

 3 ! 

 "

 $  (     )  %

   !

  !

     

! *        !

   *    

    "

   " 1  33  "  !

 !

 

    $   

   " 1!

    3  !

   /

!

  *



  1!

 !

+%= : 

!

      3 ! !

 3 -

 1ATUL SETHI

  :     3  1    

  !

 3"$

!

+  %  !

 *     3

       3

  , - (   =,45 5 +?, $  5 , - (  :  

#  $ !

        4 

  

 

     3    $  =*   !

  !

 

1      "  !

 

  !

      /

 !

       $)"  )1 +    (

    3  !  

"  1  

 3   

  !

     ) 

"      -! 1  !

     " 

3 

    !

  

  '

  !



:



      3

  3

   # !

 $ !

3 &!

, - (   4

 $ *    3 

       3    3

   

  

3

   "  ! 1              "   3 ! 1   > @             '     

  

3

 "   3



 5 3(

!  

 ! !    

!

 *!  5 

 A  !

'

 (   

!   (

!  

  A !  "3 ! 1'  

  3

 " 3 3 *   (

 5     3    ,8       

 !

  $  !  

!

 "   , -  (   @

       A    

  !    "    

 "% 

 !  $  3 

  !3 3

 +  >  "

!   "  !

!  "1

  3

 -! 1!

!

 "   "1

   3

  !

  1   !

  3   -! 1!

!

 " 3 !

   !    !

1 !

 !

 '

 (  % !

 !

'

 (    # !

 $    , -  ( 



 !     

3

3 1 3     3 ,

 8   )      3  

  !

     "  !

 

    !



    :

 !

   !

  

B "#$  - %1#!"#-"% 1##- (%% )$#$#* "#$  '() # *( ' *# *( (#  -)(()$#  ("#   39  9 /(##- (# ("#-"

%1#!"#)   ( .* -#.#2)  ()#% 1%12("#  

 9"15" %2- "$$%0 #2  (%%  *   %1#  !"#  )  %  $#$#    $#  /(##-  (#*  )#  #0  *   (  " $# #(00  $"

(1%"

#  ;-

3:-9 :=9 -9 9=9  ;(7  + %-)((( "$% *"%2 %0#%  ##    $#.      *   (  "-  ( $#" <0 ##"

!"0###+> -#&!?"$ +> - !"#-(0$% +>9-0(!"0#+> - 7(# (*) +>-%2 1%"0 +>;-7"#( !"0#+> -7!(0# *(+>:-@7(0(# *( +>3-7/ +%+> -  *(-((#(0$%  +> -7+#(.  7 .* *#+> -$##0  # *.#""0  . 



/(")#<0 "

# 9 9#+- )(# -  (2     (  $#"  .#     $%  % 0$%  7  -("<0   *(> -  1%+#$!"0#> - $% ##()# *

#$$ (2*#0 -@<-$($20    *(##"

#  ; #+* @<  0$% 012"' *# *(* ( -"*(# %) $# ("*(# %)@< +"1%  (

)$$# %#8 : ;;

 9-)#%$%

###,  -#$.%2 #(# *%# "

%#($# $#" * (.  ##-(%# #%"#5"(" #$  ((#*#0* (0 A -($#  $$% 7(.(#%# "

%#($$%%  #"%%2 $#"(% (-(0$% ( %%2%%*(( ( 1  0 # $  12 ( "  /  "1  ( %%* -($#" <0 (0$% -+>9-  !"#-+> -##"

!"0###- +> -#&!?"$$# (0 +> -##"

