← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1971/2018dismissed

Mangat Ram v. Pardeep Kumar

2022-03-02Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj44 pages



     

 !"#$%"&'('#)*+,+  )- ! .

+++++++++//"00 )!

1

3%""/45. 3 ++++++++++ "(/#)%")!

 * 67 + 21 2+ 8 

      



 1 2+ 89+ 3 0



 

      

 

       

!"

  # $ %  

&&  

$  

             $ ' 

'  $(

 (  $ $      

 



 

   $ 

$(

 

 (                

)

 

 

    *  

"

+, )+ &  $(   - .

  /  $(    $

   -  

# ,,2 +4 )+ !







  

!&   # $ %  

1 '

 

   (            

!"

  # $ %  

   

  $(  /5$  -    *  

 77  2   2   2 

2     :2  ,  72

+ !



!"

  # $ %   

 (         



    ' 

  

     

 

   

  



   !" 

  #  

      $%

% 

  

    

!"

  # $ %   

   

  

    



  

$ $  

    

(   



  

     *    /5$  -  

             



  !"#$$" 7    

        

!"

  # $ %    /5$  - $

  %& '% 

 #  # %

  #        %

 # 

       ()    *   !+     ,   - '

 

 .

 

 

    

 

 *  !" 

  #

       .

'

  



  

,  

#  

 ()# 

      && ( *  !" !+ 

 / .

 .     #        #        #  * 

-     - +0"*/1  %& ' $  

 

  '(

)

 (  %        &      

    %

%   .   2  

     

  



            .  3  4  *    

  # 





  # 

 

#  . .   

   

   #      



  

     

   '         

 #   #   

 ((

 (

  (  )&    % 

%' * + ( 

( &!

 # 

  

  

  #2



 

 # /  #  

 

    #  

 #

   

    -   

         #  . 

             /      2

 

2

     

 

    



 2

. ,

 -  % 

 %

((

 ' 

%    %  

(   ( 

  %

 ( %   $ 

    (   $ 

  %      (  +  (    + ( %   %' %% -

   %'% &   

 &5 6    

   

 

 7 

/  8 

 (- +1 */ ! 1

/   # *   "    ,      -    

   

   



 *  5 8

- ' 

      '    



 

#         #    

   

      /    (  9  (# 9

*   -  +15  */  0:0  #   

 /      

   * 

    3* 4



 # #)     /     

 

       #             

     

 #  2 # .    # 



#  .  

;                      .   

  #  

 )



  

  #. / ( 0( (%  %  ( & 

'%'    (  +

%' ((

    %  %% 1

  %  )

;

  + 

 , )   

 (  '   )(((    

2 (   

 %  %   %'    %' %  + )( 

'

% 0(  %   ) 

+ (     (' 

%      )     

 %   $    + ( %    %%       %    )   (    

       +   3

-  

 -  

+   

    %'   -    

 (    %'        (  %      %

%  

.

<*  6 

* =

 - +11 */  :1&> *   (  

'* 

(  - +1"*/ &+&

(

*    +:!3 4*//!11 $   :

%

     $    

( $         

    



      $ $(   '      

   (         

 $  

  

'        - $ 

  (  $  

    

  

    

$ 

   (

 $     $ (  $ $  

 $

        -

  $    '    '  $   $( $ $;

      $( $    5

5

<

0 

  (  $

   *    /5$  -  

 

 /+    #  $    !#$$5

  '    



  % !





  

      *  " -

        

  '

*  

#           

      

'   

      

           #)   

       



           '      

       

            #   *  " - 

 

  

   3 4      

  3

4        

3

4   3

4    

3 4    3

4   

 3

4   

 *   !+ -

   

 

   

  



*  !" 

  #  

       0

 



  #      

#    



  

  

  =     

-     

 

  -   3 4  .   .  3 4  3&4  .

  .  3 4    3!4  .

 .3

4 ' ? %

    

      



  



 2

    .  . #@ 

  

  

    @      

   

     

       



       .)        #  2     .

* 5 8

-  A 

  # ? %?

  # BA .34? %AC



 

-/           

 



    

34?

 %AC





-/    

     

 

  .

