High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6929/1994dismissed

Baba Balkar Singh v. Joint Dev.Commissioner Etc.

2024-02-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma14 pages

!"# $%& ' ' '

!$%$(%)# $%& * ' '

! "# & +,

- -- .

+, -

- - -

$ #%&' %

!#()* + ,"

*# $,! ! -*%

((*,!#()* + "# . //// -- .

0)1(02 0)34!$(%# 0 ,*," +1#" # ).2+ , * -*% 1#$ 1#**# (+3 *$4* )!05.6, *+ + , )*11#*7,1#*)7%+ , ) !1#*+ 1#$!+ 4*8$,#+))&+ ,1*#+, 1$ "1*)7*8* *9*#,,*,7!, %$, "

+,*%(*# 1$ "1*), ) (#, #

#*#05020565!*))"#,*#"*# 4*##,)* , 1#* ++) ),)8 , ) # *# 4*8 " , #+))&

2 )4"1*) 9, , # + , ) ! , 1#*++) (# # #*#26:;055: <

=0!

# #+ 4*8$ ",#+))&+008**10>4* 1*+1*#+ 7*8* *9*#,,*,7 > "# .=

*4 *),*&* +1# * *""*1 , *$*%+ ,14++) 9( !,*#*""*1 %)*4#4# . 31$#=*+#+ 4,*+ # <

=0 *#=2! "# .=

*4*),*&*"

#**""*1%+ , * ) ! 1#* + 1#$! *1*#,* , * ) !, $, # # *9:>:20552!*))"#, *#*""*1*# # #,*,"* )*$,(1

*+, # #*#05020565 ; , " +1# *""*1 *$* , # #*# :>:20552%+ , ) +1#*+ 1#$! -*%!

,*#$* ,, ) !1#*(# # #*#2.:50552

=> #),*""*""*1*# # #+

11+

, # ? ,* % *(

# , 9 " ,* , *

( 41$%*)8#

$,&* 05@@=@6!#)###(1"

3)*11)8 *#*1* )*"

,*1*),

*4 *),*&*9*,*($ $,1*# *#,4* *#!

, %&<),*$#1*#9,,1*#+," ,1*#

# #"

*#4, 1*#9*$(,+*, +, " <),*$ <

=>A 9( !"+, 1*#+,#"

#8,* * 4% 9*$(,+*, +, " ,,* "*),*#, "

&44 "

4*8 ",)* &#+))& 9( !,

*4*),*&* 8"* )$,1*#+*11$,#"

#8,* * 4% @ ,&* 055:!," *$*4*# B ,

*4*),*&*, 1*,1*# # 3)*1 4*8 ,#+))&+,1*#,,* "*),*8#," *8,1*#1**#,4*4!,&9 1#* "

$,*4,*4+," 6 ," ) #*8,1*#1*, &* 0550!0552*#055>"+, )"9, +* **),# *<

=;!=?*#=@,1*" #+," 9* $$<" >::;055.9*+

, B #,*(9+ ,*& # <

=>!,

*4*),*&*)** ), 1*# 9( !#", ) # $+ 4**$* !11,

*4*),*&*)# )#,* )+,1*#+

1*0?:.055.9, (+119$,"

5 , " +1# , *$* * " %+

"# 0!9, !,9*# )#*""* %+ ,

,*1*25:.055. 0: ,

)) #! , $, , 4"

$# #

=0.4*#25:.055.!,1#,*,* ),1# 0?:.055.! 9* )# )# *)) #*) 9,

1 *# 9, , )+%,,"*),*&* 00 , " +1# * *""*1 , *$* %+

"# 0 <

=0?!9, !,9*$ *# 4 *& " + (* # "*# %& , (1"4 44 < )$ , "9 + 44 9,

$* #4**$* B ( ,"

" &B !11,

" 9*#"# 02 31$*$$ (#!," +

, +1#C=?2;:= 055.%+ ,

9, ,, *+ < *)# # 9* "*#, !06:;055.

,*"+,*%( # ! "# .@!

9,,,1"+4, " #,#"

#1*#*# )4"11&# &#,) "9%&," 0. *"4, ,*," *1+1#* + " 4*- )*#$**& # + 4,1* #)(1

0.:;055. 0; ,* ( *11&! , *""*1 +1# %& , "

=0?9*#)##(# # #*#06:0055;*#,)* 9* 4*##%*)8

=) 4=11) !*1*#,* 0? ,4*4!," *1+1#*" #

)00+, -*% 11*$44*# $ 1*)!

