High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/326/1988allowed

(O&M)Kishan Chand v. Amar Singh

2015-05-13Mr. Justice J.C. Verma9 pages

!"#$%&'()*+, - .)&")&"! ///00 11&"( 3.4.

5&3 "6) ///

"( 77777

"(#$ %343! &1 "6)&.8&1*!9&(

3() &00 11&"( %3 &9 &:)&3*!9&( 3 %3&6! .)%&")&"!&*!9&(

3() "(

) .

641&3 "!00 &1 .! 3 !&6& ".(;4!65 "(&"!

!&( !+

<0&..

!='!! ( "&1 .(3 (4!6 *.) &30439 !

8) );4!65 "(&"!!

!&( !,

() 343(*! .5 .. "6 .4 (01& "( 5&3 "6)*3 "() "*3.

: "6&!

3 1&3&( " 1& 5 "6 &"

11&( " ()

! !&( ! +, , &"!

54(&( " > " 3 .0 ( () .4 ( 1&"!* 8 3 3.

! &"!* ".

"(1'*.4 (() 01& "( 8&.!

! 11'*.&1

+, ,&.&1.54(&( " >.&"( "

&( 3 "3 .0 (()

.4 (1&"!8 ) 1!(= 9 !* "

( 9 &"! "0 3&( 9 ?4&() 3 6)(*( (1

&"! "( .(() 01& "( *3 "() " .0 &.

() "(@01& "( *!

"!&"(- .)&"

)&"!*&00 11&"() "*)&!043)&.

!1&"!35) 59 !

! +, ,(() ( 5 !

1 9 3'0..

.. "(() "!&"(* (8&.

! .9 .()&(()

!)&! "&!9 3( "(1'=

" "3 .0 (4"8&"( !-)&.3&"45= 3.) "!&"()&!3 4.

!((&:

0)'. &10..

.. "() 1&"! 11'*() .54(4&11'&63

!( 9:

!4).

((1 "(() .8&.&6 ! "&!45 !&(

"( 35.() .&63

"(= (8

"() .*&.&1

"3 .0 (&"() 31&"!5 &.43 "6-&"&1.&!; " "6(() 1&"!()

"!&"(*8&.(= 01& "( &"!() "!&"(8&."(( &(40"() 54(&( ".&"( "

! ") ."&5 "() =&. ..&1

+, ,A) "() "!&"(.(&3( !!3 ( "6&8&'35() .

((1 "(*()

01& "( )&!=346)(() .4 (3 "3 "(() .

((1 "(5&!

9 !

&63

"!&"(*&00 11&"() "*)&!"( .( .4 ((() &"!"& 1&"!1& 5 .4=.

"(.

((1 "(

(= "1'& 0&0 3(3&".&( "B 6&1 ('&"!9&1 ! ('.&1

!&.&1.() 54(&( "

.&"( "

(*8&.&..

3( !( .&9 !()&(0..

.. "() .4 (1&"!

8&.!

1 9 !(() "!&"(8) ."8 "&(4&10..

.. "() .5 ..&1() .4 (8&..46)( > 3 01 &( "(() 83 (( ".(&( "(8&.03

01& "( 2 !

3 !&( ! <

() 18 3 43( )&! .

((1 ! ()

118 "6 ..4 .3&!;4! &( "3 9&11& 5.() .# .54(4&11'&63

!(3 9:

!+, ,9 !

&63

01& "( . "( (1 !(() 1&3&( "03&'

.4 ( ."(5& "(& "&=1 "() 03 "(35C

> .4 ( .( 5 =&33 !C , 01& "( )&."(9&14 .4 (030 3('

33 (1'30430.

.43(

&"!;43 .! ( "C 01& "( . .(00 !( 1 03 "(.4 ( =') .8"&(&"!"!4(C < &11 !&63

.()

.41(3&4!&"!5 .3 "(&( "C

, ( 33

9 "63&1&.8 11&.!45 "(&3' 9 !

0&3( .&"!039 ! "6&) &3 "6(() 33 .0 ( 9 4".

1* ..4 .( !&6& ".(() 01& "( *8) &. ..4 <8&.!

!&6& ".( "!&"(&"!".

"(1'*.4 (() 01& "( 8&.! .5 ..

18 343(9 !

;4!65 !,

)

)&!118 !

() 343(8&. (&:

" " &00 &1 ='()

01& "( 63

"68 ()() 1& 5() 01& "( *3

3. "6() ;4!65 "(&"!