   /   

      /  



   /   

 

  

 ##

   

 

 



 

:

*  " -   

      

        #       #  

*   !+      -     

 

      

 

  #        

"

 -     

      #   ? %  *   !      8

  -      

 

*  " !+ -  





 *  !" - #      #   # 

 #

2   

                 2    

      -   

       #

2               

 *  " !+ -  

    ' # 

2



 # 

  

# 



 

      

              - 

   

 ) 

      # 

2

+ '   .  

 .

*  " -  # .

 

 . *  !+ -  # 

. ..

 .



 * 5 8

-)    

  

      C      

    #

   # # 

   #   



   #  

      

&D , ((

   # (6 0(  )  (   )(  

 % +      (  ( (

(

     (

   * + (   (   %   %%   

 &



(   %

+   ,  %       '  

   ((

  + (      ( % '

 %  %   + (  (  (   , ((

 ' (  (  (

    7

) 

  %'

(  

)  % %' %  ( & %' )  - ( 

     '(

 ((

    

 * + ( (   %%' &  (   (  % (

   + (     &

 (    

%  (

  -

 

    



  

    2

        #

     # & )(  %%  % %  & (  & & %      (  ,        

 -    ((

    % & ( 

(( ( (

(

-  (  )(- (  '  %  

 (   % +    * + (  )     %%           )    ( (

(

 (

-(     ' + -

 



   #

       

          



        

  





 

      )#



   ' 

           

   *  5 8

-   

 *  " !+

- & '     A 2

 

         

   2   

   

       

        

          

    

  ;    



 



  

          

  



 )                 *  " !+ -#    %  %   :

,



        $   (  

   '     $(   $ $

  '      

  





(

         



   $(  

 

  $   $(  $   $( 

 -     (    

    '   

$ $(    $   '       $    

  

  $         

'  $       



    

  $     

         -

(  $    

$   ' 

   '

  $ $ 



          

   

 (   '

&

% 

  8& # 9   !#$$..-  /5$  - $  

       

!"

  # $ %  



  %&1    2  #   #   A     *   !+      -        2

       '   2      

  

 6 (3  4

 E#  

  # 





   

 #   



  

   -    

       

 

 # 2

         E#         

      # 

  

&:

*  !+ -

2           



  @

   

          

  

C *  !" -



 

     

     *  !+



       E#      



*  !"   

         

 

     

    

 # #  

 





       

 



                

     F       2  

      

&"

   @

       

    

   



#





#      *  !+    

  

 ?      %

' 

 



  #    2

         

 - 

      

     

  



     





F # % "

% 

  :40%   # $0%  00   .!#$$"-  /5$  - $    

   

&   

!"

  # $ %   $         8:

      

   



(2 

  



8:

      $(

     (  

(

 

 

8:

 



 $ 

< ( 

 $

           

<          

 

      $ 





  $( 

 



     

,      

  

 

(  

  *   



 

 $(   

 $ 

     



 * 

 ' 

  %1  C  #  2            A       @          /

6 





  

/ #



/    

     A   *   /

6 

#   4 , & 

  ;* 

  ((

 (     ' 

 

  

%   ) 



8 -5 - <*)  4-        



0DDDDFA    #

  

 

      

 



0DDDDFA#  # 

 A

   #  #   , &   

     %   $ % ) ) %     (  (

 

     -)  (



)

( %   $ % ) 4           

A2    

 #

 ##  



# #  #    

0DDDDFA

 4-  # #

       2     #  #

          3 4  #   



4'    # # #

 

4'

/    #               #

     

  

 # #     

+ 1      %               )  

  # (6 &)  = &% 1

 0(- %  )  '

    (       )      

    &(    '

((

> 

(  (



      '

  (   )  

     

((

) %  2  '

 %

&

  )  

&    (

       

(       

   #  #  2              

A   

        

6 #  # #    

0DDDDFA #   # 

 ## #   # #2# 2   ) # 

  -

 

  

;

                

                   

2  # #



           2    )    

  

       

      #

   # #

                  # # #

 

C



   



 

/ # #

   : @# 

  

E / # 

 

  *

  



 # 

)      *  !"

