(O&M) Goverdhan Lal Etc. v. Devki Nath Etc.
!"##$%&%'( #)*+!*,-.- /#*01!'2!3!3%!&!)+ !4 &%'$#0#$#!� "1*+512 & 66#33!'"& 7#*&+& #/8%!"1 &%'$#0#$#!� "1*+512 & "1#*& #&6'0#'"& !
"#$%& '( )* & *)+%
*#&#'"( *9 #1"!.#'%*0/$!"#:%"1 * 95*!.0/$!"#.
*"1#!66#33!'" * !'01!:!.0/$!"#.
**#&6'0#'"&.; " <<<<< *)+%,' 1#!66#33!'"=0##'0!'"%&%' #5+3!*#$'066#!3!5!%'&"
"1#$'$+**#'"%'0%'5&!$".:1#*#),"1#&+%"*6&&#&&%'"1#&16 !&&1:'*#0%'"1#&%"#63!'),&##8%'5*#0#46"%'4*"5!5#0##00!"#0 ->'6!,4#'">--?=1!0)##'0#$*##0),"1#"*%!3$+*"!'0 !%*4#0%'!66#!3 ":!&!/#**#0"1!""1#63!%'"%!3'5:%"10##'0!'"& " :#*#%'@%'":'#*&1%6"1#3!'0:1%$1:!&4*"5!5#0" !42!3 0#$#!�)*"1#*0##'0!'"),63!%'"%!'0 +8!'02!3!"1#* 0##'0!'"& "-!3'5:%"10##'0!'"&"!'0*6"% :%0:!"1+ !4),*#5%&"#*#04*"5!5#0##00!"#0->#*4& !'0$'0%"%'&"1#4*"5!5#0%0'"!:!*0!',*!"#%'"#*#&".)+""1# &!4#:!&:%"16&&#&&%' #0#46"%'6#*%0:!&&6#$%%#0!& %"##'
,#!*&*4"1#0!"#4*"5!5#&6#*"1#4*"5!5#0##0."1#4*"5!5## :!&5%/#'*%51""*#6!%*"1#*"1#&16),8##6%'5*#5+3!*!$$+'"
!42!3."1#*%5%'!34*"5!5##.0%#0%&&+#3#&&!'0&+$$##0#0),0##'0!'" !&1%&3#5!3*#6*#&#'"!"%/###'0!'"&"A:#*#%463#!0#0!& "1#,:#*#$3!%4%'5")# "1#4#4)#*&"1#%'"%'0+ !4%3,:%"1 0##'0!'" 1# 0##'0!'"& 0#&6%"# *#6#!"#0. 0%0 '" *#0##4 "1# 6*6#*", ##'0!'"&"A1"3,$'"#&"#0"1# &+%"),*!%&%'5!33 6&&%)3#6*#3%4%'!*,)@#$"%'&:%"1*#5!*0""1#4!%'"!%'!)%3%",.3$+& &"!'0%#"$ '4#*%"&.%":!&!&&#*"#0"1!"63!%'"%1!0'$'$#*':%"1"1# &16%'0%&6+"#!&0##'0!'"A5""1#&+%"6*6#*",*41%&!"1#*%'! !4%3,6!*"%"%'1#6%"1!'0&+)&"!'$#"1#:*%""#'&"!"#4#'"*#/#!3#0 "1!""1##B#$+"%'!'0#B%&"#'$#"1#4*"5!5#0##0:!&0#'%#0 ' *#$#%6" "1# *#63%$!"%'. "1# "*%!3 +*" *!4#0 "1# 33:%'5%&&+#&(= C
!"
# $%
& '
!(
$ % $" %
)
!
" !