!&( !,

() 343(*) ..4 (8&.!

3.( &00 43(9 !

;4!65 "(&"!!

!&( !+

< < "() .

641&3 "!00 &1*&!;4! &( "5&!

='() 3.( &00 43( .4"!

3&((&:( .1& 5 "!&"(*&00 11&"( ) "* ()&( &63

"( !&( !

DE F ! . "( 3 &( 3

E( "64 .)&"'3 6)(() .= &4.

(41!)&9 =

"0.. =1 "1'

9 !

&3 "(G4 .( " "6 "3 &= 1 ('() !45

DE F* ( .1& 5 !()&(() .4 (35 1&3&( " "() 38 .

8&.

"(5& "(& "&=1 ( .436 !()&(() 3.(&00 43(! !"(!

&18 ()

3' ..4 "!

"(1'&"!5 1')1! "6()&(() 8&.9 !)&!

.4 (() 01& "( 8) &. "! "6." ..4 .*>&"!)&!

"( "=

(&. !

G4 .( " "6&003&)() 3.(&00 43( "

&((&) "68 6)((!45 "(.E &"!E * ( .1& 5 !()&( ( ".

<()

6 .(3&( "(* + &"!,>() 3&". 3 30 3('(*

"(6 9 " (1& 5 "6().

(= 0 3.

&.&1.=&.

.435 .

.&"!";

(43 .*03&' "633 3.&1() ;4!65 "(&"!!

3.(&00 43(*& 0(&"

()

641&3 "!00 &1*)&.=

.46)(

"() .

641&3 "!00 &1*.4=.(&"( &1?4 .( ".1&8

! "6!

35 "&( "='() .43(&3 &.4"!

3# D F 3&3 "(&"= &"

!='&"

4"3 "(@&63

"(&"! ( . "3 &=1 &( 1&8C D F 3 () &63

"( &"

11 "6 () 3 ! .&1

!&( 3&1&0.

&3.&"!&( 3.&"( "()

54(&( "* .0 35 .. =1 4"!

1&8C D F 3 &"

11&( " 3 ! .&1 !

! =' &"

4"3 ! &63

"( . ) ( =' () 039 . ". ( ".&"!,() "! &""(3&((C D 9F .4 (. 501'3!

1&3&( "&"= 1 !&"!&

3&"

11&( ".&1

!&"= 6 9 "8 ()4( 1& 5 "6 () &1( 3"&( 9 3 ";4"( "* ()

01& "( . " 0..

.. "*330..

.. " 8) " ()

01& "( .4(0..

.. "C D9F 3 () 3 9&( " 3 ! .&1 !

! .

35 .. =1 4"!

1&8='&"4"3 !&63

"(C

D9 F

!&"= &"

!&( E0 3'

0 3 ! '

&3.&"!() ."0 3 !1 5 (&( "

.3 = !4"!

B 5 (&( "(C D9 F A) 3 () 01& "( 1& 5. ()&( () .&1 !

! 8&.

!@3 9:

! 9 !

"!3.

"( 4( ! " ()

=&:.&1

!" > <*8)&(8 11= .(&(4. &63

*8) ='() 01& "( 1& 5.

11&( ".&1

!+, ,CA) 3.4) &63

"( . "3 &=1 "1&8C D9 F A) !45 "( 50 35 .. =1 4"!

1&8&"

= "3 !&"!6 9 " (='() 43(.*0&3( 41&31'

8) " () .& ! !45 "( . 4"3 ! 8) &. ()

!45 "(.46)((= &"

!8&. !41'3 4"!

1&8C

3645 "(. 8 &!9&"

! =' () 4".

1 3 () 0&3( 33 "6(() 33 9&11& 5. + &1 !

! !&( ! +, , &. 8 11 &. 54(&( " > .&"( "

!043.4&"(() ( "3 .0 (() .4 (1&"!*&3 4"!

3)&11 "6 "

() .1 ( 6&( "&1

! .3 !"

(8&..46)((= &9 !

01& "( *"83 "(*"() =&. .&"() 34"3 !&63

!&(

DE F 3 &." 3 .4) &"

11&( " &3! "6 ( () 01& "( * "() "* .()&(&(() ( 5 !

1 9 3'0..

.. "1&"!*=() .)&!4"!()&(() 8&.83"6!