 

6#   # 2  E / # 

@ 

 /       

     # 

      

         

   

  6 E / #       

           @ E /    %   :

+

% 

 

 & 9 %   !5#$$ .6-         

     # $ %    /5$  -  $

  % 5 6 * ( *   * , -



*  - 3&DD141*//!+ 

*  "34 !" !+ - ""

#   *

"34 !+    82 

< 2

 G   H    G    H

  @ # #    , &"BA G&"

C#

 2

G  HI  HG

  H

  

  

/     =      

J3&DD04 &*//   #   3*// !DA!  0&4 G 

        

      #  

    I      K    I    K * 5&  @7  -   

       

        J 

ALA

          #   ## I  K #

'  2

I KI  K 2 

* 5 8

- ":&

  #  #

#



        

  



     

 2

I  K   # I

  K # 2

G  H   # 

 



    

    #  G H   G

 H    *   !      8

  -

# #  #   , !DB G!D  -       

   G H   G

 H

  *  "34

-    

  



  

             %  

   

(    

   +     ( 

   *

+ (      (       %%        &-   ( (

(



 (  (

-(  

 

(    

   +  M        # 

  

  

        8              

       , $  ) 

   

  %%   ( - )(  (

 ' 

((

     + ( (  %'

)' (  (      (  (    %       (   (  %     

9 #       # # 



  , !&BA G!& '     



      

          

    #





    

 

#  

:

   

  6   ( 

 9   J

E  3&DD"4  5  *//  05  

 /          

          2   

E

   

        

     



    M# #  #

 , !&BA G!& 0((

  ( && %    (       



+  

  ' ( &  %  



  %           '  %  &  

( 0((

 (   &

  ( #       ((

           

(      (  (

 

H "

 '

 /          #

                                     

G        , !5

# #  #BA G!5 M   #                                                          

G             

       # 



        

 

#  

&0 C

   #

/

  *  "34 !+##





   

/

#  BA 4;2  

 *  !+ -  #



       

4, 

  # (  % %

 

  ((

 



 %%   ( ,      % &   

          (    %%



4 ,  %     

-           

((

 '  (  %'  ((

(   '    

%  %' (         

    %%    (   1

(    (  %%

(%  )'

      %  & ( %'  

%  %' 

(  ( (

(

 )( '

'

4'



   # 

2    

 *  !+

 

   

 

&1 -  

 #  

   

 

  

   

  *   !+ #

 

       ' )



 #   #

   

A2    C #



  #   #

 

  

&0DDDFA) 

C            

C    

  

  ++:#   

 

 

") # #

   #    

  &D D  

   #  



50DDDDFA    (  J  #  

 

50DDDDFA  

      &D D            



0DDDDFA#   #  , +

&D &  #

             #   #  

 82 9& #  

   

     &D DA&D   #          

"  )

 9

  

 

2  #

  

1)

 #   # 

 



  '

    

     #  

   

   

%   :     

             (     ( 

  



   $     $            (   

(

 

        $ '          

   

    $  -        (        

( 

  /5$  -    *     (

   $  $ 



%

 $  

 

$ $ 

             (   $     $( 

 

   



2

       

  $ '

    

     /5$  - 

      *     -

     

  

 

=

 

 8:

          

 

(     0 !

> <     

 <



(  

   

( (   $

 

$   



  



/   

 



            

0 (   

     $  #

+6)") 

& +!

)+ !

 <  





 0

!

> <

 

    

 $    

/     

 $  $( 

   $ <    

    

< ?@ %A

   

+6 )+ !

 

      

     

    

8:

     



 

     $'

 -7

 

 

 

 $( 

    

/

       9'

-

B  9'

-)    $ < 9'

-!

-(    9'

-6   8:

%*  

 

 -7) 

      <  







  ( 

  

      $  



  $

8:

           !

!

-  - 

        

/    

  $(  

/        9'

2 - (   *  



/ * 

D

 

9'

 9'

2/

-  F   G      $ 

 

   $(      - .

  /  



     2         



  $(       

(   $(



       

 

   

 $  $( 

   

 2 ):

>   

  

     

   

%

   

  0

!