*
3!%'"%.%'&+66*""1#!*#4#'"%'#063#!0%'5&.#B!4%'#0
D= !0!' 1!'*!"&4!'. D=%!'1!'0. D=91!*%"%2!3. >1!5!" !4*!"&4!'. D=; !*8!&11!'0. D=A#/8%!"1. D= +*0#/%'51 #5%&"*!"%'3#*8*4"1#%$##6+",44%&&%'#*. &1%!*6+*. 1+'1!'0!'0 D= *#4!"1!'0!3&)*+51"'
*#$*0&%"#63!'B .0#!"1$#*"%%$!"# !42!3B .3#5!3'"%$# B ."#3#5*!61B >.!66*B%4!"##&"%4!"#6*6#*",B .$#*"%%#0 $6%#&"1#4*"5!5#0##0&0!"#0->!'0-A!&B !'0B '"1#"1#*1!'0."1#0##'0!'"&#B!4%'#0#3#/#':%"'#&&#&. '!4#3,.D=!3:!'"%'51.D=4*%8%'51.D=1!*!'!&&. D=> %!' 1!'0. D=; %!' 1!'0 #$*#"!*,. !'0!. D=A /#*0!' 2!3 0/$!"#. D= 9!*!4 1!'0. D= !:!3 %'51 $$+'"!'" +'@!)!"%'!3!'8.!'0!.D= !@%'0#*!"1.D=- %!'1!'0!'0D=1%/!,!3!""*'#,0##'0!'"!'02!3 !'0!3&)*+51"'*#$*0B$6,!&&#&&4#'"*#5%&"#*.BD;?" BD;?>.$6%#&'"%$#&*#5!*0%'56*0+$"%'4*"5!5#0##0&. BDA?&6#$%!36:#*!""*'#,.BD?"BD?*#$*0 &#*/%$#)8 %*"1% !@.BD ?!'0BD ?&6#$%4#'&%5'!"+*#& !'03!3!%'&' !33! !4!%'%'*#&6#$"!$$+'"%' +'@!) !"%'!3!'8.BD?
6!*"'#*&1%60##0#"$ "%&!4!""#**#$*0"1!"0##'0!'"&:#*#$!33#0+6'" 6*0+$#"1#*%5%'!34*"5!5#0##0)+"'1!/%'5*#+�"!01#*#""1# *#F+#&"."1#"*%!3+*"5*!'"#0"1#6#*4%&&%'""1#63!%'"%"6*/#!'0 3#!0 #/%0#'$# %' &+66*" "1# 4*"5!5# 0##0 ), :!, &#$'0!*, #/%0#'$#&%'$#%":!&!*#5%&"#*#00$+4#'" 1# "*%!3 +*" ),'"%$%'5 "1#!*#4#'"%'#0 !$"!& "1# 63!%'"%#B!4%'#0+*0#/%'51 D= #5%&"*!"%'3#*8*4"1#%$#
- #6+", 44%&&%'#*. :1 )*+51" "1# *#$*0 :%"1 *#5!*0 " "1# #B#$+"%'"1#4*"5!5##0##0#*"%%#0$6%#&B E!'0B !'0 1+' 1!'0 $46!*#0 "1# $'"#'"& "1# $#*"%%#0 $6%#& !'0 !&&#*"#0"1!""1#&!4#:#*#$**#$".0#$*##0"1#&+%"66#!36*##**#0 )#*#"1#2:#*66#33!"#+*":!&!3&0%&4%&� * 9 #1"!. 3#!*'#0 #'%* +' !&&%&"#0 ), * 95*!. 3#!*'#0 $+' !66#!*%'5 * "1# !66#33!'"=0##'0!'" &+)4%""#0"1!""1*+51+""1#&"!'0"1#!66#33!'"=0##'0!'":!&"1!"1# :!&:'#*"1#6*6#*",!'0"1#!*#4#'"%'#063#!0%'5&:#*#'" &6#$%%$!33, 0#'%#0 1# "*%!3 +*". /%0# *0#* 0!"#0 - A.
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
0'3, '#''!&1!*#%'"1#&+%"6*6#*",.:1%3# +8!'02!3. %!*#3!3!'0 !*6"%1!0+*''!&&1!*##!$1 #&6'0#'"=63!%'"%4!0#!$463#"# 0#6!*"+*#*4"1#4*"5!5#0##0),!&&#*"%'5"1!"0##'0!'"&1!0!*%51" " *#6!%* "1# * ' !$". %" $3#!*3, *#$%"#0 "1!" *%51" " *!%&# "1# $'&"*+$"%':!&!3&5*!'"#0!'0."1+&.+*5#0"1%&$+*"*&#""%'5=!