05?0%+ ,11) !*"

,*1*,*#"9**119# (# # #*#:.:?2::0 <

=>;!9, %&9*,1#,* ,

*4*),*&*,*#))9,,1*##" *#, "+," ( ,1*##"

+ 4,&* 05.@ 9* ",1# 0@ $$ (#*$*,*%( # ! "# .?=

*4 *),*&*7 +1# ")( *""*1 %+ ,

(1"4 44 , *#*""*1 9 *119# , $,* # 4*#02:52::2 <

=.0

06 31$*$$ (#!," +1#C=0@@.2=2::2 *# C=0@@.>=2::2 %+ ,

, $, * # 4*# , !0?:02::. <

=.2!,*#9 "9 #"#+*#,)*9* 4*##, (1"4 44 9, , # ) ,* , , 1# #)# , *""*1%&"*$* # %&$($*)1* +#$*9,, , 1*##"

9*"# $% 7 *#9,, ,*4(# ,

*4*),*&* 05 , (1"444 (# #

#*#>::62::? <

=.>#4#,*""*1+,

*4 *),*&* 2: $$ (#+ 4,*+ # !,

*4*),*&*+1# 99 " %* $ C=06>@:=2::?*#C=0@@@>= 2::?,

, $, # 4*# ")(1&0:002::?*# 20002::? <

=..*#=.;! ",*""9 " !, #4#%,,9 " 20 31$#=*+#+ 4,*%(!,

*4*),*&* +1# (1 @52@=2::@%+ , 7%1 4

9,),9*)( #(1""*1 .?6?+2::6, 7%1 "<

, $,* # 4*#, !:@:52:0@ <

=.?#4#,)(1*""*1+1#%&,

*4*),*&* !711% 1018%1 $% 9:02;

! <$%#%1 $

1$ *

22 ," 9**1+ &* 055>=055.*# ,1*<" #0;:.055. 4*+,1*,*

* , D#)) "*( ,#"

#1*#*#,*1) *# +1,9 " 2> ,<),*$+1*#4*#%&,+*, 8,* $,!

,,*#%*#0>=? +1*#*$*,1*#+0:=0. *# *##*1* *9**$ #%$(( ,4%&, "

& 44 =) 4=11) *"

,*1* 2.

4*#4= "

**% ,%$7 *+#* 7+ 7*8* *9*#,,*,7*#)

#*114+1*#11$*11& 2; ,#"

#8,* * 654*

$0>=0@ 1*#9* #)1* #*(*) "

" &*,4+4$ *+(*) , &* 05.@ )) #$1&! , *# 8,* * 4% 65 9* # 1& *11# ,

#" $, + ,* $, )

$ , )1#* "

) )*

# , &* 05;5=?:! , *%( *#

#"$,)9 $(11* 0.6AA.>!.:AA2>!.:AA2.A0!.;AA>! .;AA6 25=06 1 +, *11#* *)1 (+8,* * 65( 9,),,&,*#%"*+ )1#* 2? ,+*, +," 9*( 4*#*&*114 +,7*8*1*#789*7*8**%* *9*#,,*,7 ,9* " + 4$*& 1$ # 9( !,*%(*# 8,*

$,9**11#.8**11*#*$*,14+,1*# *%*## %& ,4 *8* , + ! $,*))

, " *8"+,7*8* *9*#,,*,71*#+*) 9,,4$ *+4 14=4 *+#* !,1*#%)*4"* +, (*) 1*# 2@ , <),*$ <

=>A , 1& #) 4 **)# %9 , +*, + , " *# , 11) !

,*1* ),!, 9*B +," %)4$ 1#*&4 1*# 26 ,*( &&* *91*##9*<) #%9 ," *#,

*4*),*&*9,),)*

##++ *4

+1*4)"&+, 1(*1*## $ **),#* <

=.A %;!%) $;

1:7 $(!1 25 , $,,1* #) 1*""* $+ ,"

%+ ,

(,41&* $ %+ ,

,*$(, ))1 (& *)B # %& , ( #) 4*# ")(1& %& , 11) <

=>;!%&, (1"444

=.>!%&,

!C=06>@:=2::? <

=..*#C=0@@@>=2::? <

=.;!*#!%&, 7%1 "<

(1 ""*1 .?6? +2::6 <

=.?!

9, %&, "##)1* #%9 +,#"

#1*# 1*1&!, %&,, + )#,*, 9*))* ,# *9$+<

=0.! , 9**&))*+ ,

*4 *),*&*)) #!"

)#4*8** )+,#"

# 1*# !9,! $,!1*# , ( , , $, %#$*#))1 (( #) *%)*4#)1* #(, " , >: ( !, %&!, $,,)#,*,""$ 44%##,* &)*+)

)( - #)** %*

#,* , &)) #!# *9<

=0. >0

9( !+ , *%*$#, *+ !% *""* ,*,))1 (&*#+*1&** $ #%&,1* # ) 1+ ," %)44%1D#%&*11,( #)

* *, *4*%1%)4+*#, >2 * 1&!+ , **% (#+ 4* *#$+ 4"

$#<

=0.!")*11&+, 1(*, ))

$ " !9,),< *)#, *+ !, , + 4*+ )

%)4$ *#B *," , *)B )$,,1#$ ,#"

#1*#1*!, %&!,4+ )#$, * )"

)#$%)*4*"1&#)1#, $,<

=0. , *# #)1$ %)*4 + ## , $ # ,* , *#

)#$4!!4*#,*""

4, %&, * )*%)4)# )#+,#"

#1*#%)*4 ",1# & '

(

$ ( '

)* + %, '

$' (

(

( '

"# (

/ # 0 /*# '