> <



      



  

  $(  



 0

> <

/ 

     (   

(

   

 ( '  $( 

%   $               



     $      $  $( 

,         $(

#   $  $(     $   

   ' 

  

        

B  $     (

    -

   '  $       

722 !:

%       



       

$

 

7    $ 

  $( 

    -  $

  G &  M

       

           /  

                           

                 *  !+ , - 

 /    



  

  

   

E#    

  

  

2    



  # 

 ,#     '

              382 / 4     

  E#   

  

  

       *   2  

   #   

    

 



!DDDDDFA 

      

  #     #           ) *       





82 /C F-

 #   

# )    # #  

 

  #  

    

 

 

    

      ) 

     ,

 

#         # 



F    #    #     #  #  

!DDDDDFA#      '     #    #         

   #        )#   





  -



     #

2 #

 #2 

#   8    2 # 

#  #       

     '        

   #      

!DDDDDFA      #   2    #

    

  #  # 

8  # 

2     

        

 

A2        # #

#            

    )   8      # #

   

      

    #    8       

        

A2      

 #   



'  

#  

   

           

!DDDDDFA    #

   

;

!

-     

#   

    

     



A2      









#  # )    E    # )   

E  





#    # 

 



  

 @  2 



&0DDDFA  

E   

 # )

     



 # ) 

 

A2  

   

!DDDDDFA# 

     

#    

50DDDDF   E#     

 

             

#  

    

50DDDDFA    

!DDDDDFA  -

 )        

  #              # #  #    )    *

  

    

!DDDDDFA    

  

/

 #   

   

# 

 

     

               

 '



#      E%-2/     

%&DD:  354  /  3/

 4    0""  &DD"  3 4  / 3/

 4 1+0%  C         #             

        

  





<

M     #       

*  

 

   9

  E#   

    

2     )# 



 82 /C F,

 #  #

  

    



       8    





 

    

  

C

 

 #  





2             82 /C F,    

    )A

,

  



  #   # 

 #  

E @  *  '     

 6 D"

&D :82 9 F-    *  !" ,  -

   E @   *       

       #             E# 



   , ! 6 E @  * ##               # 

   

' 



 

                    

     7 /  E @  *  # 

     

                  #        

 ( 

A2    #       #  

   7 9 /  

      

 

  

   82 /C F,      # 



   #  

         )#  '     

 

        @                

                  

' 

 

   /   @ 

  

 682 9 F- ' 

  



  

   #  

      #  

M                   



!DDDDDFA#          



 * &++3

4 '2-  ' E%* /    64  : 

 ? &  6 1!8$8 $  !"5 

%

   '

# ("##

1( ,+0(-'( 2 %')''

 8  - <*) %   %')'((  '

(

''    #   

 

2  #     2 

&DDDDFA             -        #     '  

  * &1+** '2- #

      

;    



                  2 

2    

       #

 



  

                #  

     

          6 ' @

 -

    !8$8 $!6  #    E%-2/   G-  #

     A,    

       A 9  

      A   

   A-      

 

 #   /#

# 

A/



A

   

  (   

  $   $ ( <   

 $

  $(  .

 

6:

      

 

 

 $  -      

  

 

 8:



        

(   $(2 (  $ $

   



8:



        ( ' 

(  

(      $  

 

8:



        

(   $   



 0 !+++++2



 (

  $( 

   

8: 9  

      

     

 

   

 $(              (   $ $    $    

     

8:



       

(   

 

( (2

(     

/ 

   (  (  

 

         <

(

  



   

8:



       



(  

  ( 

$ 

(  (2(   







  

(   

8: #

  (    

 



(      

8:        



(        ( 

  



   

 $ <

 

   

8':     

    '

     $ '

  

<

 

8':



    

      '

    

 

  



, $ (  

<  



%   $  $ 

    

  

(

   '



    ( 

8':

   ' 

  (      (        (       $ < 

   %

'

  

<     ( 

     ' 0 )++++2

 

  (  $( 

$



 $

   $ <   (

8':

     

    

   (  $ $  (      

  

 

(  (2$         

8':

   

      

(      2  

$

   $   $   

(

     $  

         

$    $(   $        2 

     

!"

