Sher Singh v. Mahinder @ Soni And ORS.




   
   

 !"!

#$%&% '( )'!#*( %%+%%,,-! # .

)"/" (!#0 )#0

)"  +%%

", #0





 

  



  
 


$ )%'% %'%/-1(203

,,-! # % )%%'%'( 1(4 203

2

)) ", #0  "%

5% )%'%'% ##/22)6#%

  



 ,,-! # '( ) '!#*(2 7 !#*

 ) '!#*( 8 9,-!## :2 (" !-  ,,-!  /#0

#5;<85:)% %% )*)# -

-*!#"

=/0*9 0

0%;%,""

076 - 0'

""!

#" /0* 29/#*) *0()!% .!0  !9,/*# 0 =/0*9 )!-   ("  >/!

0) ", #0  "%

5  ()* "/#0

#" 5&25255#05) 04!

('

#5&
% " ,  "

#2 # <%%

0  ) '!#*( 4" 09!

0 !# %%% 0/)2 9( 4")

))

!3!- ",!

-29/#*)27/ 4"

7 ",!

-29/#*)%

9)  ( 7 ",!

-%

)"

1!#* ,!#!



)) *)0!#*(!"

8: ""2

0 ) '!#*( (0 7

)0 0%
# (!" "

2 "!0  ) '!#*( "

(0 *

/7 -- )9- '!#*( # (!" 9

) 6 - 24(!- (3!#*(!"9 -2( (0-"

#"/9 0(-7

-!>/ )% 7 <%,%9%24( #( 4" 9!#*7 12( (0

)/ 1

74" #(!"( 076 , )"

#"24( 9(

!0 !6#0 ") "9 2( --0 4#

 *) /#0  #0 4" -"

 *!3 # "-," 76 9% (  , ,) 6)  ( ",

#0)

7-

0"

!# 0

2 4(! ( 4 #3

0 !#

- 0 ,) -"%  /"

0 (!#0 4" ))

# <%%%
#=/) 0 ) '!#*( 0!

%%% %%  /"

(!#0 "/  0!" - "/) "

#0,/)"/#

2( (0*

) 6 -  ) 9 (!" ( /"

 !# 3!--*  ?/#*-% #  "!0 06  /"

0#/=?/9)4"-"

))

0% #<%%2 /"

' (!# 4" ))

0% 

  /"

0 (0 -"

 "/ 0!" - "/)

" " ) *)0" !) ,) ! !, # !#

%

!#0!#*  ,)!9 !

 "

2 ()* " 4  )9 *!#"

0/#0

#"5&25255#05) 0 4!

('

#5&
% ( 0"9#6"4!

""

"% 9 #* 9) A)%.!=6 )9)2 0! - !

)2

0/)B A;)%%'%7 7 ",!

-29/#*) #0 A)% !"(/ 

-2  0! - !

)2  )-  ",!

-2 9/# *)2 4(  4"  9   )02 4(! ( (0

85:

#0/

0, 9

9 07 06

0 '!#*(% '

0/#0

#55)% %%

)0 0!#4(! ( 6,- 0 0!##

#0-- * 0-"

!9,-!  #%
#0

60!0#

#64!

""% " #

0 7 2 3!0  =/0*9  0

0 %;%2

- )!-  >/!

0) ", #0  "%

5 ()* ")9 0*!#"

9%  (3 )0 - /#"

-  ,) "2 7/ #

!#0#69 )!

!# ,,-! 

1!#*-

-% ( - )!- 24(!- ,""!#* !9,/*# =/0*9  >/!

-(" #!#

#"!0 )

#6

A)% .!=6 ?/9)2  0! - !

)2 %%% 0/)% ( "!0 4!

"" "

# ;%%2  ) '!#*(  4" 7) /*(  

 %%% 0/) #0  " !# )9 0 76 (!9 #0

#0# 2 (  (0 9

 4!

(  ) 0 "!0   !0 %    /)

 ,  4" "9 --!#*  - -2 "  ) 4(! (2 4""-/)!#(!"",

(%
4" /#0 ) 9 0! - 3!0 2 !

0 ,) # )

)0

(0 #"/9 0 (-  7

 -!>/ ) #0   (!" (3!#* 7

 %%% 0/)2 " "

0 76  

)2

4""-/)!#(!"",

(29 #!#* 76

4" /#0  !#-/  -!>/ )%  (/"2  , ""!7!-!

0(3!#*9

4!

() 0"!0  !0

7 )/-

#0 (!"4"4(

0#0(!"

#0# (0

-0



).!=6?/9)%'

!--/) )2!

4" /#0 /*(

8&:

#3 )"!

#4" 7-

0"

!# 0

4 *

0 ) 9  ",

# %%2 6

 "!0 )

) ! - "4 #

, "!

04!

(-1(# !--%%!% % )

9,-

, )!

9 (%( 
#3 !* !#* !

)24"#

7-

@,-!#  ) # 7 (!#0 

 #

 (3!#* 7

, "!

04!

-1(# !--%%#0 (!"3 )6 !#0! 

4)0"

)6"

)67 !#*#

/*( %'

!-- )2 !

 4" /#0  !#  7"

 !0 ""!-# "2  )

)6 

2 # ! # !#

#"!0 ) #2  "9  4 /-0 7  # -,%   4!

""

0 4"  4!

""

 #0

0 (!9"

- 4" !

 91

 #0 0!0"

2(!"#

(3!#*#9 0#6 ""!-# "24 /-07

#3 )"!

0(0

-0 A"/)9

'!#*(2 '

9  ( #0 .!1)9 '!#*( 7  !0  /"

0    -

) , !# 2 "

0 -"!!

0%(  !0

0(3!#*#

7

7-!"( 02  "/- ##

!#=/)!

"!#-!

, )"

0#0 (!") # (24

7 3# )% " #

0 7  - )!-   ("2 4(!- ,""!#*  !9,/*# 0 =/0*9   >/!

-2 0!" /""

!) 3!0 () 07) #0("

# -/"!

# 4" #

 7-

 !

" "

 *!#"

 /"

0 7 #0  ) #7- /7 % 
# /) ,!#!

#2 #!#* *!3 # 76  - )!-   !"  ,-/"!7- % 

(!#* (" 7

# , !#

 "( 4  !" #6 9!") 0!#* ) 9!"!#

),)

3!0  ,)

8: )!- %( 9!""!#*-!#17

7-!"(9

!0 ""!-# "#0 (/* -6!#0 , "!

!#* , #8

!# (!" "

:/"

0!# 4!

-1(#2 )

"  0  !#  3 )6 "

)6 #% 3 #"/ (0 -6) 9!# 0/# @,-!# 0#06

/) )!

/-0

 7 @,-!# 0 #0C 7-!"( # )

)0 "

 4(6

-0 7  !0  ""!-#

A" /)9

'!#*(#0

)" -

), !# 24( #

91!#*(!""

7

7"!" 4(! (
4") *!"

02( 0!0#

 #9 #6""!-# "%

) --  ) #"2 4  !#0 #  !#!)9!

) !-- *-!

6 !# !9,/*# 0=/0*9  >/!

-% #"

>/ -62 ,,-! 

1!#*-

- !"0!"9!""

0%D

-!"0 -!# 0%  

 !




  
 


!
"






"



%&% 0"
A(

)', 1!#*C

0$  "C A(

, 7- $  "C