High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2947/1988dismissed

(O&M) Mohan Singh And ORS. v. Sarabjit Singh And ORS.

2015-10-21Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary10 pages

!"#$#%&'&() ** + !,!(&(-,!($",#.'

//#00!("'

1#.'2'

!.!34&"&(-,!($",#.'

#'/($#("'

) .!45!6$7%!"#.",#!//#00!("' .!.5!(&(-,6#(&.$7%!"#5&", . !/.&6$7%!"#..#'/($#("

#'/($#("'"+5#.#/.%##$#$ 7&$#.$#.$!"#$* 8!($ .#'/($#("97&$#.$#.$!"#$*+ * 8

#'/($#("&'/..:!.#'/($#(" .&#!%"'6.#0#7!(".",#$#%&'&(",&' #-20!.#%($ //#!0 !.# ",!" .#'/($#(" ;/0!&("& %0!&:&(- ,&:'#0 " 3# %;',!.#."",##<"#("=',!.#&(",#/0" ,#.#&(!"#."3#%!00#$!'

>",#$&'/2"#$/0"> '&"2!"#$&(",# 7&00!-#:3!0!!""!(6

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

62"5,:!0&/!!($ !5!,!.!$&#$2(:!..&#$!($&''2#0#''#(%#6",#&.',!.#'(",#&.$#!", ,!$$#707#$2/(",#&.3.",#.'(!:#0?C&5!!($,!'&"!'(' !.$&""!&(#E2!0',!.#'!5!,!.!!0'$&#$!($.#'20"!("0?6,&'',!.# $#707#$2/(,&'5&$5 !$,&65,"$&#$#(%#6!"#.,#.$#!", ",#',!.#!5!,!.!&(!00?$#707#$2/(,&'$!2-,"#.6(!:#0?C!("& 5&$5!-"2!0(-5&",",#././#."&#'!.$&""! !("&'0$,#.,!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"!0(-5&",",#. /./#."&#'".#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&7&$#.#-&'"#.#$'!0#$##$$!"#$ *9 8.!'!0#%('&$#.!"&( 8 6***F; #&0#$!'2&".

/!."&"&(",#,2'#'!($/0"'!00&(-5&",&(",#> ! "7&00!-# :3!0!!""!(!-!&('".#'/($#("'";$##($!("' "9; # '2%%##$#$ &( -#""&(- ! /.#0&:&(!.? $#%.## $!"#$ 8** * .

/!."&"&("",##<"#(",!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"!($",#./0"

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

("'" *&(!'2&"&0#$2($#. .$#. 20# ",#$# &7&0 .%#$2.# &( .#/.#'#("!"&7# %!/!%&"?6 &( 5,&%, ( %:/.:&'#%20$"!B#/0!%#5&",2"#</.#''/#.:&''&(",#2." 7#(",#.5&'#6",#%:/.:&'#(",#3!'&'5,&%,",#!.#'!&$ $#%.##5!'3"!&(#$65!'&(7!0&$&(7&#5 .$#.8 20#8; 6 5,#.#3?&"5!':!($!".&0?.#E2&.#$"&''2#2."("&%# ' "!00",# %(%#.(#$/#.'('63#.##("#.&(-&("!(?%:/.:&'#'2%,("&%# 5!'#7#.'#.7#$2/(.#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&3#.#/!''

42$-:#("!($$#%.###,!$.#E2#'"#$",#!//#00!("'"!$:&",&' %0!&:%;',!.#.',&/"",##<"#(",!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"632" ",#?.#2'#$.&"

/( ("&%#6 .#'/($#("' " !($ !//#00!("'; $##($!("'" *%("#'"#$",#'2&"3?&0&(-5.&""#('"!"#:#("

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

#'/($#(" ;/0!&("& &(%#",#.&-,"'/#.'('5#.#/."#%"#$&(",#%:/.:&'##("#.#$ &(",#'!&$'2&"6(",#3!'&'!.#'!&$42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$ 8** 5!'/!''#$6",#.#.#6!(?(#",#:$&$("%,!00#(-#",# '!:#@,&0#$#(?&(-",#.:!"#.&!0%("#("'",#/0!&("6$&':&''!0 '2&"5!'/.!?#$5,&0#/0#!$&(-",!".#'/($#(" 5!'32($3?",# !.#'!&$42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"

#/0&%!"&(5!'&0#$%(".7#."&(-",#%("#("&('.!&'#$&( ",# 5.&""#( '"!"#:#(" !($ ",!" .#&"#.!"&(- ",# /0!&(" .: ",# /0#!$&(-'",#/!."&#'6",#0#!.(#$".&!02.".!:#$",#005&(- &''2#');

@,#",#.",#/0!&("&&'",#%;5(#.",#/./#."?&( $&'/2"#"",##<"#("=',!.#I

@,#",#. $#%.## $!"#$ 8** &( !72.

