High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2910/1988allowed

(O&M) Vijay Kumar v. M.C. Rupnagar

2026-02-13Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal11 pages

"#$%&''&

#$#($) "#$%*''&

% +,

' -.

! " # %&'(')&)(**"

"+ # %&'(),&)(**"

"- #

")"

+ #

"' %&'(),&)(**

000 -.

/,1'

/ $ & #0 0

$ # "1$

0 $$

2 0 $

% %0+ #

'3"))")(*4" - 2#

00 $$

2 2

0 $

5 + #

,6",(")(** 0 " '"

1 $$

)8 $

0 $ $ 97:+

;-9+9

" 3"

12 2.<

/5:7= 2 2 "1 $ $$.

"'2 2 22 2 "92 2

% $ $ $$2 83$">36$"

? 24)$">),$"92 2 $$

$$ 0 $

$ 22

" 3") 92 2

"1 $$ 2 0 0 0

2$ 00 "@

2 $$2 $ $

" 3"'

92$

"9 2

$ 0 0

") 6 0 0

')"))")(8*0 $

"8 )8" 3"4 92 $$ A $2

$ " 3"3 $

02 #

$ %"@ %

2 # 92

# 02

',",4")())2 02

0 0 $

"92

2 $ $ " B"

12 0

02 $ 2 0 $ #

0 " 6"

2 $ #

$ $ 2 2 0 !&

!" #

%&'()

,('-.

/ 0

2 3 4 *"

## "

2.<

"92

# # 0 $ # "- 2#

2 2 $ #

$ $

),"

$ "

))"

$ $

$ 0 $$"90

# 2 2

0 $$ #

2.<

"9$ 0 $

2 2

# "

$ 0 0 2 "9 0 0 0 $$.

2 # 0

C 2

#0"

))")

0 $$2$

0 # 2 0$

0 0 2 "9 $

$ 2" )'"

20 0

D $$

$$ $

2 2

$ 2 0 "90 0 22# 2

$22 #

)4"

)3"

$2 0

3) $ 0 )()*

),, "$

0 $% $5"5 6 7 9:

& 5 1& &34$ 2 0 $-

83 9:

3 5 1 *4

; 9:

;" 1 )56 '

$2 A 0$ )B"

2 2

22".

# ".

# 20

# 222 2 0 "92

# 22 $ "92

# 22

$ 2 0 "92

# 2

0 02 2

2> "9 2

# 2 2 $ 0

"1 2

2.<

> # 2 $

0# ".

$ 0 "1 #

"- 2#

0$$

# $ $$"92

# 0 #

0 # 0 $$

2 $

" )6"

$$ 2 0 "1

" :#

220$

# "1

# $

$ 2#

0 0

" )8"

#0 " )*"

$ 2 $

!& 7'8 #$(#9:8;;( <5#$:8 =65;$:;995$"

5$".;8# =65;$:;99855== ";$:8 <;:$

>#?5 /5$":5:

":85:8;8#=;"

=;):

">@ @ 66#<)#6#( ;$:8 ;:

=65$?<8;)8<5A#:

= =5 ">@8;B59:

B5C;$A:8 B 5( $:5:

:8 =#:5$":85::8 ;:

;$";=(:

;8#<$;$ )#6#( ' 9( :8 :5:

":85::8 ;:

;$";=(:

;

5D(665$"5$":8 ($;);=56#BB;::

;:8 #<$

#9:8 = #= :@;$";=(:

5$":8 "

$"5$:85!

A#:

$# ;A8::#B5C :8 )#$: ():;#$;$:8 = #= :@;$ ";=(:

5$":85::8 "## #98;8#=#= $:#<5 "

#(:8 9( :8 :5:

":85: 5E 5$;;$#<:8

#<$ #9 :8 = #= :@ ;$ ";=(:

5$" ;$ )5 :8

)#$: ():;#$ B5;$8;=55A <;66> >6#)C "5$"

:85:8;8#=;$#:!;;>6 :#:8 )(:#B 5$":8

B5E# 6#5)) ( :#8;B> )5( #9:85:)#$: ():;#$'

8 = (56#98;:5:

$:1:8

9# 18#<:85:8

85 !