 # $ %     

        

  $  

%   $  $  

 2   

,  $ 

  

 $(  



 

 * (     $ $ $( <           



7       ' 

 (  $ $   '   # $ %  

   $  -      $      

  $

 $         



 



  $

 (   

( $     $(     





    (  

$ $ 

  ( 

    

/

(    $   $  



 (  

   

 $'

77 2 

72= 7 4:

 

       $(  -   



 

 

 /5$  -    

  9?0&& )

# 9   -018 "#$ -    ' 

  G3 14* 5&!3 4

 #  / 



  

  

3434#     

 

 

 ' 

 # 

 34#  #     

 #  # 

  34#  #  



  



 E / % #  # 

   # #        

           

, 

 '

   '      # E  /         #          

        #          E   /            

  

  

     

 

 

/      

 

   # #     E / #  # 

 - /  /

  # 

  

  

 

/   # 

 

    

 

 /    #   # 

# 



 ' #

E /  #    #   #    #  

   #   

 

 

 



 # 

   *  #   #



N#  



      #    





2



#   

   (  



# 

      E /   # 

   

   # 



  

      '



 



/  **# 

'  8 1 -!+"B3- +!5 /&&:3&44 , 

8 - +50 / 0

3 :4    



/ # 

,, 

N        

 #      # 

   



  .

  

/ #     # 







   3 43 +!547  1  - !+"

3&4-  

+50

/  0       .B

* @* 

'* +0&A!*/ +! &D 3- +0&*/0&4 *    -@ * 

* @ +0!

*/  5 "  B  -  +0!  */  :1    #  

    



 E /       #    @

   

       .



     %  

     

 .

 . .

  .

         

     

     

#  #

  2  # 

       

      E   /     

  

'#   

  A      34 * 5&!3 4 / - 

  A



 

E /  #        7 



    **#     

 .

  #) 

 



 .'    2

.

    .     #  

      '



  



/ 

 *#* 

* @ - +1 */ : 0E  * 

'* @- +1&*/ 5!+ >    

  

     

  

, @         E   /      

  

   

          

'  # #  )    

# 

        E   /  #  @

        

         

#)

/ # 



 #



 ##

   

 

    

   

E  / ( -  !1## 

   

# 

    E /   #  

      



@  /5$  -    

  =&%

 # 4 2-  !5#$$-   GA( 



#      * !:"/

/   

E /    







A  (

*  3&D D4+*// "+ 

/  

   #            *   !:"  /

/       & +



  &  '

 /                #         E   /     

  #    @  





'  

 

 @    # #

#  



#      C  # @

,;

   



    



   # 

# 

 # 

  #

   '

  

# 



  

           )    





F ) 

  

               #

*   #          @A   3 ()

* =

3 +:04!*//& +* 

* (  3 ++D45*// :* 



* =

3&DD!4 *//:1 ,  * 

* 

3&DD54 D*//1++(* 

* =

3&DD14+*//:! * =

  * 3&DD:4 !*// D&* 

*   3&DD"40*//0!0- 

*3&DD+4 D*//&D1

* ) 

* -

3&DD+4 1*// +"* 

* E

3&D D4&*//5504 !

**# 

 8 - +!5 /&&: 

/ 

  B3- 5D54GO / # # 

  #  

   3 4

# 

6      # 

>3&4           #)          

 

>  3!4   

     

 >354 #

 

   

  

6#    # 

' 

  # 



#

/ 3*'



*- +05*/ (

* 

* @- +0:*/

,< & 1 J - #

*   - +1!

*/&DD

* (  3 +:D4&*// 50D*



*  3 ++"40*//5 & (#* 

* 

3&DD&45*//"0 * J

*@') 3&DD:4!*//:004 / 

*  )3&DD:45*// 5 0

/ 

  3*// 5!& 5&4G3 4-   #   

#        

 

#   



3&4  '  /    /

  

   +:!       