!"0###-(0$% ) "# *#0"*#)((0   # %00 

(0(A$#$#(0%#$#-@<+ )(((# )    0     "%  0%%  0 *  #0  (  0"(    (



0$%  (#1%$#"#)## =:#.#- )0  ((#  )#"* " ((# ( -  +>  #  &!  ?"$  $#$#    "00#2B  @<  +  



 9(, *($%-$$#<0%2#)2# ((%%*"## )(# -)0  (( ( "00"$$ ""1  %*(0%% )0 *#0(#0"(7 ()2-(0%#$#"10 12  (  0%  )   #        /(  #0   ##- @<+-)(((#* %##-(.#)# * " * 0 2$%/(#) 0   2$ ""1 (#- #(#-)*#%%20  (($ )"# * #0"*#)(()#"* "7 -(0$%  ( ##(#2$ *(#- (. "%2- (# *## %2)"%(.%(( $%     )"%  (.  %     (  .0  0#%  #  (0% %2$#(0 +> -#&!?"$-(( ( #"5($% (02;

9$0-().#- "( "0 (# (%6"#(#-((1 )#( )"$$ *- (-("*((.  (.00#%#(0% %2#%$##.(0 /("-(%%* $ * $#. (   /( %%* $#   ;7+)(#

) % *# )##5"#1$#.- #"0  )#2  #%     0$$#$#    (  0    #    (



%%*  # - (# (0$% @<+ # ( 0$% 40 ) -#((0  (#7#( 1,#0("$#  ("#" #"# (0#.#-( "

%-$% *#%  ( #.# (0$% - !"#(#*"(((

    (  )#2  )  .#  0   #  *.   @.    ( 0$% 4.# )10 -.  (-( #%*. ("$# )#"0#2*   .#"

#(  )#2 #(%%* 0 )#2 # - )1 (0$% @<+ "$$#12(0  (0$% - !"# +> -  *(-(#(# /(2  #  (  #  )     (    1"  (#  #  0#% #$  (#.# /(0 +> -  *(     0%2  (  .#  )((  (  0"  (.  (#  #0  ( "*(##.#-((#0,0#%0$#.0   <**#  (0 6#0(0 -$#.( (00##*(0$% -((% % ( $  1"      (  .#  (  ( $      %    ( 0##*6"#(#0#-)(.# (0$%  (# (#( &# # ) 0#2% )#*. ( "  $#   1"  0#%2  #0  (  $(*#$(-    

  1 $#"0((#%)#*. -$%%2 %*(( (  (.(%(1 #*# ( 0(

 0$% #(#("1 "# * .* -($"&# #)#.#12($% (%"#0 ( "-'() # *(7 -(.(%)##*#

( 0"' *# *( %# -()#*#%  $"##12(0/(# .  (%() ()  (  .(%  )#  "%%2  "#  #  $"#(  12  ( 0$% #(#0%2/(##-(# ( * ## "1 (   ((.(%)#*. (" $#  )#2 1.-(.# +> -  *(

0#%$ <**# A.# *. * %

(    ( "  %      0(  )(  (  .#    ( 0$%  (%%*)  )($# (0 2) %%*%2  (   .#  /(#  #  "0#"  0$#.0     ( .# () 7)() .# ((#%)(( )#*. ("-'() # *()#"0#2   $#7#(  (($* ("' *# *(  %1#!"# %2 *(#12-( , 12(  (($# %* )%$#"#C("' *#  *(  %1#!"## #(#$#$#2 ( 0( 0$%  (#("1 -

110 ./( #1) "-'() # *( ((#' *# *( %#%2$#./( "(0$% -(#(# (# ("1 -"'() # *( ((00%2#

 0##*-  (  0$%      (#  ("1   #  # *    

*#"%"#%  #0    .%%*  ) -   . *    + (2   #% (0$#0@<-#(#"0 )(( ##"5" * (($#"  .)(1." -("#%(( $#"  (  %    1# *  (0  *"%  *   (  " #$   (%# #%"#(#*(%25"(0( (#*#0* (0 /("-("#   2*#"

 ##)( (  0$"*   "*0 -  )((  (  1  $  #  $#$# $$# .  ## $$%  "%0   5" %2-  (  $#   $$%  %     (  0   (#120