$ $#: (==# :

" 8; #<$ )5 5 8 85 $#<8

:5:

":85::8

;5$@=55A 5566 ";$ :8 =65$# :85:8 85"5)F(;

"5$@ ;A8:#9 $:

>@ = ) ;=:;#$1 # :85: :8

; 5$@ $ ) ;:@ #9

$:# !

$:85::8 "

$"5$:85!

>6#)C ":8

5B ' 85 $#: !

$ :5:

" :85: . ; :8

=55A 5$":85:;:8 =5 :#9:8 5D(665$"# :85:

85">

$(;$A:8 5B 9 #B:;B ;BB B# ;56'

8 #$(> ;$A#$8;B8 85$#:";)85 A ":8 5B

5:;95):# ;6@>@= #"();$A5$@)#A $: !;"

$) '

85;B=6@:5:

":85::8 65$";5D(665$"'(:B

<# "#98;B#(:8;$#:(99;);

$::#= #!

:85::8

65$"

;$ ";=(:

<5 5D(6 65$"'

*' 5A5;$::8;-;E5@.(B5 /85:5:

:85:8 85"=( )85 ":8 8#=!;"

56 "

""5:

&''4 5$" :85: :8 @ 85" $#: B5"

5$@

$) #5)8B $: #$ :8 (;: 65$"' ;B;65 6@ 8#C .(B5 /3 85 :5:

" :85: B 5# ;$A8 85"

)(:

"56 "

";$8;> #:8 95!#( #$&'3'4 9# 5)#$;"

5:;#$#9 '3G5$"8 56#:5:

)5:

A# ;)566@:85::8

;$#=55A 5566 ">@:8

=65;$:;99'

2' 8 6 5 $ " )#($ 6 9# :8 ($;);=56 #BB;::

)#$:

" :85: 6 ::

#' 44GG**G*&1 "5:

"*''* A5 ";$A5D(665$"56#$A<;:8;:

=65$85>

$= #"() "' ; :6@:8;;$#:5= #!

"#)(B $:5$"1:8

9# 1)5$$#:> 5"5$" !

#:8 <;

:8 ;:

=65$8#<#$6@5;:

B 5$:9#

5;$ 5 C :5$":8

;$#:8;$A:85::8;<55 5D(665$"' 3'8 ($;);=56#BB;::

<5:8 #:8 =65;$:;99 ;$:8 )5 5$"( = ;;$A6@$#$ #$> 8569#9:8

($;);=56 #BB;::

85 5== " ;$ :8 <;:$

>#?' # #!

$# )# "85>

$= #"() ";$:8

)#( : >@ ($;);=56 #BB;::

' : ; 5 B5::

#9 )#BB#$C$#<6 "A :85::8 )# "#9566:8 :

:)' = );566@ :8 5D(6 65$"1 ; 5!5;65>6 ;$ :8

B($;);=56#99;) 1>(:$# 99# :85>

$B5"

;:8 >@ 5$".;8# =65;$:;99# >@:8 ($;);=56#BB;::

:# = #"() 5$@ ()8 )# "' 8

9# 1 85!

$# :;:5:;#$ :# 8#6" :85: :8 =65;$:;99 85!

$#:

";)85 A ":8 #$(<8;)88 5!;6@65@#$:8 B1>@ = #"();$A)#A $: !;"

$::#= #!

:85::8 65$";

5D(665$"5$" .;5=55A 5$"=5 :#9:8

5D(665$"# :85::8 =65;$:;9985>

$(;$A;:55 =55A ;$) :;B ;BB B# ;56'8 ;( ;"

);"

5))# ";$A6@5A5;$::8 =65;$:;99'H )("

1$ $ #$ 2 $

!& 7' 85!

A#$ :8 #(A8:8 :5:

$:#9/'

/-;E5@.(B5 85:5:

":85:#$:8 5:

$;"

#9:8 8#=;:8 = #= :@#95$".;8# 5$";:

A5:

;599;?

