Lakhwinder Singh & ANR v. Commissioner,Panchyat Land Chd & ORS
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH.
CWP135321999
Reserved on: 21.09.2022
Pronounced on: 27.09.2022
!
"##!
$ CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURESHWAR THAKUR HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE N.S. SHEKHAWAT %
& ' ( )
& !%
( (
!%
)+,- ( (
!%-!.& //// SURESHWAR THAKUR , J.
0
!
#23+0444!
% 5
,#!&
3+320444!
% 5
,+ FACTUAL BACKGROUND # - ! ( 6 !
-
) 27 * 0448 &
1 *
9*
.&
% !0420
*
: % :
1 &
!
*
.
!* !
;
2 + &
! **
&
#23+0444!&
< &
&
&
&
%
%
;
%
%
3+320444!
*
**
#23+0444!
*
!&
!& - ( 6 1
* !
&
&
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS =
!
* )27*0448&
! -
*
&
! &
#000044=!
1
&!
#000044=!
*
> &
1! &
& , & &
#
3
#
= * : % :!
* &
*
*
!
!& !
!
* % 1
! *
&
! !* (
!
5
5
04201!
&
*
!* :&
.
*
1
!
> ?2@% !
5
>
!
A 5555555 & 55555555 55555555 (g) ―shamilat deh , 0 &
& B # B + &
! 1 *! ! 1
* **
*
*
B <
* *
! !
! !
& B =
& &. >
*
B but does not include land which,,,, A,,,,,C
4 &
>,
&
B 555555555 (vi) lies outside the abadi deh and was being used as gitwar, bara, manure pit, house or for cottage industry, immediately before the commencement of this Act;] 5555555555 ANALYSES OF THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS THAT THE PETITION BEARING NO. 6/DDPO OF 1998 WAS BARRED BY THE PRINCIPLE OF RESJUDICATA.
2 %
*
! -
!
* & *
*&
5&
%
*
*
!
&
** *
!& -
!
& -
1
#000044=
;
!*
&
*
* ! &
&
! &
*
9
*
*
* *
!
$
+ <*
@D*
*
!0438!
*&
*
?3. Where neither party appears, suit to be dismissed., E
*
&
5 4.
! "
#
$% 8 %
* &
**
! *5
& ;
!$
<*
@D!
**!
&
!
*
* !&
*
;
!* &
&
!
*
**!
!
!
! ! *
** ** * &
**
&
!& *
!
& !
*
4 @*!
&
**
1!
&
**! & !
*
!
00* 1
&
!
*
6 !
00* !
, **
!
)
**:
1!
!
!
* $
<
@D
*
00* )
**
*
*
**!&!
CONCLUSION 03
& *
&
*$
<*
@D
5&
7!
7
! &.
! *
&
* !
& &.
*!
*
!
&
1
!
7
*
*
& ! & &.
&
& &
* & !
&
1!
&
&
!&
& ! *
&.
* !
* *
7 *
* ! * ** (
!*
>
! ! >
&
&
*
! !*
* ! * * >*
&
&
1!*
*
!
** & !
&
!
& &
& !&
* **
!
&
*
!>
&.
!&&
& & !&
1! &.
&
ANALYSES OF THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 2 (g) (5) (vi) OF 'THE ACT' 00
: % :!
* !
!
!!
7
* *
;
>
>* !&
!
!
7
% ! !
0420;
*
8 !
&
& & &
!
!7
>
&
?
% F FINAL ORDER
0# @ * !
*
& &
&
! * !
& &
! !
>
*
0+ @ ! *
1
** 0< )
(SURESHWAR THAKUR) JUDGE (N.S. SHEKHAWAT) JUDGE 27.09.2022
Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No