Balkar Singh And ANR. v. Commissioner (J.D.C.)Punchayat Lands Sec.22 Chd & ORS
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH.
CWP133711999
Reserved on: 21.09.2022
Pronounced on: 27.09.2022
!
"##! $ % CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURESHWAR THAKUR HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE N.S. SHEKHAWAT
& ' () & !
* ((
* )+,-
((
! -! .& //// SURESHWAR THAKUR , J.
0
!
#23+0444! 5,#!&
3+320444! 5,+ FACTUAL BACKGROUND # -
! ( 6 !
-
) 78$ * 0449 &* & :* 7* .&
!0420 **
;
;
1
& ! * : * . * !*
!
<
2 + $ & ! ** & : #23+0444!& = & &
&
&*
<:!
!
3+320444!
*
! ** #23+0444!:
:
* & !& * &*
!& -
( 6 1 *!
*!& &* SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS >
*
&* ! * *
)78$*0449&*
! -
* &* ! &
#000044>! : *1 *! *
&! #000044>!
*
*
? &? 1 ! &? 5 &,
&& #
*
3 #
> * ;
;!
:
* & 5 * 5 *
!
:
:
:& :!&! ! *
&* *
1 *! *
&
! !*
(! :
5 :
5
04201 ! : &* !* ;&
. *
*! &? @2A
! 5 :?!
B 5555555 & 55555555 55555555 (g) ―shamilat deh , 0 & 5 & C # C + & ! 1*! ! 1
* & ** * *
* C = * & * * ! !
!
! : : & C > & & .? * *
C but does not include land which,,,, B,,,,,D
4 & ?, &
C 555555555 (vi) lies outside the abadi deh and was being used as gitwar, bara, manure pit, house or for cottage industry, immediately before the commencement of this Act;] 5555555555 ANALYSES OF THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS THAT THE PETITION BEARING NO. 7/DDPO OF 1998 WAS BARRED BY THE PRINCIPLE OF RESJUDICATA.
2
! * * 5 ! -
* & **& 5 &?
:* *
!
&? * ** *
!& -
5 : & * & -
: #000044>
*<:!* & *! & * *! & &? 5 ! & & *
7 * & * *:* * ! %+ =*$ AE* * !0439! :
*& 5
* @3. Where neither party appears, suit to be dismissed.,
:
*
! &
5 4.
! "
#
$% 9
* &5 * & :
**
&* ! *5 * ! & :
& <:!%=*$ AE! **!:
& *
*! ** * !&
*
*<:!* & & ! * **!
! !
&*
!
* **
$
** & * &*
! & : ** :
& * *!& * !
&!:
*
*
4 A*!: & & **:
* *1 ! & &: **! &:! 5 *
!
00* 1 & ! *
6 !
00* !:
, ** ! :
& ) :
* * * **;1 !:
!
! &
*
%= $ AE 5 *
00* ) :
** * **
* **!&! CONCLUSION 03 *! &? *
& *%=* $ AE :
* * * 5 &? 8! 8 !
&. ! :* & &
* !
& &. *! * * & !
&
1 *! :
8 * * &? ! & &. : & & & & :
* & ! :
&
! * &? 5 & !& & ! *
&. * !
* *
!
7
* * *! * ** (!* :
? * ! *!: ?
& & &? *
! !* : * ! & * * ? *
:
! &? 5 & : !* : * ! * * &? !
& ! : &
& & !& * & **
*
! &* ! * !? &. !&&
& & & : !& ! &5 &. :& &* ANALYSES OF THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 2 (g) (5) (vi) OF 'THE ACT' 00 &5 ;
;! * ! !
!!
:8: * *
<:! : ? ?* !&
: ! ! :8:
&* *
!
! 0420<:! *
8 !
* &
& !
:
& &&& !
!:8:? & :
@ &* *
G FINAL ORDER
0# A :* &!
* && &* & * ! * *:!
& & : ! ? * & 0+ A ? ! * : ** 0= ) (SURESHWAR THAKUR) JUDGE (N.S. SHEKHAWAT) JUDGE 27.09.2022
Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No