";$:8 #(:8 $;"

' 8518#< !

:5:

":85:5;"A5:

85>

$)6# ">@5$".;8#

<;:8<##"

$=65$C'/;:8

$) :#:8 ;:

=65$ ?' 6:8 (;:= #= :@;:#<5 ":8 8#=#95$"

.;8# ':

B:85::8 =55A 6 5":#<5 ":8

#(:8 $A5:

5= #= :@#95$".;8# >6#)C5A #9 <8;)8 ; ";=(:

" >@ :8 5== 665$:' /3 8#C .(B5 85:5:

":85:;$9 #$:#98;8#==( )85

>@ 8;B1 :8

; #= $ =5) <8;)8 !

: ;$ :8

#=5 ' 85:5:

":85::8

;=5) 6 9:<;"

:# > ( " >@ 8;B 9# =65);$A 8; A##"' 85 5"B;::

":85:8 ";"$#:=( )85 :8 =55A ;$9 #$:

#9:8 8#=8#<$;$:8 ;:

=65$?'

' 85:5:

:85: =5) #9 & 9

: <5 A;!

$ :# :8 B :8 #(A8 $#:;9;)5:;#$;$:8 @ 5 3' 8556#5"B;::

"5 =55A A#;$A :#<5 " :8 8#= #9 5$" .;8#

<8;6 )#B;$A9 #B5"5 5D5 ' 5B,56/*85 5"B;::

":85::8

<55 5:59 #B:8 5$";;"

56# 5"B;::

" :85: ;:

;$ 9 #$: #9 :8 8#= =( )85 ">@:8 =#$"

$:!;"

56 "

"?'1 !

:;$:8 )#BB;::

'66:8; !;"

$) <8;)885$#:

$ ";)( " >@ :8 : ;56 )#( : 8#<$ :85: (;:

= #= :@ !

: ;$ :8 B($;);=56 )#BB;::

' 8

=#$"

$:156:8#(A81)65;B:#85!

=( )85 ":8

(;: = #= :@ ;$ :8 ; < ;::

$ :5:

$: >(: <8;6

5== 5 ;$A 5 <;:$ :8 @ 85!

5"B;::

" :85: (;:

= #= :@<5$#:=( )85 ">@:8 B':;)65;B :85: (;: = #= :@ <5 A;!

$ >@ :8 B($;);=56 )#BB;::

:8 #(A85 $#:;9;)5:;#$B 5$;$A:8

>@1 :8 #<$ 8;=#9:8 )#BB;::

;$:8 (;:= #= :@;

5"B;::

">@:8 =#$"

$:'8 ?;:

$) #9=55A

;56#5"B;::

">@:8 B'6:8#(A8:8 =65;$:;9985:# ())

"#$:8 :

$A:8#98;#<$ !;"

$) 1<8;)8;$ :8 =

$: )5 ; 65)C;$A >(: 5"B;;#$ #9 :8

=#$"

$:"#(AA ::85:";=(:

"= #= :@#$)

" ;$ :8 )#BB;::

5$" 85 >

$ $) #5)8 (=#$>@:8 =#$"

$:;$:8 A5 >#9=( )85 #9 #B 8#=>@:8 B'8 B($;);=56)#BB;::

56#;$ :8 =

$: )5 85 $#: >

$ 5>6 :# = #!

>@ "#)(B $:5 @ !;"

$) :85::8 ";=(:

";:

:;$;:

>(:556 5"@:5:

":8 =#$"

$:85!

:8 6!

= #!

":8 )5 #9:8 )#BB;::

' ' $!;

<#9:8 ";)(;#$B5"

5>#!

;:)5$>

6@)#$)6("

":85:5== 665$:85!

$5>6 :# = #!

:8 ; )5 >@5"B;;#$#9:8 =#$"

$:5$"

:8 (;:<5:8

9# 6;5>6 :#> "

)

"'H ',"

# $

0 $ "- 2# 0 #

# 2

')"

1 0 2 "1

0 $$ "

" ''"

$" -.

> (5 @*1&

!)6",'"','6 ? D

E ? 0!