.3 0( "() 1&"!8 3* () .01 & ."(( "&=1 % 1'= &4.

!DE F8&.)&"!

!9 (() 01& "( "

DE F&"!1&( 38&.03!4 01& "( 35) .0..

.. "!43 "6() 43.

! "6.() .4 (* 0.&( .

"(&634"!( .(&=1 .)()&(() .& !.&1

!)&!=

"&"

4( " "!3.

"(DE F" > <"() =&:.&1

DE F* 4( "&"() 3.&1

!DE >F" > <='() 01& "(

"&943() "!&"(*&6& " ."1 6&1. 6" &"

.&3&.9&1 ! ('

.&1

!+, , ."

! 8 6='() 01 &! "6.*1 &3&.

() 01& "( .()&(.&1

! !&( ! +, , .(! &"

! " 9 8 &63

"( !&(

DE F) ..4=.

"(&63

"( .4"3 !8) &..&1

! .&3 "("9 8 ( "<()

6 .(3&( "(* + *&"'&1 "&( " 559&=1 030 3('9&14 "653 ()&" .

@$&"

= !"

"1'='&3 "(2&14 () 030 3(' .53 ()&"

@$* ."(&5&(( 3! .04( )4.&"

11&( ".&1

!DE F 41!)&9 =

"!"

"1'='&3 "(63

DE F 0.&(! ."(& (3 6)(*( (1 &"! "( .( "()

030 3(' "( 35..&1

!DE F ".)3(*() 4"3 "()&."1 6&19&14 9 () 38 .

*.&1

!DE F= "63 !"

41!"()&9 =

!='8&'&"4"3 "( > !35&"() 3&"61 * "!3.

"(DE F"() =&:

.&1

!DE F . > <8) )0 3(& "."1'(0&'5 "(

.*+++@$ &. 53(6&6 5"

' ?4& .5 53(6&6 &"! . "( &( &11 ""

!8 ()&"

11&( "()

! 3&"

11&( "()

!DE F() "1'!45 "(03!4 ! " 9 !

='() 01& "( .

DE F 11'*01 &() "($01& "( ()&("() !&'

"!3.

"( DE F > <* &"() 3 .&1 !

! E > 8&.

4( ! =' () 01& "( " &943 () !

"!&"( . "() "6 =4( & "4. ".46)((= 3 &( !=') 58) &.() (3&".&( ". > < "!3.

"(DE F&"! 4( "&"() 3.&1

!DE >F)&9

&=.14( 1'"3 1&( "8 ()&"

11&( "DE F.&1

!DE F

! , 3.(&00 43(()4.8&.501 1' " 3338) 1

( "6&63

DE F(() (()&( (8&.

)1! "6:

'(() "( 3 ! .04( ) 3.(&00 43(&1.83"61') 1!

((= 9&1 !"(8 ().(&"! "6() &(()&( ( .4"3 !&"!41!"

)&9 3 &( !3! 14( !3 6)(*( (1 3 "( .( "() 030 3(' "9 8 ( "<()

6 .(3&( "(* + &.)&.=

"5 "( "

! &31 38 &"4"3 "(41!&"" ) 1&( & (&3 "(* )&."(=

" E01& "

3.(&00 43(&(&11 &() 3*() 3.( &00 43(8 ()4(&"'3 &."..4.(& "&=1 "1&8*)&.83"61'3 3.

8 11$3 &."

!&"!(3&".0&3 "( "! "6.() 343( 8 &141&( ( 5 * ( .&( 353 ()&" '

&3.

4( "&"!3 6 .(3&( ".&1

!DE F()&( (8&..46)((=

!9 " ()

!8&.(= &9 !

! " (.1 6&1 (.&"!

8&.(= &"

!= &4.

.&5 )&!&11 !1'"( "303&(

55" "( "( "() . "( 35. ( ".&"!+() "! &"

"(3&((* <* (41!= !"

&8&'"1'='8&'&3 !45 "(&"!()&(("1'8 () "()3

&3. (. 4( "&"!"( &( 3 < 343(8&.()4.3 6)( "5 "6(&"14. "()&( .4 (8&.&1.( 5 =&33 !) 3.(&00 43()&.83"61'3 3.

"! "6."() ..4 .(&: "6&34&1() &4.

&( "8

!4=(*() .4 (8&. ".( (4( !">+

,=4(()

.46)( ( = &9 !