$ *

1230-

# ,$4 (, %#

,$ 4 ( )*

' *

,'4 $(#

$ '

/%4& >> B 1&!,*#*)B ))*4*+*(, *%(< *)#" <

=0.!#*19, (# , $,*## )+)$(#)! %)4)1"# 1*1&!, %&%$*+ )(=*=(," #" *#4#1& ,1#$ 1* ( , #"

# 1*#! *, , ""

$,*#+*) 4+ 4,* &* , !9,# 9 ,( #) *!%#*1, ""

$,*#+*) 4! 1&+ 4,

% *1+ 4, 7%1,"<

>. , ""

+,*%(*)B ))!*))

$ <

=0.!+ *+ ),*,( #) 4*#%&, 11) <

=>;!%&, (1"444

=.>!%&,

!C=06>@:=2::? <

=..!*#!C=0@@@>=2::? <

=.;!*#!%&, 7%1 "<

(1 ""*1 .?6? +2::6 <

=.?!

%)4$"

)

#%&," , !, , $,,(#1& *))$,()+ ""

$$3*1! *, %+ ,* &* , *!*911*%+ ,

*#%+ , 7%1"<

>; B 1&!9,,*#( #) %)4$*# 9,,*%(()!, %&!,

1#*++ 4<

= 0.B 19,,- #$4 *%)4$"

)

#%&, " , $,,"

*))$,()+# + # 5 ( *11*%(!, %&!,*#( #) !% )* %)4*$#*&))1 (&*#%#$++) >? *1*""* ,*, 1*#**""* + 4* *#$ +<

=.0=.?!*""##9, =266;=2:05!9,),* *8 ) #!, "

,,*""$+,"* $+, &,&* 05.@! *, 9 ,"+4 14!

9,,,*""$+,"* +,) &,&* 05.@!

1++ *8*, + !9, 4+,( #) # #%& , 7%1"<

!)*!1#*7$%

!&' (%)*+, - '! " # ./0-11 ! ), 1*#1+%,#%&4 144$ **8*!%)*4(#, $ %#9,, , ( , $,!1*# *& + , * ,1# ! 9, %B 1& * 4

" , ( B 1&! "! + *&! 9,), , " , * 4#( ,#"

#1*#% *+ ,4 14 9,9 * 1 , ) 1(*$,#"

#1*#! *, 4$ *$ *8*!,11,*""$+,"* $,&* 05.@! B 1+,( #) *!*4*#%& 7%1"<

!, ,)# #4#+,

!%)

#%1*($ ($+*& $,!1*# , ( ," , , 1(*"* *$ *",* < *)#, *+ 4 6

# $- 47 ( + 89 1) 8 ( $

(

( '

' (

# $- / # $- ( # $ $ &/ :

7$ ; 9

:1 $'# ;1 ;

( # $ ( $ '

- 47 # $- $$

$( (< $

$ '

(< $

( '

# $-

( (" '

" # $- ( (

= '

( / $1 ""% :$(; 47"

# $- '$$'

#$ '

47 $( 9(

((< $((-< $ < < $ $ 4*

-< $ ' '

$$ ' ((< $' >47>'?6$ 4(@6

6 47;

(

$' $$' '' : ( #,'$

6 * $ 6( #; ( 6( 4 $'

AB 6$ >'4(6

":6 "

6$ 6 2 # 3?C@ '

( ( # ' $$ ( $$$ 6 ' ( ( : ( ( 6 ( $$$ 6 $ ' ( ' : # 66

' : 476

2$' : :6 '

(

(< $$

$ $ 4* # $-

( '($' : '

( < $-< $ ( < $'' :

# $-

' : .

$ '( 9

:479(

( ( '

:6 476 ?

( 9

: 6

$6 @# 476

( ' 8 * ' ! '

(

( ( $

' - ?@

# $- ('

' 4 ( '

7 ' '

8 ============

/ :

1( (

' (*

47 6 ";"

?#;

@ #' # :

>( D 8>( 3-; (

' B B

$'$ B A 8 & / = $ : /

: 17 # '#47E .F#:1 3C

* '

476 $ $ ' 6 -6 $( 6 ' 4 ( '

#; $$ #;

= '( '

6 C .?@ 4 $ $

>( :;

>( 3 #;

( #; $ $ ' $$ (

(

' $ /(

(

$ '

$$ ( 6 ( ) 234 ! ., ) & - !) 23

& 4 ! .5& !-%

6 >@ ") 1&!, %& 4+,)>+) 0+05;. , -*%)+05;>!"

(9, +* < *)#, *+ ! ),1*#(, $ 8 * ' ! '

(

( $

' - ?@

# $- ('

' * *),*&* ,*($ -

#)( ,(11*$E 7%02

!#!

1:7 $(!1

>6 *+ 4*,!,

+#4 ,9 " *#) *##4*#*)) #$1&#4# >5 ,4"

$#<

=0.!4**#*#*++ 4# .: # *) .0 ),4*)*1+,*%#)##!, !*11, "#$*""1)* !+*&!* *1#"#+

-- . - - * ' ' 8*($, C,, "*8$A *# '

FA C,, " *%1 '