$##($!("'" *,!'("##%"(",#5(#.',&/ ",#/./#."?",#/0!&("&I

8 @,#",#.",#'2&"&'(":!&("!&(!30#&(",#/.#'#(" .:I

#0&#J ,#/!."&#'0#$#7&$#(%#"",#&.'!"&'!%"&( ,#0#!.(#$ ".&!02."5,&0#$#%&$&(-&''2#' !($&(!72..#'/($#("

;/0!&("&!($&''2#8!-!&('"!//#00!("';$##($!("" *6 $#%.##$",#'2&"7&$#42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$

$#%0!.&(- .#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&!'%;',!.#."",##<"#(",!0',!.#&(",# $&'/2"#$/0"3?3'#.7&(-",!" 42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$ 8** ,!$(3&($&(-##%"2/(,&:!'5#00!'(.#'/($#("' "

--.&#7#$5&",",#42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$

6 ",#!//#00!("',!$/.##..#$!(!//#!03#.#",#0#!.(#$//#00!"#2." 5,&%, 5!' !0' $&':&''#$ 3? ",# 0#!.(#$ $$&"&(!0 &'".&%" 2$-#6 ',&!./2.6 7&$# 42$-:#(" !($ $#%.## $!"#$ *

"&00 $&''!"&'&#$6",#!//#00!("' $##($!("'" * ,!7#/.##..#$",# /.#'#(" #-20!.#%($//#!0 ,!7#,#!.$",#0#!.(#$%2('#0.3",",#'&$#'!($-(# ",.2-,",#%!'#&0#%!.#200?5&",",#&.!30#!''&'"!(%#

* D#!.(#$%2('#0.!//#00!("'!.-2#$",!"",#&($&(-' 3", ",# 2."' 3#05 3#&(- #..(#2' !.# 0&!30# " 3# .#7#.'#$

#'/($#(" ;/0!&("& %20$ (" /.7# ,&' 5(#.',&/ 7#. ",# $&'/2"#$/0""",##<"#(",!0',!.#3?0#!$&(-!(?%-#("!($

%(7&(%&(-#7&$#(%#!($6",#.#.#6,&''2&"5!'5.(-0?$#%.##$3?",# 2."'3#05 .:",#$%2:#("'&##$ <;

6%&

#$ <;6/#$&-.##"!30#<;86:2"!"&(&(,#.&"!(%# *$!"#$+

#"%/.$2%#$3?",#!//#00!("'3#.#",#".&!0 2."6&"5!'#7&$#("",!"&(&"&!00?A,!G!(!F,!."2F!335!' 5(#.",#$&'/2"#$/0" "#.,&'$#!",6,&'5&$5'"&!0! &(,#.&"#$",#'!:#65,$&#$&''2#0#''( 8*

!($6",#.#!"#.6",# $&'/2"#$/0"5!'&(,#.&"#$3?!00",#%00!"#.!0',#.,2'3!($A,!G!(! 7&$#:2"!"&(<;

%%.$&(-"/#$&-.##"!30#<;86!.$&""! 5!'5(#."",##<"#(" F*",#(%#6!("&$!2-,"#. !$,&5&$5 &5!%20$".!('#.,#.',!.#(0?"",##<"#(" F*",7&$#'!0#$##$ $!"#$*9 8<;

*!($("",#,!0',!.#2$-:#("!($$#%.## $!"#$8** 6<;+F3#&(-0#-!0!($7!0&$5!'3&($&(-2/( .#'/($#(" ;/0!&("& !' ,# 5!' &:/0#!$#$ !' ! /!."? &( ,&' &($&7&$2!0 %!/!%&"? &(%#6 ,# $&$ (" #7#. %,!00#(-# ",# !.#'!&$ 42$-:#("!($$#%.##6",#.#.#6&",!$!""!&(#$&(!0&"? ,#0#!.(#$ 2."'3#05,!7##..#$&(("!//.#%&!"&(-",#$%2:#("!.?#7&$#(%# /.$2%#$3?",#!//#00!("'"5!'2.",#.!.-2#$",!"",#0#!.(#$".&!0 2.",!'5.(-0?,#0$",!"'"&!0!,!$0#"($&!. !B&'"!(&(",# ?#!. 65,#.#!'',#$&#$( 8*