   2

  #  

    #

   #

3!4  

  2

       I         K  I   

    K I     

  K  I

   

K I

  

) K                2

#      *           I 

    K    

  

             

  #     #  

# 

 #

354- #    

    

  

         M

       



     

  

 @

  

  



                #  *    

  

 

, 



 







304 # 

 

 

   

   



 

      

 J 7

* =

3&DD"4 D*//50D 

/  

#

   #  # 

             

   K         

 '  

# 





  

  

   #  # 

 #  

     

# 

:

* @ 

, 3&DD+4+*//!1" /  2   @ 

/  #B3*// !:5 &D4G&D O      

 #     

            



  

 #   "

* =

(3&DD+45*//&: 

/     



  #    /   #    @

    

  #    @           E   /  '

  B3*// &"1 &"4G3 4' / K 



 



# # 

 

>

4  '  E   / K  

       

   >

,

4'

  E /   # 

#    



 @ >

4'E / K @



@    

 #  

   > 4'

/  # 

  #  



  E / >

4  '

 /   #    2    



#  #*

/     E   /             

  H-

 

#  

/ 9

*3&DD+4 D*//5D

+ ' #

 



      2     #          

        @   



 



 #          '                   

    

  K              

 

    #  

#



  

     

 H  3

 4 AC

          

        #     

    &D  

#     G&D '

      





   

  

 2   

 ) 

  

 

 F 

  



'

   



, G #  

H



    

  





  3 @     

9

-3 +"545*//1!082

'2 ;

 A-

-



J ,P*  ++& *3&4*//! &'

  P 

//8 ++5  *  3!4  *//  110  J  9  

 E

3&DD 4 *//0D - 

*3&DD+4 D *//&D1J ( # 

*

-

3&DD+4 D*//1!14 H3

 4 A

 

 # 

 

/   * 

/

   3 +++4&*// D









  

           

    

   #        #  

(

 



  # 

#   

#  



  #



# 

A   @* 

*  ) 3&D +4  0  *//  5!1  

 /         

   

 * !:"/

/  

 E /    '

/ 

 



/



 +0& #

  ! 



  G!

-   

 

/ = 6  3 +:"4 *//&&"

   

/ E / 

#    

 

 

A        

  

    

E# E / # 

  

 

 

    #            /

   

 @ E / 

/ 

    D  B3*// &!!4G D ;   #

             

 E / #      

  

           # 

;



E / #



   *

6



# 

      

 '

#      # *

6   #   

        

         

   !

*



*  3 ++"40*//5 & E /   

  

    A    



  #  E /       

     #           

      # 

#    

 

        #   #  /

       

      E  / 

      

 

   

   

 

  # 







 

/   

#  

 

E / C 

 



 

E / 

/ 



 "  B3*// 5 14G "

 C          @         # E /     

 

C

E /  

    #

 

/  (9 

* J@ 3 ++14+*//&&0

N

  

  #   

  # 

#    



    # # #   #  @

 

     

 E /   #A 

@ 

  (# 

A 

@

  

@ QC  ) 

#    

     #  

 

          @  #    



  

 

  

   # 

#   

      # @ 



   

 > 

          

   @#

 

   

 

       #       K

@ 

  (

    

@



  



   

    # @

>

 @     

 # 

# 

      E



  



#   2 @ 

 

 H !

&  )

= 

*   3 +++4!*//!D+ 

 

   

   

 

  E /    



 6    

/

 

 

 

 /  

    *

6     #

  



  *

6   #   

'

/  

 *

6 #    @

    

      F



#    E /   #     

    #

'

/ 



 # 

 



 

  

# 

#   '

/  

    

 

 # 



   #  E /  

#   

 *

6 !

!

-

* =

- +00*/"D:  0

/ 

  B3- "D+A D4 G0       @ 

  

 E /    

     

    



 @ 

6# 

  



 

       *   5 :  /

/       

@    # 

  



,   #

/ 

 E /  

 

#





#

  )  

##A 

       

   #)         @  



 #    

 # 

# 

       

 #   

# #    

           

  @

   # #      

                     #   

 # 

   

        

#    

 )      

                

 @     

 3* 

  

( * @* 

*- +0&*/0&>C 

* =

- +0!*/ &&4           

          

  / # @

 

# 

  #

!

 J

* -

3 +:+4 *//!00

/  

# 

 #    #  

  @   # 



 ) 

# 

# 

  





  E / 





    @  



@  

 H3

 4 2  3:

%     

    

     /5$  -



           %

       

!"

  # $ %  

&&    

$   (       

  $   $          - $(       $( 

( 

   $( $     

  

 $ $(  $ ' 

 

 (  $  $(

   



%       ( ( (  

     $(   - .

     * 

 



( 



 

(  

 $ 



   1 2+ 8 +,+  )'0 C ) F B R F, C   R F,