Narain Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"# $%& '
(('
!$%$)%*# $%& ('
'
(('
& +,
- -- .
+, -
-
-./ .
!"
!#"$%&"
'
(
")$) $" ""*
+!"!"$ $" ""
,,,, -- .
-
! !
$
(
."! '
/+ 0 12345/5-63 "
-7 -3340 8 2-1$"$")
( ."! '
/+012/23954:;"
76 -3390 8
" 01* % :"< ' /"&. & $-=3:0'! > & '-=3:?1 !'
)& "@ $ ' ") 24$
")*")
&") ""
"
'
) '$ '"& @$ $ !
"
)" "& ' :
' '-=3:B
@'@ "&.
(
$ ' ""
"
'&!")) 8 0"1$
$
@
)" '@"&.
!" "&!
@""
& 79 47-4$+C -;;:<'-33;" &
01$*!
"'
."! @
"&. 01$"
&
@ )" )
" % )" :
) " & )'
!"" *!
")@ &) &")
2 01 &!"))
"
$"$
"
")) ) '"
"
% 0"1")
"&&
;
* $' "
" !
"'
$
) ' " &)"@
$ ! ' ."!
010"1$"
@" % :
"<' '-=3:B$"
"&& "
) ' )"
@
%(
%' 4:041' "+@ "
" "" /" &. $ ) "
@ & $47-90!
"'
'! &")) "> & '47-9?1$ !
"&& @ <
)"" &@ D!"" 6=559 06D2-7 1$4<0-D2-4 1$<4<0-D2-3 1 "
%))"
")*")$ ")*")
$"''"%
') ;' '-=3:B$ !
' )"
1
8
" ) & '"&!)$
"@ '
"'' "
'!
$
"
!" '"%'
-("");@")")" 06;< 4;." "1!"% ) & &!)"* " .%") %"&" " "'")) D!"" 6=559 '
'
"' "-D2; ')"'@D!""6=559$" &)""
<' '-=3:B*"@" %"&" )"'")) D!"" 6=559 0<D2; 1$4<0-D2-4 1$<4< 0-D2-3 1'%))"
")*")$ ")*")$"$
" "*" -3"
7< -33;$*""
' $ &
& "
"
"
;'
B& '-=3:B$ ! ' * @" ) &
0&!)1$ *!
"$
." @" %"&" )"$ "
"&. 01 @" "&
""*"
" "&. 01"
" "*"
'
=
" @"
$& ")
$ "''"% )"" "
")&@ )"
)"
" ' &@)
") *($"@&!" )""''
)
$
")"''
3@
"$"($"")"''
:: '9@")"&"
) '$
&" " &)"@' @"( ( * )"
)"$"
*)
@"( )) ( *
")"
)"
'
@ $ ")
$ "''"% @@ 8 !"
&
&& $ "( %" ")"& % % "&. )"
")
! + &" @"( " '
)"$"
8 ' ") @'@ *" ")*( &
%
"&. )"$ !*)
$*!
) *) )& 8&!
-7 ! ) " & )'
&@"
$ $
22' $3 2$
" +)4 56% 6478 6%#
/
-969 $3 6!:6%6 6%#
! + & 79 47-4$!"% "
@ '$ *
")"))*
-- * $' "
" !
"'
$
)"& "@" " &"@2)"& )"& $"
0"1
&' ) )")&"
""
"$"$ )"
)"" " F 4 $ ")*")$ &")) *!
&
01 " " F4$ ")*")$*
)
'' $
*!
01 &!"))
% 0"1 " ") "*"$ "
" *
01"
" & '@ 01&!"))
"*"
0"1& " & "*" &"
$
* )) ' ) "
' &)"@ "
*
0"1
2
@ $'@ " ")' $"''"% $ ") ' )"
"@
! !""
G"@&!" 97: "
7< -33;$*!
"'
'*"!" %
'&" " @ " "*" -3"
7< -33;*"&
)" -9 $*!
' &"
$ "''"% $'!
&& $
")"@ '" &@ "
!3:H'
&@ "
"@ "
)" ) && @ $ !"
" '" "
&@ "
' )"'
&& $
"@
&@
$
@ 01 '$) " "@
&@
+ ' ") " #
")*")$'
&@ "%")"
'
&@ )") && -:
' ''
"
$"
")) ."
&& !"& " ."
&!" % !
"'
'""@
$"$
?
8+ % &" "B
B$ *!&!
!"# !$%& '"$!"
" "1""
&@ "@ % "&. )"
' &@ '& '47-9B1I
1 " &@ "
"@
&@
'
&@ )") && &"))
*!
" !"%
@" &@ '& '
'47-9B -;
")
&" &)"@
@"( '")" &)""
@' 4:041' '
47-9B -< & $
)" '
'@ "))
&@ "& !
&@)
%
"&.
"
&&"
'
$%
)""
" " "
"
)"*')) %&
'@ 7%64
!#!
$3 $)!9
-6 "'
@"
!$ '@
$ "$* "
%"
$ "@ @ !
@ 01$ " &
"*" " @" " " "''@ -=
" & -3
& @"&" )'!"
& !$"))
")&"
01$'" $") "01 '
-- . -./ . ('
'
(('
("%
C!
"( 5 " 5 C!
5