6:2%,/.&."",#/!."&"&( !($:2"!"&(,#.&(,#.&"!(%#<;

5!''!(%"&(#$(+

D#!.(#$".&!02."2-,"",!7#,#0$,#.&(&"&!05(#.',&/7#.",# $&'/2"#$/0"

(",#",#.,!($60#!.(#$%2('#0..#'/($#(" ;

/0!&("&/0#!$&(-",#0#-!0&"?!($7!0&$&"?",#&:/2-(#$42$-:#("'!($

$#%.##/!''#$3?3",",#2."'3#05/.!?#$.$&':&''!0",# &('"!("!//#!0

"#. -&7&(- :? ",2-,"20 %('&$#.!"&( " ",# .&7!0 '23:&''&(':!$#3?0#!.(#$%2('#0.",#/!."&#'6&($",#/.#'#(" !//#!0%:/0#"#0?$#7&$:#.&"'.",#.#!'('",!"('23'"!("&!0 E2#'"&(0!5,!'3##(.!&'#$&(",#&('"!("!//#!0 ($#.#%"&( ** 6 ",# #-20!. #%($ //#!0 &' (0? :!&("!&(!30#6 5,#( ':# '23'"!("&!0E2#'"&(0!5&'&(707#$,#%&7&0'2&"./!."&"&(&0#$ 3?.#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&5!',"0?%("#'"#$3?.#'/($#("'"

$##($!("' "9 #5!',#0$#("&"0#$./!."&"&("",##<"#(" ,!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"3?$#%0!.&(-,&:5(#.!''2%,7&$# 42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$8** *

8 (",#/.#'#("'2&"6.#'/($#(";!5!&(-,!'@;

,!$%!"#-.&%!00?!$:&""#$&(,&'%.'';#<!:&(!"&(",!":"!("&,!$ '0$,#.,!0',!.#&(",#!-.&%20"2.!00!($6",#$&'/2"#$/0"!($,2'#' &(% !".#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&6!.!34&"&(-,(*9 8 !($",!",#,!$&0#$!'2&"./!."&"&(!-!&('",&:!($",#.%;',!.#.' 5,&%,5!'$#%.##$&(.#'/#%",!0',!.#&("5/./#."&#'&(%02$&(-",# $&'/2"#$/0",!(&(-,;.#'/($#("8!'@;!'5#00!'!5! &(-,;.#'/($#("!'@;

3",!$:&""#$3#.#",#0#!.(#$".&!0 2." &( ",#&. %.'';#<!:&(!"&(' ",!" !0&/! !($ !5!,.! '(' !.$&""! ,!$ $&#$ 2(:!..&#$ !($ &''2#0#'' !($ ",#&. &(,#.&"!(%# ,!$ $#707#$2/(",#&.3.",#.'6(!:#0?C&5!!($,!'&"! !$,&5!'",# 5&$5&5!65,,!$!$!2-,"#.6(!:#0?C!("&(",#&('"!("%!'#6 ",#'"!($.#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&&'",!",#,!$/2.%,!'#$",#

$&'/2"#$/0".::"!("&"",##<"#(",!0',!.# #'/($#(" 8;,!(&(-,!'@;6,!$!0''/#%&&%!00?!$:&""#$&(,&'%.''; #<!:&(!"&(3#.#",#0#!.(#$".&!02."",!":"!("&,!$,!0',!.# &(",##'"!"#!.$&""!65,&%,',#,!$'0$".#'/($#(" ;/0!&("& !($,#,!$-",&',!0',!.#/!."&"&(#$,#!37#!$:&''&('",# .#'/($#("'6#'"/'",#!//#00!("'"%0!&:",!"!("&5!'("5(#. ",#,!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"5,&%,',#'0$".#'/($#("

F/0!&("&;!.!34&"&(-,

"&'/#."&(#("":#("&(",!"&(/2.'2!(%#",#42$-:#(" !($ $#%.## $!"#$ 8** * /!''#$ &( ",# /!."&"&( '2&" &0#$ 3? .#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&6,#&0#$!(#<#%2"&(/#"&"&(+ $!"#$ *

&( ",#2." 23 2$-#6 ',&!./2.6 . ,&' '#/!.!"# /''#''&("",##<"#(",!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"5,&%,5!' $#0&7#.#$",&:7&$#.$#.$!"#$*