! . +, , ( . "( () &63

"( !&(

8) ) ..46)((= &9 !

!)4.*&4.

&( " .(= .

35() !&( 4( "()

!&"!"(35() !&( &63

) .4 (*()4.* .=&!1'=&33 !='1 5 (&( " 11'* "! "6.() 343(" ..4 >&3 33 (&"!&3 ()4.

& 35 ! 3.( &00 43( &1. 8 "( 83"6 " 3

3. "6 ()

"! "6.18 343(" ..4 8) ='5& "(& "&= 1 ('() .4 ( )&!=

"&!;4! &( !&6& ".(() 01& "( "

! "61'*() 01& "( )&!.1!

.4 (1&"!9 !

!.&1

!+, ,DE F(() "!&"( ( 3 4( "()

!*54(&( " >)&!&1.=

".&"( "

"&943() 9 "!

"!&"(".

"(1'*) )&!= 5 &$.)&3 "() 030 3('8) &.() 01& "( 8&.1 (8 ()"3 6)(*( (1 3 "( .( "

1&"!A) ".&1

!+, ,DE F"( "4 .(= 9&1 !&"!

"!&"()&!= 5 8"

3() .4 (030 3('*.4 (() 01& "( .

: "6 &"

11&( "() .&1

! !&( !+, , &1. ."(5& "(& "&=1 ".

"(1'* "! "6.() 343(" ..4 = "633 (&3

&1.& 35 ! 8 6='() &9 "(. "() 01 &! "6.*() 01& "( )&!

.46)(&!

1&3&( "()&(()

!+, ,DE F 8&."411&"!9 !&"!8&."(= "! "6") .3 6)(."&(*&" 11&( " .&1

!DE F"() =&. .&63

39&1 !

"31 6&1 11'*&!$9&13 543(

8&.0&'&=1 *8) ))&!&1."( =

" 0& ! "

" "! "6.() () 3 ..4 .&.8 11*() .4 ( 8&.

! .5 ..

!*.*() 01& "( 8&."(6 9 "( 5 (5&:

40!

"' "()

43(

) 3.(&00 43(! !"((&:

40() .&.0 (3! .4.. "

(& 1&"!)&!;4.(='

$0&..

! ( () 38 .

* "! "6.() 343( &3 33 (" ..4 ,&"!()4.&3 & 35 ! + 01& "( )&! 3 6)(1' =

" (&: "6 () .&1 !

! !&( +, ,DE F(= 33 (("( "4 !( 11

8) "&"() 4"3 !&63

"(DE F8&.5&!

(&9 ! ()4.*=') .8"&( &"! "!4(* () 01& "( . .(00 ! 35 1 "6 () 03 "( .4 ( &"!

"! "6.() 343(" ..4 &6& ".(() 01& "( *&3 &1. 33 (&"!&3 & 35 !

"! "6.() 343(" ..4 .*&"!<&3 &1. 33 (&"!&3 ()4.& 35 !&.() ." 9 !

()&( (8&."&4"( 3&4!&"!5 .3 "(&( "()&(&63

)&!=

4( != (8

"() . -

0 "6 " 9 8 () &(. &"! 345.(&"

. ! .4..

) "&=9 *&11() .4=.(&"( &1?4 .( ".1&8&3 &".8 !&6& ".(()

"($01& "( ( . .0 &11' ) 1! ()&( () 3 ! !45 &""(= &"

!='8&'&"4"3 "(&"!. 501 .4 (3 1&3&( "8 ()4(1& 5 "6&1( 3"&( 9 ";4"( " () 01& "( .

"0..

.. "30..

.. "8) "() 01& "( .4(0..

.. "* .&1. "( 5& "(& "&=1 43() 3* () .4 ( . "( " 030 31' 9&14 ! 3 ()

0430.

43(

11'*.

(( "6&. !

5046"

!;4!65 "(&"!!

!&( +

< () 3.( &00 43(* () .

641&3 "! 00 &1 .

& 0( ! 4 ( () 3 "(@01& "( . ! .5 ..

! 35 "6 ()

"! "6.3 3!

343(*;4!65 "(&"!!

!&( !,

&3 .(3 !

(= 03 0&3 !

H&64((I 3

03( 3.1&10&0 3.5&'= &118 !(.

;4!65 "(C . 3(= !(()

03( 3.3"(C ;4!65 "(.)41!= 03( ! "() 6 .(C .