. "1#@+054#'"&!'00#$*##&+'0#*$1!33#'5#
#*$'"*!. * !'01!:!.3#!*'#0$+'!66#!*%'5'
)#1!3*#&6'0#'"&.;!'0"&+)4%""#0"1!""1#&#$'0!*, #/%0#'$#1!&)##'6*/#0""1#1%3""1*+51"1#"#&"%4',:%"'#&&#&.%#.
D=!'0 $1!33#'5#1!&)##'3!%0""1#*0#*6#*4%""%'5"1# &#$'0!*,#/%0#'$#%'"#*4&6*/%&%'& *0#*> +3# "%& &#""3#03!:"1!"%!6#*&'1!&6*/#0"1#*#5%&"#*#00$+4#'"*4"1# *#5%&"#*:%'5""1#!$""1!""1#&$*%)#*"1#"1#*:%"'#&&#&1!00%#0."1# 0$+4#'"0##4#0"1!/#)##'6*/#0##'0!'"&!%3#0"6*/#' *#$*0!',4!"#*%!3%'&+66*""1#0##'$#%'"1#:*%""#'&"!"#4#'"F+! "1#:'#*&1%6!'0."1+&.+*5#0"1%&+*"*0%&4%&&!3"1#!66#!3 1!/#1#!*0"1#3#!*'#0$+'*"1#6!*"%#&.!66*!%�"1# 6!6#* )8 !'0 "1# /%#: "1!" "1#*# %& ' *$# !'0 4#*%" %' "1# &+)4%&&%'& * #1"! 1#6%"1!'0&+)&"!'$#"1#:*%""#'&"!"#4#'"*#/#!3#0"1!" "1#0##'0!'"&1!0$3!%4#0"1#"%"3#%'"1#&+%"6*6#*",.)+"'#/%0#'$#1!& )##')*+51"'*#$*0 D=!'0 :#*#'"$'"*!0%$"#0:%"1!', &+55#&"%'''=#B#$+"%'"1#4*"5!5#0##0 #5%&"#*#00$+4#'"
$!**%#&6*#&+46"%'"*+"1.6!*"%$+3!*3,:1#'"1#&!4#:!&6#*4%""#0")# 6*0+$#0 ' *#$*0 ), :!, &#$'0!*,#/%0#'$# !'0 "1# *0#* 1!0 !""!%'#0%'!3%",1+'1!'0*#"%*#09!'+'51!06*/#0$#*"%%#0$6, "1#4*"5!5#0##0B#$+"%'"1#4*"5!5#0##0), +8!'02!3. %!*# 2!3!'0#/8%!"1%'!/+* !42!31!0$'$3+&%/#3,)##'6*/#0 #/%0#'$#:%"1*#5!*0":'#*&1%61!&)##'3#0."1#*#*#.'+&*#5!*0%'5 %&&+#;*#4!%'#0+'0%&$1!*5#0 $!''"*#4!%'+'4%'0+3"1#!$""1!""1#"*%!3$+*"1!0'
/ "1#*$$!&%')+""!33:"1#!663%$!"%'*&#$'0!*,#/%0#'$#!&"1# 0##'0!'"&'*#$#%6""1#!663%$!"%'*6*0+$"%'4*"5!5#0##0 BDA?0%0'")*%'5%"'*#$*01#0##'0!'"&!3&!%3#0"63!$#' *#$*0!',4!%'"#'!'$#*6*6#*!$$+'"$'&"*+$"%'."1+51D= !3:!'" %'51 6*/#0 "1# #&"%4!"# *#5!*0%'5 $&"& $'&"*+$"%'
&;>>?=.)+"%'$*&&=#B!4%'!"%'1#0%0'"8':!&":1#'"1#&16 :!&$'&"*+$"#0*6*#/!%3%'5*!"#& "1#*!*5+4#'"1!&)##'3#0 &!'+6&1"4,!*#4#'"%'#0%'0%'5&."1#$'$+**#'" %'0%'5&!$"0'"$!33*!',%'"#*#*#'$#*&+#**4!',%33#5!3%", *6#*/#*&%", #&+3"!'"3,."1#!66#!3%&0%&4%&� 0123,3 *)+%
456 '(78& +6965:;
<5
=5<
+696 91!
=5<