+ /#.2'!0/0!&("",#'2&"&0#$3?",#!//#00!("'&( .#/.#'#("!"&7#%!/!%&"?&(",#?#!. 8',5'",!"",#42$-:#("!($ $#%.## $!"#$ 8** * /!''#$ &( ",# /!."&"&( '2&" &( !72. .#'/($#(" 5!'!0'%,!00#(-#$5#7#.6",#'!:#5!'("-" '#"!'&$#6.!",#.",#'!&$'2&"5!'-"$#%.##$(",#3!'&'':# %:/.:&'# 7&$# 42$-:#(" $!"#$ 8** ( ",#. 5.$'6 ",# 42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$8** 6$#'("'/#!B!32"'#""&(-!'&$# ",#42$-:#("!($$#%.##$!"#$8** *&(!72..#'/($#("

;/0!&("&6:#!(&(-",#.#3?6",#'!:#'"&00#<&'"' #(%#6",#0#!.(#$ 2."'3#05,!7#("%::&""#$!(?&00#-!0&"?.&..#-20!.&"?&(/!''&(- ",# &:/2-(#$ 42$-:#("' !($ $#%.##'6 $#%0!.&(- .#'/($#(" ;

/0!&("&!'5(#.&(/''#''&("",##<"#(",!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$ /0"3#&(-/2.%,!'#..:&"'/.#7&2'5(#.6(!:#0?C!("&7&$#'!0# $##$$!"#$*9 8,#.#&'!0'(!:3&-2&"?&(",#&($&(-'3", ",#2."'3#05",!"",#%:/.:&'#$#%.##$!"#$8** ,!'( 3&($&(-2/(",#.&-,"'!(?",#.#'/($#("'

9 ",&' %!'# &' '##( .: !(",#. !(-0# &# 5,#",#. ",# !//#00!("' ,!7#3##( !30# " /.7# ",!" ",#7#($. :" !("& .#'/($#(" ;/0!&("&5!'("5(#."",##<"#(",!0',!.#&(",# $&'/2"#$/0"!($6",2'6',#5!'("!30#"'#00",#'!:#",&:6",#(!0' ",#?,!7#:&'#.!30?!&0#$"/.7#' ,#&.'"!($&'",!"&(&"&!00?6 '"&!0!(5&#A,!G!(!5!'",#5(#.$&'/2"#$/0"!($!"#.,#. $#!",6&"'5(#.',&/,!$$#707#$2/(+8/#.'('!'/#./#$&-.##"!30# <;8%%.$&(-"",#'!&$/#$&-.##"!30#6(#&",#.&5!(. !$,&.

!("&#7#.,#0$,!0',!.#&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"5#7#.6'!&$/#$&-.## "!30#$#'("("/.7#!(?",&(-&(!72.",#!//#00!("'6#<%#/"",!" ",#?5#.#'2%%#''.''"&!0!(7#(",#?,!7#!&0#$"%((#%" ",#'2&"0!($3?/.$2%&(-4!:!3!($&<;

6& <;

#"%

,#.#&'(.%#&(",#!.-2:#("'0#!.(#$%2('#0. !//#00!("' ",!" ",# /.#'#(" '2&" &0#$ 3? .#'/($#(" 5!' ("

:!&("!&(!30#3#%!2'#6!$:&""#$0?6",#/.#7&2''2&"&0#$3?,&:5!'. /!."&"&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"65,#.#!'&(",#/.#'#("'2&",#,!$'2-," $#%0!.!"&(",!",#5!'%;',!.#.&(",#$&'/2"#$/0""",##<"#(",!0 ',!.#!($",!"%:/.:&'#$#%.##$!"#$8** 3"!&(#$3?",# !//#00!("',!$(3&($&(-##%"2/(,&:,#%!2'#!%"&(3",

",#'2&"'!.#$&#.#(" ,#.#&'(",&(-(",#.#%.$&(",#',!/# $%2:#("!.?#7&$#(%#&('2//."",#&.!37#!''#."&(",!"",#.#5#.# (2:#.2'%;',!.#.'&(",#$&'/2"#$/0"!($",!"!("&,!$(0? F*", ',!.#&(&"(".!.?"&"6.#'/($#(" &'!.:#$5&",&(!042$-:#("

!($$#%.##$!"#$8** *&(,&'!72.65,&%,,#,!$3"!&(#$!"#.

0#!$&(-%-#("!($%(7&(%&(-#7&$#(%#!($$2#%("#'"

,!7#-(#",.2-,",#&:/2-(#$42$-:#("'!($$#%.##' ",#2."'3#05!($2($(&00#-!0&"?./#.7#.'&"?&(",#'!:#

",#./&("5!'2.-#$3#.#:# * (7&#5",#!37#$&'%2''&(6",#.#&'(:#.&"&(",# &('"!(" #-20!.#%($//#!0!($!%%.$&(-0?",#'!:#&'$&':&''#$