Pritpal Singh v. Narinder Kumar
!
" "
#$%$& '
()
$* +,$- $$ .%/% $0/1 %* ( )2 '
$* +,$- $$ .%/% $0/1 %* 3& 453 , 35 ,
%& 3 %$%/* 6 .# 6
*$$ 3 ,3/$6 .# 6
%*
35 ,6 % 7 *$$% $+ 89 % 1 *$$6 8 %%$ ++9 $%$-/ %/$$%$/89%*$ $% *$$6 %7 %#$#$
%*689 + $$ +$.$+ /-(,$"$.$%$)6"/$62: ;6 /-% % .8$1*/-$%*$$%6 * %%89 7 $
#/%6 8$- #/ <#/$#/
2 '6*$$# ++-%
+ $$ +"$%$# /-6, -/6 2: '6897$#
$ *$$%=$-% $ + $+89 $167 %$%1$%% +7 $+ $%>/-1 #%/
89*$$6$%/$$%$/89%*?*+ $$
%=$- # %*#$ $#* 1 # -1 % +$87 * $%6 +% %=$- # **/ + $>/#$ @/ %/$ **9
*/% + $1*/-%7% + $+89 *%*$$ 8$%1$%% 267$ ++7$- * %% % -&?
A %7 %+$% $-8/,$,09 +6 .# 6 *+ $%/#$%8 + /% +
$+ %7% +$ % - - ,$ !-% /* 6 .#
6,$,09 +6 .# 7 - - %*% 1# 989#/%+ 6$%/ 8+ -/# %8# /% $%/#$% +%# % $+#/1%7%/**+$ $1 #$#/1% #%6 $ %1% $% $%$*%#/$- +$# $% #%% 9 $ *#$-%6 $% <*#8.$-$+ +$% ##$-+9$%1$%% *%#/$B %@/+96$7$1*/-6$ %8% $
% $#$#/1% #%6%*#$ ++97*$$?>/-1 8
$<#/$*#$-% :6
;
8/
$$%#/%+ //*8 <#/$ /67$ $%=$-% $ + +% .$- 8 $++9 : '67 %-/% + ; %#*$$6$ 6*$$ %# ++- + <#/$/ C 689 7$# %7 % *%%%%$ .8$%%/(@/ =$-*%%%%$ %/$**9)6%/#7 % % - .$-8<#/ 8+89
7.6* $ $1*/-$$%*$$ ( )67 %% 989$%/ C 5 #/%+ *$$ % %/81$ *$$%.%# # $% +8% 1$%68 <#/$*#$-% $ +$D68# /%$ #1=7 $%1$%% + $% + 26$++<#/$ *#$-%7 #/ ++9$$$ 89%*?#+6
7$#6%*$$%#/%+ .$- 8 <#/$/
:6$
8 /67$#7 $ =7+- *$$( %#) %/81$% $
# $+ #1*+ $ $% #/%+##7$ /#$+ +%+$%/*7>/-1% #$ #%
$%/$ $+ 1.% 1# 6
;( )($1$ +)2:
+>$,$-.%3 1 %6 2(C)($.$+)C 5 #/%+ %* %/81$% + .$-8$%1$%% ##/
# *$$$ .-$.#1*+$%/#$%$%#/%+6
%8#89 #/$ 2 (*/#$$%1$%%$- $ % $)6
. .$- $<#/$*#$-%6*$$ 8.$/%+9#% $ %*#$-%6 *%*$$% +9 + 9$- #$# $-+% 2 .$-#%$1 6$19*$$%*$$% 8$%1$%% + 9$#6$$1*/-
2: '6* %%89+ $$ +"$%$# /-6 +$ #/ 26 $%1$%%$- + ?
*%#/$6 %8*/#6#+ +9% $-$ *$$6 .
# - #/%+89$16 $%/#$%#/%+ %/**+$ 9#/1%$1( %*#$1 8 #/ 2) + .$-8$%1$%% 26 *$$#%1 $%$+$-$++ :6897$#$1$# +%8$%%/$1$<#/$*#$-%@/ #$%%/ $
%*$67$$1 .$- 8 #//-#/%+ : /8+96+ #/%+ %%/81$ $%#/%+ $-8 <#/$#/
:67 %$%
/+
+%1 #1*+ $ $% #/%+8
/#$+E7.6%/##1*+ $8 <7$*$$ !6 . ##*$- 7 + #/%+ % % 8 8
8%+/+9##6/*%*#$ $#@/9$1 %7 9#1*+ $ %1 $%#/%+7 *$$$
+6 -/ $##+9 % $%/#$% 1 *$$ */%/ + . #/1% 8-$.$16+ #/%+
$+9%/81$% %/##1*+ $ %81 8.$/%+9 6 %- % +7$#$%7%/- 8-%67$#7 %$%1$%% 2 ?*%#/$6 *$$ #/ ++9 -$. 9$%/#$% #/1%$% #/%+(.
- -$- 7#/%+)689%7$- 7 +9$%$+ 9$-*#$-%%/ #$%%/$
%*%$-$1*+1$ /9 #6 $%% -6 $17#1/*7$ ++=$%
<#/%%898+ 1$-7$
#/%+6$7 $
+7$$%$%/#$%$#1*+6 %#7 $ <#/$*#$-%6$% $ *+9%/ #% -<#/ #6 $$-1$$%*$$%69 $%1$%%
'
*=F$%
!
"# $% "#